Haha thanks guys. I'll be trying them out later today,. Am not really active in the other forums, only got to know about them from most of my Japanese clients for some reason aldens and JM Westons are popular among them
It's a strange phenomenon that I have noticed as well.
Strange because there is a huge demand for European makers / goods among Japanese consumers, in a country where their own LOCAL makers are making great progress and (some) are world class in their own right.
And these Japanese consumers pay a huge premium for these products which might not be objectively better than what a Japanese maker can produce.
Among the 2 makers you highlighted, I would pick Weston over Alden simply because the shoes are better constructed.
Weston utilises a "one piece" insole where a leather rib is cut and raised, and reinforced with a linen strip around the border of this rib. The welt is then machine sewn like GYW. This circumvents somewhat, the deficiencies of GYW. One thing about Weston though, is that they are "stronger" in terms of the casual offerings, not so much their dress shoes / classic shoes.
Alden, is straight up GYW, I don't exactly find significant differences in construction / finishing / materials, apart from maybe a more refined welt finish. They have a certain appeal to certain people because of their general appearance / designs / lasts. If that's your thing, go for it.