9K for NSmen doing NS.

kangaR00

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2001
Messages
744
Reaction score
0
What is the whole purpose behind this incentive?

Why not award our brothers who have completed their NS+ICT ? becos i really don't see the point of this incentive, when not EVERYBODY is include when they specifically say REWARD NSMEN. so your cycle finish, means u don't exist?

Is it to show our PRs and Foreigners that Gahmen take care of their citizens? Bluff our elderly citizens? Naive and ignorant female voters?

So bloody disappointed at this pathetic attempt to garner votes for the coming GE.

come on PAP do it with more sincerity... or Do we the Men of singapore not matter to you anymore?
 

cannotliao

High Supremacy Member
Joined
May 16, 2003
Messages
48,185
Reaction score
36
ns+for+sporean.jpg


we got this ***** problem on the ground and they think can solve it by simply giving out 9K over 10yrs into CPF account?
 

snipes14

Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 13, 2001
Messages
6,127
Reaction score
0
ns+for+sporean.jpg


we got this ***** problem on the ground and they think can solve it by simply giving out 9K over 10yrs into CPF account?

How dare you disagree with the great cancer81? His infinite wisdom has shown us the way!

Scrap NS! NAO!
 

stinky_shawn

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2008
Messages
27,017
Reaction score
0
i rather give them 10k n dont tell me to go ns.....no need do reservist ippt.....
 

koxinga

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
6,435
Reaction score
76
What is the whole purpose behind this incentive?

Why not award our brothers who have completed their NS+ICT ? becos i really don't see the point of this incentive, when not EVERYBODY is include when they specifically say REWARD NSMEN. so your cycle finish, means u don't exist?

Is it to show our PRs and Foreigners that Gahmen take care of their citizens? Bluff our elderly citizens? Naive and ignorant female voters?

So bloody disappointed at this pathetic attempt to garner votes for the coming GE.

come on PAP do it with more sincerity... or Do we the Men of singapore not matter to you anymore?

the issue is practicality.

When baby bonus was announced, it was also not applied retrospectively. Otherwise, all the mothers since independence would be asking for bonus for service rendered!
 

gohsan

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2000
Messages
2,312
Reaction score
102
Old soldiers are not important anymore. Their numbers are makeup by new citizens.
 

fulaien

Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2008
Messages
9,631
Reaction score
5,244
This scheme seems catered for the potential new citizen to take up citizenship n serve NS.

If it is really meant to rewarded NSmen for their hardwork, why not give to those who had finished their cycle as well? Have they not contributed to Singapore? This seems a future-oriented policies aimed to attract, rather than reward.
 

BirdbrainZ

Master Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2009
Messages
2,938
Reaction score
1
This scheme seems catered for the potential new citizen to take up citizenship n serve NS.
I do somewhat agree with your initial assessment, and it seems a hollow gesture to give recognition to some *who* are serving national service (who may qualify for this scheme), but not all who had served national service (and not qualify).

If it is really meant to rewarded NSmen for their hardwork, why not give to those who had finished their cycle as well? Have they not contributed to Singapore? This seems a future-oriented policies aimed to attract, rather than reward.
As recognition of those who had (and currently still are) served/serving national service in a somewhat unwilling patriotic defense of the nation (given the obvious appearance of reluctance and career handicap), perhaps a more genuine gesture would be to slash public housing prices by 10%-25% off it's current pricing. Given the "security" of the nation did play a part in the current prosperity of this country, and with the constant need/demand for public housing by it's citizens, it would be an apt way to give something of substance (as opposed to the current scheme) back to it's "defenders" as compensation for their patriotic sacrifice. Not only would something along these lines address various issues all at once, this recognition of patriotism in defense of the nation may also be released back to the citizens if and when they decide to sell their property.
 
Last edited:

The_Davis

High Honorary Member
Deluxe Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2001
Messages
152,489
Reaction score
15,022
iirc, cancer81 had said that he is not born a singaporean, thus leading me to think he is in fact either a PR or naturalised Singaporean.

I also tot he mention that he did not serve NS. Thus when he say he did, I asked if he is indeed a male. This lead to questions on his gender. The part about him not being a singaporean did not surface...
i still don't get it.......

if he's now a Singaporean, why he took offense at your questions?
 

ScootS

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2003
Messages
732
Reaction score
0
I do somewhat agree with your initial assessment, and it seems a hollow gesture to give recognition to some *who* are serving national service (who may qualify for this scheme), but not all who had served national service (and not qualify).


As recognition of those who had (and currently still are) served/serving national service in a somewhat unwilling patriotic defense of the nation (given the obvious appearance of reluctance and career handicap), perhaps a more genuine gesture would be to slash public housing prices by 10%-25% off it's current pricing. Given the "security" of the nation did play a part in the current prosperity of this country, and with the constant need/demand for public housing by it's citizens, it would be an apt way to give something of substance (as opposed to the current scheme) back to it's "defenders" as compensation for their patriotic sacrifice. Not only would something along these lines address various issues all at once, this recognition of patriotism in defense of the nation may also be released back to the citizens if and when they decide to sell their property.

Isn't this even more impossible to target the 'correct group' of NSMen and even less relevant?

1.NSMen who had completed all cycles and staying in private now
2.NSMen who have yet to complete all cycles and are staying in private
-> stay private are not recognised?

3.NSMen who have completed and paid off their HDB
->pay off HDB liow not recognised?

