punggolkid
Senior Member
- Joined
- Feb 29, 2008
- Messages
- 1,778
- Reaction score
- 6
Will be going to US again
Should I choose Qatar with 6h transit in Doha 1.7k, Emirates flight about 3h transit in Dubai 1.8k or Cathay Pacific 1h transit 2k?
This is my ranking of each airline from best to, err, "worst". They're based on the factors I would consider if I were you.
Airline Service: Emirates, Cathay, Qatar
Airline Quality: Emirates/Cathay/Qatar (IMO they're all on par)
Plane Comfort: Emirates, Qatar, Cathay
Cost: Qatar, Emirates, Cathay
Transit Location: Cathay, Emirates, Qatar
Transit Time of Day: Cathay, Emirates/Qatar (transit during the wee hours)
Transit Time: Cathay, Emirates, Qatar
For me, the overall winner is Emirates, if you do not mind the red-eye on the first leg, since the transit can be quite painful in DXB so early in the morning, plus truckloads of people offloaded from A380s heading inbound to DXB may make it crowded (not sure if that's still the case with the new A380 concourse). Still, Emirates definitely offers the best value for money out of the 3.
If Emirates is not for you, I'd pick Cathay over Qatar. The food and entertainment are more to my liking. Transit in HKG is easy and smooth, and with the short duration of the transit, I'd say it's even less of an issue. Only one minor issue is the tendency for delays with Cathay. Their planes are older than EK and QR.
I'm neutral on Qatar, but being the cheapest amongst all, I'd say it's not a bad option. Qatar on its own is rather good. Ranks amongst the best airlines in the world.
And... of course if cost is no object, I will still pick SIA. Has the most comfortable Y I've been on in awhile. YMMV though.
Have a good trip!