Working Shoe for Young Exec - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

Edwardtzy

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 12, 2014
Messages
528
Reaction score
0
Hi guys! How does Carmina's Rain last compares to the Soller last in terms of fit?
 
Last edited:

adriosz

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2013
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
Am commisioning a similar pair like this but colourwise in dark brown Ilcea radica museum leather.. cos i figured i have too many classics; oxfords, brogues n d likes already..wanted something modern n edgy to add to my timeless designs collection..n to also support an awesome local talent who goes out of his way to pursue his craft and passion to bring the art of traditional shoemaking right here in Sg..vetted n verified to be truly handmade in every sense (except for closing the uppers) n im sure some of u will know who im talking about..decided to post after being a quiet observer all these years cos too much of our sartorial excess has gone to the Europeans n Japanese already..not saying its wrong..who can resist really the sharpness of yohei and the refinement of masaru..but for shoes enthusiasts like us..a local talent like this is a godsend... am confident it will turn out well..even requested a higher SPI(his average is 8) just to see how his workmanship fares against the usual bespoke suspects..also im looking forward to test how comfortable the shoes will be with the supple baby goat lining chosen..truly soft n pampering to the touch...stay tuned.

65be1bebefe22570c972c0c9567bea24.jpg
 
Last edited:

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
Am commisioning a similar pair like this but colourwise in dark brown Ilcea radica museum leather.. cos i figured i have too many classics; oxfords, brogues n d likes already..wanted something modern n edgy to add to my timeless designs collection..n to also support an awesome local talent who goes out of his way to pursue his craft and passion to bring the art of traditional shoemaking right here in Sg..vetted n verified to be truly handmade in every sense (except for closing the uppers) n im sure some of u will know who im talking about..decided to post after being a quiet observer all these years cos too much of our sartorial excess has gone to the Europeans n Japanese already..not saying its wrong..who can resist really the sharpness of yohei and the refinement of masaru..but for shoes enthusiasts like us..a local talent like this is a godsend... am confident it will turn out well..even requested a higher SPI(his average is 8) just to see how his workmanship fares against the usual bespoke suspects..also im looking forward to test how comfortable the shoes will be with the supple baby goat lining chosen..truly soft n pampering to the touch...stay tuned.

65be1bebefe22570c972c0c9567bea24.jpg

You're probably referring to Josh.
I'm a fan of what he's doing definitely. And I'm also glad local folk are going to him. He's someone who takes his craft seriously and has his priorities straightened out.

When I saw the pic (before I read your text) my heart sank.
Luckily, you'd gone for him instead of the maker in the picture.
 
Last edited:

adriosz

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2013
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
While in SG in my drive(lust) to go local, i also MTOed a Marx B dorsal cut shoe. I like how the light falls on the dorsal fin on d toecap and the cut will add variety to my otherwise collection of closefitting "sharp" shoes, matching well with jeans and chinos esp. The dorsal cut is their premium range and the italian calf uppers feels n looks much much better than their lower ranges. Leather sole and lining, hand welted and apparently Made in Japan. For the price, i did not bother to enquire on the degree of "handmadeness", no point really but close inspection shows quality uppers n construction good enough for the price and options given. Finishing, construction n stitches are neat. I chose a dual patina of dark brown n burgundy tones with darker hues on the toes, eyelets n ankles plus a bevelled waist. Lead time 6-8 weeks. This shd turn out good as well especially if u choose the right colours. If u ask me why i did not go to EEA since i wanna go local, its because they did not bother to entertain my enquiries.They were the first i enquired actually. Bern from Marx B on the other hand specially open the shop on Sunday at short notice to entertain my whims, sacrificing precious Sunday family time. Felt guilty when d wife/gf walked in but he was all smiles n patient plus threw in some worthy freebies. Ok till the next time.

