Eight Telecom discussion thread

xiaofan

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
37,316
Reaction score
12,690
I doubt the one-for-one top-up offer will come back any time soon.

eight's focus in FY2026 will be --> 5G Scaling and ARPU growth.

So they will push users to go for the 5G plan. They will also grow eight home internet through the bundle deal with eight 5G plan.

I am actually suprised that Starhub Mobile ARPU is still at pretty decent S$22. But then the cheapest SIM Only plan from Starhub is at S$22 per month for the 5G Lite plan, even thought there is a Passion Card offer to lower the price to S$17.6.

giga sub-brand is not even mentioned. I think giga will die a slow death...

Reference:
Starhub FY2025 full year results
https://ir.starhub.com/newsroom/20260212_072316_CC3_6WSP5L91T8493ZIH.3.pdf
U52ZEH4.png


ZFFeyz7.png
 

Mancunian2

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2006
Messages
82,867
Reaction score
7,420
I doubt the one-for-one top-up offer will come back any time soon.

eight's focus in FY2026 will be --> 5G Scaling and ARPU growth.

So they will push users to go for the 5G plan. They will also grow eight home internet through the bundle deal with eight 5G plan.

Referenc:
Starhub FY2025 full year results
https://ir.starhub.com/newsroom/20260212_072316_CC3_6WSP5L91T8493ZIH.3.pdf
U52ZEH4.png


ZFFeyz7.png
problem is at $14.80, Eight's 5G plan is more expensive than the competition

maxx, circles, zym, z1 all have 5G plans around $10 or lower
(I don't rate Simba as proper 5G, so not included)
 

xiaofan

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
37,316
Reaction score
12,690
problem is at $14.80, Eight's 5G plan is more expensive than the competition

maxx, circles, zym, z1 all have 5G plans around $10 or lower
(I don't rate Simba as proper 5G, so not included)

Zym/Z1/VIVIFI/CMLink have no pure 5G plans at around S$10. Their 5G plan is at around S$15 per month. But they do have 4G plan with 180 days or half year 5G trial at around S$10 (Zero1 at S$12).

M1 Maxx --> S$12 per month. They used to offer 5G for the S$10 plan but they have since removed 5G from new M1 Maxx S$10 plan users. Only existing M1 Maxx S$10 5G users will get 5G.

CL --> this one is interesting, they have so many promotion codes and indeed some of the promotion codes are very good.

Indeed I will not count SIMBA as having proper 5G now.

Main benefits for eight compared to ST MVNOs and M1 M1 Maxx may be the roaming benefits, especially the free roaming voice. ST MVNOs are catching up in terms of roaming data bundle but tough to offer free roaming voice because of Singtel. Still Zym Roam Guard (10 minutes free) is the right direction.

Down the road, eight will have more promotions for the S$14.8 and S$18 5G plans, much less on eight S$8 and S$11.8 4G plans.

Reference:
1. Low cost SIM Only plans
⚡️💻 README First! How to Select Low Cost SIM Only Plans in Singapore? ✨
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/...low-cost-sim-only-plans-in-singapore.7167328/

2. Zym roam guard
https://zym.sg/faq/roaming-calls-sms/

7. I am seeing a "Roam Guard 10 Mins" in my mobile app or bill invoice. What is this?
W.E.F Feb 2026, Roam Guard, a new feature, automatically absorbs the cost of your first 10 minutes of incoming roaming calls each month while you’re overseas to help prevent bill shock; any incoming time beyond 10 minutes and all outgoing roaming calls are charged at standard pay‑per‑use roaming rates.
 
Last edited:

JAYSCS

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 30, 2021
Messages
1,216
Reaction score
1,007
problem is at $14.80, Eight's 5G plan is more expensive than the competition

maxx, circles, zym, z1 all have 5G plans around $10 or lower
(I don't rate Simba as proper 5G, so not included)
Eight may bring down the 5G plan price or provide free 5G network to its cheaper 4G plan. What strategy or non-strategy it adopts will depend how the future industry competes I think.
 

