Personal Accident Insurance for TCM

kurt_629

Master Member
Joined
Nov 14, 2001
Messages
2,778
Reaction score
841
Hi,

i'm looking for a P.A with high coverage for TCM, as nowadays TCM are super expensives..
easily $150 per session.

was looking at MSIG ProtectionPlus - Gold plan but the max claim is $3k per year and TCM capped at $75 per visit.

any good recommendations, especially on TCM or Chiropractor
 

boredboiboi

Master Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2010
Messages
4,083
Reaction score
188
Hi,

i'm looking for a P.A with high coverage for TCM, as nowadays TCM are super expensives..
easily $150 per session.

was looking at MSIG ProtectionPlus - Gold plan but the max claim is $3k per year and TCM capped at $75 per visit.

any good recommendations, especially on TCM or Chiropractor
What ur budget?
Highest tier
$1500 per accident for tcm. No limit per year
$924 per year premium
 

BBCWatcher

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2010
Messages
23,177
Reaction score
4,690
i'm looking for a P.A with high coverage for TCM, as nowadays TCM are super expensives..
easily $150 per session.
$150 is not super expensive. If you can't handle $1,500 (10 sessions) on your own then fix that problem first.

An insurance payout should be life changing money, or nearly so anyway. If it's a "petty cash" payout it's just a lottery ticket, and you shouldn't buy lottery tickets.

If you're trying to decide between two policies that offer life changing money payouts, the premiums are the same (or similar enough), and only one of the policies offers $150 TCM payouts, OK, different story. Then you might as well pick the policy that offers a little better upside potential for payouts.
 

kurt_629

Master Member
Joined
Nov 14, 2001
Messages
2,778
Reaction score
841
What ur budget?
Highest tier
$1500 per accident for tcm. No limit per year
$924 per year premium

below $300 per year premium, is this ok?

is starr insurance ok?

i saw they are charging $13 or $25 monthly,
for $600 / $1000 for Any One Accident & Part of Accident Medical Expenses
 

boredboiboi

Master Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2010
Messages
4,083
Reaction score
188
below $300 per year premium, is this ok?

is starr insurance ok?

i saw they are charging $13 or $25 monthly,
for $600 / $1000 for Any One Accident & Part of Accident Medical Expenses
Less than $300
$750 per accident
$288 per year premium
 

luckygal

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2015
Messages
11,143
Reaction score
3,032
PA is personal accident right. You sound like you know you would get into an ‘accident’?
 

mummynew

Master Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2019
Messages
3,652
Reaction score
2,684
I have a PA insurance (premium $370+/year for $500,000 main cover and $5000/year PA medical cover).

I suffered a sprain on my back while doing CNY cleaning. Have been to TCM for several times and bills totaled about $400 (there's a sub-limit of $500/accident in the $5000/year cover).

My query is if I submit claims (so many forms to fill that is quite frustrating), anyone know whether insurer will refuse renewal or will load my renewal premiums? (currently close to 60 yo and bought the plan about 6 years ago. Payment under auto giro deduction.)
 

reddevil0728

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
64,941
Reaction score
5,424
I have a PA insurance (premium $370+/year for $500,000 main cover and $5000/year PA medical cover).

I suffered a sprain on my back while doing CNY cleaning. Have been to TCM for several times and bills totaled about $400 (there's a sub-limit of $500/accident in the $5000/year cover).

My query is if I submit claims (so many forms to fill that is quite frustrating), anyone know whether insurer will refuse renewal or will load my renewal premiums? (currently close to 60 yo and bought the plan about 6 years ago. Payment under auto giro deduction.)
You buy insurance for such purpose n can claim it. You want to avoid claiming because you fear they will refuse renewal and load your premium.

like that what’s the point of buying in the first place?
 

mummynew

Master Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2019
Messages
3,652
Reaction score
2,684
You buy insurance for such purpose n can claim it. You want to avoid claiming because you fear they will refuse renewal and load your premium.

like that what’s the point of buying in the first place?

Claim decision must be a 'rationale' one.

Like for some ISP plans, once claimed then premium will increase next year. So policyholders need to decide whether it's 'worth' to claim (have to see the claim quantum vs amount of premium increase).

