Shiny Things
Supremacy Member
- Joined
- Dec 13, 2009
- Messages
- 9,563
- Reaction score
- 772
First, everyone: stop baiting Chrisloh65. Just report his posts and move on—or, even better, block him and move on, and let me handle reporting him when he posts stuff that's in violation of the board's rules.
He's said before that he's not here to learn, or to have a discussion, he's just here because he enjoys starting fights. And that's why he doesn't post in his own thread—because when he posts in his own thread, he doesn't get the attention and he can't start fights.
That said…
Credit where credit is due: Swan02 has done a 180. Swan, if you see this, I’ve noticed you’ve been a lot more relaxed and engaged here, and I do appreciate that.
Honestly, it seems like you’re getting Pokemon syndrome - you don’t have to catch ‘em all.
Let’s go riiiiight back to first principles. You’re saying you want to overweight Asian markets, over and above what you already get from IWDA, and you want an ETF that’ll let you do that.
I don’t think that’s an amazing trade, but if you must: just buy IFFF LN.
https://www.ishares.com/uk/professi...48/ishares-msci-ac-far-east-exjapan-ucits-etf
Ah yes, but that’s why you have a healthy slug of bonds in your portfolio when you reach retirement. The income stream from those (and the pull-to-par effect) helps you maintain your account value and reduce the amount you need to sell.
It’s mostly star-star-star-star-star-star-star-star. I know people who’ve tried to quit their job and day-trade, and the vast majority of them end up either wiping their account completely, or just bouncing along and not doing any better than they would have if they’d just put it all in the index and gone to the pub.
I know a few, yeah. Quite a few of my ex-colleagues trade their own money these days… but these are people who have already been professional traders for fifteen or twenty years. And that’s the difference between you and them—fifteen years of paying their dues and learning how to trade, with someone else’s money. And with managers, and expensive risk management software, and full-time market risk management teams sitting right over their shoulder to make sure they don’t do anything dumb. Newbie day traders have exactly zero of those things, and no way to get them.
I think I mentioned upthread that one of my old bosses is semi-retired and trading his own money. He’s been trading since 1995. That’s the sort of experience you need to have.
The best thing you can do is to do whatever you can to jack up your salary and get promoted. “Invest in yourself” is good advice!
(Honestly, one of the most profitable moves I ever made was aggressively negotiating for a higher salary and stock when I joined my current company.)
The answer will almost always be “surrender it”. Don’t ever trust the “illustrated benefits” column; that number is completely made up. The insurance companies are allowed to use any number up to 4.75% to do benefit illustrations - so of course they’ll use 4.75%, because that makes them looks the best.
Yeah, we saw that column when it first came across the wires a few months ago. Michael Burry traded the GFC spectacularly well, but two things:
That’s because you shouldn’t use stop-market orders anyway. Use stop-limit orders instead, so that you don’t get stopped out with no price limit in the event of a flash crash.
Firstly, IB and Blackrock are two very different things! IB is a broker; Blackrock is a fund manager. Blackrock doesn’t touch the funds.
If you dropped an asteroid on the iShares headquarters in San Francisco, all the stocks that IWDA holds would still be there. If you dropped an asteroid on State Street headquarters in Boston, ES3 would still own all its STI stocks. The trustee would just appoint a new fund manager and the funds would keep on truckin’. You don’t need to worry about fund managers failing.
I personally think having a second broker is a huge waste of time. I’d rather keep all my money in one broker because it makes it easier to manage, and IBKR has excellent risk management.
The reason aggressive traders hate IBKR is that they’re so quick to cut your positions if you start racking up losses; and that’s why I love IBKR. If you’re just buying and holding stocks, IBKR will never cut you; but if you’re doing dumb sh*t like selling huge quantities of vol or shorting bitcoin futures or trading 100:1 leverage, IBKR will cut you off before you can do any damage to yourself.
And all of the custodians for UK-listed stocks that I can think of are noticeably worse than IBKR. DBS: custody fees. FSMOne: custody fees. Saxo: custody fees, and they rail you without lube on the FX conversion.
(But in most cases, you've already got multiple custodians. Your overseas stocks are at IBKR; your local stocks and bonds are at FSMOne or Stanchart. That's all you need!)
He's said before that he's not here to learn, or to have a discussion, he's just here because he enjoys starting fights. And that's why he doesn't post in his own thread—because when he posts in his own thread, he doesn't get the attention and he can't start fights.
That said…
There are 3 musketeers that ST has said few times they are here to start fights
1. Chrisloh65
2. Swan02
Credit where credit is due: Swan02 has done a 180. Swan, if you see this, I’ve noticed you’ve been a lot more relaxed and engaged here, and I do appreciate that.
I’m not so interested in sg and hk portion but this etf just happened to not have Australia and Japan but has singapore...
Fsmone RSP only offers the hkd option... that’s why I’m wondering what’s the diff and if it is ok for me to buy the hkd one
Can recommend a China etf or Asia etf to invest in to form a part of my portfolio ?
Honestly, it seems like you’re getting Pokemon syndrome - you don’t have to catch ‘em all.
Let’s go riiiiight back to first principles. You’re saying you want to overweight Asian markets, over and above what you already get from IWDA, and you want an ETF that’ll let you do that.
I don’t think that’s an amazing trade, but if you must: just buy IFFF LN.
https://www.ishares.com/uk/professi...48/ishares-msci-ac-far-east-exjapan-ucits-etf
1) I assume the underlying assumptions here regarding retirement are that post-65, you drawdown a portion of the portfolio (~3%) every month instead of putting in money every month? This drawdown then forms monthly income alongside any CPF life / other annuity payouts.
