It will be good if you go down to have a sample of it, our definition of masculinity may be different. Well anyway my take is since its everyday use i presume something more budgeted so i gave 2 lists of my preferences. Have tried these and like it.
Budget
1)John Varvatos Artisan Black
2)Burberry London for Men
3)Issey Miyake L'Eau d'Issey for Men
Spender
1)Terre d'Hermes for Men (Tried in shop only, haven't buy yet but kinda fits your decription)
2)YSL L'Homme
3)Hugo Boss The Scent
Good list. Though JV isn't such a budget frag. They charge decent dough for it in shops. And the scent doesn't last long. Among all I can recommend Terre d Hermes and possibly Leau dissey. Tangs sells that 200ml bottle for RIDICULOUS cheap.
Budget
1)John Varvatos Artisan Black
2)Burberry London for Men
3)Issey Miyake L'Eau d'Issey for Men
Spender
1)Terre d'Hermes for Men (Tried in shop only, haven't buy yet but kinda fits your decription)
2)YSL L'Homme
3)Hugo Boss The Scent