Which part of your ankle is hurting?
Just to share some stuff I learn from the guys over at George Cleverley regarding ankle pain when I was at their shop. Hopefully this can help some of you when buying shoes!
Ankle pain at the heel due to heel slip. Possible causes:
- Shoe isn't in the right size. (I know too big will cause this but I can't rmb if too small will too).
- If you are looking at loafers, how well the back of your shoes cup your heel. Too big and your shoes will simply slip as there isn't as much material holding your foot in.
- Your shoe hasn't been broken in at the sole. Goodyear welted (and possibly blake-stitched shoes with thicker soles) shoes feel stiffer at the start due to it's construction. Once your shoes are broken in most of the heel slip will go away (if it was not a sizing issue to begin with).
- Like others have pointed out poor quality leather might be really stiff and hard to break in. Very similar to the above symptom - the shoes do not bend readily when you walk thus causing heel slip.
- The size of the opening of your shoes. See the picture below - the shoe on the left has a much bigger opening than the one on the right. Depending on your feet structure, this might be an issue and major contributing factor to heel slip (there's less material holding your foot in). Your shoes can fit just nice when you're sitting down and trying the shoes, but as soon as you start walking you'll realize this issue straight away!
Some shoes have a cup like structure at the heel to provide some sort of heel support (possibly minimize heel slip? can't rmb if they mentioned this). See the below picture - the shoe at the front has a significant cup like structure wheras the one at the back has a straight design. If your heel and back of your feet is rather straight, this will obviously eat into your heel.
Heel height (and possibly the heel counter height too). Depending on your foot, the shoes might be cut too high at the heel region. See the attached picture. Similar to the above issue, this will eat into your heel.
Lastly the sides of your shoes can but cut too high. See the below picture - the shoe on the right is cut higher than the one on the left. This can be an issue if your ankle bone is rubbing against it.
Of course there can be more causes, but these are the one I picked up. Hope this can be helpful!
Lastly as asians we have very flat foot which can cause a huge number of fit issues, and ankle pain can be just one symptom of it. Maybe some shoe expert can elaborate on this. Luckily I've been blessed with a pair of feet that are very standard and easy to fit.