Notebook selection for university course

MoneyFace =p

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2010
Messages
35,380
Reaction score
402
Hi guys, i'm currently in the midst of helping my cousin to find the most suitable notebook for her upcoming university course, so hoping that you guys can provide some critics and insights to my selection.

Here's her profile,

1. She is taking on Bachelor of Science at NUS, specialising in Biomedical Science.

2. Her family isn't well off and she is forking out for the notebook herself, so she is trying to be frugal on this. Thus, budget for notebook should be well below $1000.

3. It's a HER, so other than work she will only use it for web surfing and social networking (not stereotyping women but that's just what she does) and strictly no hardcore gaming.

After looking at the choices offered by NUS, it is pretty dismaying that all those models offered are being too costly while lacking essential software (Microsoft Office) and yet providing all those extra, unnecessary software and hardware which inflates the overall package price, notably Adobe Creative suite. Hence, we are looking towards offerings from other mainstream retailers.

I've shortlist several brands and rounded down to Dell with one of the best customer support, build quality and low price. Does anyone have any new insights to Dell? Or anyone will like to show me the good of other brands?

I'm also concerned about the possibility of using horsepower-demanding software on her notebook, mainly modelling software for molecular biology (or anything). Can anyone already taking the relevant module clarify on this?



This is my current selection and accompanying rationale:

DELL Inspiron 14 @ $749 (+$160 for 3 years local warranty)

Grand Total: $909

CPU: Intel Core i5-3337U
She definitely wouldn't benefit any much from quad core processor and this Ivy Bridge based ULV Core i5 performs very similarly to mainstream previous gen Core i5 which should be adequately enough for all her needs.
RAM: 4GB DDR3-1600
I don't foresee her multitasking THAT much to render 4GB insufficient. DDR3 RAM prices are also on the high so i will only advise to increase when necessary.
GPU: Nvidia GeForce GT 625M with 1GB DDR3 VRAM
This should be pretty much useful on molecular modelling software acceleration, while notebook models with Nvidia chip is specifically chosen for their more stable graphics driver support, by means to play safe and minimise risk of driver bugs/crashes/incompatibility with modelling software.
And i believe she may wants to play light girly games like The Sims if she wishes to so this can be an additional value.

Monitor: 14" @ 1366 x 768
14" is just optimal, from my personal experience.
HDD: 750 GB 5400 rpm
Capacity doesn't really matter, but will be useful if she wishes to store movies/drama serial in the furture.
ODD: 8X Tray Load DVD Writer
Battery: 6 cell Li-ion (65 Whr)
Definitely practical and value added over 3 cell when it comes to working at places without power point and on the go.
Weight: 1.99 kg
The lighter the better, especially for women. Anymore lighter will be even better but that will incur higher cost commitment on the notebook.
OS: Microsoft Windows 8 64-bit
I wonder whether NUS connects via domain or VPN and will the lack of network domain support on regular Windows 8 be the main deterrent?
WiFi: Dell Wireless 1704 Wireless-N
So far i read that it doesn't perform well nor having any decent signal.
Cover: Matt Black
Appearance doesn't matter as long as the notebook is sufficiently fast for her.

Considering the price and everything, i find this configuration rather a steal compared to other brands' counterparts. What can you say for this?

Hope to hear from you guys soon!
 
Last edited:

kenny_2828

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 29, 2005
Messages
1,513
Reaction score
0
Hi guys, i'm currently in the midst of helping my cousin to find the most suitable notebook for her upcoming university course, so hoping that you guys can provide some critics and insights to my selection.

Here's her profile,

1. She is taking on Bachelor of Science at NUS, specialising in Biomedical Science.

2. Her family isn't well off and she is forking out for the notebook herself, so she is trying to be frugal on this. Thus, budget for notebook should be well below $1000.

3. It's a HER, so other than work she will only use it for web surfing and social networking (not stereotyping women but that's just what she does) and strictly no hardcore gaming.

After looking at the choices offered by NUS, it is pretty dismaying that all those models offered are being too costly while lacking essential software (Microsoft Office) and yet providing all those extra, unnecessary software and hardware which inflates the overall package price, notably Adobe Creative suite. Hence, we are looking towards offerings from other mainstream retailers.

I've shortlist several brands and rounded down to Dell with one of the best customer support, build quality and low price. Does anyone have any new insights to Dell? Or anyone will like to show me the good of other brands?

I'm also concerned about the possibiility of using horsepower-demanding software on her notebook, mainly modelling software for molecular biology (or anything). Can anyone already taking the relevant module clarify on this?



