- Joined
- Sep 16, 2018
- Messages
- 30,188
- Reaction score
- 8,255
Post updated in Sept 2024
1. Popular Mesh system
1) Most popular mesh systems in this forum.
Netgear Orbi (good but usually expensive)
Asus AImesh (comprehensive offering, good FW features and long term support)
TP-Link Deco (comprehensive offering)
Linksys Velop (good mesh performance but less choices)
Dongknows comparison of the above and Amazon eero.
https://dongknows.com/home-mesh-brands-explained/
2) TP-Link EasyMesh (not as mature as Deco mesh)
3) Among China routers, Xiaomi seems to be popular in this forum.
Xiaomi WiFi 6 and above models support mesh as well (cost effective)
4) Not so popular:
Amazon eero (VQ is promoting it)
Google mesh
D-Link mesh
Huawei mesh
ZTE mesh
Ruijie mesh
2. Top models if you have to use wireless backhaul (triband WiFi 6)
1) Asus ZenWiFi Pro XT12
2) Netgear Orbi 860 series
3) Netgear Orbi RBK850 series
4) Asus ZenWiFi XT8 and ROG GT6 (good WiFi performance but weak CPU).
5) Netgear RBK760 series and 750 series
3. Top models if you have to use wireless backhaul (triband WiFi 6E or quadband)
1) Asus ZenWiFi Pro ET12
2) Netgear Orbi 960 series (expensive)
4. WiFi 7 mesh solution
1) Netgear Orbi 970 quad band (very expensive)
2) Asus ZenWiFi BQ16 and ZenWiFi BT10
3) TP-Link Deco BE85 (higher end) and Deco BE65
Note:
1) There are also Netgear Orbi Pro series (SXK80).
2) Of course you can also use Asus Aimesh with triband AX router modes like GT-AX11000, GT-AX11000 Pro. For example, GT-AX11000 Pro + ZenWiFi XT8 will be a poweful system and it also sorts out the weak CPU issue of the ZenWiFi XT8.
3) Linksys MX4200 Velop has mixed reviews from the users in this forum.
5. Low cost triband AX/AXE mesh system:
TP-Link Deco X68, X75, XE75, XE75 Pro
Xiaomi AX9000
6. Good options if you can use Ethenet backhaul:
Asus AIMesh (dual band models will be good enough, eg: GT-AX600+RT-AX82U).
You can use Moca adapters as Ethenet backhaul if you have the Coax Cable (SCV/Starhub Cable system).
Asus ZenWiFi XD4/XD4S/XD5/XD6 can be used as well and people may like the form factor but the performance is usually less then their counterpart Asus AX router (eg: XD6 is worse than RT-AX82U or TUF-AX5400, XD5 is not as good as RT-AX58U and TUF-AX3000, XD4 is not as good as RT-AX55). It is also not recommended to use ZenWiFi XD4/XD4S as the main router as they only have 256MB RAM. I will aslo do not recommend using Asus RT-AX53U/RT-AX55/RT-AX57/RT-AX3000P as the main rotuer due to the fact that they only have 256MB RAM. You may encounter issues even with Ethernet backhaul. However, they will be okay to be used as AImesh nodes if they are behind a more powerful Asus router (eg: TUF-AX4200, TUF-AX6000, RT-AX86U or better).
You can also choose Netgear Orbi RBK350 series and Netgear MK60 series, TP-Link Deco X20/X25/X50/X50 Pro/X55/X60/X80/X90/etc.
7. Low cost mesh system for Singtel/WC ONR users if you can use Ethernet Backhaul
Asus RT-AX3000P (about S$160 for a pair, BNIB, dumped by M1 users in Carousell)
TP-Link Archer AX72 AX5400 Easy Mesh ( about S$160 for a pair, BNIB, dumped by M1 users in Carousell)
Xiaomi AX3000 NE (about S$139 per pair for local version)
TP-Link Deco X20 (about S$179 per pair)
8. Special solution with Powerline backhaul (lower performance but good coverage if you do not have LAN ports in the rooms):
Asus Zenwifi XP4 (AX1800+AV1300)
TP-Link Deco PX50 (AX3000 + G.hn G1500)
9. Top WiFi 6 Mesh System from Dongknows
https://dongknows.com/best-wi-fi-6-mesh-systems/
10. Top WiFi 6E Mesh System from Dongknows (not yet popular in Singapore)
https://dongknows.com/best-wi-fi-6e-mesh-systems/
11. WiFi 7 mesh are still quite expensive. As of now, the 10Gbp plans from ST/SH/MR provide TP-Link WiFi 7 routers which supports EasyMesh. You may be able to get other TP-Link EasyMesh compatible routers as the mesh node. But the ISPs recommend to use the same router as the 10G capable mesh node.
