Working Shoe for Young Exec - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

crunsik

Master Member
Joined
May 31, 2007
Messages
4,153
Reaction score
892
There are corrected grain and there are corrected grain.

I am sure a pair of loakes corrected grain leather shoes is still better than your mall purchased corrected grain leather shoes.

Corrected grain leather, if i remember reading correctly, just means a treated piece of leather which may be embossed with grain, a varnish or can be stretched out to yield a larger piece (and then stuck to other materials to make 'leather' shoes.

Implies corrected grain leather. Worst of the lot.
Corrected grain leather comes from substandard hides, poor quality hides with plenty of defects, blemishes, etc. As such, the grain surface is sanded and buffed down (thus losing a lot of the thickness and natural strength of the leather) to remove these visible defects. The remaining leather is then sprayed on (not aniline dyed) with some synthetic looking topcoat of paint that gives the surface an annoying, plasticky, sheen. You lose all the natural surface features and unique grain characteristics of full grain leather.
In other words, stay the f**k away.

thx for the help guys!;);)

so in general i shld avoid polished leather. but from plain reading off the website, what should i look out for a good type of leather? from loake website, http://www.loake.co.uk/byrange/loake-1880/byron.html, i see soft calf leather, burnished calf leather, would calf leather be a better choice than polished leather to get the pair of shoes?
 

urbanturban

Master Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2003
Messages
3,408
Reaction score
0
thx for the help guys!;);)

so in general i shld avoid polished leather. but from plain reading off the website, what should i look out for a good type of leather? from loake website, http://www.loake.co.uk/byrange/loake-1880/byron.html, i see soft calf leather, burnished calf leather, would calf leather be a better choice than polished leather to get the pair of shoes?

Loake 1880 is a good range to start with, IMO.
 

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
thx for the help guys!;);)

so in general i shld avoid polished leather. but from plain reading off the website, what should i look out for a good type of leather? from loake website, http://www.loake.co.uk/byrange/loake-1880/byron.html, i see soft calf leather, burnished calf leather, would calf leather be a better choice than polished leather to get the pair of shoes?

Of course, I do not intend to tell you how to spend your money. Least of all to spend beyond your means.
As someone has implied.
I'm sorry if I came across as such.

Ok. So most (not all) shoes are made from calf leather. Calf simply means young cow.
Now, calf is preferable for footwear for a variety of reasons, but mainly because since the animal is younger, the hide is usually thinner / less marked and blemished / more supple.
Steerhide and cowhide comes from the adult animal and are also used in other leather products like leather jackets for example.

I do not understand why they say specifically "soft calf leather", because good calf should be soft to begin with. But taking the term at face value, I don't think there is any negative connotation.

Burnished calf simply implies that some additional finishing touches (probably using creams or waxes) have been added on, onto certain areas of the shoes (heels or toecaps perhaps) to add on variation in color (usually some degree of darkening). This is simply an aesthetic feature that some people may enjoy but others do not. This feature has no implication on the quality of the hide used to make the shoes.

With that being said, the term you should be looking out for is "full grain leather". But only, of course, if the price is agreeable to you.

I cannot say if the terms "soft calf leather" and "burnished calf leather" are full grain or corrected grain. Even corrected grain is calf, it's just lousy calf. Shoe companies can say whatever they want on their websites.

More specifically though, I do know that the Loake 1880 range uses full grain leather. And coincidentally, I have actually even previously owned the Loake Byron.

Based on pictures alone, coupled with marketing gimmickry and funny terms that shoe companies may use, without the direct use of unambiguous terms of "full grain" or "corrected grain, you might not be able to tell from the pictures, which is which. The best indicator might be the price, or a simple email to the retailer.
 
Last edited:

crunsik

Master Member
Joined
May 31, 2007
Messages
4,153
Reaction score
892
hey dude no worries on the spending part, everyone is entitled to their view.

appreciate the deep analyse and explanation on the types of leather. after reading so much on Loake 1880, i do think i would want to move my option to purchase that. and it looks lk we got similar taste on Loake Byron. :D:D

Where did you purchase your Loake Byron? in SG or via online?

my qualms are that for other shoe brands, even paying more for the shoes doesnt guarantee its a full grained leather. i even read online for how to pick out a full leather but as much as i hate to say this, perhaps the solution would means buying more shoes from Loake lol :s22::s22:
http://www.saddlebackleather.com/craftsmanship/chpt4-leather-101-lesson-in-leather

Of course, I do not intend to tell you how to spend your money. Least of all to spend beyond your means.
As someone has implied.
I'm sorry if I came across as such.