This is my current selection and accompanying rationale:

DELL Inspiron 14 @ $749 (+$160 for 3 years local warranty)

Grand Total: $909

CPU: Intel Core i5-3337U
She definitely wouldn't benefit any much from quad core processor and this Ivy Bridge based ULV Core i5 performs very similarly to mainstream previous gen Core i5 which should be adequately enough for all her needs.
RAM: 4GB DDR3-1600
I won't foresee her multitasking THAT much to render 4GB insufficient. DDR3 RAM prices are also on the high so i will only advise to increase when necessary.
GPU: Nvidia GeForce GT 625M with 1GB DDR3 VRAM
This should be pretty much useful on molecular modelling software acceleration, while notebook models with Nvidia chip is specifically chosen for their more stable graphics driver support, by means to play safe and minimse risk of driver bugs/crashes/incompatibility with modelling software.
And i believe she may wants to play light girly games like The Sims if she wishes to so this can be an additional value.

Monitor: 14" @ 1366 x 768
14" is just optimal, from my personal experience.
HDD: 750 GB 5400 rpm
Capacity doesn't really matter, but will be useful if she wishes to store movies/drama serial in the further.
ODD: 8X Tray Load DVD Writer
Battery: 6 cell Li-ion (65 Whr)
Definitely practical and value added over 3 cell when it comes to working at places without power point and on the go.
Weight: 1.99 kg
The lighter the better, especially for women. Anymore lighter will be even better but that will incur higher cost commitment on the notebook.
OS: Microsoft Windows 8 64-bit
I wonder whether NUS connects via domain or VPN and will the lack of network domain support on regular Windows 8 be the main deterrent?
WiFi: Dell Wireless 1704 Wireless-N
So far i read that it doesn't perform well nor having any decent signal.
Cover: Matt Black
Appearance doesn't matter as long as the notebook is sufficiently fast for her.

Considering the price and everything, i find this configuration rather a steal compared to other brands' counterparts. What can you say for this?

Hope to hear from you guys soon!
Is battery life an issue? Because the model is using Ivy bridge... New model Haswell gives almost twice the battery life for the same performance...

But if budget is an issue then I guess cant be picky >.< good luck bro!
 

watzup_ken

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2003
Messages
25,670
Reaction score
2,123
Sounds pretty good for the price. If she needs something even lighter and mobile, you can also consider this.

ACER 11.6IN INTEL CORE I5-3337U 4GB WIN 8 V5-171-53334G50ASS Notebooks - Courts Online Shopping

To be honest, I am not too much of a fan of Acer, but based on personal experiences and observations, they fare better than HP. This one is 100 bucks cheaper, without an onboard graphics. If she don't game, I think it is not a bad deal, since the HD4000 graphics are pretty decent. ;)
 

Gribber

Banned
Joined
Apr 6, 2012
Messages
11,562
Reaction score
0
Hi guys, i'm currently in the midst of helping my cousin to find the most suitable notebook for her upcoming university course, so hoping that you guys can provide some critics and insights to my selection.

Here's her profile,

1. She is taking on Bachelor of Science at NUS, specialising in Biomedical Science.

2. Her family isn't well off and she is forking out for the notebook herself, so she is trying to be frugal on this. Thus, budget for notebook should be well below $1000.

3. It's a HER, so other than work she will only use it for web surfing and social networking (not stereotyping women but that's just what she does) and strictly no hardcore gaming.

After looking at the choices offered by NUS, it is pretty dismaying that all those models offered are being too costly while lacking essential software (Microsoft Office) and yet providing all those extra, unnecessary software and hardware which inflates the overall package price, notably Adobe Creative suite. Hence, we are looking towards offerings from other mainstream retailers.

I've shortlist several brands and rounded down to Dell with one of the best customer support, build quality and low price. Does anyone have any new insights to Dell? Or anyone will like to show me the good of other brands?

I'm also concerned about the possibiility of using horsepower-demanding software on her notebook, mainly modelling software for molecular biology (or anything). Can anyone already taking the relevant module clarify on this?



