scrutanise the ingredient & consult a dematologist
The menscience acne lotion is nothing more than BP in a glorified packaging w/ some exotic ingredient like green tea/Allantoin which supposedly help sooth the skin, but the problem is how much % of those ingredient are contained within, it is a
marketing technique to use 'spot treatment' instead of 'apply on affected area', as spot treatment gives the impression of effective/precision whereas 'affected area' sounds like 'dispersed effect'.
the other pic shows a 'sulphur' product w/zinc which is also commonly found in leading pharmacies,sulphur oxidises on skin & has antibacterial properties similar to that of BP, i'm not sure of the effectiveness & mechanism behind it. whereas zinc has supporting role in helping skin to heal but the actual absorption of zinc through skin is a gray zone. The oil that's in the tube that's used to prevent 'caking' of the sulphur cream may cause irritation, the lotion version under the same company ICM is often recommended for large area of coverage(chest) & hard to reach area(back/neck) due to the ease of application.
If you want BP with moisturising ingredient, you can buy Benzac AC 2.5, a water based BP with poloxamer 182,glycerin etc commonly found in many products and act as lubricant on the skin
otherwise panoxyl 2.5% will do the same job except w/o any those added moisturising agent
actually there is no need for added moisturising agent since moisturiser should rightfully be used after application of BP
they are both inexpensive products, same price for both product($/g) except they come in different size packaging definitely cheaper than the 'spot treatment' products.
Manufacturer will charge more for 'spot treatment' products as psychologically consumer will relate 'spot treatment' with 'less amount used', in that sense consumer will think it's 'value for money', in actual fact, consumer tend to use more than they need as they are conscience of the amount used as in sufficient so they tend to 'overdose' whereas for 'apply over affected area' products such as the formal 2, consumer tend to pinch on it due to the reverse mentality.
that's a razor burn you are describing which can be due to many reason, your technique(too close,shaving w/o lubrication etc) been the most crucial part, skin sensitivity whether you have eczema or easily irritated skin etc. have you tried plucking instead of shaving, it may sound ridiculous to pluck so much, but you can do a patch test pluck a certain area eg above your chin, continue to do so & observe the neck area which receive shaving as compared to above chin which been plucked, advantage of plucking, minimum irritation, skin stays smoother for longer period of time. otherwise after shave, you can either tone with a alcohol free toner->BP->moisturise or rinse with water->dab dry->BP->aftershave cream/moisturiser. but the problem may lies with repeated irritation to the inflamed skin w/o giving it sufficient time to recover. when pimple turn dark colour/blackish red, it can be due to increase in inflammatory of pimple w/o proper treatment or if it becomes big lumpy dark reddish/black & hurts when you try to squeeze it & don't seem to get anything out of it can be lymph node infection which will gradually cease away even w/o doing anything but can speed up by applying BP in the region to cut down on bacteria count otherwise it may be infection deepening expending the well of bacteria from within causing it to be more inflamed on the surface. A visit to GP/dermatologist will help resolve the real issue which can be a combination.
kiehl has a range of alcohol free toner which are recommended for aftershave
clarins also has alcohol/oil free aftershave that may help ease your problem
how abt this prouct? but it is for spot 1 not whole face.
IS BP very costly since use on whole face?
how abt this?
sry kinda confuse overt normal pimple cream and BP.
my face is now almost clear of pimple BUT the problem now is on my beard area. Due to shaving, pimple keep poping out on the surface on and below my chin and also my neck. And these pimples take a very long time to heal, been wks and the pimple although smaller but is still there, and is dark in colour, black red ???
just got a aftershave to deal with this, will that help? any advise?