PS5 or Gaming pc or both?

T

The_King

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2003
Messages
27,780
Reaction score
10,992
GPU now are so expensive that i am looking for a option that is the best value for money.



Option A:
for 4k Gaming
PS5 - $670
PlayStation Plus (Essential, to play online) - $70.90 per yr


cost count to 8yr:

1st yr to 6yr ps5 cost = $670 + $496.30 = $1166.30
7yr and 8 yr get ps6 = say cost 1k + 141.80 = $2308.10

total is at least $2308.10 (depend on ps plus sub but can cancel and sub when needed if i need to play online)





Option B:
for 1440p to 4k Gaming
PC: 9800x3d ($729) + X870E (>$450) + 32GB Ram (>$150) + PSU 1k watt (>$280) + cpu cooler + GPU 9070XT (1.3k)+ fans + case = At least $3.5k

total cost for a gaming pc is $3.5k to last 8 yr







Option C:
for 1080p Gaming
PC: 7600 ($283) + B650 (>$260) + 32GB Ram (>$150) + current PSU + current cpu cooler + GPU b580 ($420 )+ fans + case = At least $1.5k

with
for 4k Gaming
PS5 - $670 + PS6 - $1000 = $1670
PlayStation Plus (Essential, to play online) - only when needed to play online since there pc





total cost for a budget gaming pc + console is $ 3.1k





anyone any feedback? which option is the best value for money?
 
Last edited:
naked123

naked123

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2010
Messages
7,586
Reaction score
989
Ryzen 7 7700 + B650M + 32GB DDR5 CL30 ram is about 630 in carousell


and as for your X3D build, you don't need X870E or 1kW PSU
 
T

The_King

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2003
Messages
27,780
Reaction score
10,992
naked123 said:
Ryzen 7 7700 + B650M + 32GB DDR5 CL30 ram is about 630 in carousell


and as for your X3D build, you don't need X870E or 1kW PSU
Click to expand...
even i replace x870E and 1kW psu, gaming pc will still the most expensive of the 3 option and need to last 8yr cause ps 5 is 6 or 7yr life cycle to balance out the cost
 
NintendoSwitch

NintendoSwitch

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 10, 2024
Messages
21,493
Reaction score
8,481
The_King said:
GPU now are so expensive that i am looking for a option that is the best value for money.



Option A:
PS5 - $670
PlayStation Plus (Essential, to play online) - $70.90 per yr


cost count to 8yr:

1st yr to 6yr ps5 cost = $670 + $496.30 = $1166.30
7yr and 8 yr get ps6 = say cost 1k + 141.80 = $2308.10

total is at least $2308.10 (depend on ps plus sub but can cancel and sub when needed if i need to play online)





Option B:

PC: 9800x3d ($729) + X870E (>$450) + 32GB Ram (>$150) + PSU 1k watt (>$280) + cpu cooler + GPU 9070XT (1.3k)+ fans + case = At least $3.5k

total cost for a gaming pc is $3.5k to last 8 yr







Option C:

PC: 7600 ($283) + B650 (>$260) + 32GB Ram (>$150) + current PSU + current cpu cooler + GPU b580 ($420 )+ fans + case = At least $1.5k

with

PS5 - $670 + PS6 - $1000 = $1670
PlayStation Plus (Essential, to play online) - only when needed to play online since there pc





total cost for a budget gaming pc + console is $ 3.1k





anyone any feedback? which option is the best value for money?
Click to expand...
Playstation games r not cheap. PC games r cheapest. Plus got weekly free games from Epic. Monthly free games if u sub to Amazon Prime.
 
