Penrose Sims Villa

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
Kaypo time, before I charge my phone.
Demand wise for bigger units in the resale market for SUO.

Since TOP till date only 4 out of 216 (3bed, NON-DUAL KEY) entered Subsale/Resale. 1.85%

Quick check on Prop Guru, 25 sales listings for 3 bedders in SUO asking from $1.4m.

For one looking to exit Sims Drive 3 bedders, something to ponder on. Will there be demand in the future?

Penrose will add on 260, 3 bedder units to Sims Drive.
op99h1S.jpg

SEHIis0.jpg

So one can imagine if enter PR 2B2B at 1.15-1.26mil (15xxpsf-1700psf), wouldn’t the situation be worse? Given the fact that 3 bedder compact at 14xxpsf by right should be a safer bet.
To begin with, my sensing is there’s not much future resale demand there after PR joins in the party. :D

Like I always said, many just see things on the surface thinking PR price was well supported by SUO resale price. But if dig deeper, can see many questionable loopholes based on this assumption.
 

1993newbie

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2018
Messages
6,361
Reaction score
501
BINGO!!!!!!

Yes price of SUO resale is similar to Penrose launch price. However one must also take a look deeper to the volume. Is there demand for Sims Drive in the resale market especially for bigger units? Hmmm

To begin with, my sensing is there’s not much future resale demand there after PR joins in the party. :D
 
Last edited:

drkcynic

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2007
Messages
57,430
Reaction score
26,943
BINGO!!!!!!

Yes price of SUO resale is similar to Penrose launch price. However one must also take a look deeper to the volume. Is there demand for Sims Drive in the resale market especially for bigger units? Hmmm

Bro, appreciate your efforts but nobody here seems to be interested in facts. Even when it's spelt out again and again people seems to have another mind of their own.

Nobody will acknowledge this and the next few posts will be some positivity about PR again. It's weird. 😆
 

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
BINGO!!!!!!

Yes price of SUO resale is similar to Penrose launch price. However one must also take a look deeper to the volume. Is there demand for Sims Drive in the resale market especially for bigger units? Hmmm

Same concept, when looking at rental, cannot just look at rental yield only w/o looking at rentability.
 

momoksan

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2019
Messages
516
Reaction score
1
A little suggestion here for your consideration.
If u r buying for self stay and not comfortable with 2b1b, it would be better to go for 3bed compact rather than 2b2b. The quantum is quite close though.

If u have a Budget constraint, I would suggest 2b1b.

For ur consideration.
Bro Ni, do you think there is a big difference between a 2b1b vs 2b2b when it comes to resales, within the same development?
 

1993newbie

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2018
Messages
6,361
Reaction score
501
Sometimes 2b1b Low floor can be cheaper than 1 bedder high floor too in the resale market! :D

obzhXzV.jpg

Bro Ni, do you think there is a big difference between a 2b1b vs 2b2b when it comes to resales, within the same development?
 
Last edited:

momoksan

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2019
Messages
516
Reaction score
1
Sometimes 2b1b Low floor can be cheaper than 1 bedder high floor too in the resale market! :D

obzhXzV.jpg
Agreed bro.
If compare high rise condo. Eg, Stirling. The level 02 1 Bdr will be 765k VS level 39 1mil.
Those 2Bdr designs at lower floor cannot compare with those higher floor 1 Bdr resales.
 

Passerboy

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2019
Messages
7,573
Reaction score
736
Agreed bro.
If compare high rise condo. Eg, Stirling. The level 02 1 Bdr will be 765k VS level 39 1mil.
Those 2Bdr designs at lower floor cannot compare with those higher floor 1 Bdr resales.

For Stirling case, some of the recent transacted 2 bedder are even more expensive than the 2+S unit that was transacted at the less premium stack 25. I think at the end of the day, when in resale market, the premium one place on a premium stack or a high level is subjective.
 

1993newbie

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2018
Messages
6,361
Reaction score
501
Even more interesting to see resale ASR peak collection :)

Agreed bro.
If compare high rise condo. Eg, Stirling. The level 02 1 Bdr will be 765k VS level 39 1mil.
Those 2Bdr designs at lower floor cannot compare with those higher floor 1 Bdr resales.
 

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
Bro Ni, do you think there is a big difference between a 2b1b vs 2b2b when it comes to resales, within the same development?

It depends on how the project was priced.
For PR case, I’m assuming most one bedder pool facing unitbwill be ard 8xxk. Then in this case, if 2b1b starts from 943k, it may seems like a no brainer to get 2b1b.
And if 2b2b is to be priced 1.15-1.26mil, then there’s no motivation for me to get 2b2b in such case and pay a premium of 200psf more. That’s y for those aiming for PR 2b2B, I’m asking them to reconsider their options again, I.e 3 bedder compact.

Another example. I bought a 2b2b just 80-90k more than a 2b1b unit in another project, same level, same stack. So it’s a no brainer that I will choose 2b2b in this case.
Your targetted audience for 2b1b may end up just a couple, a situation that is neither here or there. If with kids, with only one toilet, bound to face a lot of inconvenience.
2b2b u can still justify it is targetted for small family of 3-4 members.

So definitely, your targeted pool of buyers/tenants for 2b2b is still a safer bet.
However, for PR case, the difference for 2B1B and 2B2b can go up to 200psf difference. Well.... hehe... it makes things more complicated
 
Last edited:

momoksan

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2019
Messages
516
Reaction score
1
It depends on how the project was priced.
For PR case, I’m assuming most one bedder pool facing unitbwill be ard 8xxk. Then in this case, if 2b1b starts from 943k, it may seems like a no brainer to get 2b1b.
And if 2b2b is to be priced 1.15-1.26mil, then there’s no motivation for me to get 2b2b in such case and pay a premium of 200psf more. That’s y for those aiming for PR 2b2B, I’m asking them to reconsider their options again, I.e 3 bedder compact.

Another example. I bought a 2b2b just 80-90k more than a 2b1b unit in another project, same level, same stack. So it’s a no brainer that I will choose 2b2b in this case.
Your targetted audience for 2b1b may end up just a couple, a situation that is neither here or there. If with kids, with only one toilet, bound to face a lot of inconvenience.
2b2b u can still justify it is targetted for small family of 3-4 members.

So definitely, your targeted pool of buyers/tenants for 2b2b is still a safer bet.
However, for PR case, the difference for 2B1B and 2B2b can go up to 200psf difference. Well.... hehe... it makes things more complicated
Thanks for sharing bro.
 

Passerboy

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2019
Messages
7,573
Reaction score
736
Even more interesting to see resale ASR peak collection :)

Avenue South Residences is one project that I don’t uds, and more so those buying into the Peak Collection, some pay 22-23xxpsf for the peak collection, why pay such a high premium when this price could possibly get u a mid floor unit at One Pearl Bank, so much better location. And the rest of ASR are paying as low as 18-20xxpsf. The peak collection is personally not fascinating when I visited the showflat,
 

rlskyline

Master Member
Joined
May 21, 2012
Messages
4,343
Reaction score
1,125
It depends on how the project was priced.
For PR case, I’m assuming most one bedder pool facing unitbwill be ard 8xxk. Then in this case, if 2b1b starts from 943k, it may seems like a no brainer to get 2b1b.
And if 2b2b is to be priced 1.15-1.26mil, then there’s no motivation for me to get 2b2b in such case and pay a premium of 200psf more. That’s y for those aiming for PR 2b2B, I’m asking them to reconsider their options again, I.e 3 bedder compact.

Another example. I bought a 2b2b just 80-90k more than a 2b1b unit in another project, same level, same stack. So it’s a no brainer that I will choose 2b2b in this case.
Your targetted audience for 2b1b may end up just a couple, a situation that is neither here or there. If with kids, with only one toilet, bound to face a lot of inconvenience.
2b2b u can still justify it is targetted for small family of 3-4 members.

So definitely, your targeted pool of buyers/tenants for 2b2b is still a safer bet.
However, for PR case, the difference for 2B1B and 2B2b can go up to 200psf difference. Well.... hehe... it makes things more complicated

yes agree that 2b2b is better. I have a 2b2b and I struggle to imagine how a small family can share just 1 bathroom. not practical
 

rlskyline

Master Member
Joined
May 21, 2012
Messages
4,343
Reaction score
1,125
Kaypo time, before I charge my phone.
Demand wise for bigger units in the resale market for SUO.

Since TOP till date only 4 out of 216 (3bed, NON-DUAL KEY) entered Subsale/Resale. 1.85%

Quick check on Prop Guru, 25 sales listings for 3 bedders in SUO asking from $1.4m.

