[Official] Home Automation Thread

zoneguard

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2000
Messages
1,957
Reaction score
398
One of the bros mentioned the concern about this going thru a China cloud...I have read that these Tuya devices can be hacked like Sonoff to run custom firmware to localised the control.

List of compatible devices that can be flashed to Sonoff with OTA.

This wiki has more details on the app associated with similar devices: Smart Life or Jinvoo Smart or eFamilyCloud.

With local_key obtained, it is also possible to use the device locally without going through CN cloud.

I hooted 2 'Tuya' smart plugs and waiting for them to arrive to try out.
 
Last edited:

Alphas

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2004
Messages
41,390
Reaction score
5,804
Did you buy this locally? how much is this?

One of the bros mentioned the concern about this going thru a China cloud...I have read that these Tuya devices can be hacked like Sonoff to run custom firmware to localised the control.

Locally, $47.80 for a 4 gang and USB ports is good value.
 

shacboi

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 25, 2017
Messages
758
Reaction score
0
Any of u using IP camera which uses SMART Life / eWelink app? Or know any IP camera using that app, cos I wanna get one that can integrate with IFTTT to trigger something when motion detected for example, thanks in advance! :s13:
 

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
Thanks for responding back.

If only IFTTT, I have set that up already. However, im facing the problem to connect that to alexa scene (routine) via fibaro. I.e. to be added as a device in fibaro. I want a scene where i can call out to somfy to lower blinds, dim my lights, turn on projector etc. However with ifttt, i can only do 1 thing at a time with alexa.
from my engineer perspective to consumer, it makes sense for Alexa to set the limitation.

Apple and Google and Amazon have their own devices. They cannot say " NO u must use our devices" that will make 3 of them to lose market share. They do what the angmos always does, limit u, make u taste alexa and u will use devices that is under their production.

Not that the abv is 100% truth, but it doesnt goes far from that

Disclaimer: no i dun work for somfy. we also have agreement w somfy for them to tag on our products. So that when our integrators use somfy, they still get their warranty using our products as part of the bigger picture

Thank you for sharing the 1 at a time thing. Will bring that up if i get to see the somfy guy(usa) in next roadshow if any answers will share here

=====//=====
Personal understanding with IFFFT applets / modules; the only solution i can think of, is have developer to create a lump action. say u command, "option Alpha" instead of end user to go, 1 at a time, all these actions have been pre-program to do that single string of actions (max at 3); Althernatively, it has been programed to do certain set of actions (max 3) in pre-schedule time. There is a product i am aware of does it as Geo-fencing, where user is within the 1 KM from home, the system will pop up, and the person (who is driving) will say to alexa, I will be home in 5 mins. and Alexa simply open ac unit, on audio in the house w fave music, upload dinner recipe on fridge and lastly garage door. Saw that in roadshow also. So there are products that does that not one at a time with Alexa, the price is :s34:cos product basically have signed agreement w Google and Apple
 
Last edited:

pajamasguy

Junior Member
Joined
Sep 28, 2007
Messages
83
Reaction score
0
Thanks for responding back.

If only IFTTT, I have set that up already. However, im facing the problem to connect that to alexa scene (routine) via fibaro. I.e. to be added as a device in fibaro. I want a scene where i can call out to somfy to lower blinds, dim my lights, turn on projector etc. However with ifttt, i can only do 1 thing at a time with alexa.

have you tried stringify.com ?
you can do multiple things with one trigger
 

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
NO6l6zp.jpg


Has anyone bought this smart plugs before? It has a 4x sockets and can be connected to Alexa, IFFT and Google home. The square plug has energy monitoring. I just tried it and it works very well. THe app to connect is smart life, has both android and iOS version.
https://www.tuya.com/
I am not a big fan for using switches as such. In fact, none of my sso at home is without a toggle switch.

- Safety reasons (it burns out, u dunno)
Kaboom fire whole strip thru ur devices attached

- do they have thermal overload protection on that strip?