This is my current selection and accompanying rationale:

DELL Inspiron 14 @ $749 (+$160 for 3 years local warranty)

Grand Total: $909

CPU: Intel Core i5-3337U
She definitely wouldn't benefit any much from quad core processor and this Ivy Bridge based ULV Core i5 performs very similarly to mainstream previous gen Core i5 which should be adequately enough for all her needs.
RAM: 4GB DDR3-1600
I won't foresee her multitasking THAT much to render 4GB insufficient. DDR3 RAM prices are also on the high so i will only advise to increase when necessary.
GPU: Nvidia GeForce GT 625M with 1GB DDR3 VRAM
This should be pretty much useful on molecular modelling software acceleration, while notebook models with Nvidia chip is specifically chosen for their more stable graphics driver support, by means to play safe and minimse risk of driver bugs/crashes/incompatibility with modelling software.
And i believe she may wants to play light girly games like The Sims if she wishes to so this can be an additional value.

Monitor: 14" @ 1366 x 768
14" is just optimal, from my personal experience.
HDD: 750 GB 5400 rpm
Capacity doesn't really matter, but will be useful if she wishes to store movies/drama serial in the further.
ODD: 8X Tray Load DVD Writer
Battery: 6 cell Li-ion (65 Whr)
Definitely practical and value added over 3 cell when it comes to working at places without power point and on the go.
Weight: 1.99 kg
The lighter the better, especially for women. Anymore lighter will be even better but that will incur higher cost commitment on the notebook.
OS: Microsoft Windows 8 64-bit
I wonder whether NUS connects via domain or VPN and will the lack of network domain support on regular Windows 8 be the main deterrent?
WiFi: Dell Wireless 1704 Wireless-N
So far i read that it doesn't perform well nor having any decent signal.
Cover: Matt Black
Appearance doesn't matter as long as the notebook is sufficiently fast for her.

Considering the price and everything, i find this configuration rather a steal compared to other brands' counterparts. What can you say for this?

Hope to hear from you guys soon!

i rather you gun for Dell Vostro 5460
<1.6KG
<$1000

have everything you listed above except the GPU. iirc.
 

MoneyFace =p

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2010
Messages
35,380
Reaction score
402
Sounds pretty good for the price. If she needs something even lighter and mobile, you can also consider this.

ACER 11.6IN INTEL CORE I5-3337U 4GB WIN 8 V5-171-53334G50ASS Notebooks - Courts Online Shopping

To be honest, I am not too much of a fan of Acer, but based on personal experiences and observations, they fare better than HP. This one is 100 bucks cheaper, without an onboard graphics. If she don't game, I think it is not a bad deal, since the HD4000 graphics are pretty decent. ;)

Thanks for the suggestion but i would avoid Acer (being one user myself right now) as i don't have much faith in its budget series to last longer than 2-3 years. Durability and longevity is critical as this is the first time she is spending so much money at one go herself and wants something reliable. I wonder how did HP fare even worse than Acer this time. :s13:

i rather you gun for Dell Vostro 5460
<1.6KG
<$1000

have everything you listed above except the GPU. iirc.
I have once considered this model but the 3 years warranty cost is on the steep side and she just requires basic RMA support. :(

I'm also thinking whether should i just get her the cheapest model and downgrade to Windows 7 *ahem* Professional. She doesn't care about the sizes, weight from what i know.

Anyone got any lobang for other brands like ASUS?
 

Ark Law

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2013
Messages
11,578
Reaction score
540
DELL Inspiron 14 @ $749 (+$160 for 3 years local warranty)
ASUS Vivobook S200e @ $699 (+$??? for additional 3rd year local warranty)

Grand Total: $909 (Dell)
Temp Total: $888 (Asus)

CPU: Intel Core i5-3337U (Dell)
CPU: Intel Core i3-3217U (Asus)


RAM: 4GB DDR3-1600 (Dell)
RAM: 4GB DDR3-1333, soldiered (Asus)

GPU: Nvidia GeForce GT 625M with 1GB DDR3 VRAM (Dell)
GPU: Intel HD Graphics (Asus)

Monitor: 14" @ 1366 x 768 (Dell)
Monitor: 11.6" @ 1366 x 768 (Asus) (768p will appear nicer on this more compact size, plus it's also touchscreen :D)

HDD: 750GB 5400rpm (Dell)
HDD: 500GB 5400rpm (Asus), + $159 for Samsung 840 SSD upgrade + $30 for nice USB3 2.5" HDD enclosure

ODD: 8X Tray Load DVD Writer (Dell)
ODD: None (Asus)

Battery: 6 cell Li-ion (65 Whrs, 3000mAh) (Dell)
Battery: 2 cell Li-ion (38 Whrs, 5136mAh) (Asus)

Weight: 1.99kg (Dell)
Weight: 1.40kg (Asus)

