Question for IMDA on mobile app security & user's privacy

ceestudent

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2010
Messages
19,098
Reaction score
3,701
If the apps is free, then you are the product. Do you think all of the programmer salary is cheap meh? They need to diligently farm your info and habit for advertisement mah.
Unless you are big shot or what, then need to worry about your privacy. Scare so much then just shop from mamak shop daily, ok?
 

K202020K

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2017
Messages
5,372
Reaction score
1,051
what is the point complaining about a singaporean company app invading privacy while every gen alpha still scrolling tiktok and xhs everyday
They have a different account and phone for serious business, unless they are broke financially and intellectually. Means they have nothing to lose come what may.
 

K202020K

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2017
Messages
5,372
Reaction score
1,051
Ts sure is shopee app turn on wifi to auto update itself? I just checked the shopee app info on my phone, the last update time is last year dec.

Check your google play settings auto update option.
My Google play store app is set to do not auto-update apps. Other possible reasons include whether it's Android or an iOS device, the Android version and the Shopee app version. Or something else we don't know yet. But the version of Shopee app on my phone has Wi-Fi control access which cannot be disabled from the phone's Android system settings under Settings > Apps > Special app access > Wi-Fi control
 

K202020K

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2017
Messages
5,372
Reaction score
1,051
Becos other than u nobody else is complaining.

This is an issue complete unique to u.
I already stated in my other post that many people complained about them on Google play store's Shopee app reviews.
 

K202020K

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2017
Messages
5,372
Reaction score
1,051
If the apps is free, then you are the product. Do you think all of the programmer salary is cheap meh? They need to diligently farm your info and habit for advertisement mah.
Unless you are big shot or what, then need to worry about your privacy. Scare so much then just shop from mamak shop daily, ok?
Yes you right. I actually shop at FP & SS stores. But scared or not worried, Big Shot or small fry, it is much better for everyone if we can get them right. You don't like that?
 

jeff79

High Supremacy Member
Joined
May 26, 2001
Messages
34,334
Reaction score
2,522
Checked shopee app permissions request list in google play. Only has view wlan connection and view network connection.

I think the permission to connect and disconnect from wlan is 'change network connectivity'

AI search said many network changing api are restricted to system apps or google apps after android 10.
 

jeff79

High Supremacy Member
Joined
May 26, 2001
Messages
34,334
Reaction score
2,522
Checked my phone settings wlan control, shopee app not inside the list. The shopee app version installed in my phone is 3.60.30. Not sure about newer version.

Anyway most of the apps in the list are system apps or the phone brand apps. Only non system apps are alipay, taobao and huawei health.
 

whatheheck

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
64,048
Reaction score
16,748
My Google play store app is set to do not auto-update apps. Other possible reasons include whether it's Android or an iOS device, the Android version and the Shopee app version. Or something else we don't know yet. But the version of Shopee app on my phone has Wi-Fi control access which cannot be disabled from the phone's Android system settings under Settings > Apps > Special app access > Wi-Fi control

Don't think it's possible for the app to update itself if you set Google play to disable auto update . It can probably download to storage new dynamic content to change it's display view etc but can't overwrite to reinstall a new version unless you click bah.
Majority of the apps needs the full internet access bah, if not, they cannot update app pages ,sync cart , perform checkouts with their servers , basically cannot function right?
 

coyote

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 20, 2000
Messages
86,823
Reaction score
29,251
Can someone please enlightened me?
I found that apps like Shopee & Lazada are able to read what users entered in their search bar and clipboard. Where is the data privacy committed?
Even worse, Shopee app is capable of turning on our Wi-Fi control and change our Android system settings. It updated my Shopee app when my phone was disconnected from the internet, turns off my phone's play media sound's volume to OFF/SILENT.
That is not respecting the user's personal preferences. More concerning is that the extra permissions approved by Google could pose a security threat by providing unapproved access to the user's device.
IMDA or the cyber-security authority needs to work on that before the breaches actually happened.
Edit: The Shopee app does not allow users to disable access to Wi-Fi control and Modify system settings in Android settings although those are available for Lazada app and AliExpress app. I believe Shopee's developer needs to be reined with a tight rein before the user's security and privacy are compromised.

User problem... If they cannot read what you typed in the search box, how they find you the products you wanted to buy???

Those things that you mentioned are under the "apps permission" in your phone. You were asked to "give permissions" to the app to do those things, you probably accepted those and forgotten about them. You can visit those CC or community hub and ask the young workers to help when they are free...As a fellow middle aged man, I agreed with you many of those could be daunting, especially to less IT savvy folks... But those are not IMDA fault...it's just how technologies evolved...
 
Last edited:

coyote

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 20, 2000
Messages
86,823
Reaction score
29,251
Sorry sir. Need to get the attention of the relevant authority and regulatory body. And wanted to know the general audience's experience for the questions raised.
Yea and they probably deleted the app unlike u.

That's true. It's strange tech savvy members here asking Imda to help them, when the simplest thing is to uninstall the app if you find them unsafe or get some help from the young children or adults how to configure their phones.
 

Emperor_Hippo

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Messages
27,665
Reaction score
11,424
That's true. It's strange tech savvy members here asking Imda to help them, when the simplest thing is to uninstall the app if you find them unsafe or get some help from the young children or adults how to configure their phones.
That one is not "tech savvy".

is just some dumb kiddie who just sprout random terms without knowing what the hell is going on and using "other ppl problem" as a shield.

stupid dun use smartphone. Cos clearly, the phone's smarter than TS.
 

whatheheck

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
64,048
Reaction score
16,748
That's true. It's strange tech savvy members here asking Imda to help them, when the simplest thing is to uninstall the app if you find them unsafe or get some help from the young children or adults how to configure their phones.

Noting what we search in the app is one thing , but kena this before
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/...zada-app-pasting-from-your-clipboard.7002037/
No idea if the app really copied anything though.


Anyway , basically from the permissions I posted above , all those under 'others' are classified as normal standard ones and enabled by default upon installation, no way to switch off natively .
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top