Ok. So most (not all) shoes are made from calf leather. Calf simply means young cow.
Now, calf is preferable for footwear for a variety of reasons, but mainly because since the animal is younger, the hide is usually thinner / less marked and blemished / more supple.
Steerhide and cowhide comes from the adult animal and are also used in other leather products like leather jackets for example.

I do not understand why they say specifically "soft calf leather", because good calf should be soft to begin with. But taking the term at face value, I don't think there is any negative connotation.

Burnished calf simply implies that some additional finishing touches (probably using creams or waxes) have been added on, onto certain areas of the shoes (heels or toecaps perhaps) to add on variation in color (usually some degree of darkening). This is simply an aesthetic feature that some people may enjoy but others do not. This feature has no implication on the quality of the hide used to make the shoes.

With that being said, the term you should be looking out for is "full grain leather". But only, of course, if the price is agreeable to you.

I cannot say if the terms "soft calf leather" and "burnished calf leather" are full grain or corrected grain. Even corrected grain is calf, it's just lousy calf. Shoe companies can say whatever they want on their websites.

More specifically though, I do know that the Loake 1880 range uses full grain leather. And coincidentally, I have actually even previously owned the Loake Byron.

Based on pictures alone, coupled with marketing gimmickry and funny terms that shoe companies may use, without the direct use of unambiguous terms of "full grain" or "corrected grain, you might not be able to tell from the pictures, which is which. The best indicator might be the price, or a simple email to the retailer.
 

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
hey dude no worries on the spending part, everyone is entitled to their view.

appreciate the deep analyse and explanation on the types of leather. after reading so much on Loake 1880, i do think i would want to move my option to purchase that. and it looks lk we got similar taste on Loake Byron. :D:D

Where did you purchase your Loake Byron? in SG or via online?

my qualms are that for other shoe brands, even paying more for the shoes doesnt guarantee its a full grained leather. i even read online for how to pick out a full leather but as much as i hate to say this, perhaps the solution would means buying more shoes from Loake lol :s22::s22:
http://www.saddlebackleather.com/craftsmanship/chpt4-leather-101-lesson-in-leather

I'd bought that pair from Pediwear.
Anyway, if you have doubts or questions regarding any particular shoe, yuo should probably just email the retailer and ask them questions.
It's their job to answer your questions.
If not, do not bother buying from them.
 

All in a Day

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2014
Messages
14,850
Reaction score
1,560
hey dude no worries on the spending part, everyone is entitled to their view.

appreciate the deep analyse and explanation on the types of leather. after reading so much on Loake 1880, i do think i would want to move my option to purchase that. and it looks lk we got similar taste on Loake Byron. :D:D

Where did you purchase your Loake Byron? in SG or via online?

my qualms are that for other shoe brands, even paying more for the shoes doesnt guarantee its a full grained leather. i even read online for how to pick out a full leather but as much as i hate to say this, perhaps the solution would means buying more shoes from Loake lol :s22::s22:
http://www.saddlebackleather.com/craftsmanship/chpt4-leather-101-lesson-in-leather

If you are not in a hurry, wait for Robinsons shoes' discount codes, which are available quite frequently. You can typically expect discounts ranging from 10 to 20% off retail price, before VAT deduction.

Sign up to receive their newsletters/promos. The folks here usually also SIC when they are aware of any new promo/codes.

Good luck!
 

Daniel.Y

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2013
Messages
731
Reaction score
0
jUBp8M7.jpg
Old shoe looks new again after Vibram resole
 
Last edited:

crunsik

Master Member
Joined
May 31, 2007
Messages
4,153
Reaction score
892
If you are not in a hurry, wait for Robinsons shoes' discount codes, which are available quite frequently. You can typically expect discounts ranging from 10 to 20% off retail price, before VAT deduction.

Sign up to receive their newsletters/promos. The folks here usually also SIC when they are aware of any new promo/codes.

Good luck!

gratefully for your advice dude! the quality of the replies in this thread is so much higher than in the EDMW forum :s13::s13:

I'd bought that pair from Pediwear.
Anyway, if you have doubts or questions regarding any particular shoe, yuo should probably just email the retailer and ask them questions.
It's their job to answer your questions.
If not, do not bother buying from them.

cool! i guess you took the free shoe tree and paid the 18 pound for the delivery??:s13::s13: did the shoe arrive in a good condition? any negative feedback on your end? slight bumps to the box is fine with me.

if i knew abt Pediwear, i would buy most of my shoes online.:s13::s13:
 

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
gratefully for your advice dude! the quality of the replies in this thread is so much higher than in the EDMW forum :s13::s13:



cool! i guess you took the free shoe tree and paid the 18 pound for the delivery??:s13::s13: did the shoe arrive in a good condition? any negative feedback on your end? slight bumps to the box is fine with me.

if i knew abt Pediwear, i would buy most of my shoes online.:s13::s13:

Ey, the people who post here are a different kettle of fish from EDMW.

