Working Shoe for Young Exec - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

CustomMade

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 4, 2016
Messages
65
Reaction score
1
Hi,
I have these problems on a pair of new shoe.
What do you foresee the problems to be?

Herringshoes%202_zps2julw6lu.jpg.html]


Herringshoes%201_zpsdtvupakm.jpg
[/URL][/IMG]

Herringshoes_zpsjoalwqec.jpg
[/URL][/IMG]

Hey,

Firstly, it is hard to diagnose the issue with two pictures. From the looks of the picture, this is a goodyear welted shoe.

And the stitching and broguing of the shoes seems fairly high quality so i would presume the shoes are not cheap.

Fitting of the shoes

One thing that comes to mind is the fitting of the shoe. One of the reason why shoes break down quickly or go out of shape is because it is bad fitting.

Your feet put pressure on areas of the shoe not meant to take pressure, putting it out of shape.

How long have you been wearing this pair of shoe? If it is an old pair, of course the leather will be out of shape after numerous wear.

Is the fit good - meaning is it exceptionally tight around the arch or instep area?

Leather quality

The highest quality leather is from the "tightest" part of the calf - the center/spine of the calf skin.

The further away from the centre, the looser and more wrinkly the leather will be. This means they will not hold the shape as much as the tighter area of the leather.

Such fold could also be a result of the leather being from a looser area of the calf.

That being said, unless the shoe is expensive, more than $600++, it is unlikely the whole shoe to be made from the tightest part of the calf.

It could be a combination of both factors or more that result in the issue.
 

DT1212

Junior Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2007
Messages
42
Reaction score
0
Hi,

It is a new pair and I just received it this morning from Herringshoes.

All other sides of shoe fit well, except this area which i observe to have excessive material.

Am not sure now whether it is manufacturing faults or it has to be in this shape according to this shoe design.

To me this pair of shoe is ex, S$500 and if this fault cannot be rectified or unable to due to its design, then it will be a sad experience for me. My other Loake shoes have not such problem.
 

darthsid11111

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 12, 2015
Messages
6,393
Reaction score
60
Hi,

It is a new pair and I just received it this morning from Herringshoes.

All other sides of shoe fit well, except this area which i observe to have excessive material.

Am not sure now whether it is manufacturing faults or it has to be in this shape according to this shoe design.

To me this pair of shoe is ex, S$500 and if this fault cannot be rectified or unable to due to its design, then it will be a sad experience for me. My other Loake shoes have not such problem.
If you bought it direct from Herring I would suggest contacting them directly with your concerns. In my dealings with them I have found that their customer service is responsive and forthcoming.

Sent from Samsung SM-G930F using GAGT
 

jeremiah!

Junior Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2017
Messages
31
Reaction score
0
i had the same problem before bro. try shoetree.sg. i bought shoetrees from them before and they were very decent. cheap too
 

Hidetoshi

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 11, 2008
Messages
1,090
Reaction score
3
Anyone getting anything from Allen edmonds website since they having their anniversary sale?

The price is good but shipping to sg seems to be about 10% of the price... may i know if this is normal and reasonable? Do other online shops (eg robinsons) have free online shipping to sg?
 

CustomMade

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 4, 2016
Messages
65
Reaction score
1
Hi,

It is a new pair and I just received it this morning from Herringshoes.

All other sides of shoe fit well, except this area which i observe to have excessive material.

Am not sure now whether it is manufacturing faults or it has to be in this shape according to this shoe design.

To me this pair of shoe is ex, S$500 and if this fault cannot be rectified or unable to due to its design, then it will be a sad experience for me. My other Loake shoes have not such problem.

Oh? It was just this morning.

And $500 is not cheap. It is considered middle to high end range to me a well.

This seems like a full brogue adelaide. It is unlikely due to the design, especially if it is just this morning.

I would say it is likely due to the lasting process. When the upper is not lasted well, or when it is not give sufficient time to rest on the last, it might result in excessive space like your shoe.

My suggestion is to contact the customer service at herringshoes and explain your situation.
 

CustomMade

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 4, 2016
Messages
65
Reaction score
1
Anyone getting anything from Allen edmonds website since they having their anniversary sale?

The price is good but shipping to sg seems to be about 10% of the price... may i know if this is normal and reasonable? Do other online shops (eg robinsons) have free online shipping to sg?

Hey,

yes, shipping from US to SG is expensive. It is within reason. You are shipping an item all the way across the globe.

It is unlikely for you to find any online stores that will absorb this cost.

Even if they did, you would already be paying for them in the price of the shoe.
 

Hidetoshi

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 11, 2008
Messages
1,090
Reaction score
3
Hey,

yes, shipping from US to SG is expensive. It is within reason. You are shipping an item all the way across the globe.

It is unlikely for you to find any online stores that will absorb this cost.

Even if they did, you would already be paying for them in the price of the shoe.

Thanks man, appreciate the great help! Cheers!
 

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
Hi,
I have these problems on a pair of new shoe.
What do you foresee the problems to be?

Sorry to see this. But I must be brutally honest and tell you the shoes look terrible.