T

The_King

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2003
Messages
27,780
Reaction score
10,992
NintendoSwitch said:
Playstation games r not cheap. PC games r cheapest. Plus got weekly free games from Epic. Monthly free games if u sub to Amazon Prime.
Click to expand...
me got plenty of free epic and steam game so i thought to add option C.

not sure if optionC at 1080p gaming is a good idea or goes for option B to last 8yr which i believe is hard
 
Elnoxv

Elnoxv

Master Member
Joined
Jan 28, 2008
Messages
4,321
Reaction score
6,809

Deepseek R1 Analysis:​

Value Analysis of Gaming Options Over 8 Years

Option A: Consoles (PS5 + PS6)​

Total Cost Estimate: ~$2,308 (with continuous PS Plus)
Pros:

  • Lower upfront cost: Initial PS5 + PS6 upgrade is cheaper than a high-end PC.
  • Optimized for 4K gaming: Consoles offer hassle-free performance with minimal maintenance.
  • Exclusive titles: Access to PlayStation-only games.
    Cons:
  • Recurring PS Plus fees: Adds ~$70/year for online play (can be reduced by subscribing only when needed).
  • Less versatility: No productivity/PC features.
    Value: Best for budget-focused gamers who prioritize simplicity and exclusives.

Option B: High-End Gaming PC​

Total Cost Estimate: $3,500
Pros:

  • Superior performance: Targets 1440p–4K gaming with high settings.
  • Versatility: Doubles as a workstation for other tasks (streaming, editing, etc.).
  • No online fees: Free multiplayer on most platforms (except specific games).
  • Long-term savings: Cheaper games, mods, and no console upgrades.
    Cons:
  • High upfront cost: Most expensive option.
  • Potential upgrades: GPU/CPU may need refreshing after 4–5 years for cutting-edge performance.
    Value: Ideal for enthusiasts who want top-tier performance and PC flexibility.

Option C: Budget PC + Consoles​

Total Cost Estimate: ~$3,100
Pros:

  • Hybrid flexibility: Access to console exclusives and PC gaming.
  • Lower initial PC cost: Targets 1080p gaming.
    Cons:
  • Compromised experience: Budget PC may struggle with newer games, risking mid-cycle upgrades.
  • Split ecosystem: Risk of higher game costs (buying titles on both platforms).
    Value: A middle-ground compromise, but risks higher long-term costs if upgrades are needed.

Key Considerations​

  1. Game Costs: PC games are often cheaper, with frequent sales and no subscription fees for online play.
  2. Upgrade Costs: High-end PCs (Option B) may last longer without upgrades, while budget PCs (Option C) might need GPU updates.
  3. Usage Needs: Consoles (Option A) lack productivity features; PCs add versatility.
  4. PS6 Price Speculation: If the PS6 launches closer to $600 (historically plausible), Option A becomes even cheaper.

Final Recommendation​

  • Best Value for Money: Option A (Consoles)
    • Lowest total cost, optimized for 4K gaming, and minimal hassle.
    • Reduce PS Plus costs by subscribing only when needed (potential savings of ~200–200–300).
  • Alternative for Enthusiasts: Option B (High-End PC)
    • Justifies higher cost with better performance, versatility, and game savings over time.
  • Avoid Option C: The hybrid approach risks higher expenses from upgrades or dual-platform game purchases, offering less value than dedicated options.
TL;DR: Stick with consoles (Option A) for affordability and ease. Invest in a high-end PC (Option B) only if you prioritize performance and versatility. Skip the hybrid (Option C).
 
wongminmin

wongminmin

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 10, 2014
Messages
33,578
Reaction score
17,866
gaming console never been cheap. the controller accessories games subscription etc.... is really not for u....i swear. People said ps5 console with graphic card is cheap..... but 1 game title already $100 liao.
i buy 1 game title $100, i sell it as second hand.... can only recoup $50. lol

computer is the cheapest. gpu is expensive.... but chiu save a lot on the games if chiu ahem. can even use emulator.
 
GundamG

GundamG

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
May 17, 2004
Messages
22,788
Reaction score
3,196
u buy ps games, confirm can play swee swee. can buy 2nd hand ps or games.

u buy pc games, not 100% can play smoothly with your pc.
 
