hiring helper or nursing home?

phunware

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2025
Messages
1,084
Reaction score
892
khaw-boon-wan.jpg


Maybe he could help u decide?

Hope ur father speedy recovery like HSK
 

socrates

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
2,215
Reaction score
71
if your dad requires assistance with his ADLs,

below are the schemes that you can apply for him, check with your social workers if he meets the criteria,

https://www.aic.sg/financial-assistance/pioneer-generation-disability-assistance-scheme/

https://www.aic.sg/financial-assistance/home-caregiving-grant-hcg/

https://www.aic.sg/financial-assist...y-assistance-programme-for-the-elderly-idape/

https://www.aic.sg/financial-assistance/Elderfund/

Does your father insured with ElderShield or CareShield Life?
This is good advice. Talk to the Medical Social Worker and they can refer you to AIC and they will help you see what subsidies and support that you can get. There is a lot of support that one does not know about.
 

socrates

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
2,215
Reaction score
71
Go to a good miad agency. Tell them excactly your needs and requirements and they usually can find a suitable helper for you. May costs quite a lot through the agency but I think it gets a load off you.
 

starrynite138

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2014
Messages
1,086
Reaction score
626
U mean no children cannot employ helper if dementia?
Do you mean as the person that has dementia being the employer of the helper with no sponsor? If so, how to? Can't even remember own self. At late stage, can't even talk, walk, move, eat or do anything on his/her own. Spend whole day laying on bed and rely on others to keep him/her alive.
 

qhong61

Banned
Joined
Nov 3, 2015
Messages
73,153
Reaction score
12,239
Do you mean as the person that has dementia being the employer of the helper with no sponsor? If so, how to? Can't even remember own self. At late stage, can't even talk, walk, move, eat or do anything on his/her own. Spend whole day laying on bed and rely on others to keep him/her alive.
Siblings?
 

jywy2005

Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 22, 2013
Messages
5,298
Reaction score
2,475
Dementia cannot?
As an employer, you cannot be suffering from dementia. So must get another employer who can be the children, siblings etc. The problem here is the FDW must reside in the same household as the employer. MOM is worried that the FDW might be abused if the employer has dementia.

So for those with elderly parents, please engage a FDW earlier. My mum had a fall 3 years ago and is now diagnosed with Parkinson’s which affected her mobility. Before her discharge from hospital, the FDW must undergo a serious of training like change of diapers, bathing, transfer from bed to wheelchair etc.
 

qhong61

Banned
Joined
Nov 3, 2015
Messages
73,153
Reaction score
12,239
As an employer, you cannot be suffering from dementia. So must get another employer who can be the children, siblings etc. The problem here is the FDW must reside in the same household as the employer. MOM is worried that the FDW might be abused if the employer has dementia.

So for those with elderly parents, please engage a FDW earlier. My mum had a fall 3 years ago and is now diagnosed with Parkinson’s which affected her mobility. Before her discharge from hospital, the FDW must undergo a serious of training like change of diapers, bathing, transfer from bed to wheelchair etc.
I see
Thanks
 

arsenalfc85

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2015
Messages
11,980
Reaction score
8,826
My helper’s contract ending in a few months time

though I feel she has many areas for improvement, eg being very slow in doing things, bad cook (always cooking same food and cooking unhealthy food)

I feel overall she is still responsible and honest la

im worried if I change helper, I might get a worse one.

hence I will just let her know her areas to change and pray pray hope she will change.

Haiz
 

Panerex

Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 29, 2010
Messages
6,357
Reaction score
91
My helper’s contract ending in a few months time

though I feel she has many areas for improvement, eg being very slow in doing things, bad cook (always cooking same food and cooking unhealthy food)

I feel overall she is still responsible and honest la

im worried if I change helper, I might get a worse one.

hence I will just let her know her areas to change and pray pray hope she will change.

