I will give a contrarian view as I explored the same situation. After my lavender BTO, I went for a Kallang 5-room resale, high floor.
The money I could have pumped into the EC I pumped into S&P and hit CPF FRS fr my wife and myself by 36. 5-year HDB is 1 year left to pay, and with cash and retirement buffer, we feel quite secure in today's climate.
I would say that upon analysing with my wife, our S&P portfolio has outperformed EC gain, and we feel that we have no regrets, as honestly, it is a low-stress lifestyle, and even if 1 of us lose our jobs, we will be fine. Even if both lose jobs, we will also be fine for 2 years. We are able to go for 6 holidays a yea,r bring our parents on 4 of those trips.
Anyways whatI am saying is that if the EC gives u a nice place to stay, go for it. Just note that in light ofthe resale volume transaction dropping significantly, any short gains better be ruled out so it is better to go for the EC especially if it gives u a better lifestyle.
For myself, wife n kids n parents-in-law in law, as everything operates near town, we felt the EC would result in aan dditional 30 mins travel time for everyone and honestly, i hate driving in spore during peak periods unless necessary.