Example:
Starhub EB810v + HB710 TP-Link EasyMesh combination
Singtel HB810 + HB810 TP-Link EasyMesh combination
M1/MR TP-Link Archer BE805 + Archer BE805 TP-Link EasyMesh combination
VQ/SIMBA Amazon eero Max 7 mesh solution
12. More about TP-Link Deco, EasyMesh and the older OneMesh by Dongknows
https://dongknows.com/tp-link-deco-overview/
https://dongknows.com/tp-link-easymesh-wi-fi-system-review/
https://dongknows.com/tp-link-onemesh-wi-fi-system-review/
13. More about Asus AImesh by Dongknows
https://dongknows.com/asus-aimesh-overview/
https://dongknows.com/asus-aimesh-setup-and-signal-handoff/
https://dongknows.com/tips-and-rules-on-picking-the-best-asus-aimesh-combo/
14. Dedicated mesh vs Asus AIMesh, Xiaomi Mesh and Huawei HiLink Mesh
Dedicated mesh solution like TP-Link Deco and Asus ZenWiFi (Still AImesh based) and Netgear Orbi: usually nicer looking with internal antennas, got triband options, ease of use, potentially limited features (eg: TP-Link Deco, Linksys Velop, Netgear Orbi; exception is Asus ZenWiFi).
Normal router based mesh solution like Asus AImesh, Netgear Nighthawk Mesh (Easymesh based) and TP-Link EasyMesh: not many triband options, more complete features
15. Mesh routers to be avoided if using SingTel.
No 1 to avoid is Google Nest WiFi (or the old Google WiFi).
Two major problem:
1) if used with ONR, Google does not support mesh in AP mode, so you will face Double NAT.
2) if used with ONT, it does not support SingTel VLAN, so again you need to use it after VLAN capable router, so Double NAT will happen again.
No 2, avoid Askey/Airties/Arcadyan unless you need wireless connection for the SingTel TV box.
They are heavily tied to SingTel network as you need to be on SingTel network for firmware updates
16. A long but pretty good write-up for the mesh system vs others, and Ethernet backhaul vs wireless backhaul.
From DongKonws.com
https://dongknows.com/mesh-wi-fi-system-explained/
Mesh system vs. individual extenders or access points
A mesh system consists of multiple Wi-Fi broadcasters (access points or extenders) that work together and can be managed in one place, such as a mobile app or the primary router unit's web user interface.
In a mesh with wireless backhauling, each satellite unit is essentially a centrally managed Wi-Fi extender. In a mesh with wired backhauling, each satellite unit is essentially a centrally managed access point.
1) Wired backhaul: The only way to get the best performing mesh
The best way to implement a mesh is by using network cables to link the hubs together in a wired backhaul setup. In this case, you’ll always have the best possible Wi-Fi speeds throughout.
...
You don’t need to worry much about how to arrange the hubs in a wired backhaul setup. Within reason, no matter the distance or placement, you’ll get the same performance.
...
2) Wireless backhaul: Super convenient but can be temperamental
Running network cables can be hard or even not possible at all. So wireless mesh setups are popular. In this case, how you arrange the hubs is crucial. That’s because, over the air, the connections between them can vary a great deal.
To deal with that, there are two things to consider, the distance and the topology.
...
17. Related threads:
1) Netgear Orbi discussions
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/threads/is-the-orbi-good.5561625/page-23
2) TP-Link Deco discussion
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/...-x20-x50-x55-x60-x68-x75-x90-x95-etc.6723167/
3) Linksys Velop disussion
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/threads/linksys-velop-wifi-that-sets-you-free.5605530/
4) Asus ZenWiFi XT8 and ZenWiFi Pro XT12
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/threads/maylyn-networking-asus-zenwifi-xt8.6177953/
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/threads/asus-zenwifi-pro-xt12-in-singapore-discussion.6737682/
5) Aimesh capable AX routers
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/...-tuf-ax5400-rt-ax5400-and-tuf-ax4200.6315347/
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/...ax55-rt-ax53u-rt-ax1800hp-rt-ax1800u.6394549/
1. Popular Mesh system
1) Most popular mesh systems in this forum.