13000275_1364753240205279_5301307597076656270_n.jpg

10363608_1331458893534714_7485748259082752421_n.jpg



Am commisioning a similar pair like this but colourwise in dark brown Ilcea radica museum leather.. cos i figured i have too many classics; oxfords, brogues n d likes already..wanted something modern n edgy to add to my timeless designs collection..n to also support an awesome local talent who goes out of his way to pursue his craft and passion to bring the art of traditional shoemaking right here in Sg..vetted n verified to be truly handmade in every sense (except for closing the uppers) n im sure some of u will know who im talking about..decided to post after being a quiet observer all these years cos too much of our sartorial excess has gone to the Europeans n Japanese already..not saying its wrong..who can resist really the sharpness of yohei and the refinement of masaru..but for shoes enthusiasts like us..a local talent like this is a godsend... am confident it will turn out well..even requested a higher SPI(his average is 8) just to see how his workmanship fares against the usual bespoke suspects..also im looking forward to test how comfortable the shoes will be with the supple baby goat lining chosen..truly soft n pampering to the touch...stay tuned.

65be1bebefe22570c972c0c9567bea24.jpg
 

jonleelk

Master Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
4,122
Reaction score
97
You're probably referring to Josh.
I'm a fan of what he's doing definitely. And I'm also glad local folk are going to him. He's someone who takes his craft seriously and has his priorities straightened out.

When I saw the pic (before I read your text) my heart sank.
Luckily, you'd gone for him instead of the maker in the picture.

Josh makes every pair of shoes by hand himself?
 

jonleelk

Master Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
4,122
Reaction score
97
Aye.
Apart from the closing of the uppers (sewing machine) as mentioned earlier.

Able to share his price range for MTO and bestspoke (as in custom last)? I like to support locals, but don't feel quite right when the shoes are mass made in Vietnam.

Can PM me if not good to post. :)
 

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
Able to share his price range for MTO and bestspoke (as in custom last)? I like to support locals, but don't feel quite right when the shoes are mass made in Vietnam.

Can PM me if not good to post. :)

Actually I do not know his exact prices.
But let me message him and get back to you guys.
 
Last edited:

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
Ok.
So for Josh...
He offers an MTO service at $1800.
And also bespoke at $3500.
Blind welting at the waist is an extra $100 SGD.
 

adriosz

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2013
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
Ok.
So for Josh...
He offers an MTO service at $1800.
And also bespoke at $3500.
Blind welting at the waist is an extra $100 SGD.

Yes, these are the base prices with surcharges for various options. He also has a blake option for $1200. Did not want to disclose the prices earlier but im sure its ok now since u have msg him.

Im glad i chose him and if his workmanship is up to standard will commission future ones with him. Compared to overseas MTO, u can be assured a great fit as his workshop is here and iron out all ur doubts face to face with your own personal shoemaker. He does everything by hand..most overseas MTOs, like St Crispins, who are handmades as well still does the outsole stitch via machine.He uses top leather DuPuy n Ilcea n JR. Details like wooden shanks used, no synthetics, and he stacks d heel old school layer by layer with a japanese like smooth finish. Compared to local MTOs n craftsmanship, i stand to be corrected but he is d next best thing to handmade traditional art of shoemaking.its d real deal and the next best option is to go to Italy really for this kind of experience. Also his is not a shop like others in SG, he is the artisan n "factory" itself. IMHO, the price is worth it. U are paying for top quality materials n craftsmanship. The only cons are that he outsource his uppers closing but the "pros" here are that its outsourced to Italy and the closings are top notch. Compare his samples side by side..eg his adelaide vs another adelaide..u will see the stitches, brouges n perforations r superior in detail.

Regarding his boxes, yes, they are another plus point. Shows his high attention to detail. It allows the shoes to breath nicely amongst other benefits. IIRC its sourced from Australia and has a good social cause behind it.
 

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
Yes, these are the base prices with surcharges for various options. He also has a blake option for $1200. Did not want to disclose the prices earlier but im sure its ok now since u have msg him.