- 16A (13A rated) cable to the plug? if its 13A (10 rated) really its gg.com i have one of that at home. 2/4 burn out liao. everytime i switch on devices, only can switch on 2 at any time. (i need to count the wattage usage before switching if that make sense)

- bear in mind that the 4USB plug-in, generically, when 4 use are plug in the max output current is jus 1A each. Not suitable for charging devices requiring more than 1A i.e iPad. Say if u wanna charge a device that need 2A, then u only can max use 2 out of 4 USB. Simply, there is only a max O/P of 4Amps again, that's generic speaking
 
Last edited:

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
have you tried stringify.com ?
you can do multiple things with one trigger
too much products out there. some products change name when they sold in different regions of the world.

I am not end user, but 1/10 of my job scope is observe different type of end user concerns.
 

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
"cloud" also another jurisdiction issue. one of many issues, Like China haven't sign agreement, so anything goes, you are not protected.
 

AsusEpoxy

Master Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2003
Messages
3,438
Reaction score
23
Kaboom fire whole strip?? dude, this is fear mongering.
While i respect that you are in this respective industry, ask yourself which powerstrip (even Spring certified ones) in this price range offers thermal overload protection? Having fuse protection at this price point is good enough.

You talk about 4 devices can't support, you did not even specify which high drain devices you plugged in. It's all about common sense. High drain devices should never share electrical outlets.

The usb ports are a convenience. For that price point, don't tell me you are expecting Qualcomm Quick Charge 3.0 or 4.0? Might as well add Dash VOOC ya?

This is all about serving different HA needs at different price points. The stuff you are talking about is definitely more expensive.



I am not a big fan for using switches as such. In fact, none of my sso at home is without a toggle switch.

- Safety reasons (it burns out, u dunno)
Kaboom fire whole strip thru ur devices attached

- do they have thermal overload protection on that strip?

- 16A (13A rated) cable to the plug? if its 13A (10 rated) really its gg.com i have one of that at home. 2/4 burn out liao. everytime i switch on devices, only can switch on 2 at any time. (i need to count the wattage usage before switching if that make sense)

- bear in mind that the 4USB plug-in, generically, when 4 use are plug in the max output current is jus 1A each. Not suitable for charging devices requiring more than 1A i.e iPad. Say if u wanna charge a device that need 2A, then u only can max use 2 out of 4 USB. Simply, there is only a max O/P of 4Amps again, that's generic speaking
 
Last edited:

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
Kaboom fire whole strip?? dude, this is fear mongering.
While i respect that you are in this respective industry, ask yourself which powerstrip (even Spring certified ones) in this price range offers thermal overload protection? Having fuse protection at this price point is good enough.

You talk about 4 devices can't support, you did not even specify which high drain devices you plugged in. It's all about common sense. High drain devices should never share electrical outlets.

The usb ports are a convenience. For that price point, don't tell me you are expecting Qualcomm Quick Charge 3.0 or 4.0? Might as well add Dash VOOC ya?

This is all about serving different HA needs at different price points. The stuff you are talking about is definitely more expensive.
i have seen enough non common sense..even in the office. the technical ppl wun do this, what about admin staff or even cleaners? the same common sense rule really dun apply to everyone. u can say i am paranoid, which personally i mention, i wun buy such.

sometimes is not about people in this thread who actually post. sometimes is about people at home who doesn't know. For one i know that if u plug in high wattage device, e, u cannot switch on another device. the cable will heat up and u can feel it. cos its 13A meaning it rated 10A

if u refer usb, i din say it cannot support, i am only saying, if u plug in all 4 usb, be aware that the max load may not be what u reckon due to the way how some manufacturer "sell' it or "word" it.

What i mention is just generic, i did not consider if that product is spring certified.
Think of it as this scenario, ur whole strip have no toggle switch, out of convenience, of la someone just wanna quickly charge device. and there are already 3 devices that are plug in, but since there is no "off" toggle available, the whole board(strip) is running max load. I am just stating in a worst case scenario, it will catch fire. at least my mother wun think, oh have 3 devices liao, go n calculate eh-say buay. tio boh?
 
Last edited:

Epi_curean

Member
Joined
Feb 25, 2001
Messages
246
Reaction score
0
I was looking into SmartThings to replace my existing hub and I stumbled upon Hubitat. From their forum, it seems that the community is growing positively with community-developed device handlers. I think one of the key advantages it has over SmartThings is localised device control, i.e. commands do not have to go through the cloud.

Unfortunately, they do not ship to Singapore. After speaking to Bruce (Chairman of Hubitat), he had made it available for shipping to Singapore. However, they only have it in UK and US z-wave frequencies (Singapore has moved to Korean z-wave frequency).

Since my existing z-wave products are on EU frequency, I had placed order for the UK version of Hubitat. For now, I'm waiting for its arrival from US, will share more once I gotten my hands on it. :)

What is your total outlay including shipping? I am also interested in getting the exact same EU freq model.
 

hAiZzZ86

Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2004
Messages
8,241
Reaction score
1
Hi, Can someone please educate me what is the advantage of running Home Assistant on RPi?
Currently i have a smart system of broadlink and xiaomi devices which integrates with GH.
Everything works fine here. I cant find a reason to "upgrade"
 

zoneguard

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2000
Messages
1,957
Reaction score
398
Hi, Can someone please educate me what is the advantage of running Home Assistant on RPi?
Currently i have a smart system of broadlink and xiaomi devices which integrates with GH.
Everything works fine here. I cant find a reason to "upgrade"
Removes dependency on cloud as both Broadlink and Xiaomi uses cloud servers. If cloud servers get hacked, your network may also be vulnerable..

Latency should also improve for response time to commands since it is handled locally.
 

medscy

Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2006
Messages
497
Reaction score
5
Removes dependency on cloud as both Broadlink and Xiaomi uses cloud servers. If cloud servers get hacked, your network may also be vulnerable..

Latency should also improve for response time to commands since it is handled locally.

If I may add that hassio on RPI gives you more flexibility and control and you can also integrate stuffs that run on mqtt. Furthermore, Hassio also allows you to have fanciful dashboard unlike the boring UI of Broadlink iHC or EControl.

But of course there is downside. If you are looking for voice controls like GH, it will be tougher since u might need to configure port forwarding in your network , dabble with dynamic dns and get developer accounts on Google to get it working. Alternatively, you can run on HACloud. But this is a chargeable service... Not forgetting that you also need to pay for the electricity consumed by RPI which some may argue that it is negligible. This RPI will also become a single point of failure if it is down unlike cloud providing high availability. Also note that by opening up to GH, you are also inadvertently opening up the security Pandora box. GH is a cloud service anyway.

All these depends on your needs and risk appetite. Fully agree that the cloud security of these Chinese providers is likely questionable. But more importantly, u might want to assess what is the impact to u if it HA network gets compromised. For me, I will never link up door access systems like digital lock to this and would put all these HA stuff on a different vlan.
 

sellun

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2013
Messages
1,487
Reaction score
51
Interesting. But how serious is a breach in security if somehow someone managed to get into your system? I mean who would want to waste effort to attack normal people like us?
Worse I can think of is open door if your HA is link to door lock? Secretly filming using your security cam?

I mean what is the real risk for us "nobody"?

Sent from HUAWEI BLA-L29 using GAGT
 

medscy

Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2006
Messages
497
Reaction score
5
Interesting. But how serious is a breach in security if somehow someone managed to get into your system? I mean who would want to waste effort to attack normal people like us?
Worse I can think of is open door if your HA is link to door lock? Secretly filming using your security cam?

I mean what is the real risk for us "nobody"?

Sent from HUAWEI BLA-L29 using GAGT
My friend, nowadays hackers also cast their nets using script bots and not necessary spear attacks. Cloud is a good target because of risk concentration.

You can google Mirai on the IoT attack a couple of years ago. Usually, these IoT devices are collateral damages... There is usually another jewel crown. It can be a DDoS campaign or it can use the compromised IoT devices to attack your PC on your network which will have more valuable data like your personal photos (for extortion) or even credential thefts.

Nearer to HA, there are also perverts who can take over control of your cameras like the one below.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmi...say-lewd-things-to-a-2-year-old/#3d7e2f24aad6
 

hAiZzZ86

Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2004
Messages
8,241
Reaction score
1
Thank you all for all the insights!
Definitely linking to GH is my priority due to voice command activation.
I find it controlling with phone a hassle.

I will go read up on the integration with GH before jumping into it.
Thanks!
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top