Yes, I am not a professional singer so I can only listen. Maybe technical wise she is flawless but the feel is not really there. I guess it is cos she is still young.
There are some who are not as flawless but they are telling a story when they are singing. That kind of soul can't be learnt and can't be heard unless you have gone through certain stuff in your life.
Touching on technicals becoz the rest already flawless.. and she choose relatively super easy songs which made it even harder unlike many competitors always trying go for hard songs to try score points.
she is a class above last season competitors … very evident from just her entrance performance.
anway singing is like all performance art can be subjective … but her wide acceptance and popularity is undeniable.
I also think 1 of the most accomplished contestants is Joanna Dong. But many sinkies says otherwise.