So ok, let's go off tangent and stretch arguemnts a little. before 2007/08, the numbers were not that many to have an impact. Now. there's definitely some (maybe perceived even) impact. A change in surrounding/situation can warrant a change in policy. If everything were to remain as of "day 1", we'd still be a fishing village.
Now that I can agree. Yes, the crux is too lax an immigration filter. But I think you're stretching it by the argument that they live in "some outer plane where everything is cheaper" In truth, I really don't think any do.
But let's look at the picture in detail
A mainland Chinese, India-born Indian and Malaysian PR who is here only for the higher paying job DO translate their savings to a higher purchasing power in their native homeland. So they DO have an advantage over the Singaporean who has all his debts and obligations in Singapore. Especially if they, like their Singapore counterpart, also contribute to their parents expenses. And frankly, if a person only plans to be staying in a place for a certain period of time, honestly they would not want to sink that much of financial commitment into a place beyond what they need to
In short, an excess of $300/month may do little for a Singaporean family, but it does quite a fair bit for those countries I meantioned earlier.
I would think that your perception of what's acceptable, while rightlfully your own, is on the extreme.
Buring their weekends serves no purpose to eqaualize the situation on the workfield except to make their lives difficult, which is not the intent.
Wasting taxpayers money and their time doing fruitless tasks serves no purpose. Again, not the intent.
And while it will please some of the extreme minded to "burn 2 years first and then 10 year immediately after. No pay too" for the PRs and 1st generation citizens, it's not a fair expectation, nor is it realistic.
But what's so wrong in requiring them to be called away from work for 2-3weeks a year, to do, say...community service?