Singapore Mahjong Rules

[insouciantbutt]

This one is wrong.

I had to add on in that post mah, cos u didn't explain further that the tai status of the wind tiles depends on the round wind and the seat wind.

oh.. i didn't know lack of explanation is wrong.

what about lack of comprehension?

anyway i was simply answering to TS qns about winning with ping hu, so i guess if my first post caused some confusion then your post will help then.

 

[Kiwi8]

oh.. i didn't know lack of explanation is wrong.

what about lack of comprehension?

anyway i was simply answering to TS qns about winning with ping hu, so i guess if my first post caused some confusion then your post will help then.

Cos your that post, as it is, would be very misleading without further explanation mah. Cos it implies that all the wind tiles give 1 tai and so cannot be used for the Ping Hu pair.

 

[cleffa3000]

Only in sg mj kahlong zimo the hand is considered pinghu

For other rules its not

 

[sk8terb0i]

Any body can help me with this 'bao' scenario?

Player 1 has 4 tai shown (animals and flower) on the outside.
So he bao da pai.

Player 2 discards a white dragon and player 1 games.

However, the white dragon is the eye. But player 2 games the limit 5 tai. Due to 'ban se' and not because of the white dragon.

Does player 2 bao in this scenario?

 

[hermes76]

Any body can help me with this 'bao' scenario?

Player 1 has 4 tai shown (animals and flower) on the outside.
So he bao da pai.

Player 2 discards a white dragon and player 1 games.

However, the white dragon is the eye. But player 2 games the limit 5 tai. Due to 'ban se' and not because of the white dragon.

Does player 2 bao in this scenario?

Nope, no tai no bao.

Sent from OPPO R7SF using GAGT

 

[cleffa3000]

Any body can help me with this 'bao' scenario?

Player 1 has 4 tai shown (animals and flower) on the outside.
So he bao da pai.

Player 2 discards a white dragon and player 1 games.

However, the white dragon is the eye. But player 2 games the limit 5 tai. Due to 'ban se' and not because of the white dragon.

Does player 2 bao in this scenario?

If player 1 only have 1 white dragon dan diao, nvr reveal any tiles,no chi,pon,kan,
no bao.

If got reveal due to ban se, got bao

If player have 2 white dragon player 2 discard 1 white dragon got bao