9K for NSmen doing NS.

koxinga

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
6,435
Reaction score
76
Personally, I still have my doubts that peoeple like us who has done our dues will get the full 9K.....

the hint was given. milestone payments.

this means that there is a pretty good chance for existing active nsmen, we get pro-rated amount. but those who finish their 10 year cycle, may not get anything. the devil is indeed in the details. anyway, i am not complaining as it is still money.

i don't think there would be any end to this discussion on who deserve how much. does the storeman deserve lesser than the infantry man who went to sispec? or how about a citizen storeman versus a PR infantry man? not to mention our police reservist and scdf reservist. there are too many permutations to consider.
 

cancer81

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 27, 2007
Messages
61,055
Reaction score
0
So ok, let's go off tangent and stretch arguemnts a little. before 2007/08, the numbers were not that many to have an impact. Now. there's definitely some (maybe perceived even) impact. A change in surrounding/situation can warrant a change in policy. If everything were to remain as of "day 1", we'd still be a fishing village.


Now that I can agree. Yes, the crux is too lax an immigration filter. But I think you're stretching it by the argument that they live in "some outer plane where everything is cheaper" In truth, I really don't think any do.

But let's look at the picture in detail
A mainland Chinese, India-born Indian and Malaysian PR who is here only for the higher paying job DO translate their savings to a higher purchasing power in their native homeland. So they DO have an advantage over the Singaporean who has all his debts and obligations in Singapore. Especially if they, like their Singapore counterpart, also contribute to their parents expenses. And frankly, if a person only plans to be staying in a place for a certain period of time, honestly they would not want to sink that much of financial commitment into a place beyond what they need to

In short, an excess of $300/month may do little for a Singaporean family, but it does quite a fair bit for those countries I meantioned earlier.


I would think that your perception of what's acceptable, while rightlfully your own, is on the extreme.

Buring their weekends serves no purpose to eqaualize the situation on the workfield except to make their lives difficult, which is not the intent.

Wasting taxpayers money and their time doing fruitless tasks serves no purpose. Again, not the intent.

And while it will please some of the extreme minded to "burn 2 years first and then 10 year immediately after. No pay too" for the PRs and 1st generation citizens, it's not a fair expectation, nor is it realistic.

But what's so wrong in requiring them to be called away from work for 2-3weeks a year, to do, say...community service?

meanwhile the PR needs to eat, commute (paying the same expensive train/bus fare), live (paying a mortgage if they bought a HDB resale and is a bank loan not HDB loan). Guess all those are paid in SGD. No please do not bring up the majority is single thing. I asked around and almost each and everyone of the PRs I asked are not single. Only the Malaysians I come across are single...

Those who do not intend to stay are not going to buy house. They will rent enriching a Singaporean with their rent money. They need to spend here, giving GST. They work here paying income tax with no tax relief. AND If all of them are asking for substantially lesser pay than the average Singaporean. I really wonder how they can save up any money at all. We are sucking their blood and enjoying it yet cursing them for having only so little blood.

community service != wearing green, helmet and carrying a rifle. They are not sweating buckets in mandai/penkang hill/lim chu kang/gedong. It is unfair. What I need to do, they need to do. In fact they need to do more. I go 3 weeks they go 6 weeks.

community service is lobo (no offence to the poster with that nick) and lame. Oh they need to take Cat X Ippt until they are forty. Fail IPPT, everyday RT.

DRACONIAN LAWS FOR THE WIN!!
 

ScootS

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2003
Messages
732
Reaction score
0
Because we simply need them for our economy to grow. That's one of their carrots. Personally, i think it will never happen UNLESS riots start, terrorist attack or opposition dominates.

I disagree.
According to Sinagpore Stats (http://www.singstat.gov.sg/stats/keyind.html#keyind) on data for 2009, there are 3,733900 Singapore Residents with 3200700 being Singaporeans (ie, 533,200 PRs)

Assuming the distribution of male/female/children/aged to eb relatively equal amoung PRs and Citizens, it's roughly a 1PR to 6Citizen ratio.

If we can afford to have 6 Singaporeans going in for Reservist training with no issue, I don't think that the economy is gonna collapse by asking that 1 more PR to do NS duties.
 

sunzoner

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2002
Messages
14,864
Reaction score
343
...

Those who do not intend to stay are not going to buy house.

They can buy a flat now, stay in it for 5/10 years, sell to make a profit and leaves.

esp since we cannot lower the price of HDB flats because this will make those who bought at the height unhappy.