Haiz
So what your family did about the cooking? Continue eating or more frequent eat-outs?
 

boredom2012

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2012
Messages
22,686
Reaction score
9,910
My helper’s contract ending in a few months time

though I feel she has many areas for improvement, eg being very slow in doing things, bad cook (always cooking same food and cooking unhealthy food)

I feel overall she is still responsible and honest la

im worried if I change helper, I might get a worse one.

hence I will just let her know her areas to change and pray pray hope she will change.

Haiz
Learnt cooking yourself. Maid can never cook to your likes. Slow wise is expected. Maid is just employee. So if she is honest and clean that's the best you expect from the maid. My ex maid got hiv after coming to Singapore.
 

arsenalfc85

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2015
Messages
11,980
Reaction score
8,826
Learnt cooking yourself. Maid can never cook to your likes. Slow wise is expected. Maid is just employee. So if she is honest and clean that's the best you expect from the maid. My ex maid got hiv after coming to Singapore.
I know how to cook

but I don’t understand why I got helper then I cook myself . For what?

nvm I will train her to cook la

can’t believe it. Need to train her to cook…

that’s why getting helper also got problems . You also Suay to get one with hiv
 

starrynite138

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2014
Messages
1,086
Reaction score
626
I know how to cook

but I don’t understand why I got helper then I cook myself . For what?

nvm I will train her to cook la

can’t believe it. Need to train her to cook…

that’s why getting helper also got problems . You also Suay to get one with hiv
How about get her to wash, chop, cut all ingredients (first must teach how you want it cut into). Prepare ready liao and you do the cooking. After that she does the washing. Cooking doesn't take long, is the preparation and washing. And you plan the menu not her. Ai helper got helper problems 😔
 

arsenalfc85

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2015
Messages
11,980
Reaction score
8,826
How about get her to wash, chop, cut all ingredients (first must teach how you want it cut into). Prepare ready liao and you do the cooking. After that she does the washing. Cooking doesn't take long, is the preparation and washing. And you plan the menu not her. Ai helper got helper problems 😔
Realised she’s also not very detailed and meticulous.

always leave my dad to do things on his own. As a result of that he fell down before, just now he stubbed his toes

all cuz she never hold him or make sure he’s safe

I already give her discount in housework liao, ie I do some of the housework myself, so that she can be more meticulous in the taking care of my dad part. Yet she still do half a55 job on taking care of my dad.

I still give her so much money to buy food.her birthday I also giver her angpow. Seriously very disappointed

but compared to my second helper, she’s still ok liao la.

I guess I just have to keep reminding her and telling her. Helpers are still helpers. They are not going to give their 100%.
 

boredom2012

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2012
Messages
22,686
Reaction score
9,910
I know how to cook

but I don’t understand why I got helper then I cook myself . For what?

nvm I will train her to cook la

can’t believe it. Need to train her to cook…

that’s why getting helper also got problems . You also Suay to get one with hiv
She get it from her bf in Singapore. My mom with dementia and kidney failure have to go for hiv blood test with entire family.
 

qhong61

Banned
Joined
Nov 3, 2015
Messages
73,153
Reaction score
12,239
Realised she’s also not very detailed and meticulous.

always leave my dad to do things on his own. As a result of that he fell down before, just now he stubbed his toes

all cuz she never hold him or make sure he’s safe

I already give her discount in housework liao, ie I do some of the housework myself, so that she can be more meticulous in the taking care of my dad part. Yet she still do half a55 job on taking care of my dad.

I still give her so much money to buy food.her birthday I also giver her angpow. Seriously very disappointed

but compared to my second helper, she’s still ok liao la.

I guess I just have to keep reminding her and telling her. Helpers are still helpers. They are not going to give their 100%.
If they cooking and doing housework how to take care of ur dad?
 

arsenalfc85

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2015
Messages
11,980
Reaction score
8,826
If they cooking and doing housework how to take care of ur dad?
my dad is still mobile. not immobile or wheelchair bound that kind.

So she can still do some housework and cooking la.

But i never ask her to cook every meal. only dinner. and its not everyday

some of the housework i also help to do. She never bao all the housework alone.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts.

Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards, Terms of Service and Member T&Cs for more information.
Top