yeah Rauzan-Segla is the only 2nd Growth i went to, the other two are third i think.
Would like to try some 2nd growth wines, i rarely buy cos my palate is still new to this, dont wanna waste a good wine.
Yeah I could sense that it was because I couldn't find a single 1st/2nd growth 2005 vintage in any wine shops in BDX (the chateaus do sell them tho, saw some 05s sitting around). Man i'm so new to wines it's alot for me to absorb, but how does one define a vintage as a great year? Just the weather?
Yeah, agree. You may want to expand your palate first before investing heavily into expensive wines and end up you don't like it.
Just take your time, try out some entry level wines, attend some wine tasting events find out what kind of style you like. Take some notes and then read up on some tasting notes and compare those with yours.
There are some great reference Ikileo has posted on this thread and you may refer to that.
2005 is considered a great vintage not just because of perfect weather but also there is a great level of consistency for many appellations. Most of the Cheatuax made great wines.
You may have also learnt during your visit to the Cheatuax how the wines were made and store and also the type of soil they used to plant the vines.
So basically the weather / climate, type of soil used (eg. gravel, chalk, limestones,) condition of vines (old, young), wine making techniques (extraction methods, choosing the harvest dates, storage methods (new / old oak, steel tanks, duration) - all of these factors contributed to the success of a great wine in a vintage.