Proposal Ring - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

KingKhan

Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2012
Messages
100
Reaction score
0

bedposthalo

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2004
Messages
781
Reaction score
0
Of course! Must ask!! When you spend so much money, how can they not show the GIA cert...

Looking at the GIA cert will only tell you like 40% of the diamond's quality.. the rest you need to use the different scopes to see the diamond to tell how good it is.

Just to add on, from the certificate, you can at least try to calculate the HCA score of the diamond.

Holloway Cut Advisor | HCA Tool | PriceScope

It can make a big difference in the diamond. But then again, you still need to use the other scopes to analyze the diamond becos the HCA score is still limited.

 

charred123

Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2006
Messages
258
Reaction score
1
wa, okay bros please feedback whether this ring worth it not?

from a branded chain store, 0.5ct D VVS2 $3532, it is normal solitarie range so not ideal/excellent cut. GIA certified.

worth it or kena chop? this price they say is severly discounted. original price $8k plus. i dunno whether can believe not. need ur help man.
 

bedposthalo

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2004
Messages
781
Reaction score
0
wa, okay bros please feedback whether this ring worth it not?

from a branded chain store, 0.5ct D VVS2 $3532, it is normal solitarie range so not ideal/excellent cut. GIA certified.

worth it or kena chop? this price they say is severly discounted. original price $8k plus. i dunno whether can believe not. need ur help man.

Do you have the certificate of the diamond? It's easier to see from the certificate. There's alot of other factors to consider too.. (what's the polish and symmetry, does it have fluorescence? etc).

I don't believe in any shops "original prices". It's always marked up for the sake of giving a big discount.. Like suppose I want to sell Item A for $10, I'll just put the original price as $20, and market it at a 50% discount and sell if for $10. No one buys their diamonds at their original prices anyway..
 

taqiyuliy

Junior Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2012
Messages
46
Reaction score
0
I remember one of the bros here got his at
LED Lighted Proposal Ring Box

Or you can also try
Bling the Ring - LED lighted engagement ring box store

If you have extra cash to spare, you can get the Kiss Luvu..
Kiss the LUVU Engagement Ring Box Case Light Music Proposal Idea
It opens up when you kiss the ring box =:p
Thanks! The 1 in bling the ring is cool! I want to place order but which one do you think will be more shiny? The 1 with white velvet or black? Any suggestions?
 

cssua2833

Junior Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2006
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Hi all, just wondering if a 0.8carat, VS1, colour F, triple excellent, super ideal cut diamond (stone alone) at SGD8,400 a reasonable price? Appreciate any honest comments from you guys here. Thank you! :)
 

bedposthalo

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2004
Messages
781
Reaction score
0
Hi all, just wondering if a 0.8carat, VS1, colour F, triple excellent, super ideal cut diamond (stone alone) at SGD8,400 a reasonable price? Appreciate any honest comments from you guys here. Thank you! :)

Congrats! Where did you get it from? The price seems fine for a Super Ideal. Did you see the diamond through the scopes?
 

cssua2833

Junior Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2006
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Congrats! Where did you get it from? The price seems fine for a Super Ideal. Did you see the diamond through the scopes?

Hi, thanks for your prompt response. I saw the diamond at JANNPAUL and wish to know if it is a reasonable price to pay. I saw the scopes they provided and the results appear to be acceptable... :)
 

cssua2833

Junior Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2006
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Hi, thanks for your prompt response. I saw the diamond at JANNPAUL and wish to know if it is a reasonable price to pay. I saw the scopes they provided and the results appear to be acceptable... :)

I might like to add that I am not well-versed in matters of diamonds and my inspections of the scopes are based on layman eyes. :)
 

aLpHa-Ev7

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
1,270
Reaction score
0
Hi guys, just wondering if any of you bought diamonds off GoldoldGold.com and Bluenile.com before? I just checked the sites and found some diamonds at good prices.

Checking if any bros could offer some feedback and help :)
 

Zerstorer

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
7,947
Reaction score
0
After going to numerous jewelers and going through trays of diamonds, I've managed to find my own "super ideal cut".

All thanks to all the contributors in this thread and especially with the help of dawnmin's guide:
The Diamond Dictionary: The Super Ideal Cut Diamond

That helped immensely in my search.

I must also commend the patient and professional service at Jannpaul, although ultimately I didn't get one from them as they didn't have much stocks in my budget range for me to choose from and ultimately I did manage to find one that equals what they had in cut quality.

CTY_1850.jpg

CTY_1862.jpg

CTY_1866.jpg


0.58ct, D, VS1, GIA Ex/Ex/Ex, HCA 0.7, hearts & arrows.