T

The_King

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2003
Messages
27,780
Reaction score
10,992
Elnoxv said:

Deepseek R1 Analysis:​

Value Analysis of Gaming Options Over 8 Years

Option A: Consoles (PS5 + PS6)​

Total Cost Estimate: ~$2,308 (with continuous PS Plus)
Pros:

  • Lower upfront cost: Initial PS5 + PS6 upgrade is cheaper than a high-end PC.
  • Optimized for 4K gaming: Consoles offer hassle-free performance with minimal maintenance.
  • Exclusive titles: Access to PlayStation-only games.
    Cons:
  • Recurring PS Plus fees: Adds ~$70/year for online play (can be reduced by subscribing only when needed).
  • Less versatility: No productivity/PC features.
    Value: Best for budget-focused gamers who prioritize simplicity and exclusives.

Option B: High-End Gaming PC​

Total Cost Estimate: $3,500
Pros:

  • Superior performance: Targets 1440p–4K gaming with high settings.
  • Versatility: Doubles as a workstation for other tasks (streaming, editing, etc.).
  • No online fees: Free multiplayer on most platforms (except specific games).
  • Long-term savings: Cheaper games, mods, and no console upgrades.
    Cons:
  • High upfront cost: Most expensive option.
  • Potential upgrades: GPU/CPU may need refreshing after 4–5 years for cutting-edge performance.
    Value: Ideal for enthusiasts who want top-tier performance and PC flexibility.

Option C: Budget PC + Consoles​

Total Cost Estimate: ~$3,100
Pros:

  • Hybrid flexibility: Access to console exclusives and PC gaming.
  • Lower initial PC cost: Targets 1080p gaming.
    Cons:
  • Compromised experience: Budget PC may struggle with newer games, risking mid-cycle upgrades.
  • Split ecosystem: Risk of higher game costs (buying titles on both platforms).
    Value: A middle-ground compromise, but risks higher long-term costs if upgrades are needed.

Key Considerations​

  1. Game Costs: PC games are often cheaper, with frequent sales and no subscription fees for online play.
  2. Upgrade Costs: High-end PCs (Option B) may last longer without upgrades, while budget PCs (Option C) might need GPU updates.
  3. Usage Needs: Consoles (Option A) lack productivity features; PCs add versatility.
  4. PS6 Price Speculation: If the PS6 launches closer to $600 (historically plausible), Option A becomes even cheaper.

Final Recommendation​

  • Best Value for Money: Option A (Consoles)
    • Lowest total cost, optimized for 4K gaming, and minimal hassle.
    • Reduce PS Plus costs by subscribing only when needed (potential savings of ~200–200–300).
  • Alternative for Enthusiasts: Option B (High-End PC)
    • Justifies higher cost with better performance, versatility, and game savings over time.
  • Avoid Option C: The hybrid approach risks higher expenses from upgrades or dual-platform game purchases, offering less value than dedicated options.
TL;DR: Stick with consoles (Option A) for affordability and ease. Invest in a high-end PC (Option B) only if you prioritize performance and versatility. Skip the hybrid (Option C).
Click to expand...
i forgot to ask AI. BTW i still need a pc for work, edit video, movies, etc..... option C all i need is a intel B580 can liao but limited at 1080p
 
woshihock

woshihock

Banned
Joined
Mar 13, 2010
Messages
16,639
Reaction score
4,327
waa didn't know
buy ps5 liao still need to subscribe playstation plus to play online

really siao siol

i still at the PS3 era
 
Z

zephxion

Master Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2015
Messages
4,497
Reaction score
3,097
Do you play older games? PS1 - PS4 era games you cannot play on PS5 whereas PC can play them.
 
Nevereatrice

Nevereatrice

Honorary Member
Joined
May 15, 2015
Messages
146,578
Reaction score
27,254
woshihock said:
waa didn't know
buy ps5 liao still need to subscribe playstation plus to play online

really siao siol

i still at the PS3 era
Click to expand...
Ya very lame i got wifi still need subscribe this to play Diablo 3 on ps the days u play or no play also need to pay
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top