9K for NSmen doing NS.

justicesg

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2010
Messages
719
Reaction score
0
come on the ppl in mycarforum are ok with taking it and i believe they are of a better financial standing....i cannot believe what the ppl here are saying...i am not defending the government in anyway.....but its is impossible to be equal for everyone....even my time as an nsf was reduced by 2 months only...and you guys are talking as though u dun need the 9k....anyway what gives? :s13:

Because we are Singaporeans and it is in our nature to complain about anything and see any policy as a means to screw or insult us further.
 

tazzycorner

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2004
Messages
40,740
Reaction score
6,508
speaking of which ... i kwai kwai completed my cycle last year and MR already ... so $0

so, those guys who kept deferring get the $$ ?!
 

justicesg

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2010
Messages
719
Reaction score
0
The payment should be broken down into 3 portions with payment milestones tied to the supposed serving of the NS and reservist training.

OK my turn to whine.

Actually the payment should be in rebates at the end of the "full" ICT cycle. Good balance of "cash" pot at the end of the rainbow and government can count on people trying to finish the cycle to get real money, not CPF money.
 

cancer81

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 27, 2007
Messages
61,055
Reaction score
0
it is still OA CPF money which can be used to service your HDB purchase. Now if it was thrown into your SPECIAL ACCOUNT. I might agree with it being "neopet money".

if it is just salary, I believe that since you get NSpay there is no loss?? Even if you speculate in stocks and what nots, the phone and a competent agent/wife/buddy can take care of it while you take your ever powerful eye-power off the index.
 

ScootS

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2003
Messages
732
Reaction score
0
it is still OA CPF money which can be used to service your HDB purchase. Now if it was thrown into your SPECIAL ACCOUNT. I might agree with it being "neopet money".

if it is just salary, I believe that since you get NSpay there is no loss?? Even if you speculate in stocks and what nots, the phone and a competent agent/wife/buddy can take care of it while you take your ever powerful eye-power off the index.

Actually, the milestone amounts of $3000 / $3500 will be further divided at the current proportions to the 3 accounts ... so there is 'neopet money' portion too
 

ScootS

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2003
Messages
732
Reaction score
0
Please note PM's speech quoted below.

He said:
This will be a significant token to appreciate the contributions of citizens who have served NS

Note the bold and underlined. It is in past tense. Meaning, those who used to serve NS. Thus means everyone who had served NS. These people may still be serving their ICTs (commonly called reservist or ORNS) or maybe not.

The policy detail announcement following his speech seems to be not in line with what the PM announced. As a citizen of a democratic country, we should not talk about it when policy details seems to contradict the announcement of the people-elected Prime Minister?
National Day Rally Speech (English) by Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong on 29 August 2010, at 8.00pm at University Cultural Centre, National University of Singapore

http://www.pmo.gov.sg/News/Speeches...+PM+Lee+at+University+Cultural+Centre+NUS.htm


When it truth:

1. Those who have served more are recognised less.

2. Those currently in fulltime NS are promised recognition for obligations yet to be fulfilled

3. PRs serving fulltime NS are dangled carrots to take up citizenship

4. Giving the first time, yong and impressionable voters a sweetener to vote for the incumbent

Bottomline: This is NOT a recognition of NSMen nor distinction of citizenship
 

xdivider

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2000
Messages
60,707
Reaction score
19,041
When it truth:

1. Those who have served more are recognised less.

2. Those currently in fulltime NS are promised recognition for obligations yet to be fulfilled

3. PRs serving fulltime NS are dangled carrots to take up citizenship

4. Giving the first time, yong and impressionable voters a sweetener to vote for the incumbent

Bottomline: This is NOT a recognition of NSMen nor distinction of citizenship

Personally, PRs will be DAFT to serve NS for 9K, and since we are getting 'talents', they will know that too............
 

ScootS

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2003
Messages
732
Reaction score
0
Personally, PRs will be DAFT to serve NS for 9K, and since we are getting 'talents', they will know that too............
True ...

But for those who are already serving, I would think it's more of a "why not'?

use the 3K/3.5K ... offset against Uni fees.. then after that then see what other freebies come along
 

germaphobe

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
1,044
Reaction score
0
Debate all you want... but in the end most of us here wont even get it.

News @ AsiaOne

NSmen who passed cycle won't get award

Servicemen who have passed any of the milestones will not get the associated payments. -myp

Wed, Sep 01, 2010
my paper

By Kenny Chee

NATIONAL servicemen can expect to get the disbursement of the National Service Recognition Award (NSRA) by the time they complete their Operationally Ready National Service training cycle.

The monetary award will range between $9,000 and $10,500.

The payout depends on their service period and rank.