I must say, getting a perfect or near perfect H&A pattern is the hardest part of the search, out of 20 shortlisted diamonds with good <1.5HCA scores....only 2 had somewhat perfect H&A. Getting solid hearts without clefts inside the pattern seems to be hardest of all.

Keeping the diamond free from dust for photography is also pretty darn difficult! Left a few specks here and there in the pics that I can't be bothered to clone away..:)
 

KingKhan

Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2012
Messages
100
Reaction score
0
Hi guys, just wondering if any of you bought diamonds off GoldoldGold.com and Bluenile.com before? I just checked the sites and found some diamonds at good prices.

Checking if any bros could offer some feedback and help :)

I bought my ring from Bluenile before and regretted my decision. The diamond hardly sparkle. I would suggest reading up more about diamonds before making any decision. Alot of websites like bluenile operate in drop ship mode. This means they have very limited quality control as they don't physically inspect the diamond.

Between the 2, I would recommend Goodoldgold. At least they focus more on the diamond cut quality.

Beware of all the extra costs when buying online, shipping, taxes, casing and after services (wrong ring size)!
 

darcdarc

Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2008
Messages
421
Reaction score
0
which site are good and should i buy the ring online?

Hi I had done some read-ups and found that we can not only go to the malls to look at the chain of stores such as lee hwa, goldheart etc etc...i also notice about some sites that bros here go to, what are the recommendable sites and are they just for reference or can i buy from them? or should i just head to the malls to settle my proposal ring? i am looking at buying a proposal ring in the next few months! any recommendations?
 

felali

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
1,026
Reaction score
6
I bought my ring from Bluenile before and regretted my decision. The diamond hardly sparkle. I would suggest reading up more about diamonds before making any decision. Alot of websites like bluenile operate in drop ship mode. This means they have very limited quality control as they don't physically inspect the diamond.

Between the 2, I would recommend Goodoldgold. At least they focus more on the diamond cut quality.

Beware of all the extra costs when buying online, shipping, taxes, casing and after services (wrong ring size)!

Yeah, you won't go wrong with GoodOldGold... Can also try WhiteFlash and JamesAllen...
 

teqrise

Member
Joined
Nov 12, 2011
Messages
111
Reaction score
0
Would like to seek some opinions..

Option 1
Get a 0.42 carat E VS1 with a halo design side diamonds for $3.4k

Option 2
Get a 0.64 carat G VS1 with plain setting for $4.9k

The 0.42 carat with the halo side diamonds would look close to the same size as the 0.64 carat. I can get a "same size" ring at a lower price if I go with Option 1.

Is the halo design popular? Or would girls prefer a diamond ring by itself?
 

aLpHa-Ev7

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
1,270
Reaction score
0
I bought my ring from Bluenile before and regretted my decision. The diamond hardly sparkle. I would suggest reading up more about diamonds before making any decision. Alot of websites like bluenile operate in drop ship mode. This means they have very limited quality control as they don't physically inspect the diamond.

Between the 2, I would recommend Goodoldgold. At least they focus more on the diamond cut quality.

Beware of all the extra costs when buying online, shipping, taxes, casing and after services (wrong ring size)!

Woah, really that bad? i was reading thru the GIA certs and some of the diamonds looked pretty good.
 

firewalker85

Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2009
Messages
106
Reaction score
0
Woah, really that bad? i was reading thru the GIA certs and some of the diamonds looked pretty good.

I suggest visiting JannPaul for their diamond education session. Its free anyway.. There are plenty that they explain, but all I can say is that you shouldn't buy a diamond just by looking at the certificate. The certificate can show that the diamond is "Excellent" but the actual diamond can still look dull, with heavy light leakages
 

hollander

Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2012
Messages
228
Reaction score
0
Would like to seek some opinions..

Option 1
Get a 0.42 carat E VS1 with a halo design side diamonds for $3.4k

Option 2
Get a 0.64 carat G VS1 with plain setting for $4.9k

The 0.42 carat with the halo side diamonds would look close to the same size as the 0.64 carat. I can get a "same size" ring at a lower price if I go with Option 1.

Is the halo design popular? Or would girls prefer a diamond ring by itself?

1st option is a good buy. Considering the colour, the halo design starting price is $750++ so your diamond of .42ct is somewhere around 2.7K.
A .30ct G VS2 starting price is 1.5K, see how much is the price diff, it would be cheaper if it is .38ct.

2nd option is really a very good buy for a .64ct ;-), if you can bargain for .67ct then it is better, you'll have a .70ct feel ;-)

from which store is this? if you dont mind me asking.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top