They will rent enriching a Singaporean with their rent money.

They may be renting from another PR...

They need to spend here, giving GST. They work here paying income tax with no tax relief.

Their spending here will be smaller than their earnings. The rest of the money will flow back home to their home country.

Most Singaporean dun pay income tax too...

AND If all of them are asking for substantially lesser pay than the average Singaporean. I really wonder how they can save up any money at all.

It is not uncommon to see malaysian take bus ride back home to JB every night.

It is not uncommon to see other nationalities eat little and send most of their money back. BTW, this is their objective here, sending money back...

We are sucking their blood and enjoying it yet cursing them for having only so little blood.
...

Nope... we are not sucking their blood dry. At least I am not doing the sucking. Maybe the employers are.

We dun curse them. We merely state that the current policies are leveraged in their favour and we asked that the policies be changed. The incumbent is acknowledging that what we stated is not untrue, and they new have new policies to mitigate the uneveness.

of cos, different people have differing opinions on the effectiveness of the policies.
 

ScootS

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2003
Messages
732
Reaction score
0
meanwhile the PR needs to eat, commute (paying the same expensive train/bus fare), live (paying a mortgage if they bought a HDB resale and is a bank loan not HDB loan). Guess all those are paid in SGD. No please do not bring up the majority is single thing. I asked around and almost each and everyone of the PRs I asked are not single. Only the Malaysians I come across are single...

Those who do not intend to stay are not going to buy house. They will rent enriching a Singaporean with their rent money. They need to spend here, giving GST. They work here paying income tax with no tax relief. AND If all of them are asking for substantially lesser pay than the average Singaporean. I really wonder how they can save up any money at all. We are sucking their blood and enjoying it yet cursing them for having only so little blood.
Yes, while the spendings of a PR will be equal to that of a Singaporean's in terms of the daily/necessities expenditure, but the big ticket would be weighed differently.

Housing, furnishing, car will be weighed differently when a person is position differently based on his/her planning

PRs enjoy the same tax rate as Singaporeans. Please check here
http://www.iras.gov.sg/irasHome/page04.aspx?id=1190

If you are referring to the tax reliefs, that's deducted against the taxible income which actually does not translate to a significant differnt in the actual tax itself

community service != wearing green, helmet and carrying a rifle. They are not sweating buckets in mandai/penkang hill/lim chu kang/gedong. It is unfair. What I need to do, they need to do. In fact they need to do more. I go 3 weeks they go 6 weeks.

community service is lobo (no offence to the poster with that nick) and lame. Oh they need to take Cat X Ippt until they are forty. Fail IPPT, everyday RT.

DRACONIAN LAWS FOR THE WIN!!
Here you are just going to the extreme and arguing for the sake of arguing. I don't see any meaningful exchange if that's your intention here
 

cancer81

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 27, 2007
Messages
61,055
Reaction score
0
you need to understand... I need to support that kind of extreme NS for PR thing. Otherwise, people might start thinking I am some FTrash... and that hurts no matter how you spin it.

getting slighted like that over the fact that I was not born here is a serious "universal sign of brotherhood".

I understand that by making them miss 3 weeks of work, people might feel better about it. BUT at the end of the day, the fact they are doing community work is going to rile them when they think about their ATEC, Coastal defence and wearing green sweating buckets in Mandai.
 

ahwei86

Banned
Joined
Dec 6, 2007
Messages
8,071
Reaction score
0
http://www.straitstimes.com/BreakingNews/Singapore/Story/STIStory_572451.html



Seriously what kind of policy is this!?
Not only it cheapen the NS but ask yourself this:

Left Pocket in, Right pocket out..
Where does the 9k come from?
Unless it come from Male PR, Male Foreigner(s) then prehap it sound better, but still not necessary correct. :(

got 9k rebate better than nth... no wonder kids nowadays all chiong command school

i just hope they continue to recognise NS efforts and not shut us up with this pathetic 9k
 

ahwei86

Banned
Joined
Dec 6, 2007
Messages
8,071
Reaction score
0
hiaz... noticed they used the words "stand to get $9,000 each." that means not all nsmen who are singapore citizens will get 9k. most likely the criteria to get the full 9k will be a really strict one... like your nsmen appointment, numbers of years you have serve as nsmen, your financial capability, your ict frequency, etc.

i think in the end most of us will only get a miserable few hundreds... somemore go to cpf and psea... can see cannot touch...

okay...now that sucks. macam an insult to nsmen... and others even like RECORD chairman amy koh wun get it...they still think we gain alot and are ungrateful whiny lot who dun appreciate things
 

ahwei86

Banned
Joined
Dec 6, 2007
Messages
8,071
Reaction score
0
Rather pointless, since they still have not addressed the fact that employers must still give CPF contribution during ICT, making Singaporeans less desirable as potential employees and that long training periods up to three weeks are disruptive for employee / employers as well.