Wouldn't that imply that on bad performing stretches, your monthly "income" is substantially reduced since you can drawdown on a depressed portfolio?
Ah yes, but that’s why you have a healthy slug of bonds in your portfolio when you reach retirement. The income stream from those (and the pull-to-par effect) helps you maintain your account value and reduce the amount you need to sell.
Yep!2) How to treat investing for 2 goals - e.g. retirement (in 40 years) and buying a house house in 10 years (downpayment)? I would assume you invest similarly (local stock / global stock / local bond) with differing time horizons and simply keep track of them separately?
Hey Shiny and frens, don't kill me for bringing up this topic LOL:
What's your opinion on day trading?
It seems that you can actually make a consistent, and maybe huge, profit if you train really hard and be very "good" at it? Is that ********? And is it worth the effort?
[…]
It’s mostly star-star-star-star-star-star-star-star. I know people who’ve tried to quit their job and day-trade, and the vast majority of them end up either wiping their account completely, or just bouncing along and not doing any better than they would have if they’d just put it all in the index and gone to the pub.
Do you know any day traders irl? What is it like? Or should he go do something else that is "more meaningful"?
I know a few, yeah. Quite a few of my ex-colleagues trade their own money these days… but these are people who have already been professional traders for fifteen or twenty years. And that’s the difference between you and them—fifteen years of paying their dues and learning how to trade, with someone else’s money. And with managers, and expensive risk management software, and full-time market risk management teams sitting right over their shoulder to make sure they don’t do anything dumb. Newbie day traders have exactly zero of those things, and no way to get them.
I think I mentioned upthread that one of my old bosses is semi-retired and trading his own money. He’s been trading since 1995. That’s the sort of experience you need to have.
On that note, what else out there can give you a good $/time ratio? Other than selling backside
The best thing you can do is to do whatever you can to jack up your salary and get promoted. “Invest in yourself” is good advice!
(Honestly, one of the most profitable moves I ever made was aggressively negotiating for a higher salary and stock when I joined my current company.)
Number 2 is easiest.1. Should I continue buying G3B via FSMone?
2. Buy ES3 and stop buying G3B?
3. Buy both ETFs to 50/50 ratio (one a month) for my local stock ETF?
Anyone has an idea of how to weigh surrendering endowments (and redeploying to a 3-fund portfolio) vs keeping it?
[…]
Question is whether scenario 1 should be looking at the illustrated benefits (i.e. 4.75% performance) column since it's likely that the insurer's par fund will be performing at ~4% as well if my investment is performing at that level?
The answer will almost always be “surrender it”. Don’t ever trust the “illustrated benefits” column; that number is completely made up. The insurance companies are allowed to use any number up to 4.75% to do benefit illustrations - so of course they’ll use 4.75%, because that makes them looks the best.
Saw one AIA advisor sharing on his Instagram that Michael Burry talking about the index bubble.
Yeah, we saw that column when it first came across the wires a few months ago. Michael Burry traded the GFC spectacularly well, but two things:
- He’s fallen into the trap that a lot of traders fall into, where they hit a jackpot once and then they do the same trade over and over again, hoping for the same outcome even when they keep losing money. It’s John Paulson - he made money being an Uber-bear in 2008 and then lost it all. It’s John Meriwether - he made money shorting vol ahead of 1998, lost it all, then started another fund and tried to do the same thing and lost it all again.
- He’s outside his area of expertise, and he’s saying stuff about ETFs that is clearly and blatantly wrong. ETFs are not like CDOs.
Hi all,
Is there any other recommended brokerage, but with STOP LOSS function?
Standard Chartered doesn't seem to offer STOP LOSS, all I see is stop limit.
Any advice would be appreciated.
That’s because you shouldn’t use stop-market orders anyway. Use stop-limit orders instead, so that you don’t get stopped out with no price limit in the event of a flash crash.
Because it's worse for global stocks. And the custodian doesn’t really matter in my view: see below.Hi all,
Is there any particular reason for DBS Vickers' prefunded account not recommended over SC?
While I think the possibility/risk of failure of IB/Blackrock is very very very very low, I am mindful of history:
Firstly, IB and Blackrock are two very different things! IB is a broker; Blackrock is a fund manager. Blackrock doesn’t touch the funds.
If you dropped an asteroid on the iShares headquarters in San Francisco, all the stocks that IWDA holds would still be there. If you dropped an asteroid on State Street headquarters in Boston, ES3 would still own all its STI stocks. The trustee would just appoint a new fund manager and the funds would keep on truckin’. You don’t need to worry about fund managers failing.
I personally think having a second broker is a huge waste of time. I’d rather keep all my money in one broker because it makes it easier to manage, and IBKR has excellent risk management.
The reason aggressive traders hate IBKR is that they’re so quick to cut your positions if you start racking up losses; and that’s why I love IBKR. If you’re just buying and holding stocks, IBKR will never cut you; but if you’re doing dumb sh*t like selling huge quantities of vol or shorting bitcoin futures or trading 100:1 leverage, IBKR will cut you off before you can do any damage to yourself.
And all of the custodians for UK-listed stocks that I can think of are noticeably worse than IBKR. DBS: custody fees. FSMOne: custody fees. Saxo: custody fees, and they rail you without lube on the FX conversion.
(But in most cases, you've already got multiple custodians. Your overseas stocks are at IBKR; your local stocks and bonds are at FSMOne or Stanchart. That's all you need!)
Last edited:



