High Cholesterol. Need advice.

KPO_SAHM

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2018
Messages
31,481
Reaction score
14,404
Think abt the Bad Habits of unhealthy eating.

Look at books for nutrition s and healthy eating.

Spend time reading it rather than eating
Cut down on beer. Cigarette s and soft drinks

Just drink mineral water Only


Sugar plays a huge part in our healthy. It makes Ur liver produces bad cholesterol
 

KPO_SAHM

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2018
Messages
31,481
Reaction score
14,404
My wife report v wierd

TC 240+
LDL borderline high

Funny is she jogged 3-4x a week
Occasionally eat snacks



She likes sugar? Usually bakes or snacks and instant beverages use hydrogenated oil
 

Asure7

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2009
Messages
5,253
Reaction score
309
Just sharing my short experience, maybe can help or get some insights too.
I was eating unhealthily because I was well, "skinny, can afford to eat", and didn't mind gaining weight.

Was at polyclinic for separate illness and had to take a blood test.

f1pBSOD.png



As can be seen on the spreadsheet,
Sep 2023: LDL was on High side. Started to take a low dosage statin (10mg), and kind of glossed over the slightly out of range ALT reading.
On top of the med, started to take note of diet, no more McD just before I go to sleep. Tried to eat more healthily. Nothing drastic.

Dec 2023: Within just 3 months, huge improvement. LDL fell from 4.3 to 2.0 (using a different unit here). Since cholestrol was back to good levels, doc then started to look into the ALT reading and arranged to do liver test.

Jun 2024: Can see LDL went up a little bit, but still good. Liver test results came back not looking good. Numbers jumped compared to previous values. Confirm NAFLD, liver inflammation.
I actually kinda knew why. I got complacent because of the statin with good cholestrol results. Was having either bubble tea or a large McD Oreo Mocha Frappe almost every day.

Lesson learnt: Just because you take statins does not mean you can ignore your diet.
Stopped the frappe McD, reduce bubble tea etc. Couldn't cut completely (I still eat these, just not as frequently).
Also avoided rice at night for dinner. No pepper lunch!
Of course I can get faster/better results if i cut all the unhealthy things, but i was trying to go for something more sustainable, something i can continue to follow through and not give up and stop 1/2 way.
Basically I eat whatever I want for lunch, and avoid rice for dinner. I do have many cheat days still. I still have my snacks but reduced portion.
I still have soft drinks, but instead of finishing an entire can with a meal, a can can now last for 5 days.
Also switched to low sugar drinks (not the zero sugar due to artificial sugar). In fact I'm so used to the taste now, when i tried the McD mocha frappe again, i felt it was far too sweet and stopped drinking it. Even for bubble tea, I had to go for minimum sugar level instead of "normal".


Nov 2024: Liver results good this time (no more inflammation) ! Oh yeah, forgot to mention I was also taking milk thistle to "detox" liver and reduce inflammation. All these results based on diet only, no increase in exercise. I do think one of the biggest factor is reducing sugar drinks and avoiding rice at night.
Just through the above, I've lost more than 8% of body weight "naturally" (and hopefully the liver fats).

ps: Will be a liver stiffness soon to see how bad the fatty liver is, or whether any improvement.
 
Last edited:

rogze79

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2004
Messages
2,369
Reaction score
704
well reducing overall weight will reduce visceral fat ie. fatty liver included. Certain components of diet do affect fatty liver. Saturated fat, trans fat, fructose affect liver worse than other macros. In fact saturated fat increases liver fat more than fructose in overfeeding studies (something which our carnivore friends here will never mention). While commercial fructose syrup is harmful, fruit intake has not been shown to worsen fatty liver. Other toxins may induce fatty liver like alcohol and certain drugs.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7082640/

Saturated Fat Is More Metabolically Harmful for the Human Liver Than Unsaturated Fat or Simple Sugars​

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9428722/
Well, we do not know what's the base diet for these 38 overweight individuals averaging bmi of 30.

For a weight gauge of what's a 170cm person with BMI of 30, that's 87kg. Everyone in the study is a high risk individual of numerous health issues.

It will be really interesting if a control group of regular folks with average BMI of 23 is included.
 

AcquiT

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 19, 2011
Messages
5,412
Reaction score
766
What is her daily food intake like? 🤔
Some snack are heavy process as well🤔
Ate chips once a month and a can of beer

But usually she dont take dinner

I saw someone posted same pattern as her as in readings for regularly exercise.