ZhuTou!

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2008
Messages
37,727
Reaction score
1,459
actually the promo is too 'good' for this age.

the amount per user spent on a mobile plan on average is 1/3 of the price 20 years ago. not to mention with the 1 for 1 promo, it become 1/6. i seriously wonder how can the telcos/MVNOs survive. haha.
Same thought lol. The moment i saw under $10 no contract plan, first thing came to my mind is not abt signing up. It was how they gonna survive haha.
 

xiaofan

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
37,316
Reaction score
12,690
i seriously wonder how can the telcos/MVNOs survive. haha.

Indeed quite some MVNOs already ceased operation because of the fierce competition, including two on M1 network recently (Changi Mobile and Geenet Mobile).

Let's see which MVNOs be next one to go.

I tend to think RedOne may well be the next one.

giga may be gone as well in the future, or maybe only selling travel eSIMs.

I also think one of Zym/Zero1/VIVIFI will go since the offerings from the three are very much similar.

Reference
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_in_Singapore
  • MVNOs:
    • Circles.Life (on M1's network)
    • CMLink SG (on Singtel's network)
    • CUniq SG (on StarHub's network)
    • eight Telecom (sub-brand of StarHub)
    • giga! (Sub-brand of StarHub)
    • GOMO (Sub-brand of Singtel)
    • Maxx (Sub-brand of M1)
    • MyRepublic Mobile (on StarHub's network for 5G plans; on M1's network for 4G plans)
    • redONE Mobile SG (on StarHub's network)
    • Singtel hi! (Sub-brand of Singtel; formerly known as heya by Singtel)
    • VIVIFI (on Singtel's network)
    • Zero1 (on Singtel's network)
    • ZYM Mobile (on Singtel's network)
  • Former operators:
    • MVNOs:
      • Changi Mobile (July 2021 - February 2026)
      • Geenet mobile (March 2020 - December 2025)
      • ZΩH (August 2022 - December 2023)
      • Gorilla Mobile (June 2021 - January 2023)
      • Grid Mobile (June 2019 - 6 December 2021)
      • Zero Mobile (December 2017 - March 2020)
      • Virgin Mobile Singapore (on Singtel's network, ceased operations in 2002)
 

Laguna123

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 30, 2005
Messages
96,190
Reaction score
30,432
Anyone here using their 5g plan? How’s the speed and connectivity compare to 4g?
Currently there is this 1 year 5g plan for $128, quite tempting.
 

xiaofan

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
37,316
Reaction score
12,690
Anyone here using their 5g plan? How’s the speed and connectivity compare to 4g?
Currently there is this 1 year 5g plan for $128, quite tempting.

It will be very much depending on the location, use cases and expectations.

My colleague and his wife are using eight 5G and he told me eight 5G is pretty good.

They were using giga 5G before and SingTel last time.

Now he wants to try eight 4G next billing cycle. Let's see what will happen to him.

I do not have eight 5G but I have StarHub Prepaid S 5G plan (80 GB data, S$3 per month Happy Prepaid Card migration offer) and eight S$8 4G (S$4 effective price for 22 months). The speed of StarHub Prepaid 5G is often 5 to 20 times faster than eight 4G, using Poco X7 Pro phone.

But take note I do not usually take MRT during weekdays. I commute using Bus Service daily to work. And I stay and work in the west area (to the west of Jurong East).
 
Last edited:

Laguna123

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 30, 2005
Messages
96,190
Reaction score
30,432
My colleague and his wife are using eight 5G and he told me eight 5G is pretty good.

They were using giga 5G before and SingTel last time.

Now he wants to try eight 4G next billing cycle. Let's see what will happen to him.

