Telco roaming discussion thread

WaterDrinker

Junior Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2023
Messages
97
Reaction score
35
Noticed that there isn't a tread discussing roaming speeds of different telcos. Wonder what telco would be the best for smooth data usage. Post your roaming speedtests overseas.
 

xsoldix

Supremacy Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2010
Messages
8,918
Reaction score
1,672
Noticed that there isn't a tread discussing roaming speeds of different telcos. Wonder what telco would be the best for smooth data usage. Post your roaming speedtests overseas.
No thread for this because roaming speed is not dependent on local telco. It is their partner telco that is providing the service at the destination.
Very hard to do a comparison bro.
 

froztheart

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2012
Messages
10,273
Reaction score
4,451
Noticed that there isn't a tread discussing roaming speeds of different telcos. Wonder what telco would be the best for smooth data usage. Post your roaming speedtests overseas.
All on the SLA etc. that is between local MNOs/MVNOs and their corresponding counterparts. Not privy and tons of factors so roaming usage experience is a rather subjective topic.

If you are comparing deals across our MNOs & MVNOs then it makes better comparison as a thread.
 

xiaofan

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
37,299
Reaction score
12,682
Noticed that there isn't a tread discussing roaming speeds of different telcos. Wonder what telco would be the best for smooth data usage. Post your roaming speedtests overseas.

Not so much data as it is location specific and roaming partner specific.

Which locations are your specificly interested?

I tend to think SpeedTest results may not be so important in this case, but rather user experiences sharing.
 
Last edited:

xiaofan

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
37,299
Reaction score
12,682
One example good info with some speedtest results.

Guangzhou, China
Zym, Maxx and SIMBA

These are the lines I brought with me for holiday while in Guangzhou

All roaming, while in the hotel
  • ZYM: average 165 mbps 5G
  • Maxx : average 294.03 mbps 5G ( was using the shared 600GB )
  • Simba: average 130 mbps 5G ( 16 dollar recharged package 500GB )
Streaming Youtube using data plan and not hotel wifi:
  • zym : smooth but no prolong using ( data plan not as much as both Maxx and Simba )
  • Maxx : smooth
  • Simba: smooth
None of them exceed 10GB data...

Some places loading the WeChat mini program website experience in restaurants
  • ZYM: smooth ( support China Mobile / Telecom / Unicom ) --- mostly connected China Mobile / Telecom during the trip
  • Maxx: smooth (support China Mobile / Telecom ) ---mostly connected China Mobile / Telecom during the trip
  • Simba: will struggle as it trying to get hold -- possible due to only one roaming partners China Telecom

Metro Experience: CNN news, surfing website, youtube, shopping taobao
  • ZYM: smooth
  • Maxx: smooth
  • Simba: quite stable, sometimes at different stops will slow

Some of my friends who are on Eight 5G+ Power Plan and Ultra Plan had some issues connecting when attempt to pay the toll passenger entry to take the underground metro train.
These are limited to places... they able to resolve after I provided hotspot for them to use SIMBA and it was very stable.

None of my data plan hits more than 5GB per day while visiting places
 

Groudon

Member
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
363
Reaction score
148
One important thing to note is that there are barely any 5G SA roaming available at the moment, even if you can get 5G SA on a local SIM in that location, many times for SG SIM it is only able to roam onto 4G/5G NSA networks and 5G NSA is getting quite limited, e.g. in China.
 

gapboy

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2003
Messages
20,774
Reaction score
6,510
in Jeju it is all 4g network i dont get any 5g on ST roaming partners like SK Telecom but still works fine
 

firesong

Supremacy Member
Deluxe Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2001
Messages
8,952
Reaction score
4,952
To add, I think the SLAs matter also.

I was in JB, Malaysia in September, and in Adelaide/Melbourne, Australia earlier in May/June.

I have a SIMBA plan and had ported to Vivifi for roaming data. I left both on Auto-Roaming.

There were times when both lines connected to the same carrier. I did have moments when I tried switching carriers for fun, just to compare whether they were equal. I recognise this is not scientific - tested while stationery and waiting for food, and while moving from point to point, or even waiting on a tour bus for tourists who were delaying the bus while doing a Great Ocean Road tour.. However, I did observe that my data connected via Vivifi was generally faster/more reliable than on SIMBA.

In JB, the difference was less stark, likely because we were around the malls and not outdoors. I concluded that SIMBA was still useful - having data is still better than no-data. If I had a choice, I chose Vivifi nearly every time. And there were places in Australia when my iPhone displayed the Satellite-only Mode for both lines cos we were just too far out for any cellular connection.
 

froztheart

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2012
Messages
10,273
Reaction score
4,451
To add, I think the SLAs matter also.