OS: MS Win8 x64 (Dell)
OS: MS Win8 x64 (Asus)

WiFi: Dell Wireless 1704 Wireless-N
WiFi: Atheros AR9485WB-EG Wireless-N

NBCheck review of the Vivobook S200e Review Asus VivoBook S200E Subnotebook - NotebookCheck.net Reviews

I personally recommend you drop by a Challenger/other laptop store and see the build quality. It's more robust and impressive than my sister's 2012 Zenbook and other laptops of similar/higher price points :o

Edit: You can fresh install Win7 *ahem* Ultimate x64 on the SSD which would be "NUS-domain" ready anw :crazy:

My worthless RM0.02
 
Last edited:

MoneyFace =p

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2010
Messages
35,380
Reaction score
402
Is battery life an issue? Because the model is using Ivy bridge... New model Haswell gives almost twice the battery life for the same performance...

But if budget is an issue then I guess cant be picky >.< good luck bro!

For Dell notebooks? SIC link please. =:p
 

Streetwise

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
2,287
Reaction score
0
Thanks for the suggestion but i would avoid Acer (being one user myself right now) as i don't have much faith in its budget series to last longer than 2-3 years. Durability and longevity is critical as this is the first time she is spending so much money at one go herself and wants something reliable. I wonder how did HP fare even worse than Acer this time. :s13:


I have once considered this model but the 3 years warranty cost is on the steep side and she just requires basic RMA support. :(

I'm also thinking whether should i just get her the cheapest model and downgrade to Windows 7 *ahem* Professional. She doesn't care about the sizes, weight from what i know.

Anyone got any lobang for other brands like ASUS?

I'm not a fan of Dell...but hving own one(see another thread on vostro 5460), personally, it's the best value budget laptop for now. The weight, battery life(3-4hrs) and two years warranty won me over. It has a dedicated graphic card(GT630). If I'm not wrong, the price is approx. $900 for IT shows(base on the recent few exhibitions). To my knowledge, the two yr warranty are only offered during IT fairs. Pls also note there are various iterations of the model, I3, I5 and those with msata. The $990 is the one with I5 and without msata. Fyi, I've a Lenovo set(2 1/2yr old), a Acer(1yr old); and now a Dell....of course, not all meant for myself....bought due to needs of different needs of family :D.

Best wishes in finding the best valued laptop for ur cousin.
 

MoneyFace =p

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2010
Messages
35,380
Reaction score
402
NBCheck review of the Vivobook S200e Review Asus VivoBook S200E Subnotebook - NotebookCheck.net Reviews

I personally recommend you drop by a Challenger/other laptop store and see the build quality. It's more robust and impressive than my sister's 2012 Zenbook and other laptops of similar/higher price points :o

Edit: You can fresh install Win7 *ahem* Ultimate x64 on the SSD which would be "NUS-domain" ready anw :crazy:

My worthless RM0.02

I've seen and touch that particular model before (in hot pink cover some more :s34:) and definitely feels classy and solid but here's my concern...

ASUS Vivobook S200e @ $699 (+$??? for additional 3rd year local warranty)

Temp Total: $888 (Asus)

Monitor: 11.6" @ 1366 x 768 (Asus) (768p will appear nicer on this more compact size, plus it's also touchscreen )
Still the same screen real estate yet fonts will look smaller, which would be less ideal than the 14" screen. And touchscreen won't be useful anyway.

HDD: 750GB 5400rpm (Dell)
HDD: 500GB 5400rpm (Asus), + $159 for Samsung 840 SSD upgrade + $30 for nice USB3 2.5" HDD enclosure
SSD indeed would improve power consumption and tasking speed, resulting in more useful work hours but she will want to keep things neat and simple and minimum modification (due to warranty issues and wants to be more meticulous with her notebook)

ODD: 8X Tray Load DVD Writer (Dell)
ODD: None (Asus)

Battery: 6 cell Li-ion (65 Whrs, 3000mAh) (Dell)
Battery: 2 cell Li-ion (38 Whrs, 5136mAh) (Asus)
Only 3-4 hrs of usage possible with her usage pattern, which is not going to be ideal, from my personal experience as well.

Weight: 1.99kg (Dell)
Weight: 1.40kg (Asus)
Definitely a plus.

OS: MS Win8 x64 (Dell)
OS: MS Win8 x64 (Asus)

WiFi: Dell Wireless 1704 Wireless-N
WiFi: Atheros AR9485WB-EG Wireless-N
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top