Upgrade or Overhaul this i7-930 Rig?

darkarn

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2005
Messages
10,626
Reaction score
186
Hi guys, I need a bit of input over this situation. You see, my bro has a rig with the following specs:

  • i7-930
  • MSI X58 Pro-E Mobo
  • 3 x 2GB Kingston HyperX PC3-12800 (1600MHZ) RAM (triple channel kit)
  • Sapphire AMD Radeon HD 7850
  • Coolermaster Real Power M620 (i.e. Modular 620W PSU)
  • Samsung SSD 840 PRO (256GB)
  • Seagate/Samsung ST2000DL004 HD204UI (i.e. 2TB HDD)
  • Liteon DVD drive/writer
  • Sound Blaster Z
  • Coolermaster HAF 922 Casing
  • Built in March 2010 (soundcard, SSD, newer HDD and newer graphics card added in much later)

Also here's some requirements:

Use Cases: 1080p gaming (most intense games so far are Battlefield 4, Star Wars Battlefront; already facing slight issue with Battlefront, some games already not supported based on requirements alone), web browsing, watching 1080p videos, office work.

Budget: approx $750

Reusing: DVD drive, soundcard, casing, SSD, HDD, PSU (if need be)

So, should he upgrade the graphics card or is an overhaul due?

To us, upgrading is the cheapest option but something tells me that the CPU is starting to bottleneck the performance. Also, the triple-channel RAM is a concern since the market is mostly double-channel RAM; can just put in another 3 x 2GB sticks?

Doing an overhaul means being able to go for newer technology like USB 3.0 (yes, this rig has no USB 3.0 ports :eek:) but the parts are still working and we are not sure what to do with them after the overhaul (Selling is possible option but we don't think can fetch anything). We are trying to be not that wasteful either...

So, what do you all think?

Thanks!
 

superzheny

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 20, 2011
Messages
545
Reaction score
11
I will say upgrade instead of overhaul.

6gb ram still survivable if you make sure to kill background processes. You can always just buy a dual channel kit 8gb and run in dual channel.

For your processor you can try to further overclock it. Or buy a cheap second hand higherend i7 or maybe even a xeon if your mobo can support.
 

Koenig168

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2007
Messages
10,109
Reaction score
1,783
Minimum CPU requirement for decent gaming is i5-2500K so overhaul is the better option.
 

cKm

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2003
Messages
934
Reaction score
4
I would say upgrade. Personally still using a i7 860 with a GTX680. Most games no problems running high. Probably just need a gfx upgrade to run ultra.
 

herman1314

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2014
Messages
1,032
Reaction score
2
Hi guys, I need a bit of input over this situation. You see, my bro has a rig with the following specs:

  • i7-930
  • MSI X58 Pro-E Mobo
  • 3 x 2GB Kingston HyperX PC3-12800 (1600MHZ) RAM (triple channel kit)
  • Sapphire AMD Radeon HD 7850
  • Coolermaster Real Power M620 (i.e. Modular 620W PSU)
  • Samsung SSD 840 PRO (256GB)
  • Seagate/Samsung ST2000DL004 HD204UI (i.e. 2TB HDD)
  • Liteon DVD drive/writer
  • Sound Blaster Z
  • Coolermaster HAF 922 Casing
  • Built in March 2010 (soundcard, SSD, newer HDD and newer graphics card added in much later)

Also here's some requirements:

Use Cases: 1080p gaming (most intense games so far are Battlefield 4, Star Wars Battlefront; already facing slight issue with Battlefront, some games already not supported based on requirements alone), web browsing, watching 1080p videos, office work.

Budget: approx $750

Reusing: DVD drive, soundcard, casing, SSD, HDD, PSU (if need be)

So, should he upgrade the graphics card or is an overhaul due?

To us, upgrading is the cheapest option but something tells me that the CPU is starting to bottleneck the performance. Also, the triple-channel RAM is a concern since the market is mostly double-channel RAM; can just put in another 3 x 2GB sticks?

Doing an overhaul means being able to go for newer technology like USB 3.0 (yes, this rig has no USB 3.0 ports :eek:) but the parts are still working and we are not sure what to do with them after the overhaul (Selling is possible option but we don't think can fetch anything). We are trying to be not that wasteful either...