Actually I took the free delivery.
I've bought from Pediwear on numerous occasions in the past (mainly Crockett and Jones) and they've been very responsive and gave me pretty good sizing advice.
For the Loake Byrons, I had no issues with the shoes whatsoever.
Generally, I have had rather positive experiences buying online. Apart from maybe one occasion where the shoes were a complete piece of crap.
 

jonleelk

Master Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
4,122
Reaction score
97
gratefully for your advice dude! the quality of the replies in this thread is so much higher than in the EDMW forum :s13::s13:



cool! i guess you took the free shoe tree and paid the 18 pound for the delivery??:s13::s13: did the shoe arrive in a good condition? any negative feedback on your end? slight bumps to the box is fine with me.

if i knew abt Pediwear, i would buy most of my shoes online.:s13::s13:
Take free delivery during discount from Pediwear or Robinsonshoes. Loake Strand @ £179.13 less VAT. If 15% discount, £152.26. Free shipping and no need to pay GST.
http://www.robinsonsshoes.com/loake-strand.html

Buy shoe tree from taobao.
https://world.taobao.com/item/39609...m=a230r.1.14.4.8thXID&ns=1&abbucket=18#detail
 
Last edited:

crunsik

Master Member
Joined
May 31, 2007
Messages
4,153
Reaction score
892
Take free delivery during discount from Pediwear or Robinsonshoes. Loake Strand @ £179.13 less VAT. If 15% discount, £152.26. Free shipping and no need to pay GST.
http://www.robinsonsshoes.com/loake-strand.html

Buy shoe tree from taobao.
https://world.taobao.com/item/39609...m=a230r.1.14.4.8thXID&ns=1&abbucket=18#detail

taobao is a wonder. but i have yet to figure out how to place an order there. lol. hav u placed an order from this particular seller? mayb i would go try it out and see how good is the quality.

Ey, the people who post here are a different kettle of fish from EDMW.

Actually I took the free delivery.
I've bought from Pediwear on numerous occasions in the past (mainly Crockett and Jones) and they've been very responsive and gave me pretty good sizing advice.
For the Loake Byrons, I had no issues with the shoes whatsoever.
Generally, I have had rather positive experiences buying online. Apart from maybe one occasion where the shoes were a complete piece of crap.

thx dude ur replies have been very helpful. perhaps i shall begin waiting for any discount on Pediwear or the other online websites. btw which shoe was a complete piece of crap so that i can avoid getting it
 

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
thx dude ur replies have been very helpful. perhaps i shall begin waiting for any discount on Pediwear or the other online websites. btw which shoe was a complete piece of crap so that i can avoid getting it

Granted my experience might not be representative of everyone's, and I probably shouldn't brand bash, but I'd bought a pair of shoes by a certain English maker from A Fine Piece of S**t (AFPOS).
Just Google around, you'll figure it out.
 
Last edited:

walk_the_talk

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 13, 2016
Messages
20
Reaction score
0
Granted my experience might not be representative of everyone's, and I probably shouldn't brand bash, but I'd bought a pair of shoes by a certain English maker from A Fine Piece of S**t (AFPOS).
Just Google around, you'll figure it out.

Haha, I remember that experience of yours. For those that are wondering, the brand is AS.
 

Daniel.Y

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2013
Messages
731
Reaction score
0
Bro, where do u do the resole? I want to do it for my new shoes with leather sole.

Kipsnkwik @ Bishan j8 basement. General rule of thumb is to break in shoe in for 3 - 4 times before adding on the sole protector. In anyway, the cobbler will sand down your leather sole to get a rough surface in order to stick on the vibram.
 

greenbeam1980

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 23, 2004
Messages
2,067
Reaction score
0
Kipsnkwik @ Bishan j8 basement. General rule of thumb is to break in shoe in for 3 - 4 times before adding on the sole protector. In anyway, the cobbler will sand down your leather sole to get a rough surface in order to stick on the vibram.

Which means not advisable to apply the protective sole to brand new shoes. Must break in first?
 

chickenbackside

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2008
Messages
2,292
Reaction score
0
Which means not advisable to apply the protective sole to brand new shoes. Must break in first?
No difference.

If you don't, they will sand the brand new sole down. If you do, they will still sand it down for evenness. The main thing is that the surface has to be rough and even so that the rubber can be glued on effectively.

No need to think so much. Just do it at your convenience.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top