4.NSMen who have completed and yet to pay off their HDB
5.NSMen who have yet to complete their cycle and have yet to pay off their HDB
6.NSMen who delay getting housing and stay with parents because of high prices
->Buy at different times, Market price different. NSMen who delay buying of HBD due to high prices are not recognised?

7.NSMen who have yet to complete their cycle but have paid off their HDB
->pay off HDB liow not recognised?
 
Last edited:

BirdbrainZ

Master Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2009
Messages
2,938
Reaction score
1
Isn't this even more impossible to target the 'correct group' of NSMen and even less relevant?

1.NSMen who had completed all cycles and staying in private now
2.NSMen who have yet to complete all cycles and are staying in private
-> stay private are not recognised?

3.NSMen who have completed and paid off their HDB
->pay off HDB liow not recognised?

4.NSMen who have completed and yet to pay off their HDB
5.NSMen who have yet to complete their cycle and have yet to pay off their HDB
6.NSMen who delay getting housing and stay with parents because of high prices
->Buy at different times, Market price different. NSMen who delay buying of HBD due to high prices are not recognised?

7.NSMen who have yet to complete their cycle but have paid off their HDB
->pay off HDB liow not recognised?
You do have a point there, I hadn't consider that not all citizens stay in public housing.

Any suggestions?
 

superman

Master Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
4,144
Reaction score
103
Why the Double Standard between the Additional GST Credit in 2007 and This. That time all NSMen get the Additional GST Credits including those who finish their NS cycle decades ago. It is whether they want to do it or not, maybe this time the sum is much bigger and the Govt dun want to give to all NSMen, but I think they should rather give a smaller sum and give to all who completed the whole cycle and I think lesser people will KPKB.
 

ScootS

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2003
Messages
732
Reaction score
0
Why the Double Standard between the Additional GST Credit in 2007 and This. That time all NSMen get the Additional GST Credits including those who finish their NS cycle decades ago. It is whether they want to do it or not, maybe this time the sum is much bigger and the Govt dun want to give to all NSMen, but I think they should rather give a smaller sum and give to all who completed the whole cycle and I think lesser people will KPKB.

Because this time round it isn't really about recognising NSMen in the first place?!

Look at how it's structured and which group will get the most out of it...
Those who are currently serving/about to complete NS... who happen to be
Those who are just coming to voting age ... and it so happens that

ELECTION IS COMING
 

ScootS

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2003
Messages
732
Reaction score
0
You do have a point there, I hadn't consider that not all citizens stay in public housing.

Any suggestions?


Honestly, I've not looked at this as a 'recognition' from the beginning.

And if you read my earlier posts, you can see what I think this is about and what I think the Government can really do if they want to level the differences between PRs and Singaporeans who served NS...the issue that they are skirting by 'recognising' NSMen
 

Fatfool

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
32,307
Reaction score
107
You do have a point there, I hadn't consider that not all citizens stay in public housing.

Any suggestions?
For newly minted NSmen who are going to further their studies, there is this same issue.

It'll only count if they're going to the a government institution.

Private uni/diploma students cannot use it.

Overseas students cannot use it.

Those who are going out to work cannot use it.
 

BirdbrainZ

Master Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2009
Messages
2,938
Reaction score
1
For newly minted NSmen who are going to further their studies, there is this same issue.

It'll only count if they're going to the a government institution.

Private uni/diploma students cannot use it.

Overseas students cannot use it.

Those who are going out to work cannot use it.
You do have a point too.

This scheme does appear not to do that which it's name suggests.
 

Fatfool

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
32,307
Reaction score
107
You do have a point too.

This scheme does appear not to do that which it's name suggests.
I don't even see why solutions are being sought.

it's SO SIMPLE

Just pay it out in cash. neopets money is total crap.
 

xdivider

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2000
Messages
60,707
Reaction score
19,041
I do somewhat agree with your initial assessment, and it seems a hollow gesture to give recognition to some *who* are serving national service (who may qualify for this scheme), but not all who had served national service (and not qualify).


As recognition of those who had (and currently still are) served/serving national service in a somewhat unwilling patriotic defense of the nation (given the obvious appearance of reluctance and career handicap), perhaps a more genuine gesture would be to slash public housing prices by 10%-25% off it's current pricing. Given the "security" of the nation did play a part in the current prosperity of this country, and with the constant need/demand for public housing by it's citizens, it would be an apt way to give something of substance (as opposed to the current scheme) back to it's "defenders" as compensation for their patriotic sacrifice. Not only would something along these lines address various issues all at once, this recognition of patriotism in defense of the nation may also be released back to the citizens if and when they decide to sell their property.

i suggested a 20K rebate in CPF for purchase of houses. Govt can probably top up CPF of NSMen still living in the HDBs they bought and serviced using CPF. Not difficult to track as it is all in the system.....
 

crankyedwin

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 17, 2005
Messages
2,440
Reaction score
0
i suggested a 20K rebate in CPF for purchase of houses. Govt can probably top up CPF of NSMen still living in the HDBs they bought and serviced using CPF. Not difficult to track as it is all in the system.....

yup. housing grants sounds like the best appeasement.
 

xdivider

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2000
Messages
60,707
Reaction score
19,041
yup. housing grants sounds like the best appeasement.

The idea is
1) Use neopets money, govt dun really lose anything
2) Does not affect valuation. PR still pay full rate. MBT can still claim his sky high 'subsidised' housing rhetoric......
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top