Her hdl is low ,high ldl
And yes fatty liver too

Her diet is normal i would say
Mixture of food but seldom eat fried etc also
 

wawalau

Banned
Joined
Sep 29, 2008
Messages
153
Reaction score
27


Someone more qualified than me commented on the study



Prof Bikman also commented on this study towards the end of his video (around 26 mins)

Anyway, nobody in their right mind would recommend overfeeding in any circumstances

well if a carnivore advocate cannot accept human trials of overfeeding showing the toxic effect of saturated fat on the liver, then how about an underfeeding human trial (ie .caloric restriction) showing substituting sat fat with unsaturated fat leading to more desirable outcome in fatty liver.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39290088/
..Dietary and plasma FA were investigated in patients with non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (n 48) previously enrolled in a 12-week-long open-label randomised controlled trial comparing two energy-restricted diets: a low-carbohydrate high-fat diet and intermittent fasting diet (5:2), to a control group..


Replacing SFA with PUFA may improve metabolic parameters in non-alcoholic fatty liver disease patients during weight loss treatment.


The irony is ben hikman like other carnivore advocates like to give biased statements like high fat + high carb leading to the skewed result for sat fat. The trial above shows sat fat in low carb hypocaloric environment is worse off for fatty liver. One can always give all sorts of mechanisms for justifying their stand but human data shows otherwise. So ben can eat his words now.
 
Last edited:

KPO_SAHM

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2018
Messages
31,481
Reaction score
14,404
Seldom drink cold or sweet drink

Maybe kopi in morning
I guess is more to genetic


I don believe in genetic. Last time dr also told me that and I believed in it. Till I met my classmate who also believed in genetic and under medication. He cut down all fried food, processed, dressing & sauces , sugar and pastries ....exercise daily and eating oats. 3 months cholesterol dropped by 50%. I didn that too and cholesterol dropped too
 

Ironside

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2005
Messages
41,691
Reaction score
21,352
How many people with lousy cholesterol profile also have unhealthy poo, meaning unhealthy intestinal flora? This is a sign of metabolic disorder. Diet, probiotics, exercise and good sleep can tune back the problematic metabolism if it is at early stage of deterioration.
 

rogze79

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2004
Messages
2,369
Reaction score
704
well if a carnivore advocate cannot accept human trials of overfeeding showing the toxic effect of saturated fat on the liver, then how about an underfeeding human trial (ie .caloric restriction) showing substituting sat fat with unsaturated fat leading to more desirable outcome in fatty liver.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39290088/
..Dietary and plasma FA were investigated in patients with non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (n 48) previously enrolled in a 12-week-long open-label randomised controlled trial comparing two energy-restricted diets: a low-carbohydrate high-fat diet and intermittent fasting diet (5:2), to a control group..


Replacing SFA with PUFA may improve metabolic parameters in non-alcoholic fatty liver disease patients during weight loss treatment.


The irony is ben hikman like other carnivore advocates like to give biased statements like high fat + high carb leading to the skewed result for sat fat. The trial above shows sat fat in low carb hypocaloric environment is worse off for fatty liver. One can always give all sorts of mechanisms for justifying their stand but human data shows otherwise. So ben can eat his words now.
Guess you only read briefly about the secondary analysis trying to prove associations or correlations regarding the link you posted.

You can read more on the original clinical trial regarding the POSITIVE benefits of lchf and IF towards fatty liver disease.

https://www.jhep-reports.eu/article/S2589-5559(21)00032-X/fulltext

There's always noise. Aka weak studies.or analysis. Do not confuse yourself/others or stick to certain ideology.
 

wawalau

Banned
Joined
Sep 29, 2008
Messages
153
Reaction score
27
Guess you only read briefly about the secondary analysis trying to prove associations or correlations regarding the link you posted.

You can read more on the original clinical trial regarding the POSITIVE benefits of lchf and IF towards fatty liver disease.

https://www.jhep-reports.eu/article/S2589-5559(21)00032-X/fulltext

There's always noise. Aka weak studies.or analysis. Do not confuse yourself/others or stick to certain ideology.
Firstly you misunderstood me. i am in agreement that lowering sugar and calories are good for fatty liver.

secondly the study subjects are in caloric deficit which means all fatty liver will improve. the question is how much they improve based on their diet qualities.

the sub-analysis shows that low carb high sat fat is worse off than low carb high unsat fat for fatty liver, consistent with many other studies in humans and mice showing sat fat is bad

It is the denial trait that is present in many carnivores that keep insisting sat fat is good, by giving excuses that the liver toxicity present in overfeeding is caused by carbs. Ironically the less than stellar effect is also present in underfeeding with low carb.


When such human RCTs whether overfeeding or underfeeding studies contradicts the carnivore narrative, it becomes "noise" or "weak studies".

It appears faith is dominant over science.

Both fructose and saturated fat are bad for the fatty liver, and if one wants to optimise their diet, they can go LOW CARB, LOW SAT FAT/MODERATE UNSAT FAT, HIGH PROTEIN.
 
Last edited:

rogze79

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2004
Messages
2,369
Reaction score
704
Firstly you misunderstood me. i am in agreement that lowering sugar and calories are good for fatty liver.

secondly the study subjects are in caloric deficit which means all fatty liver will improve. the question is how much they improve based on their diet qualities.

the sub-analysis shows that sat fat is worse off than unsat fat for fatty liver, consistent with many other studies in humans and mice.

It is the denial trait that is present in many carnivores that keep insisting sat fat is good, by giving excuses that the liver toxicity present in overfeeding is caused by carbs. Ironically the less than stellar effect is also present in underfeeding with low carb.


When such human RCTs whether overfeeding or underfeeding studies contradicts the carnivore narrative, it becomes "noise" or "weak studies".

It appears faith is dominant over science.

Both fructose and saturated fat are bad for the fatty liver, period.
you are relying on the subjective interpretation of the secondary analysis to make your conclusion. The researchers implied correlations and associations.

Faith is never the factor in science. There's always good science and bad science. Strong evidence matters.

Did you even read the original rct?
 

wawalau

Banned
Joined
Sep 29, 2008
Messages
153
Reaction score
27
you are relying on the subjective interpretation of the secondary analysis to make your conclusion. The researchers implied correlations and associations.

Faith is never the factor in science. There's always good science and bad science. Strong evidence matters.

Did you even read the original rct?
i did.

and i am agreeing that hypocaloric low carb works for fatty liver. but in the same group i told you also that the unsat fat group does better than sat fat.

it clearly shows the sat fat narrative from the carnivore is bs, whether overfeeding or underfeeding


so whats there to argue?
 

rogze79

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2004
Messages
2,369
Reaction score
704
i did.

and i am agreeing that hypocaloric low carb works for fatty liver. but in the same group i told you also that the unsat fat group does better than sat fat.

it clearly shows the sat fat narrative from the carnivore is bs, whether overfeeding or underfeeding


so whats there to argue?
Where's the part that show the unsat fat does better in the original study?

I will be glad to be proven wrong.
 

wawalau

Banned
Joined
Sep 29, 2008
Messages
153
Reaction score
27
Where's the part that show the unsat fat does better in the original study?

I will be glad to be proven wrong.
this is amusing. the original study did not report the breakdown. the subsequent study breakdown the original study's data to do further subanalysis.

this is common in many studies as original study may not provide all the analysis whether in pure, diet fits etc
 

rogze79

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2004
Messages
2,369
Reaction score
704
this is amusing. the original study did not report the breakdown. the subsequent study breakdown the original study's data to do further subanalysis.

this is common in many studies as original study may not provide all the analysis whether in pure, diet fits etc
I guess logic is not needed at all.

Why not read this to see if your logic holds?

https://www.bmj.com/content/353/bmj.i1246
 

Nuclear Boy

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2009
Messages
22,687
Reaction score
11,956
I don believe in genetic. Last time dr also told me that and I believed in it. Till I met my classmate who also believed in genetic and under medication. He cut down all fried food, processed, dressing & sauces , sugar and pastries ....exercise daily and eating oats. 3 months cholesterol dropped by 50%. I didn that too and cholesterol dropped too

Just curious, what kind of oat do you guys consume? I've read that GI for quick cook kind is worse than white rice. At home, only quick cook kind is stocked, because my father is the main consumer and he doesn't like the long cooking time for rolled oats. He just douses them in hot water for 30mins to reconstitute.

Meanwhile, I don't cook those oats, but soak in cold milk for a handful of hours for them to soften in the fridge, but not fully puff up like after hot water. I find cold oats tend to sustain me longer too. So that's a compromise I'm making for now.
 

wawalau

Banned
Joined
Sep 29, 2008
Messages
153
Reaction score
27
I guess logic is not needed at all.

Why not read this to see if your logic holds?

https://www.bmj.com/content/353/bmj.i1246
so it appears that you are unable to retort the overfeeding and underfeeding argument and chose to throw another rct with limitations clearly written to sidestep the issue.

btw unsat fat does not equate seed oil

i have read that rct before, no trans fat info, no smoking hx, no pre-existing cardiac info taken into consideration for cohort>65 yrs old in 1 yr stay in hosp. do you know there are many uncorrected confounders that can cloud the conclusion?

i can also throw many other studies with fair share of limitations such as this
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33853582/

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40200-024-01453-z

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-024-03124-1#Sec2
 
Last edited:
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top