*my thought of insurer may refuse renewal / load premium likely to be an unfounded one and so seeking advice from experienced PA claimants.
 

mummynew

Master Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2019
Messages
3,652
Reaction score
2,684
I went to check premium of PA covers, then realised it's much more expensive now:



and so more concerned about losing my more reasonable-priced old cover.
 

bluerail

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2014
Messages
62
Reaction score
17
GST increase making everything more expensive, and PA polices have GST.

Now you can get up to $1000 TCM reimbursement for $325.
I have a PA insurance (premium $370+/year for $500,000 main cover and $5000/year PA medical cover).

I suffered a sprain on my back while doing CNY cleaning. Have been to TCM for several times and bills totaled about $400 (there's a sub-limit of $500/accident in the $5000/year cover).

My query is if I submit claims (so many forms to fill that is quite frustrating), anyone know whether insurer will refuse renewal or will load my renewal premiums? (currently close to 60 yo and bought the plan about 6 years ago. Payment under auto giro deduction.)
Do you have someone to assist you with the claims? This is the value of an advisor, where they will be able to help you settle the claims.

If they refuse renewals, they will have a proper reason one, so they must have found that somewhere your claims aren't as legit as it seems or something to that effect, quite improbable they suddenly decline renewal. There is also no loading for PA policies.
 

BBCWatcher

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2010
Messages
23,177
Reaction score
4,690
Now you can get up to $1000 TCM reimbursement for $325.
Does this "insurance" make any logical sense to most people?

The $325/year you would spend on this policy would pay for 2 sessions of $150/session TCM, guaranteed. Plus 2 decent lunches to go along with the TCM sessions. The only way you'd do better is if you have at least $350/year of claims (since you'll lose some interest at least on your $325 upfront premium payment). But your claims are capped at $1,000/year. That's a very tight range when you could possibly "win" this lottery ticket.

Surely you would never buy this policy unless there's some other benefit (and it'd have to big), right? Or unless you have high confidence (for example) you're going to have at least $500/year in TCM claims that you'd otherwise definitely pay for out of pocket — that you know you're going to be a bad risk to the insurance company (and truthfully answer the questions on the application).
 

bluerail

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2014
Messages
62
Reaction score
17
Does this "insurance" make any logical sense to most people?

The $325/year you would spend on this policy would pay for 2 sessions of $150/session TCM, guaranteed. Plus 2 decent lunches to go along with the TCM sessions. The only way you'd do better is if you have at least $350/year of claims (since you'll lose some interest at least on your $325 upfront premium payment). But your claims are capped at $1,000/year. That's a very tight range when you could possibly "win" this lottery ticket.

Surely you would never buy this policy unless there's some other benefit (and it'd have to big), right? Or unless you have high confidence (for example) you're going to have at least $500/year in TCM claims that you'd otherwise definitely pay for out of pocket — that you know you're going to be a bad risk to the insurance company (and truthfully answer the questions on the application).
Well it depends on your lifestyle, if you exercise often you might have a higher likelihood of injuries.

The policy also has other benefits like additional allowance for MRI/CT so it is not like it only covers 2 TCM sessions. Not to mention the cover for accidental death or disablement, and it doesn't have to be a total disability.
 

BBCWatcher

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2010
Messages
23,177
Reaction score
4,690
Well it depends on your lifestyle, if you exercise often you might have a higher likelihood of injuries.
That's what I mean. You've got to be rather confident that you're going to have valid claims that exceed the premium.
The policy also has other benefits like additional allowance for MRI/CT so it is not like it only covers 2 TCM sessions. Not to mention the cover for accidental death or disablement, and it doesn't have to be a total disability.
OK, so let's take the latter first. The latter is "junk insurance." And I'll explain it this way. Suppose the police calls your surviving spouse with this bad news....

Police: "Are you Madame Tai?"
Spouse: "Yes, I am. Who is this?"
Police: "I'm Officer Soo calling from the police station. Unfortunately Aaron Tai arrived at Singapore General Hospital in critical condition and has passed away. I'm terribly sorry this happened. May we send a police car to pick you up to bring you to SGH?"
Spouse: "Oh, that's terrible! But may I ask...how'd my husband die?"
Police: "We believe he fell out of a window that failed in his office building."
Spouse: "Woo hoo! We're getting an insurance payout!"