The award, which took effect last Sunday, will be paid out in tranches of $3,000 across three milestones of an NSman's service cycle: the completion of full-time national service; the middle of the NSman's In Camp Training cycle; and at the completion of this cycle.

NSmen who are commanders, or hold the ranks of Third Sergeant and above for Singapore Armed Forces (SAF) servicemen and Sergeant and above for Home Team servicemen,will receive $500 more at each milestone to make up a total of $10,500.

The award will not be paid retrospectively, so servicemen who have passed any of the three phases will not get the payments associated with those milestones. They will be eligible only for payouts at milestones they have not yet crossed.


This also means that servicemen who do not have to serve a reservist cycle will get only the first payout after they complete their two-year full-time national service, regardless of vocation.

Regulars will typically not be eligible for the award, but this would depend on when they signed on.

The Ministry of Defence yesterday provided details on the NSRA, which was announced by Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong during his National Day Rally speech on Sunday. The award is only for Singapore citizens.

Minister of State for Defence Koo Tsai Kee reiterated yesterday that the award is to provide "sustained recognition to Singapore citizens who serve national service".

Dr Koo declined to reveal the annual cost to the Government for disbursing the award, but said that it was "significant".

However, he stressed that there was no monetary value that could be put on the contributions of NSmen.

The first payout will be deposited into each NSman's Post-Secondary Education Account (PSEA) after his full-time national service is completed. It can be used for further education in approved institutions here.

The PSEA, run by the Education Ministry, cannot be used for education overseas.

The remaining two payouts will be deposited into NSmen's Central Provident Fund (CPF) accounts and allocated based on prevailing rates for the Ordinary Account, Special Account and Medisave Account.

Any unused funds in the PSEA will be transferred to the NSman's CPF Ordinary Account when he turns 30.

Payouts of the award will be done within two months of reaching any of the three disbursement phases.

NSmen can go to www.mindef.gov.sg/nsra for more details.


kennyc@sph.com.sg

For more stories on the National Day Rally speech, click here.
For more my paper stories click here

Copyright ©2010 Singapore Press Holdings Ltd. Co. Regn. No. 198402868E. All rights reserved.
Privacy Statement Conditions of Access Advertise
 

crankyedwin

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 17, 2005
Messages
2,440
Reaction score
0
must game the system. if smart defer and defer to avoid ict. and if cannot avoid, then serve and get neopet money! for those who ord already, second and last payment is mid-way and end. game it. after get mid-term, defer defer and defer until last year they will surely call you back give you gold watch, swiss army knife or ntuc voucher on stage.
 

MioFan

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2010
Messages
1,079
Reaction score
0
I just read the newspaper today. Sian. I am not eligible for the 1st milestone. I have not serve my first ICT though.

The true amount of compensation the government must pay us is the total work income that might have been gained if we didn't serve NS.
 

xdivider

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2000
Messages
60,707
Reaction score
19,041
Actually, If u assume an average singaporean to get a job starting from 3K, therefore, the 2 yrs u owe can be approximated to 24x3=72K. Pple who do not want to send there kids to NS can then pay MINDEF the difference by installments (200-300 per month) and the money collected can be used to hire professional soldiers or to run a standing army. Factor in 1-2 month's pay as levy every yr in lieu of ICT...........
 

fox1

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2001
Messages
28,007
Reaction score
561
Actually, If u assume an average singaporean to get a job starting from 3K, therefore, the 2 yrs u owe can be approximated to 24x3=72K. Pple who do not want to send there kids to NS can then pay MINDEF the difference by installments (200-300 per month) and the money collected can be used to hire professional soldiers or to run a standing army. Factor in 1-2 month's pay as levy every yr in lieu of ICT...........

The thing is people do not want to sign on because;

- regulars beh kan
- you want you sign on lor
- what can you do after your contract ends
- no cam hp
- no degree no talk


Many more crap floating around. Just dig.
 

silx1980

Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2007
Messages
257
Reaction score
0
Hmm, seems like opportunity costs are not brought up at all. Imagine you are the employer, you have an impt project to delegate out. Now you have 2 person that can take this project up, however, the local is gonna serve his ICT soon and it clashes with the project. But the FT doesn't. Common sense here, who are you gonna give the project to?
That is basically one of the biggest gripe here that serves as a advantage for the FTs. That is further compounded by the opening of the floodgates. If the FT numbers were small, employers can't really choose but rather have to make do and adjust the schedule accordingly. But now, they can simply choose to get the FTs to do the project instead.

Its pro-business but can you blame the locals for griping over this. I really don't see it benefiting locals in any way.
 

lampano

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 9, 2007
Messages
30,738
Reaction score
12,919
Huh, I dun deserved the 1st 2 milestones?

3K for my 2.5yrs in army?



Well done keep it up.
You are sure pushing us pretty well
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top