iPhone 12 Series

Shadow79

Senior Member
Joined
May 27, 2001
Messages
1,355
Reaction score
40
I believe many are disappointed with the MagSafe wireless charging performance. I have the MagSafe wireless charger and the original 20W power adaptor. Did another test using the USB meter, this time in an air conditioned room. The phone took 1 hour to charge from 46% to 89%. This time I observed no pause in charging compared to afternoon test. I believe the phone is really sensitive to the temperature when doing wireless charging. The charging slowly increased to 18W at start. Probably spent around 10 mins around 15-18W and then dropped to around 10W+ before stabilising at around 7.5W for at least half an hour or more. Definitely not the fastest but rather more for convenience. My use case is basically to charge overnight. As I usually off the room light and do some reading before sleep, it’s easier for me to just put the phone on the magnetic charger instead of trying to find the cable and the port in the dark.
 
Last edited:

sylves

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 13, 2005
Messages
708
Reaction score
14
I believe many are disappointed with the MagSafe wireless charging performance. I have the MagSafe wireless charger and the original 20W power adaptor. Did another test using the USB meter, this time in an air conditioned room. The phone took 1 hour to charge from 46% to 89%. This time I observed no pause in charging compared to afternoon test. I believe the phone is really sensitive to the temperature when doing wireless charging. The charging slowly increased to 18W at start. Probably spent around 10 mins around 15-18W and then dropped to around 10W+ before stabilising at around 7.5W for at least half an hour or more. Definitely not the fastest but rather more for convenience. My use case is basically to charge overnight. As I usually off the room light and do some reading before sleep, it’s easier for me to just put the phone on the magnetic charger instead of trying to find the cable and the port in the dark.


I guess this use case could easily be replace by a smart energy plug which you can set for it
 

icyflame

Master Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
3,900
Reaction score
316
I believe many are disappointed with the MagSafe wireless charging performance. I have the MagSafe wireless charger and the original 20W power adaptor. Did another test using the USB meter, this time in an air conditioned room. The phone took 1 hour to charge from 46% to 89%. This time I observed no pause in charging compared to afternoon test. I believe the phone is really sensitive to the temperature when doing wireless charging. The charging slowly increased to 18W at start. Probably spent around 10 mins around 15-18W and then dropped to around 10W+ before stabilising at around 7.5W for at least half an hour or more. Definitely not the fastest but rather more for convenience. My use case is basically to charge overnight. As I usually off the room light and do some reading before sleep, it’s easier for me to just put the phone on the magnetic charger instead of trying to find the cable and the port in the dark.

From what I read, Apple had good intentions. The MagSafe uses the PD3.0 profile based on 9v 2.2a. This newer profile “talks” to the iPhone and slows down the speed/output when the phone gets warm (seems to be around 39 degrees). This is probably aligned with Apple’s intentions to pressure battery life.

So if the intention was good, what failed Apple is their engineering team. The MagSafe gets too hot too fast, making me wonder whether it is more harmful to the phone battery instead of preserving it.

The more heat there is, it implies that the MagSafe is inefficient. I am hoping that a firmware upgrade will solve it, but I believe it is a hardware design issue given how widespread this is. So I am returning both sets till they sort this out
 

ragnarok95

Senior Moderator
Senior Moderator
Joined
Mar 9, 2004
Messages
125,419
Reaction score
6,657
Bad charging on the MagSafe might be software issue. MagSafe use NFC to talk to the phone right? Maybe future iOS update will fix this. Maybe.
 

icyflame

Master Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
3,900
Reaction score
316
Bad charging on the MagSafe might be software issue. MagSafe use NFC to talk to the phone right? Maybe future iOS update will fix this. Maybe.

Am still hoping so, especially given that iOS 14.2 is coming soon. What Apple can do is probably increase the temp allowable from 39- say 45. However, given that people are experiencing “hot” when touching, I doubt this will solve the problem and will degrade the battery more.

Because it is an inefficient design, the inefficiency is translated to heat, causing the slow down.
 

ragnarok95

Senior Moderator
Senior Moderator
Joined
Mar 9, 2004
Messages
125,419
Reaction score
6,657
Am still hoping so, especially given that iOS 14.2 is coming soon. What Apple can do is probably increase the temp allowable from 39- say 45. However, given that people are experiencing “hot” when touching, I doubt this will solve the problem and will degrade the battery more.

Because it is an inefficient design, the inefficiency is translated to heat, causing the slow down.

Imagine connecting magsafe. with tracetogether app in the background and playing genshin impact. lololol
 

bedlamite

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2002
Messages
1,977
Reaction score
51


Review is a little bit up it’s own arse, for lack of a better term, but some ppl might enjoy this kind of stuff
 

icyflame

Master Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
3,900
Reaction score
316
Which area of SG u stay bro. I'll take note of the explosion to be reported in the news lol

Nah, I believe that it will be safe. Just that you will probably see “reverse charging” working, meaning that the iPhone percentage keeps dropping even when plugged in with MagSafe 😆
 

ragnarok95

Senior Moderator
Senior Moderator
Joined
Mar 9, 2004
Messages
125,419
Reaction score
6,657
Pro apple user will hate this but i feel apple sucks at charging related thing. Their Airpower is still no-where in sight. Nomad already have a similar product selling for months.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top