In other words, it absolutely doesn't matter HOW someone dies in terms of insurance needs. ANY cause of death results in the same financial issues (if there are financial issues) for dependents. And that's why you should never pay even one penny for "accidental death" insurance. It's a joke policy, the sort of policy that credit card companies provide free of charge when you charge an air ticket. It costs almost nothing, and superficially it seems nice. But it's a complete joke. It provides zero value in terms of defending against the risks you actually want to defend against (loss of a breadwinner with dependents and his/her future income).

Don't fall for the "soap opera" stories when it comes to insurance. Insofar as possible insure against big losses that you cannot possibly handle on your own, no matter what the dramatic story. If Aaron Tai died of a brain aneurysm instead of falling out an office window would his children be any less needy? Of course not!

With respect to MRIs and CTs, how much do they cost? And what insurance and/or compulsory medical savings do you already have that covers them? And what additional coverage does this $325/year policy provide that would help you defend against the remaining financial risk? Would this coverage help you cope with a financial risk that you cannot reasonably handle on your own? If this policy doesn't pass these threshold questions then you probably shouldn't buy it.
 

mummynew

Master Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2019
Messages
3,652
Reaction score
2,684
GST increase making everything more expensive, and PA polices have GST.

Now you can get up to $1000 TCM reimbursement for $325.

Do you have someone to assist you with the claims? This is the value of an advisor, where they will be able to help you settle the claims.

If they refuse renewals, they will have a proper reason one, so they must have found that somewhere your claims aren't as legit as it seems or something to that effect, quite improbable they suddenly decline renewal. There is also no loading for PA policies.


Which insurer giving $1000 TCM reimbursement for $325 with $500,000 cover?

I am more into the $500,000 cover than for the misc benefits (that are good to have but not so essential for me).

*thanks for info on 'no loading for PA policies'.
 

Qiliang

Junior Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2008
Messages
3
Reaction score
1
Does this "insurance" make any logical sense to most people?

The $325/year you would spend on this policy would pay for 2 sessions of $150/session TCM, guaranteed. Plus 2 decent lunches to go along with the TCM sessions. The only way you'd do better is if you have at least $350/year of claims (since you'll lose some interest at least on your $325 upfront premium payment). But your claims are capped at $1,000/year. That's a very tight range when you could possibly "win" this lottery ticket.

Surely you would never buy this policy unless there's some other benefit (and it'd have to big), right? Or unless you have high confidence (for example) you're going to have at least $500/year in TCM claims that you'd otherwise definitely pay for out of pocket — that you know you're going to be a bad risk to the insurance company (and truthfully answer the questions on the application).
I have a plan that costs $150 or so for class 1, medical expenses claim limit is $4,000 per accident, and the TCM Sub limit is $1,000 per accident. It’s exclusive as the insurer created the plan for us so it’s not available to try r general public, But only through us
 

zi

Master Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2000
Messages
3,096
Reaction score
1,411
Does this "insurance" make any logical sense to most people?

The $325/year you would spend on this policy would pay for 2 sessions of $150/session TCM, guaranteed. Plus 2 decent lunches to go along with the TCM sessions. The only way you'd do better is if you have at least $350/year of claims (since you'll lose some interest at least on your $325 upfront premium payment). But your claims are capped at $1,000/year. That's a very tight range when you could possibly "win" this lottery ticket.

Surely you would never buy this policy unless there's some other benefit (and it'd have to big), right? Or unless you have high confidence (for example) you're going to have at least $500/year in TCM claims that you'd otherwise definitely pay for out of pocket — that you know you're going to be a bad risk to the insurance company (and truthfully answer the questions on the application).
Thanks for sharing your view and ideas. Indeed, there are some people who are just accident prone.
 

alyssax

Member
Joined
Feb 8, 2013
Messages
314
Reaction score
0
Bumping this thread up. I’m looking for PA plan for TCM. New company doesn’t cover it.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts.

Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards, Terms of Service and Member T&Cs for more information.
Top