Penrose Sims Villa

hirokassy

Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2008
Messages
297
Reaction score
4
I am thinking extremely hard if I should go in PR 2BR... Another alternative is to look at low balling SUO 2BR after PR TOP lol :s13:
 

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
Isnt looking at it purely from a ‘200psf diff’ as mentioned in the last para kind of myopic here, in the sense that the 2b1b in question here is facing the PIE that’s why it is 200psf cheaper?

My current stance is that:
1) SUO doesnt have 2b2b
2) if PR 2b2b pricing is decent, even more reason to have a go at it.

Do advise and looking forward to yr view on what I said above! Once again I have no incentive to be overly positive :)

No worries, many bros here are keen to discuss this project objectively (despite there might be some differing views here and there) instead of steering to house warming nonsense by some. :s13:

Firstly, u need to understand that what were discussed here were purely based on piece meal info on the indicative price shared by some bros, not the cfm price yet.
It was mentioned that 2b2b by some bros here to be expected from 1.15-1.26mil (translate to 16xxpsf to 17xxpsf). At this location, u may want to make a Guess what’s the chance of appreciating to 18xxpsf to 19xxpsf in near future if u enter PR at this price? If u believe in it, of coz u can get your Cheque ready and take the plunge.
Of coz if 2b2b happens to launch cheaper, say 15xxpsf, it’s an added bonus one should seriously consider instead of going for 2b1b.

In plain simple text, it doesn’t matter SUO has 2b2b or not, u have to ask yourself whether this site should worth that much? Some bros like newbie has dropped many hints here and there (comparison done betw PE and PR launch price, data to show Antares not moving etc) whereas I’m more direct in my comments. Guccoland bid this site lower than they bid for SUO, isn’t the developer telling us something? If Guocoland is so confident about PR site, they should bid higher than SUO isn’t it?

Antares at 17xxpsf with mrt at doorstep is not moving at all. Whether we myopic or not we can give ourselves 5 years and come back to see how Penrose resales is faring if u enter at 16xxpsf-17xxpsf.

Is penrose location more superior than Antares? My opinion is no.
The stress test came when Antares priced at 17xxpsf is not even moving much at all. So what makes me believe PR can appreciate to 18xxpsf in near future? :D

My stance is still consistent throughout, if one die die must buy PR, it’s better to enter at 14xx-15xxpsf and nothing more.
 
Last edited:

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
Ok I damn confused. First someone said 3BR would dilute the 3BR scene in that area and according to transactions data, SUO is not selling well for 3 bedders. Then why suggest to go for 3BR for PR?

I went to that area today and I really find it to have the kampung feel, you get to see really old HDB estates around, light industrial, big hawker centre.. Kopi only 80cent..

And when you take a bus, 3 stops later, u will go into PL and you will see a stark difference. Yes, PE is more lively but also come at a bigger price tag.

I don’t know.. I find that 1.4X is a justified entry price.

A few regulars here are trying to point out a few scenarios:
1) NSZ - if 2b2b cost u 16xxpsf-17xxpsf, wouldn’t it be logical to go for 3bedder compact at 14xx-15xxpsf? Quantum wise could be just 100k difference only. Psf wise is also safer. The added discussion betw 2b2b vs 2b1b is also to let buyers think hard who will be your potential buyers/tenants in near future.
2) bro newbie - he is trying to offer buyers a word of caution by providing more supporting data and transaction history. while 3 bedder compact seems to be a good buy for PR, but the resales data in SUO 3 bedder seems to say otherwise.

Not confusing at all. These are the “con” factors penrose buyers have to consider carefully. This site is ranked 3rd class for a reason...if PPR/PE can’t see cap gain in near future, what’s the chance to expect penrose resale price to take off in future? All these are logical consequences.

And it’s not entirely true PE comes with much higher price tag. We had already compared PE and PR launch price in the previous post. In fact they r pretty close. Unfortunately, the boat for PE has sailed as it’s already near 100% sold.
 