Unfortunately, this is indeed something that can happen in RTW shoes. And again, unfortunately, with factory made shoes, many things can and will probably go wrong.

1) Clicking
- The clicking of the leather is a very detached process here. Many hides can be clicked at once when one batch of shoes (in the same pattern) is made. Clicking is usually done by machine, not by hand. Hides may even be stacked one on top of the other and all clicked at once. The problem can arise from here, if say, one hide is not lying completely flush, and the leather is clicked, giving rise to one piece that may be oddly shaped. Further down the line, this could give rise to problems during the lasting process.

2) The leather itself
- Conventionally, the best cut for a pair of shoes, will be reserved for the vamp, as this is the area that undergoes the most stress. The involved area in your pair of shoes, is actually the vamp piece (the adelaide oxford has a "long" vamp, somewhat like a balmoral oxford. For factory made shoes, this is usually not observed, and you can get bad cuts of leather even on the vamp. This is because most RTW makers cut for economy, not for quality. This could give rise to the problem you see.

3) Lasting
- Yet again, this is a machined process. Machine lasting is a very rapid process, and does not take into account the fact that each hide can behave differently, or the different temper and resistance of the skin, that someone who hand lasts, will be able to feel. Every shoe would be lasted with the exact same force. Additionally, machine lasting doesn't get the uppers as close to the last as hand lasting does. The shape of the last is lost, somewhat.

I am going to hazard a guess that the shoes looked something like that even prior to wearing them, so I think fit doesn't really come into play here.

Likewise, the time spent on the last, between different pairs, probably isn't significantly different as well, meaning, each pair doesn't much time at all, on the last. The process of Goodyear welting is fairly rapid. And once inseaming is done, the shoe is more or less "fixed".

I've seen similar defects on a pair of shoes I've owned, and sent them back to the maker, only to hear them say that the shoes were "perfectly fine". The shoes were then polished (and otherwise exactly the same), and sent back to me with the words, "I am sure you agree that they look much better now."

I wish you luck in your return, and hope they will do either a full refund, or an exchange.
 

DT1212

Junior Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2007
Messages
42
Reaction score
0
Sorry to see this. But I must be brutally honest and tell you the shoes look terrible.

Unfortunately, this is indeed something that can happen in RTW shoes. And again, unfortunately, with factory made shoes, many things can and will probably go wrong.

1) Clicking
- The clicking of the leather is a very detached process here. Many hides can be clicked at once when one batch of shoes (in the same pattern) is made. Clicking is usually done by machine, not by hand. Hides may even be stacked one on top of the other and all clicked at once. The problem can arise from here, if say, one hide is not lying completely flush, and the leather is clicked, giving rise to one piece that may be oddly shaped. Further down the line, this could give rise to problems during the lasting process.

2) The leather itself
- Conventionally, the best cut for a pair of shoes, will be reserved for the vamp, as this is the area that undergoes the most stress. The involved area in your pair of shoes, is actually the vamp piece (the adelaide oxford has a "long" vamp, somewhat like a balmoral oxford. For factory made shoes, this is usually not observed, and you can get bad cuts of leather even on the vamp. This is because most RTW makers cut for economy, not for quality. This could give rise to the problem you see.

3) Lasting
- Yet again, this is a machined process. Machine lasting is a very rapid process, and does not take into account the fact that each hide can behave differently, or the different temper and resistance of the skin, that someone who hand lasts, will be able to feel. Every shoe would be lasted with the exact same force. Additionally, machine lasting doesn't get the uppers as close to the last as hand lasting does. The shape of the last is lost, somewhat.

I am going to hazard a guess that the shoes looked something like that even prior to wearing them, so I think fit doesn't really come into play here.

Likewise, the time spent on the last, between different pairs, probably isn't significantly different as well, meaning, each pair doesn't much time at all, on the last. The process of Goodyear welting is fairly rapid. And once inseaming is done, the shoe is more or less "fixed".

I've seen similar defects on a pair of shoes I've owned, and sent them back to the maker, only to hear them say that the shoes were "perfectly fine". The shoes were then polished (and otherwise exactly the same), and sent back to me with the words, "I am sure you agree that they look much better now."

I wish you luck in your return, and hope they will do either a full refund, or an exchange.

Thanks all guys for your prompt comments. It's indeed a well learned lesson for me.

Just to share. This pair is made by Cheaney for Herring (model is Chamberlain) and honestly I can't imagine such defects and herring still go ahead and ship it out.

I spoke to them yesterday and they agreed it is a defects. I will send the shoe back and they will provide full refund.

Looking at Carmina shoe. Any guys can suggest which online store to buy with good price? Understand Singapore has a store but price is not attractive.
 

jonleelk

Master Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
4,122
Reaction score
97
Hey,

yes, shipping from US to SG is expensive. It is within reason. You are shipping an item all the way across the globe.

It is unlikely for you to find any online stores that will absorb this cost.

Even if they did, you would already be paying for them in the price of the shoe.
Amazon does offer free shipping for order over USD125, and they do sell AE shoes as well.
 

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
Thanks all guys for your prompt comments. It's indeed a well learned lesson for me.