I do not have eight 5G but I have StarHub Prepaid S 5G plan (80 GB data, S$3 per month Happy Prepaid Card migration offer) and eight S$8 4G (S$4 effective price for 22 months). The speed of StarHub Prepaid 5G is often 5 to 20 times faster than eight 4G, using Poco X7 Pro phone.

But take note I do not usually take MRT during weekdays. I commute using Bus Service daily to work.
Thanks for the review, think I will upgrade to 5g, seem quite worth at $128 for 1 year plan.
 

xiaofan

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
37,316
Reaction score
12,690
Thanks for the review, think I will upgrade to 5g, seem quite worth at $128 for 1 year plan.

I think that is a good move especially if you have not got the one for one top-up offer before.

Whether eight 5G is good for you or not will depend on the location you frequent, the use cases and expectations.

Some users have negative reviews of eight 5G here. So you may want to mention the locations you frequent.

I stay and work in the west area (to the west of Jurong East).
 

Laguna123

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 30, 2005
Messages
96,190
Reaction score
30,432
I think that is a good move especially if you have not got the one for one top-up offer before.

Whether eight 5G is good for you or not will depend on the location you frequent, the use cases and expectations.

Some users have negative reviews of eight 5G here. So you may want to mention the locations you frequent.

I stay and work in the west area (to the west of Jurong East).
I stay Tampines area and work around cbd. So our 5g user experience might be different?😅
 

BBCWatcher

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2010
Messages
24,678
Reaction score
5,644
Eight may bring down the 5G plan price or provide free 5G network to its cheaper 4G plan. What strategy or non-strategy it adopts will depend how the future industry competes I think.
I think a MVNO ought to try a split allocation offer to see if that works competitively — for example, 288GB total data per month but with up to 8GB at 5G speeds, thereafter at 4G speeds. Price that split allocation somewhere in between the current 4G and 5G price offers. (Those who don't want to use their 5G allocations right away can simply disable 5G on their phones until they're ready.) This approach might be a way to persuade some price sensitive customers to pay a little more.

Maybe redONE or Circles.Life could try this?🤔
 

hereiam7788

Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2015
Messages
5,272
Reaction score
1,017
I think a MVNO ought to try a split allocation offer to see if that works competitively — for example, 288GB total data per month but with up to 8GB at 5G speeds, thereafter at 4G speeds. Price that split allocation somewhere in between the current 4G and 5G price offers. (Those who don't want to use their 5G allocations right away can simply disable 5G on their phones until they're ready.) This approach might be a way to persuade some price sensitive customers to pay a little more.

Maybe redONE or Circles.Life could try this?🤔

unless 4G is gone and 5G is taking over as the only network to use, else 4G plan will likely to exist, and so far MVNOs has not been increasing price for existing plans, but in fact they lower down price to current 4G price so far.

else, impossible for existing 4G users to move to 5G plan no matter how they plan with the plan.
and obviously, ppl do not go to 5G is becos 4G is more than sufficient so they dun bother to get 5G by paying extra which does not give much use and NOT becos of the bundled data is not enough. with the current quota given by either 4G or 5G, there is no way one can 'finish' the quota in any case.
 

BBCWatcher

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2010
Messages
24,678
Reaction score
5,644
....else, impossible for existing 4G users to move to 5G plan no matter how they plan with the plan....
My supposition (only that) is that there are some current 4G mobile plan customers who'd be willing to pay a little more to get a small allocation of 5G data for "special occasions." Much like how some people get practically all their medical care from public medical providers, but they're willing to pay somewhat more for occasional visits to private hospitals. (Raffles Shield covers this exact segment of the insurance market, actually.) I could be wrong, but I think it makes sense for an MVNO to test whether this market segment exists. RedONE could try since they currently don't offer any 5G plans at all. Assuming they want to stay in business.🤔 Maybe at $10/month with a few gigabytes of 5G data (and a much larger allotment of 4G data) they'd have a competitive offer?
 