I was in JB, Malaysia in September, and in Adelaide/Melbourne, Australia earlier in May/June.

I have a SIMBA plan and had ported to Vivifi for roaming data. I left both on Auto-Roaming.

There were times when both lines connected to the same carrier. I did have moments when I tried switching carriers for fun, just to compare whether they were equal. I recognise this is not scientific - tested while stationery and waiting for food, and while moving from point to point, or even waiting on a tour bus for tourists who were delaying the bus while doing a Great Ocean Road tour.. However, I did observe that my data connected via Vivifi was generally faster/more reliable than on SIMBA.

In JB, the difference was less stark, likely because we were around the malls and not outdoors. I concluded that SIMBA was still useful - having data is still better than no-data. If I had a choice, I chose Vivifi nearly every time. And there were places in Australia when my iPhone displayed the Satellite-only Mode for both lines cos we were just too far out for any cellular connection.
Yes, I strongly believe primarily SLA definitely matter since it defines the bandwidth provided for the amount paid. Then the other factors like user's device. location, time etc. come into play.

Vivifi being on ST highly likely have "better' SLA compared to SIMBA thus the differing experience and yes, having data is any time better than not having data in this day and age.
 

minimalis

Senior Member
Joined
May 5, 2001
Messages
516
Reaction score
53
Was recently in JB on SIMBA and it seems to be logging onto U Mobile rather than the other networks like Maxis or Celcom. U Mobile did not allow tethering on iPhone, which resulted in a lot of inconvenience.
 

Blacky

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2002
Messages
1,676
Reaction score
780
Was recently in JB on SIMBA and it seems to be logging onto U Mobile rather than the other networks like Maxis or Celcom. U Mobile did not allow tethering on iPhone, which resulted in a lot of inconvenience.
A mobile wifi will solve this problem.

Maxis is not 1 of Simba's roaming partners, unless you are on the other 3 telcos

I've tried connecting to Celcom, Digi & U-mobile. Celcom shows 3G, Digi is on 5G/4G but speed is kinda slow. Only U-mobile gave me the fastest & most stable connection thruout.
 

username03

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2021
Messages
932
Reaction score
228
Was recently in JB on SIMBA and it seems to be logging onto U Mobile rather than the other networks like Maxis or Celcom. U Mobile did not allow tethering on iPhone, which resulted in a lot of inconvenience.
At least not onto Yes, which I previously experienced, which the mobile data is almost not working despite being full bar.

As for tethering, I'm auto roaming with simba and auto locked onto umobile, can do tethering no issues on android.
 

Kitaro9202

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
44,158
Reaction score
1,965
I notice when in jb I go those shop house to eat whether I using Singapore or Malaysia number most of the time I can't load any web page
Funny is I exit the shop got no issue
Not sure why jb like that lol
 

loganrunning

Master Member
Joined
May 12, 2017
Messages
3,848
Reaction score
2,360
One important thing to note is that there are barely any 5G SA roaming available at the moment, even if you can get 5G SA on a local SIM in that location, many times for SG SIM it is only able to roam onto 4G/5G NSA networks and 5G NSA is getting quite limited, e.g. in China.

just one data point (i was expecting 4G roaming with reported lack of 5G SA roaming).

Was in Chongqing a few months ago. Was connected to 5G SA all the way (if one believes Netmonitor and Netmonster apps :)). Didn't need the speed, just grateful for the connectivity and no data dropping/data blackholes.

Was roaming on Simba, btw
 

xiaofan

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
37,299
Reaction score
12,682
My wife needed to travel to China pretty often this year. She has good experiences with SingTel hi! Postpaid plan (eSIM on her iPhone 14, main SIM is SingTel hi! S$15.28 plan with roaming data disabled) for roaming in China (Guangzhou, Fuzhou, Xiamen, Putian). She only uses eight S$8 plan for roaming voice call and backup for the roaming data (only 3GB).

I seldom travel myself. The following is my personal expenses with roaming for my Dec 2025 short trip to Fujian, China (Xiamen and Quanzhou). I will try again for the upcoming short trip in Dec 2026.

Just some simple tests in Southern Fujian.

My ranking.
1) giga Shopee China Travel eSIM
2) Gomo 5G plan (my brother's)
3) eight S$8 4G plan
4) SIMBA S$12 plan and Cuniq S$9.9 4G plan (Similar performance)
 

yotoden

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
1,131
Reaction score
101
Many shops offered free wifi to tackle the weak cell signal especially for QR payment.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top