
basically hedging their currency risks in other regions and country, global macro strategies u meant ?
my question is very simple
u say u scalp 1-5 pips but
how deep is ur stop.
wat is ur win/loss ratio?


..... Yes, I pay lots for the spread incurred. But, if you mastered the skill ... the win ratio can be surprisingly high (I am pleasantly surprised myself).
Just to let newbie know, I have been trading for close to 10+ years, and it is only recently that I am starting to be profitable.
I am very good at analyzing longer term trends and TA, on paper can make a lot of 'money', but when it comes to executing longer term positions ... most times I get knocked out by the short term volatility. Being proven 'right' in theory is no use. In trading, your profitability and bottom-line is your ultimate KPI.
I have never believe in ultra short term scalping (too much work) ... but ironically, it is this method that I least believe in that is showing the results.
Life is funny, I strive so hard to be a position (swing) trader ... but only to discover that I am a good scalper.
So, whatever floats your boat ... as long as you can make profit consistently ... that's the method that you should stick to.

how hard you need to work for those few pips?
......
saying there is a trend in the short term (5-10mins) is like saying you know what everyone is going to do today.
.
Let me ask a simple question here ....
Which would be simpler to do: Catching 100pips 100% of the time, or catching 5 pips 100% of the time?
The answer is obvious isn't it, if you have been trading forex long enough.
The idea is to first train consistency by identifying price actions with good profit pattern, always..... there is definitely more patterns (call it trends, head & shoulders, double tops, consolidation, anything that you like ....) to identify in 10sec charts than 1hr charts isn't it? For one, hourly, daily charts, will take many hours to form a good pattern, not to mention days .... and good trends .... only occur 30% of the time. Which means 70% of the time is basically price action trading between support and resistance levels, .... no trend that is.
2nd, with consistency, the trading volume via leverage can be increased.
10K lot - 1pip = 1dollar profit (before commission cost)
100K lot - 1pip = 10dollar profit
200K lot - 1pip = 20dollar profit.
5pip per trade = 100dollar profit.
Just some basic maths here using leverage.
I believe you should catch the geise of what i m saying here. Low pip profit, high consistency versus what you do now, high pip profit, low consistency. To increase the profit, increase the trading volume proportionally.



At least there are several things we agree on
No, Forex is not easy money. This is a misconception. Neither is getting 100% win rate for 5pips easy. Needs long period of training, improvements,etc. I started off from less than 70% win rate to currently ~80%, sometimes hitting 100%. Took me close to a year to handle the consistency. Honestly, there is no sitting on the laurel to say i am there. To say that, would be to risk dropping off the cliff.
Trader's psychology is very important. If one has money stress, or time-stressed to perform, one will not perform almost magically.
It is a maths game which you are right. Money management is key. Win rate, versus risk reward ratio. The system that i work with has a win rate of at least 70%, 80% and above would be good. Risk reward ratio is ave loss of 6-8pip, ave win of 3-6pip. That would be abt 1:2 roughly. However the ave pip win (including losses) must always be above 1.5 Max loss per trade is 12 pip, per day is 24pip. And the emphasis here is consistency (i.e. win rate), not win qty (how many pips). This is practically very achievable.
However in taking positions, whether carry trade or day trades, i agree with you. My win rate is much lower. 65% at current count. Risk Reward ratio is ~ 1:1 (i.e. the ave win and ave loss is the same). I don't think anything above 80% is possible, unless i have a crystal ball
Well .... there are certain points which we agree upon and not .... but let's leave it as that.
I believe this forum was not meant to trash out disagreements between our core values .... rather it is to see where one trader's system can complement the other, or where one could help out the other. How is that? Otherwise this thread would go on and on .... unproductively.