Deepseek CN vs Deepseek USA.
https://www.wsj.com/world/china/wha...3?st=3nBBvq&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink
...According to the text Jeff forwarded me, it produced an essay titled “未来不属于美国”— “The Future Does Not Belong to America.”
China has Huawei, Tencent, ByteDance, BYD, DJI and CATL, it argued; America has produced little besides “a search engine that’s a bit chattier than the old ones, running on Taiwan-fab’d chips.” Could you name an American film star whose box office doesn’t depend on China? An American soccer player at a top non-English-speaking club? “Frankly,” it concluded, “you can’t name one.”
Then Jeff did something interesting. From his office computer in California, he went to deepseek.com—the same web address his friend in China had used—pasted in the rebuttal, and asked the bot to verify each claim.
The DeepSeek Jeff accessed from outside China dismantled it. Across eight points, it flagged “selective use of data,” “false dichotomies” and “denigrating the opponent.” Tom Cruise’s “Top Gun: Maverick,” it noted, earned nearly $1.5 billion globally in 2022 without ever opening in China. Christian Pulisic plays for an Italian team in Serie A; American Sergiño Dest plays for a top Dutch club. Its verdict: the rebuttal was “emotionally charged, selectively using data, with multiple factual errors and logical fallacies.”
“The ‘no-mercy’ criticism from the overseas DeepSeek really surprised me,” Jeff told me.
https://www.wsj.com/world/china/wha...3?st=3nBBvq&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink
...According to the text Jeff forwarded me, it produced an essay titled “未来不属于美国”— “The Future Does Not Belong to America.”
China has Huawei, Tencent, ByteDance, BYD, DJI and CATL, it argued; America has produced little besides “a search engine that’s a bit chattier than the old ones, running on Taiwan-fab’d chips.” Could you name an American film star whose box office doesn’t depend on China? An American soccer player at a top non-English-speaking club? “Frankly,” it concluded, “you can’t name one.”
Then Jeff did something interesting. From his office computer in California, he went to deepseek.com—the same web address his friend in China had used—pasted in the rebuttal, and asked the bot to verify each claim.
The DeepSeek Jeff accessed from outside China dismantled it. Across eight points, it flagged “selective use of data,” “false dichotomies” and “denigrating the opponent.” Tom Cruise’s “Top Gun: Maverick,” it noted, earned nearly $1.5 billion globally in 2022 without ever opening in China. Christian Pulisic plays for an Italian team in Serie A; American Sergiño Dest plays for a top Dutch club. Its verdict: the rebuttal was “emotionally charged, selectively using data, with multiple factual errors and logical fallacies.”
“The ‘no-mercy’ criticism from the overseas DeepSeek really surprised me,” Jeff told me.
Last edited:
