High Cholesterol. Need advice.

rogze79

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2004
Messages
2,369
Reaction score
704
so it appears that you are unable to retort the overfeeding and underfeeding argument and chose to throw another rct with limitations clearly written to sidestep the issue.

i have read that rct before, no trans fat info, no smoking hx, no pre-existing cardiac info taken into consideration for cohort>65 yrs old in 1 yr stay in hosp. do you know there are many uncorrected confounders that can cloud the conclusion?

i can also throw many other studies with fair share of limitations such as this
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33853582/

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40200-024-01453-z
 

rogze79

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2004
Messages
2,369
Reaction score
704
I have shown you the original rct proving the case.

Maybe you just took a quick glance at the Minnesota coronary experiment rct. You decided that it's not good enough for you.
Did you come across a better study that that?

Yet you throw in an epidemiological questionnaire type study to prove your point.

I'm surprised that you cannot see the evidence right in your face. To each his own. You can continue to double down on your unsaturated fats
 

testerjp

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2006
Messages
46,845
Reaction score
16,188
Just curious, what kind of oat do you guys consume? I've read that GI for quick cook kind is worse than white rice. At home, only quick cook kind is stocked, because my father is the main consumer and he doesn't like the long cooking time for rolled oats. He just douses them in hot water for 30mins to reconstitute.

Meanwhile, I don't cook those oats, but soak in cold milk for a handful of hours for them to soften in the fridge, but not fully puff up like after hot water. I find cold oats tend to sustain me longer too. So that's a compromise I'm making for now.
Instant oats should be still alot more superior compare white rice being rich in fibre which slows down the absorption of cholesterol and sugar.

It creates this Beta-Glucan which is gooey soluble fibre which sounds like how psyllium husk works too. I asked chatGPT, it seem to strongly recommend psyllium husk.

Psyllium husk when mixed with water becomes a jelly, it smells like wood fibre, like hay. :(
The best brand is yerba with the lowest amount of lead tested by consumerlab.


Chatgpt o1

I’ll approach this question from the perspective of a nutrition scientist, focusing on the mechanisms of how dietary fiber affects LDL (“bad”) cholesterol and comparing instant oats to psyllium husk.

How Instant Oats Help Against LDL​

  1. Beta-Glucan Content
    • Oats (including instant oats) are rich in a type of soluble fiber called beta-glucan. Beta-glucan forms a gel-like substance in the intestines, which helps trap dietary cholesterol and reduce its absorption into the bloodstream.
  2. Impact on Bile Acids
    • Beta-glucan also binds to bile acids (which the body uses to digest fats). Because bile acids are made partly from cholesterol, binding and excreting them prompts the body to pull more LDL cholesterol from the blood to make new bile acids, thereby lowering circulating LDL.
  3. Effectiveness of Instant Oats vs. Other Oat Forms
    • The soluble fiber content (beta-glucan) in instant oats is generally similar to rolled or steel-cut oats, although the overall glycemic index might be higher in instant oats.
    • When it comes to lowering LDL specifically, the form of oat (instant, rolled, steel-cut) doesn’t drastically change the total beta-glucan content, as long as you choose a product that is mostly whole oats (i.e., limited added sugars or flavorings).
  4. Practical Intake
    • The American Heart Association suggests that consuming about 3 grams of beta-glucan per day (roughly the amount in 1½ cups of cooked oats) can have a noticeable effect on lowering LDL.

2. Comparison: Instant Oats vs. Psyllium Husk​

  1. Fiber Type and Concentration
    • Oats provide beta-glucan (a viscous soluble fiber), but also contain vitamins, minerals, and a small amount of protein.
    • Psyllium husk primarily provides soluble mucilage (another type of gel-forming fiber). Psyllium is more of a concentrated fiber supplement—meaning you get mostly fiber and very few other nutrients.
  2. Cholesterol-Lowering Effects
    • Both beta-glucan (from oats) and psyllium (particularly the soluble part) have been shown to reduce LDL cholesterol.
    • In some clinical studies, psyllium husk may lower LDL by anywhere from 5% to 10% when taken in sufficient amounts (often 7–10 grams of soluble fiber from psyllium daily).
    • Oats can have a similar percentage reduction in LDL if enough beta-glucan is consumed (about 3 grams or more daily).
  3. Additional Nutritional Value
    • Oats provide a broader nutrient profile: B vitamins, minerals (magnesium, iron), and antioxidants. This makes oats a good dietary staple beyond just the fiber.
    • Psyllium husk is primarily used for fiber supplementation (cholesterol-lowering, digestion, and bowel regularity). It doesn’t offer the same vitamin/mineral profile.
  4. Ease of Use & Taste
    • Instant oats can be easy to incorporate daily—hot cereal, overnight oats, smoothies, etc.
    • Psyllium husk is often taken dissolved in water or added to smoothies, but it has minimal flavor and can become very thick (gel-like) if left to sit.
  5. Possible Downsides
    • Instant oats: Watch out for added sugars or flavors, which can undermine the health benefits. Plain instant oats are fine.
    • Psyllium husk: Taking too much too quickly may cause bloating, gas, or constipation if you don’t also increase your fluid intake.

3. Practical Tips & Takeaways​

  1. For LDL Management
    • You can use either instant oats or psyllium husk—or even both—to help lower LDL. The main factor is getting enough soluble fiber consistently.
  2. Balancing Fiber Intake
    • Aim for 25–38 grams of total fiber per day (depending on age, gender, and overall diet). Of this, try to ensure at least 5–10 grams come from soluble fiber.
    • A typical serving of oats has 2–3 grams of soluble fiber; a tablespoon of psyllium husk can have around 3–5 grams of soluble fiber.
  3. Overall Dietary Context
    • Soluble fiber is just one aspect of cholesterol management. Other key factors include:
      • Limiting saturated and trans fats.
      • Incorporating healthy fats (e.g., from nuts, seeds, avocados).
      • Maintaining a balanced diet with plenty of vegetables, fruits, and other whole grains.
      • Getting regular physical activity.
  4. Getting the Most Out of Instant Oats
    • Choose plain or low-sugar instant oats.
    • Enhance the nutritional value by adding seeds (like chia or flax), fruits, or nuts.
  5. Using Psyllium Husk
    • Introduce it gradually if you’re new to fiber supplements.
    • Mix it in water, juice, or a smoothie and drink promptly before it gels.

Conclusion​

Instant oats (thanks to their beta-glucan) and psyllium husk (due to its concentrated soluble fiber) can both be powerful in helping to reduce LDL. Which is “better” often depends on personal preference, tolerance, and how each fits into your overall diet. Oats provide extra nutrients and are easy to incorporate into meals, whereas psyllium is more of a fiber-focused supplement that you can add to nearly any beverage. Both are worthwhile options in a cholesterol-lowering strategy, especially when paired with a balanced diet and a healthy lifestyle.
 

Mecisteus

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2002
Messages
56,078
Reaction score
12,452
I don believe in genetic. Last time dr also told me that and I believed in it. Till I met my classmate who also believed in genetic and under medication. He cut down all fried food, processed, dressing & sauces , sugar and pastries ....exercise daily and eating oats. 3 months cholesterol dropped by 50%. I didn that too and cholesterol dropped too

You can read r/cholesterol.

Some people share their numbers there.

There are people with LDL of 200+ and triglycerides of 1000+ at young age. These are no way due to lifestyle and diet.
 

qhong61

Banned
Joined
Nov 3, 2015
Messages
72,439
Reaction score
12,048
Will char siew pau, red bean paste pau and lotus paste pau bad for cholesterol?
 

Ironside

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2005
Messages
41,691
Reaction score
21,352
You can read r/cholesterol.

Some people share their numbers there.

There are people with LDL of 200+ and triglycerides of 1000+ at young age. These are no way due to lifestyle and diet.
Metabolic disorder due to exposure to unnatural food and poor lifestyle habits
 

standarture

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2009
Messages
63,300
Reaction score
19,746
You can read r/cholesterol.

Some people share their numbers there.

There are people with LDL of 200+ and triglycerides of 1000+ at young age. These are no way due to lifestyle and diet.
I wont be surprised for SG context. Young people dont really go for health checkup. I think only NS is their major checkup. If they have been eating hawker food and mala, bbq regularly, i can bet many actually have borderline or high cholesterol already but just that they never went for checkup.

But high cholesterol is definitely somewhat genetic. Diet with the right chemicals or drugs can reduce it.
 

carey

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2002
Messages
40,964
Reaction score
5,247
well if a carnivore advocate cannot accept human trials of overfeeding showing the toxic effect of saturated fat on the liver, then how about an underfeeding human trial (ie .caloric restriction) showing substituting sat fat with unsaturated fat leading to more desirable outcome in fatty liver.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39290088/
..Dietary and plasma FA were investigated in patients with non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (n 48) previously enrolled in a 12-week-long open-label randomised controlled trial comparing two energy-restricted diets: a low-carbohydrate high-fat diet and intermittent fasting diet (5:2), to a control group..


Replacing SFA with PUFA may improve metabolic parameters in non-alcoholic fatty liver disease patients during weight loss treatment.


The irony is ben hikman like other carnivore advocates like to give biased statements like high fat + high carb leading to the skewed result for sat fat. The trial above shows sat fat in low carb hypocaloric environment is worse off for fatty liver. One can always give all sorts of mechanisms for justifying their stand but human data shows otherwise. So ben can eat his words now.
There are NO human trials that can show direct causation, only correlation, as other confounding factors cannot be removed

And like I said before, NO human in their right mind advocates over feeding

Anyone who has tried a low carb high fat diet would know that it's very hard to over eat - so I really don't know where your premise that we are over feeding on SFA comes from

I think if you listen to Ben's video, a combination of high carb (highly processed food) and high fat is a recipe for disaster - nobody disputes that and typically folks who eat such a diet tend to be overweight, smoke and have other issues to begin with

Anyway, I get the impression that you seem more qualified than Prof Ben - mind sharing your credentials? What trials and research have you conducted? My curious mind wants to know :unsure:
 

carey

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2002
Messages
40,964
Reaction score
5,247
Just curious, what kind of oat do you guys consume? I've read that GI for quick cook kind is worse than white rice. At home, only quick cook kind is stocked, because my father is the main consumer and he doesn't like the long cooking time for rolled oats. He just douses them in hot water for 30mins to reconstitute.