So, what do you all think?

Thanks!
i7 930 still buay pai, no need upgrade(might wanna oc). if you want usb 3.0 can get usb 3.0 pci-e add-on card for the mobo. if want more ram should be able to place a 4gb stick inside, but check to see if compatible first.
 

Elijahonli

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2008
Messages
25,846
Reaction score
159
maybe can consider getting a gtx970/ AMD290/390 first see if there is a bottleneck
 

alvintan89

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 22, 2010
Messages
2,434
Reaction score
4
I would say upgrade the gpu, psu and ram.

Graphics card to >GTX970. PSU time to change as already 5years and RAM 8GB or 16GB
 

Goodshot

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 20, 2013
Messages
62,640
Reaction score
4,528
Hd7850 can't really play intensive game , so....change higher gfx
 

darkarn

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2005
Messages
10,626
Reaction score
186
Wow, thanks for the fast responses! Here's what I am thinking so far based on your responses:

1. Overhaul v.s. Upgrade?: Hmm. Seems to me that there are almost equal number of supporters on both sides, which means that I should do an eventual overhaul. In other words, slowly upgrade each part until Skylake prices are right, then one-shot change the CPU+Mobo+RAM?

2. Overclocking: Can consider, give me some time to look up the guides for doing so. But in the meantime, am I right to say that I should look into changing from stock cooler to something else?

3. CPU: I did source for Socket 1366 CPUs. Best place to get them seems to be from Taobao. I am not that comfortable with that option though so I think going to stick with the i7 930 for now.

4. RAM: A quick check of the manual shows that I can use 4GB sticks, up to a maximum of 24GB. RAM speed can be 1600(OC)/1333/1066/800. Am I right to say that I should replace the current kit if upgrading the RAM due to compatibility issues? (i.e. cannot mix HyperX RAM kit with say, singular sticks of ValueRAM?)

5. GPU: This looks like the first place to start with, so I should be looking at slightly more high-end this time round compared to previous cards?

6. PSU: Somewhat surprised that I should upgrade it; was under the impression that it can last for 10 years rather than 5 years. But then again, having too little wattage seems to limit my options a bit. So, if need to change, will 750W be good this time?

Thanks again for responses, keep them coming! :)
 

Elijahonli

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2008
Messages
25,846
Reaction score
159
Wow, thanks for the fast responses! Here's what I am thinking so far based on your responses:

1. Overhaul v.s. Upgrade?: Hmm. Seems to me that there are almost equal number of supporters on both sides, which means that I should do an eventual overhaul. In other words, slowly upgrade each part until Skylake prices are right, then one-shot change the CPU+Mobo+RAM?

2. Overclocking: Can consider, give me some time to look up the guides for doing so. But in the meantime, am I right to say that I should look into changing from stock cooler to something else?

3. CPU: I did source for Socket 1366 CPUs. Best place to get them seems to be from Taobao. I am not that comfortable with that option though so I think going to stick with the i7 930 for now.

4. RAM: A quick check of the manual shows that I can use 4GB sticks, up to a maximum of 24GB. RAM speed can be 1600(OC)/1333/1066/800. Am I right to say that I should replace the current kit if upgrading the RAM due to compatibility issues? (i.e. cannot mix HyperX RAM kit with say, singular sticks of ValueRAM?)

5. GPU: This looks like the first place to start with, so I should be looking at slightly more high-end this time round compared to previous cards?

6. PSU: Somewhat surprised that I should upgrade it; was under the impression that it can last for 10 years rather than 5 years. But then again, having too little wattage seems to limit my options a bit. So, if need to change, will 750W be good this time?

Thanks again for responses, keep them coming! :)
620w is still more than enough for most single GPUs
 

koikoe

Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2010
Messages
381
Reaction score
0
i am also using i7-930 since 2010 too.
my rig --->

the processor is still very strong imo
i only changed my gpu and increased ram from 6gb to 16gb over the 5yrs

if you want to get a new comp, i would say, overhaul and get new parts, and use i7 as backup computer
 

GrimaH

Master Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2007
Messages
2,901
Reaction score
49
You can use dual channel RAM with X58 boards. There's no need to go out of your way to look for old triple-channel RAM unless they're available for cheap.
 