Last edited:

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
I am thinking extremely hard if I should go in PR 2BR... Another alternative is to look at low balling SUO 2BR after PR TOP lol :s13:

If I were u, I will take this opportunity to Low ball SUO sellers after PR actual pricing is released :D
This is a much viable option imo if one die die must stay there.
Afterall SUO isn’t that old compared to PR. :D
 
Last edited:

AyuReady

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 11, 2003
Messages
6,810
Reaction score
3
Hi Mr NSZ,

The penrose will be for investment. Sorry was not clear.

Paisay paisay

A little suggestion here for your consideration.
If u r buying for self stay and not comfortable with 2b1b, it would be better to go for 3bed compact rather than 2b2b. The quantum is quite close though.

If u have a Budget constraint, I would suggest 2b1b.

For ur consideration.
 

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
Hi Mr NSZ,

The penrose will be for investment. Sorry was not clear.

Paisay paisay

In this case, the more u should keep the quantum/psf Low.
Not implying u to choose the worst unit at cheapest price but need to strike a balance somewhere in between. Cheers :D
 

1993newbie

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2018
Messages
6,361
Reaction score
501
Thanks bro for the detailed analysis .
A few regulars here are trying to point out a few scenarios:
1) NSZ - if 2b2b cost u 16xxpsf-17xxpsf, wouldn’t it be logical to go for 3bedder compact at 14xx-15xxpsf? Quantum wise could be just 100k difference only. Psf wise is also safer. The added discussion betw 2b2b vs 2b1b is also to let buyers think hard who will be your potential buyers/tenants in near future.
2) bro newbie - he is trying to offer buyers a word of caution by providing more supporting data and transaction history. while 3 bedder compact seems to be a good buy for PR, but the resales data in SUO 3 bedder seems to say otherwise.

Not confusing at all. These are the “con” factors penrose buyers have to consider carefully. This site is ranked 3rd class for a reason...if PPR/PE can’t see cap gain in near future, what’s the chance to expect penrose resale price to take off in future? All these are logical consequences.

And it’s not entirely true PE comes with much higher price tag. We had already compared PE and PR launch price in the previous post. In fact they r pretty close. Unfortunately, the boat for PE has sailed as it’s already near 100% sold.
 

1993newbie

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2018
Messages
6,361
Reaction score
501
It’s okay bro, I will still share my Kaypo data and figures. :)

Bro, appreciate your efforts but nobody here seems to be interested in facts. Even when it's spelt out again and again people seems to have another mind of their own.

Nobody will acknowledge this and the next few posts will be some positivity about PR again. It's weird. 😆
 
Joined
Jun 6, 2019
Messages
2,557
Reaction score
318
seems like SUO 3 bedders can't make any profit at all. bad investment.

Got la, after minus their BSD & Agent's Professional Fees, still got make about $100k.. holding period about 4-5yrs..

suo.jpg
[/url][/IMG]
 

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
Got la, after minus their BSD & Agent's Professional Fees, still got make about $100k.. holding period about 4-5yrs..

suo.jpg
[/url][/IMG]

That’s when they bought only 13xxpsf during property lull period.
Try paying 16xxpsf to 17xxpsf now for this site and we can come back 4 years later to see. :D
 

hirokassy

Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2008
Messages
297
Reaction score
4
If I were u, I will take this opportunity to Low ball SUO sellers after PR actual pricing is released :D
This is a much viable option imo if one die die must stay there.
Afterall SUO isn’t that old compared to PR. :D

But can low ball how much sia ... :s13::s13::s13:
 

hirokassy

Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2008
Messages
297
Reaction score
4
Got la, after minus their BSD & Agent's Professional Fees, still got make about $100k.. holding period about 4-5yrs..

suo.jpg
[/url][/IMG]

Can give a breakdown after he give bak CPF interest and other misc fees he has paid, how much he potentially earn for 4 sims drive.
 