Just to share. This pair is made by Cheaney for Herring (model is Chamberlain) and honestly I can't imagine such defects and herring still go ahead and ship it out.

I spoke to them yesterday and they agreed it is a defects. I will send the shoe back and they will provide full refund.

Looking at Carmina shoe. Any guys can suggest which online store to buy with good price? Understand Singapore has a store but price is not attractive.

This is called "trying their luck". No doubt they are hoping that a less savvy customer will just accept the shoes without raising a dispute.

What is your UK size, by the way?
 

Hidetoshi

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 11, 2008
Messages
1,090
Reaction score
3
Amazon does offer free shipping for order over USD125, and they do sell AE shoes as well.

Unfortunately, it is sold by Allen Edmonds and not Amazon so it doesnt qualify for FSSG.

I just bought a Fifth Avenue Brown since it is on sale. Hope all goes well!
 

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
Unfortunately, it is sold by Allen Edmonds and not Amazon so it doesnt qualify for FSSG.

I just bought a Fifth Avenue Brown since it is on sale. Hope all goes well!

This is besides the point, but I thought his name was Matsumoto Hideto, not Hidetoshi?
 

CustomMade

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 4, 2016
Messages
65
Reaction score
1
Sorry to see this. But I must be brutally honest and tell you the shoes look terrible.

Unfortunately, this is indeed something that can happen in RTW shoes. And again, unfortunately, with factory made shoes, many things can and will probably go wrong.

1) Clicking
- The clicking of the leather is a very detached process here. Many hides can be clicked at once when one batch of shoes (in the same pattern) is made. Clicking is usually done by machine, not by hand. Hides may even be stacked one on top of the other and all clicked at once. The problem can arise from here, if say, one hide is not lying completely flush, and the leather is clicked, giving rise to one piece that may be oddly shaped. Further down the line, this could give rise to problems during the lasting process.

2) The leather itself
- Conventionally, the best cut for a pair of shoes, will be reserved for the vamp, as this is the area that undergoes the most stress. The involved area in your pair of shoes, is actually the vamp piece (the adelaide oxford has a "long" vamp, somewhat like a balmoral oxford. For factory made shoes, this is usually not observed, and you can get bad cuts of leather even on the vamp. This is because most RTW makers cut for economy, not for quality. This could give rise to the problem you see.

3) Lasting
- Yet again, this is a machined process. Machine lasting is a very rapid process, and does not take into account the fact that each hide can behave differently, or the different temper and resistance of the skin, that someone who hand lasts, will be able to feel. Every shoe would be lasted with the exact same force. Additionally, machine lasting doesn't get the uppers as close to the last as hand lasting does. The shape of the last is lost, somewhat.

I am going to hazard a guess that the shoes looked something like that even prior to wearing them, so I think fit doesn't really come into play here.

Likewise, the time spent on the last, between different pairs, probably isn't significantly different as well, meaning, each pair doesn't much time at all, on the last. The process of Goodyear welting is fairly rapid. And once inseaming is done, the shoe is more or less "fixed".

I've seen similar defects on a pair of shoes I've owned, and sent them back to the maker, only to hear them say that the shoes were "perfectly fine". The shoes were then polished (and otherwise exactly the same), and sent back to me with the words, "I am sure you agree that they look much better now."

I wish you luck in your return, and hope they will do either a full refund, or an exchange.

Wow bro, that's a very detailed and technical answer.

It seems like you know a thing or two about the manufacturing of shoes! Perhaps even more so than me, despite being in the shoe industry for a couple of years, taking professional courses and heading down to various factories/workshop across S.E Asia.

Are you in the shoe industry as well?
 

CustomMade

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 4, 2016
Messages
65
Reaction score
1
Thanks all guys for your prompt comments. It's indeed a well learned lesson for me.

Just to share. This pair is made by Cheaney for Herring (model is Chamberlain) and honestly I can't imagine such defects and herring still go ahead and ship it out.

I spoke to them yesterday and they agreed it is a defects. I will send the shoe back and they will provide full refund.

Looking at Carmina shoe. Any guys can suggest which online store to buy with good price? Understand Singapore has a store but price is not attractive.

Manufacturing defects are a norm in every industry. There is no such thing as defect free manufacturing or production.

I believe it is unlikely an organization as reputed as Herringshoes would knowingly send you a defected product. This is not some China website.

We don't know their defective rate. For all you know, you are that one suay guy out of a 1000 customers who have a defective shoe, which means they have a 0.001% defective rate. That is quite a well run organization if you ask me.

Such things happen and as long as they took the appropriate corrective response, which they did in this case, it is good. What is unacceptable is them not admitting their mistake and not providing a refund.

I'm not too familiar with Carmina, but yes, the prices of the Carmina store in Singapore is marked up around 10 to 20%
 

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
Wow bro, that's a very detailed and technical answer.

It seems like you know a thing or two about the manufacturing of shoes! Perhaps even more so than me, despite being in the shoe industry for a couple of years, taking professional courses and heading down to various factories/workshop across S.E Asia.

Are you in the shoe industry as well?

Just a regular shoe lover, nothing else really.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top