Im glad i chose him and if his workmanship is up to standard will commission future ones with him. Compared to overseas MTO, u can be assured a great fit as his workshop is here and iron out all ur doubts face to face with your own personal shoemaker. He does everything by hand..most overseas MTOs, like St Crispins, who are handmades as well still does the outsole stitch via machine.He uses top leather DuPuy n Ilcea n JR. Details like wooden shanks used, no synthetics, and he stacks d heel old school layer by layer with a japanese like smooth finish. Compared to local MTOs n craftsmanship, i stand to be corrected but he is d next best thing to handmade traditional art of shoemaking.its d real deal and the next best option is to go to Italy really for this kind of experience. Also his is not a shop like others in SG, he is the artisan n "factory" itself. IMHO, the price is worth it. U are paying for top quality materials n craftsmanship. The only cons are that he outsource his uppers closing but the "pros" here are that its outsourced to Italy and the closings are top notch. Compare his samples side by side..eg his adelaide vs another adelaide..u will see the stitches, brouges n perforations r superior in detail.

Regarding his boxes, yes, they are another plus point. Shows his high attention to detail. It allows the shoes to breath nicely amongst other benefits. IIRC its sourced from Australia and has a good social cause behind it.

You've really done your homework.
Thumbs up.

Just one thing to add, Josh is working on his skills at closing so he aims to eventually do everything himself, on site.
He just needs keep doing what he's doing and I can only see him getting better.
Proud to have a true artisan / craftsman like him, and Gerald, in SG.
 

adriosz

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2013
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
I am wondering what differentiates the $1,800 MTO and the $3,500 bespoke.

Any idea?

Bespoke has custom last of your own precise feet measurements and a much sharper last design.it has fitting session/s to ensure perfect fit. He has an exclusive last design for bespoke, much sharper. Its nice. He has 3 other last designs for MTO. The Italian last for MTO has a nice eagle claw at the toe. Its my choice. Also he designs his last catered for Asian feet which are wider compared to others. I have a picture of all his last designs but wifi is shitty where im now n uploading pics keeps failing. Pity...

Im frm the sch of thought that if your feet is rather average in length n width with no problems such as bunions or excessively wide/long etc, MTO is good enough PROVIDED you have had the opportunity to try some samples or basic measurements taken on site. Josh takes ur measurements for MTO as well, tracing it on paper etc so fit shd b good compared to overseas online MTOs. Of course online MTOs can be perfect n has its benefits but its better to be careful with your hard earned money..a shoe has to be comfortable as well. the return policy of most MTOs r strict.

Im sure bespoke has more benefits but thats all im aware of. Hope that helps
 

darthsid11111

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 12, 2015
Messages
6,393
Reaction score
60
Bespoke has custom last of your own precise feet measurements and a much sharper last design.it has fitting session/s to ensure perfect fit. He has an exclusive last design for bespoke, much sharper. Its nice. He has 3 other last designs for MTO. The Italian last for MTO has a nice eagle claw at the toe. Its my choice. Also he designs his last catered for Asian feet which are wider compared to others. I have a picture of all his last designs but wifi is shitty where im now n uploading pics keeps failing. Pity...

Im frm the sch of thought that if your feet is rather average in length n width with no problems such as bunions or excessively wide/long etc, MTO is good enough PROVIDED you have had the opportunity to try some samples or basic measurements taken on site. Josh takes ur measurements for MTO as well, tracing it on paper etc so fit shd b good compared to overseas online MTOs. Of course online MTOs can be perfect n has its benefits but its better to be careful with your hard earned money..a shoe has to be comfortable as well. the return policy of most MTOs r strict.

Im sure bespoke has more benefits but thats all im aware of. Hope that helps
I'm sure urban knows this already. I'm guessing his (and my) question is how is it differentiated such bespoke costs double of MTO.

Sent from LGE LG-H815 using GAGT
 

urbanturban

Master Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2003
Messages
3,408
Reaction score
0
If the $3,500 includes personal lasts, it is not too bad a price.

I need to restrain myself from buying/getting more shoes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top