Penrose Sims Villa

Passerboy

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2019
Messages
7,573
Reaction score
736
Carpark will become residential, many more supply there :)

7iGAU4e.jpg

When that happens, DFR also need to bear w the construction noise and dust for 3-5years?
 

shadow84

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2009
Messages
34,295
Reaction score
423
I am looking at PR with interest but I really fail to convince myself how the two schools you’ve listed add value... it’s not brand name schools, so to speak...

Maybe it may attract a small pool of expats with kids there or students studying in JCU, but it’s not like - WOW branded primary school!

Just saying as it is.

A branded school does not produce a branded student. Moreover, i have frens who are from branded atas school and some were stuck up, some cant cope with the stress from school and parents. Better off going to neighborhood sch.
 

Passerboy

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2019
Messages
7,573
Reaction score
736
A branded school does not produce a branded student. Moreover, i have frens who are from branded atas school and some were stuck up, some cant cope with the stress from school and parents. Better off going to neighborhood sch.

This one ain’t branded school, it is an international school so as to speak, thus it is looking more from the rentability aspect to tap on families or staff who attend JCU.
 

1993newbie

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2018
Messages
6,361
Reaction score
501
Indeed, similar case for those that bought 1 bedder Trilinq for investment coz wanna be next to Nan hua.

Up till today, no 1 bedder resale transacted. Quick check on prop guru, 19 One bedder listing asking from $860k. That’s even higher than new launch Parc clem 1 bedders, $696k.
CJjtuPM.jpg

Branded sch also must see the kind of unit. I ever hear someone said he wants to invest in a 1 bedder and one of the reason is because got pei hwa nearby. For someone who wants to send their kids to sch, it's highly unlikely he will rent or buy the 1 bedder. So the sch is almost irrelevant to the consideration, just something agents use to convince buyers to buy.
 
Last edited:

aiyahwhatever

Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2007
Messages
273
Reaction score
1
Branded sch also must see the kind of unit. I ever hear someone said he wants to invest in a 1 bedder and one of the reason is because got pei hwa nearby. For someone who wants to send their kids to sch, it's highly unlikely he will rent or buy the 1 bedder. So the sch is almost irrelevant to the consideration, just something agents use to convince buyers to buy.

I agree with you that there are other considerations if people are purchasing for the school. Well if someone is rich enough, they can buy a one bedder to put down the address. But there are other better ways of doing it.

Yes, want to market the proximity of good schools also got other considerations lar... hahaha. It’s not a major selling point.
 

aiyahwhatever

Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2007
Messages
273
Reaction score
1
A branded school does not produce a branded student. Moreover, i have frens who are from branded atas school and some were stuck up, some cant cope with the stress from school and parents. Better off going to neighborhood sch.

Agree that branded school does not produce a branded student, but this isn’t the point of my earlier comment haha. This is another discussion all together :p
 

drkcynic

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2007
Messages
57,430
Reaction score
26,943
I agree with you that there are other considerations if people are purchasing for the school. Well if someone is rich enough, they can buy a one bedder to put down the address. But there are other better ways of doing it.

Yes, want to market the proximity of good schools also got other considerations lar... hahaha. It’s not a major selling point.

It's plausible yes. But you are supposed to stay at your register address for 30 mths or get kicked out of the sch if it's found you are not staying there. I think parents won't want to live in fear for 30 mths.

Anyway 2C less than 1km isn't much of an advantage these days if you want to enter a branded school.
 

song2608

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2007
Messages
33
Reaction score
9
Looking at some of the views and reply, and as someone who has stayed in the area in the late 1970s to early 1980s, and now still go back at least once a week for lunch with old pals, I am now tempted to also give my two cents.

-What type of vibes are you expecting? this is an old HDB estate with some of the neighboring land becoming light industry over the years. 20/30 years back, nobody would have expected a private condo (and now 2) to be in this area. So what would happen in 10 years time... maybe room for imagination with that piece of residential land beside Penrose, and the commercial land beside the MRT.

Food and shops: This is just a stones throw away to one of the best hawker centre (and surrounding coffee shops) in a 5 km range. Maybe only second to Old airport road. Green chilli chicken rice, 2 Duck rice (the ex-hollywood and the teochew), 2 carrot cake stall equally good. The pig organ soup which is sold out before 12pm. And of course the wan ton mee at the coffee shop (1 hour wait).

For the shops, there is a s-pool 4D shop (great!) , durian store, a china physician (Mr Liu?) who cured my asthma, the overhead bridge to the MRT has a lift as well, good for old man like me.

The 2 international schools will provide some rental pool as well, (the foreign students from the JCU and the staff from the Nexus).

Branded developer, Nice layout, the Magical last question, Price, which we will find out on the 26th Sept. Hoping to have Vested Interest.
 

propertyinvestor40

Master Member
Joined
Feb 24, 2020
Messages
3,973
Reaction score
1,168
Looking at some of the views and reply, and as someone who has stayed in the area in the late 1970s to early 1980s, and now still go back at least once a week for lunch with old pals, I am now tempted to also give my two cents.

