cosmothecat
High Supremacy Member
- Joined
- Jan 13, 2010
- Messages
- 37,535
- Reaction score
- 21,457
Hi Boltstorm,
...
Since the people they are targeting are people who don't have the right qualification. Therefore, it is only reasonable to have this measure to protect company interest?
....
Ok, this is the part where the dilemma comes in. If an aspiring trader has already proven track record, with consistent profits ... why would this trader want to join a trading firm then? He can easily multiply his $1000 into $2k, into $4k, into $8k, into $16k, into $32k, into hundreds of thousands in a few years time.
Which means, most aspiring traders who look to join these proprietary trading firms DO NOT have proven track record, and are NOT able to derive consistent profits from their existing trading method(s) ... in that case, why would the company wants to employ these "traders" then?
I can tell you that a trader that trades his own money and a trader that trades the firm's money have a totally different trading mindset and risk management mindset. Those dealers that trade for firms, they dared to average down (a practice known as shading) and to take profit when the market rebound, as the credit line and financing is from company's fund. Thus, the trader does not panic when the tide goes against him. They have "holding power". Stress, yes, Panic ... not so.
But, if you are trading your own money, and to use the same method as above ... more likely than not you will start to panic once you average down a few times, and the trend is still against you. There is a likelihood that you will close your positions and take the loses before they widen further - this prevents the chance and possibility of a profit on a re-bounce.
Take for example, EUR/USD during the last few days ... it crashed to a low, and then re-bounced strongly. For those with holding power trying to time a reversal, even if they got in slightly earlier, they could keep on averaging down and wait for the reversal to happen ... in the end making profits.