Netgear Orbi (good but usually expensive)
Asus AImesh (comprehensive offering, good FW features and long term support)
TP-Link Deco (comprehensive offering)
Linksys Velop (good mesh performance but less choices)
Dongknows comparison of the above and Amazon eero.
https://dongknows.com/home-mesh-brands-explained/
2) TP-Link EasyMesh (not as mature as Deco mesh)
3) Among China routers, Xiaomi seems to be popular in this forum.
Xiaomi WiFi 6 and above models support mesh as well (cost effective)
4) Not so popular:
Amazon eero (VQ is promoting it)
Google mesh
D-Link mesh
Huawei mesh
ZTE mesh
Ruijie mesh
2. Top models if you have to use wireless backhaul (triband WiFi 6)
1) Asus ZenWiFi Pro XT12
2) Netgear Orbi 860 series
3) Netgear Orbi RBK850 series
4) Asus ZenWiFi XT8 and ROG GT6 (good WiFi performance but weak CPU).
5) Netgear RBK760 series and 750 series
3. Top models if you have to use wireless backhaul (triband WiFi 6E or quadband)
1) Asus ZenWiFi Pro ET12
2) Netgear Orbi 960 series (expensive)
4. WiFi 7 mesh solution
1) Netgear Orbi 970 quad band (very expensive)
2) Asus ZenWiFi BQ16 and ZenWiFi BT10
3) TP-Link Deco BE85 (higher end) and Deco BE65
Note:
1) There are also Netgear Orbi Pro series (SXK80).
2) Of course you can also use Asus Aimesh with triband AX router modes like GT-AX11000, GT-AX11000 Pro. For example, GT-AX11000 Pro + ZenWiFi XT8 will be a poweful system and it also sorts out the weak CPU issue of the ZenWiFi XT8.
3) Linksys MX4200 Velop has mixed reviews from the users in this forum.
5. Low cost triband AX/AXE mesh system:
TP-Link Deco X68, X75, XE75, XE75 Pro
Xiaomi AX9000
6. Good options if you can use Ethenet backhaul:
Asus AIMesh (dual band models will be good enough, eg: GT-AX600+RT-AX82U).
You can use Moca adapters as Ethenet backhaul if you have the Coax Cable (SCV/Starhub Cable system).
Asus ZenWiFi XD4/XD4S/XD5/XD6 can be used as well and people may like the form factor but the performance is usually less then their counterpart Asus AX router (eg: XD6 is worse than RT-AX82U or TUF-AX5400, XD5 is not as good as RT-AX58U and TUF-AX3000, XD4 is not as good as RT-AX55). It is also not recommended to use ZenWiFi XD4/XD4S as the main router as they only have 256MB RAM. I will aslo do not recommend using Asus RT-AX53U/RT-AX55/RT-AX57/RT-AX3000P as the main rotuer due to the fact that they only have 256MB RAM. You may encounter issues even with Ethernet backhaul. However, they will be okay to be used as AImesh nodes if they are behind a more powerful Asus router (eg: TUF-AX4200, TUF-AX6000, RT-AX86U or better).
You can also choose Netgear Orbi RBK350 series and Netgear MK60 series, TP-Link Deco X20/X25/X50/X50 Pro/X55/X60/X80/X90/etc.
7. Low cost mesh system for Singtel/WC ONR users if you can use Ethernet Backhaul
Asus RT-AX3000P (about S$160 for a pair, BNIB, dumped by M1 users in Carousell)
TP-Link Archer AX72 AX5400 Easy Mesh ( about S$160 for a pair, BNIB, dumped by M1 users in Carousell)
Xiaomi AX3000 NE (about S$139 per pair for local version)
TP-Link Deco X20 (about S$179 per pair)
8. Special solution with Powerline backhaul (lower performance but good coverage if you do not have LAN ports in the rooms):
Asus Zenwifi XP4 (AX1800+AV1300)
TP-Link Deco PX50 (AX3000 + G.hn G1500)
9. Top WiFi 6 Mesh System from Dongknows
https://dongknows.com/best-wi-fi-6-mesh-systems/
10. Top WiFi 6E Mesh System from Dongknows (not yet popular in Singapore)
https://dongknows.com/best-wi-fi-6e-mesh-systems/
11. WiFi 7 mesh are still quite expensive. As of now, the 10Gbp plans from ST/SH/MR provide TP-Link WiFi 7 routers which supports EasyMesh. You may be able to get other TP-Link EasyMesh compatible routers as the mesh node. But the ISPs recommend to use the same router as the 10G capable mesh node.