-What type of vibes are you expecting? this is an old HDB estate with some of the neighboring land becoming light industry over the years. 20/30 years back, nobody would have expected a private condo (and now 2) to be in this area. So what would happen in 10 years time... maybe room for imagination with that piece of residential land beside Penrose, and the commercial land beside the MRT.

Food and shops: This is just a stones throw away to one of the best hawker centre (and surrounding coffee shops) in a 5 km range. Maybe only second to Old airport road. Green chilli chicken rice, 2 Duck rice (the ex-hollywood and the teochew), 2 carrot cake stall equally good. The pig organ soup which is sold out before 12pm. And of course the wan ton mee at the coffee shop (1 hour wait).

For the shops, there is a s-pool 4D shop (great!) , durian store, a china physician (Mr Liu?) who cured my asthma, the overhead bridge to the MRT has a lift as well, good for old man like me.

The 2 international schools will provide some rental pool as well, (the foreign students from the JCU and the staff from the Nexus).

Branded developer, Nice layout, the Magical last question, Price, which we will find out on the 26th Sept. Hoping to have Vested Interest.

I think the sg pool got help u win some money. :)
The doctor also quite power
 

propertyinvestor40

Master Member
Joined
Feb 24, 2020
Messages
3,973
Reaction score
1,168
Today I visited the penrose actual site again. My 3rd time visiting.
Walking distance with just 100-200 metres I can access to a total of 3 coffee shop, 1 hawker and market and a total of 3 convenient shops.
For food and necessities, ppl above the age 35 definitely will appreciate the convenience. No need to drive or take bus to get the basic needs settled.
Also total of 3 hair salon, 2 clinics , 2 Chinese tcm shop. Stationary shop, lighting shops, 五金店, sg pool shop, 2 durian shop, and a few other shops that I might have missed out.
It is not crowded, consider to me, it is a slow pace environment, u dun see people rushing here and there etc paya lebar square, cck lot 1, Punggol waterway point. It feel like time move at a slower pace around this area which I feel it is a very livable place, make u feel relaxed and dun think about work so much, like retirement.
For those in doubt, do come pop by at this area and feel for yourself. U will agree with what I say. Basic needs are all settled within 100-200 metres. For a early breakfast or lunch or tabao dinner after work or even just buying a coffee or tea. It is so convenient. Even for buying groceries in the market or daily products from convenient shops.
A few of u talk about the vibes which I dun quite understand, if everyday u see people rush here rush there, office wear, crowded, ppl ask u do survey, u also feel stress and it affects health in the long run. Try alighting at tampines mrt, u will know what I mean. People rushing here and there. Crowded. See Liao also stress.
Let’s say u wanna have a family day for Once a week or twice a week -u can use mrt go to Bugis (3 station away) or paya lebar (1 station away) or if u drive, it is just 5-10 minutes away. For friends or family gathering day and shopping mall I think it is pretty convenient.
With Dakota , kallang , geylang bto mop incoming, your potential of capital appreciation is there. And the bto is not cheap in this area. This pool will wanna upgrade someday.
 
Last edited:

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
Today I visited the penrose actual site again. My 3rd time visiting.
Walking distance with just 100-200 metres I can access to a total of 3 coffee shop, 1 hawker and market and a total of 3 convenient shops.
For food and necessities, ppl above the age 35 definitely will appreciate the convenience. No need to drive or take bus to get the basic needs settled.
Also total of 3 hair salon, 2 clinics , 2 Chinese tcm shop. Stationary shop, lighting shops, 五金店, sg pool shop, 2 durian shop, and a few other shops that I might have missed out.
It is not crowded, consider to me, it is a slow pace environment, u dun see people rushing here and there etc paya lebar square, cck lot 1, Punggol waterway point. It feel like time move at a slower pace around this area which I feel it is a very livable place, make u feel relaxed and dun think about work so much, like retirement.
For those in doubt, do come pop by at this area and feel for yourself. U will agree with what I say. Basic needs are all settled within 100-200 metres. For a early breakfast or lunch or tabao dinner after work or even just buying a coffee or tea. It is so convenient. Even for buying groceries in the market or daily products from convenient shops.
A few of u talk about the vibes which I dun quite understand, if everyday u see people rush here rush there, office wear, crowded, ppl ask u do survey, u also feel stress and it affects health in the long run. Try alighting at tampines mrt, u will know what I mean. People rushing here and there. Crowded. See Liao also stress.
Let’s say u wanna have a family day for Once a week or twice a week -u can use mrt go to Bugis (3 station away) or paya lebar (1 station away) or if u drive, it is just 5-10 minutes away. For friends or family gathering day and shopping mall I think it is pretty convenient.
With Dakota , kallang , geylang bto mop incoming, your potential of capital appreciation is there. And the bto is not cheap in this area. This pool will wanna upgrade someday.

Who need 2 durian shops, 3 hair saloons and lighting shop? Typical old neighborhood settings. You asking those bto at better location at Kallang and dakota to downgrade their location to stay in PR?
你头脑进水呀? (Quote from u :s13:)
Try harder :D
 
Last edited:

Seipher

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2004
Messages
581
Reaction score
4
Talking about btos mop.. I've seen this being raised as an exit point not just for this but also for other projects.. how big of an impact does this actually have on the resale transaction? Especially since agents are pushing u to go for new launches in order not to miss the first mover advantage.

For these buyers they experienced unlocking their property value by going in first hand for hdb. Why will they actually go for a resale when I'm sure there's just gonna be long list of new launches waiting?
 

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
Talking about btos mop.. I've seen this being raised as an exit point not just for this but also for other projects.. how big of an impact does this actually have on the resale transaction? Especially since agents are pushing u to go for new launches in order not to miss the first mover advantage.

For these buyers they experienced unlocking their property value by going in first hand for hdb. Why will they actually go for a resale when I'm sure there's just gonna be long list of new launches waiting?

Go for resale is perfectly fine, but what’s the motivation of upgrading to this “depressing” site? I wouldn’t even call this as upgrading. HDB Upgraders have tons of choices to upgrade to better locations.
 
Last edited:

Passerboy

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2019
Messages
7,573
Reaction score
736
Go for resale is perfectly fine, but what’s the motivation of upgrading to this “depressing” site? I wouldn’t even call this as upgrading. HDB Upgraders have tons of choices to upgrade to better locations.

BTO Upgraders have plenty of choice after unlocking the value of their newly MOP flat, Dakota residents would likely consider Waterbank@Dakota in that same area or even Kallang Riverside.
 

Seipher

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2004
Messages
581
Reaction score
4
Go for resale is perfectly fine, but what’s the motivation of upgrading to this “depressing” site? I wouldn’t even call this as upgrading. HDB Upgraders have tons of choices to upgrade to better locations.
That's my concern about potential exit plans. I guess investment wise doesn't make sense to me except for the low psf units but for own stay definitely possible as pointed out by some bros who are familiar with the area.

Can't wait to see what price this finally launch at �
 

beccaberry

Junior Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2012
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
PE I visited twice together with my frens, I quite like the 4 bedder 1227sqft layout at 1.9xmil.
But my fren was looking at studio/1 bedder unit and it was selling at 19xxpsf, which I discourage her to buy.

Hi hi, I’m looking at 1 bedder type for investment and wondering if PR or GR (1+S) is a better choice? Hope to hear your view! 😊
 

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
Hi hi, I’m looking at 1 bedder type for investment and wondering if PR or GR (1+S) is a better choice? Hope to hear your view! ******************

PR 1 bedder around 16xxpsf, translate to 788k to 8xxk
GR 1+S also around 16xxpsf, translate to 8xxk.

Not a fan of both but Will pick GR as the 1+S has a decent study room of decent size.
Price difference betw the two not big but u get one extra study room for GR and earlier TOP date instead of waiting till 2025 for PR.
Food wise got chomp chomp.
 
Last edited:

Falafell

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2020
Messages
1,141
Reaction score
388
That's my concern about potential exit plans. I guess investment wise doesn't make sense to me except for the low psf units but for own stay definitely possible as pointed out by some bros who are familiar with the area.

Can't wait to see what price this finally launch at *********

I think its important if considering for own stay to spend some time walking around the area to experience it for yourself, best if u know someone staying in SUO. Start from Aljunied MRT, walk to penrose, walk to the market stretch, walk to geylang, try some of the food at the market or geylang.. I think geylang food quite good. Then maybe end off with a trip to PLQ.

Some people will like Aljunied, but not all will appreciate it. When thinking of an exit strategy, both own stay or investment, must consider the next buyer in mind.
 

Passerboy

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2019
Messages
7,573
Reaction score
736
Hi hi, I’m looking at 1 bedder type for investment and wondering if PR or GR (1+S) is a better choice? Hope to hear your view! 😊

Garden Residences finishing is quite good, if u do a like to like comparison it is one notch up. Both are expected to be similar in psf terms. Garden Residences if u are holding out to 2030 you would be able to see the fruitition of Serangoon North MRT station, meanwhile, commute without a car can be slightly inconvenient.

Layout wise, GR is better too, in terms of future completion, GR has Affinity directly opposite to compete with and maybe even nearby Hundred Palms EC. Penrose has SUO and possibly the plot beside it too.

If you are looking at a short time frame 5 years, I would pick Penrose as it’s prices are heavily supported by SUO, entry price is already supported by SUO 16xxpsf v 16xxpsf resale at SUO.

If you are looking at 8-10years, and looking to self stay for a short while, GR at Serangoon north enclave seems better given that there is no more land plot there from what I see.
 

drkcynic

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2007
Messages
57,430
Reaction score
26,943
I always wonder what's the motivation of getting a new launch for own stay, environment aside.

If you are an upgrader, you need to pay absd first to wait 3-4 years for TOP. Is it worth?

If you already sold your place and intend to rent while waiting 3-4 years for TOP, is it worth the rent paid?

If you don't currently hold a property, SUO is ready to be lowballed, by the time 3-4 years is up (the time for PR to TOP), you could flip another property already. But you waste 3-4 years waiting for PR to TOP. Is it worth?
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top