For one looking to exit Sims Drive 3 bedders, something to ponder on. Will there be demand in the future?

Penrose will add on 260, 3 bedder units to Sims Drive.
op99h1S.jpg

SEHIis0.jpg

seems like SUO 3 bedders can't make any profit at all. bad investment.
 

homechaser

Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2020
Messages
211
Reaction score
17
Isnt looking at it purely from a ‘200psf diff’ as mentioned in the last para kind of myopic here, in the sense that the 2b1b in question here is facing the PIE that’s why it is 200psf cheaper?

My current stance is that:
1) SUO doesnt have 2b2b
2) if PR 2b2b pricing is decent, even more reason to have a go at it.

Do advise and looking forward to yr view on what I said above! Once again I have no incentive to be overly positive :)
It depends on how the project was priced.
For PR case, I’m assuming most one bedder pool facing unitbwill be ard 8xxk. Then in this case, if 2b1b starts from 943k, it may seems like a no brainer to get 2b1b.
And if 2b2b is to be priced 1.15-1.26mil, then there’s no motivation for me to get 2b2b in such case and pay a premium of 200psf more. That’s y for those aiming for PR 2b2B, I’m asking them to reconsider their options again, I.e 3 bedder compact.

Another example. I bought a 2b2b just 80-90k more than a 2b1b unit in another project, same level, same stack. So it’s a no brainer that I will choose 2b2b in this case.
Your targetted audience for 2b1b may end up just a couple, a situation that is neither here or there. If with kids, with only one toilet, bound to face a lot of inconvenience.
2b2b u can still justify it is targetted for small family of 3-4 members.

So definitely, your targeted pool of buyers/tenants for 2b2b is still a safer bet.
However, for PR case, the difference for 2B1B and 2B2b can go up to 200psf difference. Well.... hehe... it makes things more complicated
 

Falafell

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2020
Messages
1,141
Reaction score
388
Avenue South Residences is one project that I don’t uds, and more so those buying into the Peak Collection, some pay 22-23xxpsf for the peak collection, why pay such a high premium when this price could possibly get u a mid floor unit at One Pearl Bank, so much better location. And the rest of ASR are paying as low as 18-20xxpsf. The peak collection is personally not fascinating when I visited the showflat,

The whole idea of ASR is to be at the front row seat of the GWS transformation. The view is very different for Heritage (Facing one of the oldest rental blocks, very depressing view) vs Peak (Facing the whole sea front & future GWS). Some people may see this as an opportunity to own a property with significant views at a slightly acceptable psf. After all 40th floor and up is a very impressive height.

I personally feel both isn’t bad, if you are a pure investor, heritage would have been the best bet. But if its a chance for you to own an iconic unit that you can truly impress people, peak is no doubt it.

But I still dont like the fact that ASR is situated in one of the poorest neighbourhoods in sg, it really shows the rich/poor divide.

People in ASR are still praying that NE2 station will be announced.
 
Last edited:

momoksan

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2019
Messages
516
Reaction score
1
yes agree that 2b2b is better. I have a 2b2b and I struggle to imagine how a small family can share just 1 bathroom. not practical
I just thought 2b1b or 2b2b are never meant for big family... maybe just parents with 1 kid. Anything more maybe not suitable.
 

hirokassy

Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2008
Messages
297
Reaction score
4
Isnt looking at it purely from a ‘200psf diff’ as mentioned in the last para kind of myopic here, in the sense that the 2b1b in question here is facing the PIE that’s why it is 200psf cheaper?

My current stance is that:
1) SUO doesnt have 2b2b
2) if PR 2b2b pricing is decent, even more reason to have a go at it.

Do advise and looking forward to yr view on what I said above! Once again I have no incentive to be overly positive :)

Ok I damn confused. First someone said 3BR would dilute the 3BR scene in that area and according to transactions data, SUO is not selling well for 3 bedders. Then why suggest to go for 3BR for PR?

I went to that area today and I really find it to have the kampung feel, you get to see really old HDB estates around, light industrial, big hawker centre.. Kopi only 80cent..

And when you take a bus, 3 stops later, u will go into PL and you will see a stark difference. Yes, PE is more lively but also come at a bigger price tag.

I don’t know.. I find that 1.4X is a justified entry price.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top