ThinkCarefully

Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2019
Messages
7,194
Reaction score
2,813
just sharing my exp, i was relatively new to this property game. my first foray was Kopar at Newton during April 2020 this year.

i was so convinced that it was a good buy but closer to balloting/booking day started getting jitters. i told myself i wanted the lower floor pool unit and my upper limit was around 22xx psf (because i couldnt foresee a LH in newton going up to 24xx-25xx in the near future, and that Kopar's location is pretty lacklustre)

when the price was released it was actually 23xx psf and i found myself really struggling whether or not to proceed. some of my non-vested (read: objective) friends told me that 23xx at CCR D9 was still a good buy. i asked myself, since 23xx psf was above my upper limit at 22xx psf, does it mean its a straight no-go?

i feel after having gone through the experience the answer is it depends. depends on whether its for investment, or if its for ownstay. looking back for investment, i'd have gone for the lousier-facing stack at 21xx psf with a fair quantum of 1.47mio for 2B2B config.

in the end, i skipped Kopar because i felt i wasnt ready to take the plunge. to be fair that doesnt mean Kopar was a poor product - in fact 21xx psf for 2b2b is a really good investment pricepoint still.

i also find setting upper limits sometimes might work against you, because if its about 30-50psf above your upper limit, but its a smaller size unit , the increase in quantum may not be as much. of course if the actual price is lower than your limit than its a no brainer...

so i'd say set a upper limit, but also be flexible. the actual booking day, even if its no longer in the traditional tent set-up will be quite stressful. its meant to be a psychological warzone =:p you say that you are not emotionally involved but if its your first property purchase, its tough not to be.

i walked away from Kopar because i felt i'd rather lose out on a good deal, than be stuck in the wrong one for a long time .


####

Absolutely. Once you have the knowledge, calculated the upside and downside risks and have been THINKing CAREFULLY before reaching the decision, just do it. Those people who have done online bidding for projects will know how to do it.

Just to share, there was a project, launching from about 1350 psf...I was so determined to get the lowest quantum but lost the ballot for the cheapest units...went home. Then unit bounced back, agent called me if I would like one that was 1,410 psf, better facing...I calculated the risks and went for it. After three years, project almost 100% sold,...now about 1,620 psf (estimate 15% paper gain) still not the 25% gain I wanted. Will it rise another 10% in 2-3 years time? I don’t know..but still ok lah..the gain...

You have to trust yourself sometimes...

####
 
Last edited:

propertyinvestor40

Master Member
Joined
Feb 24, 2020
Messages
3,973
Reaction score
1,168
Parc Esta and Park place 100% and SUO 100% sold. They are RCR and 100% sold for a reason. Other launches still struggling to sell specially OCR sites.
Dun miss the boat this time for Penrose. It will be 100% sold in no time because only 500 units. Follow your heart.
Dun need listen the nishizhu too much. He no money buy, currently he stuck with OCR property. Nobody buy from him at OCR. Salty kid. All the SUO resale units exit with profits. He say non profit, tell lies. This joker.
 

Emo_Rhino

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2008
Messages
6,609
Reaction score
30
Parc Esta and Park place 100% and SUO 100% sold. They are RCR and 100% sold for a reason. Other launches still struggling to sell specially OCR sites.
Dun miss the boat this time for Penrose. It will be 100% sold in no time because only 500 units. Follow your heart.
Dun need listen the nishizhu too much. He no money buy, currently he stuck with OCR property. Nobody buy from him at OCR. Salty kid. All the SUO resale units exit with profits. He say non profit, tell lies. This joker.

I like reading your posts. please invite me to the next house warming party. lol :(
 

ThinkCarefully

Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2019
Messages
7,194
Reaction score
2,813
I can share with you my personal experience that if it is your first time, u would feel very pressured regardless if the price is good. I walked away from the ballot at Jadescape even though it was the one in closest proximity to my current place of residence, and walked away from Stirling Residences though the price was really attractive at 16xxpsf simply cos I do not frequent that location and my first love was actually Queens Peak, add to that I don’t fancy that uphill climb and the less than stellar finishing. Both Jadescape and Stirling Residences also failed to win approval from my closed ones.

Ended up buying into sth my dad actually liked because it was of decent size and impeccable finishing in his opinion. Get inputs from ur family member or other half, the opinions of ur loved ones are very important, it is not the views of us on forum that matters. At times, I would also have doubts over my purchase and fancy something else like the M, to be honest, I think the grass is always greener on the other side.


####

I was also there for the ballot. Walked away, never regretted.

That Chinese developer later offered stack discount, same price for level 3 to 15 or something like that...if you buy later, for what you pay, you can ,upgrade’ to a higher floor.

####
 
Last edited:
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top