Edifier S2000MKIII review

benedium

Banned
Joined
Jan 22, 2005
Messages
12,474
Reaction score
3,715
I don't mind big speakers and I got no wife or kids. Live alone so no problem. I already have my avr subwoofer and passive speakers. Just want something up to standard to hear what music is supposed to sound like and to act as a sound quality reference point for future passive speaker purchases.
 
Last edited:

wwenze

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2002
Messages
82,950
Reaction score
27,022
Wah the krk rokit 7 g4 is half price of JBL. Is JBL still worth the upgrade in terms of sound quality? Thanks for your help.

Wish I was rich enough for it to not matter heheh. My rich friend got the Genelec 8341a at about $7.5k. Ouch.

It's pricing for each, so rokit g4 is more expensive
 

benedium

Banned
Joined
Jan 22, 2005
Messages
12,474
Reaction score
3,715
I will go audition KRK and JBL one day then. Lemme Google research more first heheh. Thanks again wwenze, u the best, as always.
 
Last edited:

wwenze

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2002
Messages
82,950
Reaction score
27,022
What about compare this to JBL LSR308mkii?

TBH I prefer this tweeter to LSR series's but LSR *should* have better dispersion*accurate response
Bass is 305's loss for sure

So 308 should give better bass extension while still providing the same treble performance. If your application requires a big speaker, then go for it.
 

Dhitto

Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
367
Reaction score
0
The LSR308 is superceded by the 308P MkII .

If you can get them on sale, they are really good. But a little bit on the big side. Make sure you have sufficient space to place them before buying though. As the bass port is rear facing, you need a little bit of space at the back for best results. At least 20~30 cm for adjustment.

If you want something slightly smaller, but with enough power to fill a typical HDB room, the 306P might be worth considering. Lazada is selling at SG$399 now.
 

wwenze

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2002
Messages
82,950
Reaction score
27,022
Measurements

1. Close mic
XJJkqG4.png

- 2.4kHz crossover
- A lot of the bass extension comes from the port
- There's a jump in the tweeter's response with close-mic, but this does not show up / is not obvious in other measurements. Weird.
- Response is squiggly for some reason

2. Table edge 0 degrees (blue) vs 45 degrees (orange)
in5fUX3.png

Interesting off-axis behavior. Drops fairly early on at 4.5kHz but stays flat after that, until it drops again after 13kHz.

Table edge 0 degrees: Can be interpreted as a shelf filter in treble, or just simply downwards sloping. From eyeball estimates, it's a 5dB variation, but the loudest is in the bass at roughly 100Hz and then it's a straight line downwards until the end at ~16kHz, with some slight boosts in the middle frequencies.

Retake with grilles off, blue is 0 degrees the other two are 45 degrees. The one with less reduction I set measuring point at the phase plug.
3PNcAXa.png
3. Listening position, straight
On the table with back against the wall, like how it would be in practice. Mic cal 0 degrees pointing straight on tweeter axis.
7nv88pp.png


Dip at 5kHz is likely due to reflections as it fluctuates upon repeated measurements. Dip at 10kHz... probably not.

Interestingly straight, until the bass where it *might* have peaked slightly before rolling off. Still a downward sloping straight line but now we're at 6 to 7dB total variation.

4. Listening position, 90 degrees
Actual usage scenario, sitting between two speakers and measuring one, no toe in which means 45 degrees off-axis. Mic cal 90 degrees pointing upwards.
BTDOHLa.png


I subjectively like that boost below 1kHz
Bass starts rolling off at around 100Hz, but slowly, so we still get usable output at 40Hz before it starts to decrease fast.
Going 45 degrees off-axis means getting less >5kHz. Strangely it doesn't feel that way subjectively, having more HF details than S-520 which measures flat from 2kHz to 10kHz. Maybe that on-axis HF somehow finds its way into my ear but doesn't get picked up by the mic.
 
Last edited:

wwenze

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2002
Messages
82,950
Reaction score
27,022
Problem with tweeter close-mic

That waveguide phaseplug thingy in the middle makes close-mic results inconsistent
DCpK8ps.png
 

BillyKueek

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 24, 2019
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
I am considering between this Edifier S2000MKIII and Swan M200MKIII. From youtube reviews, the Swan sounds better but the S2000MKIII has 5.0 BT and is Hi Res. Comments please?
 

benedium

Banned
Joined
Jan 22, 2005
Messages
12,474
Reaction score
3,715
I am considering between this Edifier S2000MKIII and Swan M200MKIII. From youtube reviews, the Swan sounds better but the S2000MKIII has 5.0 BT and is Hi Res. Comments please?

Maybe you should rephrase and say something like... edifier S2000mkiii sounds like a radio compared to swan m200mkiii. Heheh.
 

zzzzzzz

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2004
Messages
48,381
Reaction score
10,545
I don't mind big speakers and I got no wife or kids. Live alone so no problem. I already have my avr subwoofer and passive speakers. Just want something up to standard to hear what music is supposed to sound like and to act as a sound quality reference point for future passive speaker purchases.
i also live alone

i have this in my "study" room and the r2000db in my living room
:frown:
 

zzzzzzz

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2004
Messages
48,381
Reaction score
10,545
what volume level do u all usually listen at? i find at vol 6 onwards is get loud and i scared my neighbour come up and hamtum me

input is motherboard spdif, just listening to youtube
:frown:
 

wwenze

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2002
Messages
82,950
Reaction score
27,022
You can reduce your spdif volume......

My computer has EqualizerAPO which adds a -14dB preamp. Then OS volume control is 20 when playing music and 100 when playing movie. I need to set volume to 40. Highest is 50 I think?
 

zzzzzzz

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2004
Messages
48,381
Reaction score
10,545
You can reduce your spdif volume......

My computer has EqualizerAPO which adds a -14dB preamp. Then OS volume control is 20 when playing music and 100 when playing movie. I need to set volume to 40. Highest is 50 I think?
40? :s31:

where to reduce spdif volume? i thought is just a digital signal cannot be alter? do u mean the windows volume bar thinggy? i always thought the windows volume should set it to max so that there is as little loss in fidelity, at least when using analogue outputs

funny thing is my tv spdif is too low when watching dvbt2 and too loud when watching youtube (R2000DB)
:frown:
 

wwenze

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2002
Messages
82,950
Reaction score
27,022
where to reduce spdif volume?

When you adjust the OS volume in Windows

i thought is just a digital signal cannot be alter?

Windows is constantly generating new signals then converting it into audio. That's why you can do things like play music and youtube and a game at once. It only becomes non-alterable when bitstreaming is occurring, in which case you can't play music and youtube and game at once either.

do u mean the windows volume bar thinggy? i always thought the windows volume should set it to max so that there is as little loss in fidelity, at least when using analogue outputs

Yes, and no. A car is most efficient when driving at 5th gear but that doesn't mean you shouldn't use lower gears.

funny thing is my tv spdif is too low when watching dvbt2 and too loud when watching youtube (R2000DB)

Youtube and CD music are loud. Digital TV and BD are soft. This is just how it is, nothing to do with SPDIF or anything.
 

rocket

Senior Member
Joined
May 31, 2003
Messages
850
Reaction score
2
thinking of plunging into buying this Edifier s2000 mkIII.
any recommended store to buy and what is the price? saw lazada around $569
Also does anyone upgrade the stock cables? how is the original stock cables quality?
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts.

Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards, Terms of Service and Member T&Cs for more information.
Top