Koenig168

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2007
Messages
10,109
Reaction score
1,783
Unless you can get RAM cheap, there is no point upgrading the DDR3 memory if you intend to move to Skylake eventually, which uses DDR4. 6GB should suffice in the interim.

I would say go for the GPU upgrade and possibly the PSU as well. These components can be moved over to the Skylake rig later.
 

SEvsNK

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2004
Messages
22,594
Reaction score
514
Maybe the next Gen then upgrade processor ba. Unless your hand itchy and want something new. Gfx card can last for another year or go for an Nvidia gtx 970 or an AMD R9 390. You'll be able to see a spike up in graphical performance in gaming just by changing the gfx card
 

Gymrat76

Supremacy Member
Joined
May 8, 2003
Messages
7,851
Reaction score
80
I just upgraded from an i7 920 last week. One of the biggest difference I've felt was in heat generation - when I played games such as Witcher my room would feel like a furnace, this was because both CPU and GPU would heat up considerably. Now, I'm surprised that it doesn't run so hot anymore - GPU still hits 80C but CPU much cooler <60C during gaming
 

aErOpLaNe911

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2005
Messages
650
Reaction score
75
I'm on the following since 2010:
I7 920 (stock)
ROG Rampage III Gene (bought brand new in 2015)
H105 (bought 2015)
Team Elite 6GB
Crucial 12GB (bought 2015)
Evo 840 1TB (bought 2015)
290 Tri-X (bought 2015)
LG Blu-Ray Writer (bought 2015)
AX760 (bought 2015)
Corsair 350D (bought 2015)

Practically a new rig, but I was doing piecemeal upgrades. On hindsight, I should have just done a one-time upgrade for not much more money.

Plays GTA V Online just fine.

I can / will wait till Cannonlake.
 
Last edited:

darkarn

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2005
Messages
10,626
Reaction score
186
Thanks again for the response guys! Here's what I am thinking now after seeing them and also showing this thread to my bro and talking to him on what he exactly needs e.t.c.:

1. Overhaul or Upgrade?: My bro decided that he wants to use the parts as much as possible. This means that he is more towards some upgrading now, but slowly heading to an overhaul, rather than an outright overhaul.

2. Mobo+CPU+RAM: Seeing how Skylake (and eventually Cannonlake so on) is using completely different socket and RAM type, these three parts will not be changed as of now; they will be used until they die off or something lol.

3. CPU Cooler: Looks like I should change the cooler after all after seeing some reviews; am shocked at how just $50 can reduce the temps greatly. Changing it also means that I can do some minor overclocking to tide over. Only thing is to find a cooler that works for both Socket 1151 and Socket 1366 since this will be something I will bring over during the overhaul. (as higher-end Skylake CPUs do not have stock coolers). Will be using air cooling cos' not comfortable with water cooling :o

4. Overclocking: I will most probably try some slight overclocking. Perhaps push from 2.8 GHz to say, 3.2 GHz? Note that this CPU is a D0 stepping, which I think should do fine?

5. GPU: This will most probably be upgraded too, but bro says that as he is just playing BF4 and it is pretty smooth, and also he not going to touch those newer AAA titles for now (yes, he not playing Battlefront for now cos' of server issues, just found out sorry), he is ok with the HD 7850. In other words, if got new game that he is interested in come out, we will then upgrade the GPU.

6. PSU: I will play by ear on this for now; will upgrade if necessary (e.g. if new GPU comes in). I am not sure if this is the best approach though :X

7. Planning: So with all these considered, here's how I will go about doing these in this order (if part is not stated in the list, it means I am reusing).

  • CPU Cooler (and overclock)
  • PSU (?)
  • GPU (?)
  • CPU + Mobo + RAM
  • Front Panel Ports (if needed)

Thanks again for responses, keep them coming! :)
 
Last edited:

herman1314

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2014
Messages
1,032
Reaction score
2
Cooler best if you buy used. Carousell has a prolimatech megahalems for $35 and coolermaster v8 for $30 from yorino1, both will cool that i7 like a beast and allow for decent oc(as long as your case can fit). Just nd thermal paste
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top