Meanwhile, I don't cook those oats, but soak in cold milk for a handful of hours for them to soften in the fridge, but not fully puff up like after hot water. I find cold oats tend to sustain me longer too. So that's a compromise I'm making for now.
If you have to eat oats, go for steel cut oats, not the instant ones

Some "ferment" them overnight
 

carey

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2002
Messages
40,964
Reaction score
5,247
I guess logic is not needed at all.

Why not read this to see if your logic holds?

https://www.bmj.com/content/353/bmj.i1246
Exactly, a lot of folks are still pushing the lipid hypothesis even though studies after studies show little, if any, benefits from replacing SFA with PUFA

Instead, the reverse may be true if cholesterol is lowered too much (from the above meta analysis)

The traditional diet heart hypothesis predicts that participants with greater reduction in serum cholesterol would have a lower risk of death (fig 1⇑, line B). MCE participants with greater reduction in serum cholesterol, however, had a higher rather than a lower risk of death.

F6.large.jpg
 

Nuclear Boy

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2009
Messages
22,687
Reaction score
11,956
If you have to eat oats, go for steel cut oats, not the instant ones

Some "ferment" them overnight

Do they require cooking (with heat), or can be reconstituted cold with milk over time?

What means "ferment" here? 😮
 

carey

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2002
Messages
40,964
Reaction score
5,247


Interesting watch about what are better "predictors" of CHD - LDL is not one of them
 

grevq80o

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2008
Messages
8,157
Reaction score
4,740
My LDL also jumped alot in 6 months.

I did yearly ultrasound, the last check says that they observed more fatty liver.
I don't drink, so it's non-alcoholic fatty liver.

So I'm wondering is the fatty liver causing it to haywire and drive up a lot of cholesterol.
Those with high cholesterol may want to check if they have fatty liver.
Since 80% of cholesterol is produced by the body than diet.

I'm 62kg 173cm.
I read that reducing weight 5 to 10% is the key, but that will put me to 56kg to 59kg, very thin man,
Don't see how else to effectively reduce that.

If reducing the fatty liver is indeed the key, then isn't the target is to fast and reduce weight, more than the diet itself?
Rike that you on any statins? Statins work by inhibiting liver produce cholesterol
 

grevq80o

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2008
Messages
8,157
Reaction score
4,740
I exercised for several x more than 3 months. And controlled my diet too.
My LDL refused to go down... my HDL did go down instead! 😔 😢. ... only the test taken early this month showed a finally showed a slight decrease, but still too high. HDL and Triglycerides both went in wrong direction for this latest test

Deep fried, beef , mutton, cakes, ice cream , sugar, fatty pork , chicken drumsticks etc are no no. Except on special occasions eg birthdays.
Plenty of fibre, but still......
Lost a lot of weight.
exercise is supposed to increase HDL... but yours actually dropped! ... this is really real world.. not everything works according to the book.
 

ahnyaahnya

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2010
Messages
34,664
Reaction score
10,975
exercise is supposed to increase HDL... but yours actually dropped! ... this is really real world.. not everything works according to the book.
Fortunately, I have high level HDL still. Was 4+ mmol. Now 3+ only.
But strangely my Triglycerides showed a huge jump at latest test although it had been going down previously . From less than 1 to 2.6. Within 2 months . Doc said that it's cos the latest test was a non fasting one ( needed non fasting for the sugar test done at same time). Googled, found article that said there would be an increase in Triglycerides as compared to a fasting test. But the figure quoted was negligible, IIRC 0.2 or 0.3. So I'm puzzled, why the big jump?
 
Last edited:

testerjp

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2006
Messages
46,845
Reaction score
16,188
Rike that you on any statins? Statins work by inhibiting liver produce cholesterol
No, polyclinic doctor asked me not to take first. Asked me to change diet and monitor 4 months later with another blood test. The blood test also has some test on the enzymes from the liver, the readings are okay. My glucose is also fine.

My ldl was 3.x in July, so it's quite a jump within a short period.
 

AngelRomeo

Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 14, 2024
Messages
9,312
Reaction score
3,611
Just did a health check and cholesterol numbers are:
- Total Cholesterol: 252 mg/dL
- HDL Cholesterol: 51 mg/dL
- LDL Cholesterol: 182 mg/dL
- TC/HDL Ratio: 4.95
- Triglycerides: 95 mg/dL

Need to start taking meds? Any other advice?
EDMW not your personal doctors.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top