jhchoo85
Senior Member
- Joined
- Mar 8, 2011
- Messages
- 504
- Reaction score
- 0
here is the problem which lies in the HCA scoring limitations
for diamond number 2: the crown angle is above 35 degeres, which makes the diamond top heavy, this is why you're also sitting on the bare minimum of gia's cut grade excellent proportions. i just saw your hearts you uploaded too, the uneven clefting in the hearts shows the uneven lower girdle facets, also shows the table leakage at 2 oclock between the arrows (would not go with this)
i really don't know if you will want to consider SI1 especially with a feather on it, plus i can see the crystal inclusions right under the table and diamond 3 isn't a H&A at all. these are just "alright" excellent cuts, in whiteflash, they would just be under expert selection, not ACA![]()
Good analysis! I noticed diamond 2 has more light leakages (green) than the others too.. Like thick green lines.. Don't think that's a good sign. I can see diamond 3 "hearts", although they are not symmetrical. Does that mean its not a H&A already?