Lasik eye Surgery

weathersohot

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 18, 2012
Messages
7,754
Reaction score
405
I have done pre-assessment at Shinagawa and Clearvision.
1. Shinagawa: Staff were professional, however, seems like clinic only provides intralase lasik (bladeless, flap creation). Response via Whatsapp very quickly, assessment took 2.5hours.
2. Clearvision: Felt that assessment was done in a rush, but doc (Dr Huang) was alright, answered my questions patiently. Clinic provides transPRK and Smilerelex. Response via Whatsapp very quickly too, assessment took 1.5 hours.

Decided to go for transPRK as I thought it's better in the long term though recovery is longer. Booked surgery date with Clearvision mid July (earliest slot quoted was end June).

Not sure if these clinics can claim Medisave, suppose you will be eligible to use Medisave since the power between both eyes is 300.
Can I know why you say TransPRK is better got the long term?
 

LV Boi

Junior Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2020
Messages
43
Reaction score
8
Table 1 - Comparison of Trans-PRK, LASIK, and SMILE


Trans-PRK​
LASIK​
SMILE​
Indication​
Myopia (−0.5 to −9.75D), astigmatism (0.0 to 5.0d), hyperopia (+0.5 to +6.0D)​
US FDA: myopia (−0.5 to −8.0d), astigmatism (0.0 to 3.0d), hyperopia (+0.5 to +6.0D)​
U.S FDA: myopia (−1.0 to −10.0d), astigmatism (0.75 to 3.0D)​
Refraction correction​
Surface ablation​
Lamellar ablation​
Lenticule extraction​
Globe contact/suction-required​
No​
Yes​
Yes​
Platform​
Single​
Two (flap creation and excimer laser)​
Single​
Eye-tracking system​
Yes​
Yes​
No​
Cyclotorsion compensation system​
Yes​
Yes​
No​
Customized treatment profile​
Yes​
Yes​
No​
Visual recovery time​
3rd (mo)​
1st (d)​
2nd (wk)​
Aberrations​
Least (limited compared data with LASIK or SMILE)​
Higher SA, HOAs​
Higher coma when compared with wavefront-guided FS-LASIK​
Dry eye (corneal nerve reinnervation %)​
90% at 2 y FU​
27% at 6 mo FU; 79% at 5 y FU​
55% at 1 month FU​
49% at average 4.1 y FU​
59% at average 4.1 y FU​
100% at 6-16 mo FU​
86% at 6 mo FU. Limited long-term data.​
Dry eye (corneal sensitivity recovery %)​
100% at 3-6 mo FU​
Biostability​
Strongest​
Weakness​
Intermediate​
Other advantages​
Thin cornea, epithelial basement membrane disease, subtle topographic irregularities​
No flap-related complication​
Disadvantages​
Postoperative pain, corneal haze​
Flap-related complication, potential risk of corneal ectasia​
Lenticule-related complication, limitation in enhancement​
 

LV Boi

Junior Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2020
Messages
43
Reaction score
8
summary :

prk = stongest for weak thin corneas , but long recovery& discomfort .

Lasik = immediate vision, longer dry eyes, has iris tracking / wavefront so treat high degree / astig the best.

Smile = less dry eye but no tracking rotaton compensation / poorer for high power & astig.

DYOR.
 

weathersohot

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 18, 2012
Messages
7,754
Reaction score
405
summary :

prk = stongest for weak thin corneas , but long recovery& discomfort .

Lasik = immediate vision, longer dry eyes, has iris tracking / wavefront so treat high degree / astig the best.

Smile = less dry eye but no tracking rotaton compensation / poorer for high power & astig.

DYOR.
Yes, I already did my research. Was just wondering why do people pick prk over smile.
 

chasingsunset7

Junior Member
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
9
Reaction score
2
Can I know why you say TransPRK is better got the long term?
I decided on TransPRK as I wasn't entirely comfortable with the thought of creating a flap which may cause any complications in future e.g. IF I were to fall, do bungy jump etc. though recovery takes a while. But of course, I had the luxury of taking almost 1.5 weeks of MC and not worry about my work email exploding.
 

chasingsunset7

Junior Member
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
9
Reaction score
2
Why do most of you choose TransPRK over SMILE? Any specific reasons?
Technically I didn't choose TransPRK over SMILE, but rather was recommended by my clinic. I didn't second question why not SMILE over TransPRK but I did my research and was comfortable and aware of the TransPRK procedure/recovery. I would say it's never a specific procedure that is better (each clinic will sure say all the good things about the procedure they are recommending, and highlight the negative side of the rest), it's just how comfortable you are with the clinic/doctor/procedure/recovery.
 

kinosa

Junior Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2017
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Hi, I requested for an appointment on Eagle Eye website about a week ago and have yet to receive any replies. Does anyone know how long it usually takes for them to get back to me?
Thanks.
 

Covid19_Phase2

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 23, 2020
Messages
527
Reaction score
171
Hi, I requested for an appointment on Eagle Eye website about a week ago and have yet to receive any replies. Does anyone know how long it usually takes for them to get back to me?
Thanks.

I think the best way is to give them a call bah?
 

twinbaby

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2014
Messages
5,460
Reaction score
1,527
I have went for lasik. Close to one month. Still have glare at night time. And dry eyes when wake up in the morning. But no big deal compared to wearing glasses
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top