hereiam7788

Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2015
Messages
5,272
Reaction score
1,017
My supposition (only that) is that there are some current 4G mobile plan customers who'd be willing to pay a little more to get a small allocation of 5G data for "special occasions." Much like how some people get practically all their medical care from public medical providers, but they're willing to pay somewhat more for occasional visits to private hospitals. (Raffles Shield covers this exact segment of the insurance market, actually.) I could be wrong, but I think it makes sense for an MVNO to test whether this market segment exists. RedONE could try since they currently don't offer any 5G plans at all. Assuming they want to stay in business.🤔 Maybe at $10/month with a few gigabytes of 5G data (and a much larger allotment of 4G data) they'd have a competitive offer?

i doubt so. eight 4G plan is $8, 5G plan is $14.80. the difference is only $6.80. the difference is not significant even now. Both 4G and 5G plans give significant amount of data that one can never even utilise more than 1/5 per month.

if one really needs 5G, they would have switch to 5G now by adding $6.80. There is not even need for MVNOs to come out anything now to 'attract' 5G customers.

as anyone is still on $8 plan now, obviously they know that they do not need 5G at all, and unlikely they will need it near future so long that 4G plan contiunes to exist.

If most ppl are keen to move to 5G plans, the 4G network should be freed up instead, while remaining users can enjoy this dedicatd network, it will not have such complaint that existing 4G customers will face conjestion issue.
 
Last edited:

xiaofan

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
37,316
Reaction score
12,690
i doubt so. eight 4G plan is $8, 5G plan is $14.80. the difference is only $4.80. the difference is not significant even now. Both 4G and 5G plans give significant amount of data that one can never even utilise more than 1/5 per month.

if one really needs 5G, they would have switch to 5G now by adding $4.80. There is not even need for MVNOs to come out anything now to 'attract' 5G customers.

as anyone is still on $8 plan now, obviously they know that they do not need 5G at all, and unlikely they will need it near future so long that 4G plan contiunes to exist.

If most ppl are keen to move to 5G plans, the 4G network should be freed up instead, while remaining users can enjoy this dedicatd network, it will not have such complaint that existing 4G customers will face conjestion issue.

Now it is a bit of bad time for StarHub 4G network. Down the road it may become a bit better in 2026/2027. Then it will get worse and worse in 2028/2030 time frame since 4G spectrums will be migrated to 5G/6G. Most likely no more 4G plans in Singapore in 2032 or maybe even earlier.

Now in 2026:
eight 4G: many customers and still growing (including eight senior plan)

CUniq: temporarily disabled 5G for all plans

redONE: all 4G plans now.

Later it may get a bit better with some eight and CUniq customers go to 5G. redONE may exit the market.
 

uncle_josh

Master Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2018
Messages
3,152
Reaction score
789
i doubt so. eight 4G plan is $8, 5G plan is $14.80. the difference is only $4.80. the difference is not significant even now. Both 4G and 5G plans give significant amount of data that one can never even utilise more than 1/5 per month.

if one really needs 5G, they would have switch to 5G now by adding $4.80. There is not even need for MVNOs to come out anything now to 'attract' 5G customers.

as anyone is still on $8 plan now, obviously they know that they do not need 5G at all, and unlikely they will need it near future so long that 4G plan contiunes to exist.

If most ppl are keen to move to 5G plans, the 4G network should be freed up instead, while remaining users can enjoy this dedicatd network, it will not have such complaint that existing 4G customers will face conjestion issue.
1. $14.80 - $8.0 = $6.80 not $4.80
Your maths really bad

2. 5G drains battery
with 5G, everyday need to charge, my electric bill goes up. With this Iran war my electric bill goes even higher,this is really very bad.
with 4G, my 5000mAh last 2.x day, I only need to charge on the 3rd day

3.lastly reducing 4G and giving to 5G is bad. You are putting a gun on people's head and forcing ppl to go 5G unnecessarily. Bad move.
 
Last edited:
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top