Example:
Starhub EB810v + HB710 TP-Link EasyMesh combination
Singtel HB810 + HB810 TP-Link EasyMesh combination
M1/MR TP-Link Archer BE805 + Archer BE805 TP-Link EasyMesh combination
VQ/SIMBA Amazon eero Max 7 mesh solution
12. More about TP-Link Deco, EasyMesh and the older OneMesh by Dongknows
https://dongknows.com/tp-link-deco-overview/
https://dongknows.com/tp-link-easymesh-wi-fi-system-review/
https://dongknows.com/tp-link-onemesh-wi-fi-system-review/
13. More about Asus AImesh by Dongknows
https://dongknows.com/asus-aimesh-overview/
https://dongknows.com/asus-aimesh-setup-and-signal-handoff/
https://dongknows.com/tips-and-rules-on-picking-the-best-asus-aimesh-combo/
14. Dedicated mesh vs Asus AIMesh, Xiaomi Mesh and Huawei HiLink Mesh
Dedicated mesh solution like TP-Link Deco and Asus ZenWiFi (Still AImesh based) and Netgear Orbi: usually nicer looking with internal antennas, got triband options, ease of use, potentially limited features (eg: TP-Link Deco, Linksys Velop, Netgear Orbi; exception is Asus ZenWiFi).
Normal router based mesh solution like Asus AImesh, Netgear Nighthawk Mesh (Easymesh based) and TP-Link EasyMesh: not many triband options, more complete features
15. Mesh routers to be avoided if using SingTel.
No 1 to avoid is Google Nest WiFi (or the old Google WiFi).
Two major problem:
1) if used with ONR, Google does not support mesh in AP mode, so you will face Double NAT.
2) if used with ONT, it does not support SingTel VLAN, so again you need to use it after VLAN capable router, so Double NAT will happen again.
No 2, avoid Askey/Airties/Arcadyan unless you need wireless connection for the SingTel TV box.
They are heavily tied to SingTel network as you need to be on SingTel network for firmware updates
16. A long but pretty good write-up for the mesh system vs others, and Ethernet backhaul vs wireless backhaul.
From DongKonws.com
https://dongknows.com/mesh-wi-fi-system-explained/
Mesh system vs. individual extenders or access points
A mesh system consists of multiple Wi-Fi broadcasters (access points or extenders) that work together and can be managed in one place, such as a mobile app or the primary router unit's web user interface.
In a mesh with wireless backhauling, each satellite unit is essentially a centrally managed Wi-Fi extender. In a mesh with wired backhauling, each satellite unit is essentially a centrally managed access point.
1) Wired backhaul: The only way to get the best performing mesh
The best way to implement a mesh is by using network cables to link the hubs together in a wired backhaul setup. In this case, you’ll always have the best possible Wi-Fi speeds throughout.
...
You don’t need to worry much about how to arrange the hubs in a wired backhaul setup. Within reason, no matter the distance or placement, you’ll get the same performance.
...
2) Wireless backhaul: Super convenient but can be temperamental
Running network cables can be hard or even not possible at all. So wireless mesh setups are popular. In this case, how you arrange the hubs is crucial. That’s because, over the air, the connections between them can vary a great deal.
To deal with that, there are two things to consider, the distance and the topology.
...
17. Related threads:
1) Netgear Orbi discussions
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/threads/is-the-orbi-good.5561625/page-23
2) TP-Link Deco discussion
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/...-x20-x50-x55-x60-x68-x75-x90-x95-etc.6723167/
3) Linksys Velop disussion
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/threads/linksys-velop-wifi-that-sets-you-free.5605530/
4) Asus ZenWiFi XT8 and ZenWiFi Pro XT12
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/threads/maylyn-networking-asus-zenwifi-xt8.6177953/
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/threads/asus-zenwifi-pro-xt12-in-singapore-discussion.6737682/
5) Aimesh capable AX routers
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/...-tuf-ax5400-rt-ax5400-and-tuf-ax4200.6315347/
https://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/...ax55-rt-ax53u-rt-ax1800hp-rt-ax1800u.6394549/
Last edited:



