Quick question:
How much corkage charge is worth paying or are you willing to pay if you byob to your favourite restaurant?
one of my fave rest don't charge corkage; that's why it's my favourite hahahaha
for other restaurants, to be honest personally i don't include the cost of the bottle that i bought as part of the 'overall expenditure' as usually i buy these in advance and it's a sunk cost.
these days, i'm bringing my own wine wherever I go and i'm cheapskate enough to ask which days they don't charge corkage (if any).
as for how much i'm willing, it all depends really:
1) I check out their winelist online to assess whether it's worth buying from them in terms of their selection and their pricing
- If they have a good range at a good price and it clearly shows that they have put in effort to select their wines, i would gladly pay to drink them. Depending who i'm with, it could be a bottle, it could be a glass. I judge an establishment's wine program by their 'by-the-glass' selection; because anyone can sell big brand names and first growth bordeaux. but it's the ones that do their homework and put in the effort to select wines that deliver on quality and price which may not be as well known but they know how to introduce the suggest these wines to you to match their food; these are the ones I don't mind paying (assuming good price)
2) I check out their corkage charge to see if it's worth bringing my own stuff
- so if the range is uninspired or the markups are too ridiculous; i may bring my own. for chinese restaurants i'm too used to ZERO corkage so anything more than ZERO, i just drink tea. (which i love also). for western restaurants, if there are no free corkage days and depending on the restaurant (casual, semi casual, fine etc...) the acceptable price range depends on the level of restaurants.
- but my usual upper limit is $50 because the premise of corkage is to pay for the additional service the wait-staff has to do like opening bottles, glassware, chilling, decanting, pouring etc... by principle it should
NOT be a pricing mechanism to force people to buy their own wines instead. that's why i don't understand why some restaurants can justify a $100 corkage. What on earth am i paying for? If your restaurant as a great wine list (great doesn't meant big labels) and within reasonable pricing; i would gladly buy a bottle rather than bring my own. but if the wine list is fancy and overpriced AND still charging me $100 to bring my own bottle; then it's clearly extortion. Harsh words but that's my opinion and perhaps i'm idealistic in this way as restaurants are businesses too.
- it also probably doesn't help that when i look at a wine list at most restaurants here i know which importers they got it from and most likely i'm a private customer of those importers and i get it at that lower price point. so a really great wine list is something that is priced reasonably, showcases a selection of that may be off the radar but overdelivering on the quality or having aged bottles (those i don't mind paying a premium due to the rarity).
- my comparison are restaurants overseas in asia and europe for both casual, semi fine and fine dining. due to a stronger wine culture in those countries and high competition; the good establishments have a really well selected range at prices that you can't say no to; even considering currency exchange.
that's my long answer. short answer, nowadays i go for free corkage chinese restaurants.
western dining, either i order cocktails (if they're good) or if their wine list is good then their wine. if not either by the glass or i bring a bottle if corkage is reasonable.