Mr. Prime Minister, these issues will not disappear. A one time payment of S$9K isn't going to wish all these side effects away. What happened to all the scholars you have under you? Is this the best thing they can think up or your defence chiefs not going to budge on training doctrine and policies?

he ownself ROD oredi... so gib himself 9k inside celebrate loh

anw lucky i come this thread, if not i really thot got 9k ****...newspaper really useless...bluff children only
 

Ferrari^^

Banned
Joined
Mar 2, 2008
Messages
2,558
Reaction score
0
i am amazed at the maturity of the forumers here.....if you guys do not want the 9k cpf...you can always deposit it into my cpf account
 
Last edited:

mclemente

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2006
Messages
37
Reaction score
0
The curx of the matter is that Singaporean males are not complainging about NS not being recognised, it's how disadvantaged we are by NS (compared to PRs)... which was not addressed

I'd rather:
1. Pay them 9K to get back 2.5yrs of lost opportunities and income
2. Pay them 9K to hold a PR in limbo from work and study for 2.5yrs

Of course, the above is just wishful thinking... but on a serious note, if they want to level the resentment, they need to look into how to level the playing field.

As it is, Singaporean males are delayed (2yrs fulltime NS) and disadvantaged (10yr NS distruptions from career. They must be daft to think that yearly callups do not affect career progression)

If asking PRs to serve fulltime NS is too impratical (and too taxing for their platoon commanders), at least level the playing field on the yearly disruption at work... require all 1st generation PRs to serve NS duties just like NS men.

PRs' NS duties can take the form of NDP activities or other community related activites ... just make them serve as well


I'm a 1st gen PR and I wouldn't mind serving NS duties like NS men. Serving your adopted country is a way of giving back and showing appreciation for the good things that you enjoy while staying here.
 

Ferrari^^

Banned
Joined
Mar 2, 2008
Messages
2,558
Reaction score
0
I'm a 1st gen PR and I wouldn't mind serving NS duties like NS men. Serving your adopted country is a way of giving back and showing appreciation for the good things that you enjoy while staying here.

i am a true blue singaporean born and bred in singapore, and yes i have IPPT and reservist, and my reservist is in combat....i have nothing against PRs, why bother so much? if there is really so much resentment, then leave the country...work in the UK or US which will yield much more...
 

Ferrari^^

Banned
Joined
Mar 2, 2008
Messages
2,558
Reaction score
0
adding to that, not all foreign workers are foreign talent....some are some are not...

identifying them, that is the question....but the distinction has already been made by the goverment...anyway this is singapore so just chill

wanna migrate? just book a plane ticket, take the plane, land at the airport, look for a hotel, turn on your laptop, email out yr cv, wait for calls, and voila, you got a job and can start work tommorow, after that buy a house then buy a car, and there you have it, a new life in a new country, sounds easy rite?
 

ahwei86

Banned
Joined
Dec 6, 2007
Messages
8,071
Reaction score
0
The admin guys are more cat cleared than the average soldier as they handle more papers which are often classified confidential / secret.

actually thats y all the foot soldiers are throw to rifle coy or RP
 

sunzoner

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2002
Messages
14,864
Reaction score
343
lol i wonder if switzerland's NS gets so much hate..

I wonder if the much famed swiss living standard requries it citizens to work past retirement age and if they still have any retirement age...

Since we are at it, why not wonder about their welfare system, natural resources, politician pay, and immigration figures too???
 

cancer81

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 27, 2007
Messages
61,055
Reaction score
0
and we are back to the usual programming... the gahment suck donkey bawls....

change gahment!! change change change!!
 

lemontree5544

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2007
Messages
638
Reaction score
0
I wonder if the much famed swiss living standard requries it citizens to work past retirement age and if they still have any retirement age...

Since we are at it, why not wonder about their welfare system, natural resources, politician pay, and immigration figures too???

ok you win our lives are terrible
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top