[Official] Home Automation Thread

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
Appreciate the quick reply. I'm getting a better sense now of the lighting setup but now in a slight dilemma.

I'm also not sure which is a better approach?

a) smart bulb + dumb switch
b) smart switch + dumb bulbs
c) smart switch + smart bulb --> costly and redundant

I guess if I need dimming + moods + colors, I would need to go with option A or option C only?

What are you guys planning for lighting?

Cheers,
P

Personal opinion? If you have areas need mood + colour, go with dumb switch + smart bulb. Remember that you can use phone app/hub to control the light bulb directly. I not sure how you going to plan the switch, because if you switch off your smart bulb light switch out of habit, it won't work. :s13: Must label the switch "DO NOT OFF"?

Those areas only need white light, no need dimming or all that nonsense, go smart switch + dumb bulb. I feel like there's no need for smart switch + smart bulb under any circumstances.
 

awful999

Supremacy Member
Joined
May 1, 2008
Messages
5,899
Reaction score
0
Broadlink can use for KDK fan, but have to setup as custom device. But Alexa and GH can't control a custom device, so...
I am setting up my KDK using light control and can control by GH thru broadlink pro, but my KDK is infrared control , what you mentioned is RF control model ?
 

viix

Master Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
3,236
Reaction score
2
Appreciate the quick reply. I'm getting a better sense now of the lighting setup but now in a slight dilemma.

I'm also not sure which is a better approach?

a) smart bulb + dumb switch
b) smart switch + dumb bulbs
c) smart switch + smart bulb --> costly and redundant

I guess if I need dimming + moods + colors, I would need to go with option A or option C only?

What are you guys planning for lighting?

Cheers,
P

Ya, quite redundant to have switches actually (smart or hardwired both) as I've motion sensored the whole place.

When I first started, all my switches were smart switch and dumb lights.
Then slowly philips hue/yeelight the whole places. What I did then was to remove my switch and terminate the light to always on. The switches with smartlight now don't connect to load (meaning no connection to light) and I use it to turn on scenes (to turn on a few lights configuration base on time of the day or the colour of the light based on time of the day.)

The scene is useful cause when someone is sleeping, or its past 2359hrs, the same switch will only on the indirect spotlights at 10% dimness vs brighter downlights when we come home in the evening, or when someone wake up at 4am where it's 1% dimmness and only all the recessed lights and table lamps will be on.

So why I say redundent is because with PIR sensor, I dont touch the switch anymore.. I have it just because the other members of my family prefer to physically use a switch to turn off although I always nag at them that it will auto off after a while when there is no movement..

Broadlink can use for KDK fan, but have to setup as custom device. But Alexa and GH can't control a custom device, so...

Can try scenes? Its exposed to alexa IIRC
 

earthtk

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2008
Messages
1,704
Reaction score
4
Anyone has issues with broad link auto turning on stuff? Kinda weird coz it sometimes turn on my fan in the middle of the night

Sent from Samsung SM-G965F using GAGT
 

JackDulouz

Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2002
Messages
5,432
Reaction score
57
I am setting up my KDK using light control and can control by GH thru broadlink pro, but my KDK is infrared control , what you mentioned is RF control model ?

Broadlink Pro comes with IR leh.. Else how to control AC..
 

porker997

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2007
Messages
59
Reaction score
0
Interesting and thanks for sharing.

I think motion sensor would be the coolest thing ever, especially if I can do it for the whole house like you. But not sure if I have the buy-in for that far in the HA project just yet at this point :)

Increasingly, it seems that going with dumb switch + smart bulb could be a more practical way to go for me. I save $ on the expensive switches and I don't need the electrician to pull the neutral wires to the switches.

Cheers


Ya, quite redundant to have switches actually (smart or hardwired both) as I've motion sensored the whole place.

When I first started, all my switches were smart switch and dumb lights.
Then slowly philips hue/yeelight the whole places. What I did then was to remove my switch and terminate the light to always on. The switches with smartlight now don't connect to load (meaning no connection to light) and I use it to turn on scenes (to turn on a few lights configuration base on time of the day or the colour of the light based on time of the day.)

The scene is useful cause when someone is sleeping, or its past 2359hrs, the same switch will only on the indirect spotlights at 10% dimness vs brighter downlights when we come home in the evening, or when someone wake up at 4am where it's 1% dimmness and only all the recessed lights and table lamps will be on.

So why I say redundent is because with PIR sensor, I dont touch the switch anymore.. I have it just because the other members of my family prefer to physically use a switch to turn off although I always nag at them that it will auto off after a while when there is no movement..



Can try scenes? Its exposed to alexa IIRC
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
Ya, quite redundant to have switches actually (smart or hardwired both) as I've motion sensored the whole place.

When I first started, all my switches were smart switch and dumb lights.
Then slowly philips hue/yeelight the whole places. What I did then was to remove my switch and terminate the light to always on. The switches with smartlight now don't connect to load (meaning no connection to light) and I use it to turn on scenes (to turn on a few lights configuration base on time of the day or the colour of the light based on time of the day.)

The scene is useful cause when someone is sleeping, or its past 2359hrs, the same switch will only on the indirect spotlights at 10% dimness vs brighter downlights when we come home in the evening, or when someone wake up at 4am where it's 1% dimmness and only all the recessed lights and table lamps will be on.

So why I say redundent is because with PIR sensor, I dont touch the switch anymore.. I have it just because the other members of my family prefer to physically use a switch to turn off although I always nag at them that it will auto off after a while when there is no movement..



Can try scenes? Its exposed to alexa IIRC
How often do you have a faulty bulb? I heard smart bulbs don't really spoil that easily but I'm a bit concerned.
 

gheesung

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2000
Messages
49
Reaction score
0
I believe one of the most irritating experiences about motion sensor is it switched off when one still needed the light.

I have implemented using Xiaomi motion sensor with light intensity for my kitchen and the light is controlled by a smart switch.

I am using the kitchen smart light switch to disable the motion sensor. When the light is switched on via the switch, it will deactivate the motion sensor. This is useful because previously when someone was in the kitchen for long period, the light will switch off and one has to wave in front of the motion sensor to switch on the light. To activate back the sensor again, just switch off the light via the smart switch.

The light sensor in the motion sensor comes in handy too. During day time, the light will not be switched on when there is bright ambient light.

All this was implemented using openhab rules.

Ya, quite redundant to have switches actually (smart or hardwired both) as I've motion sensored the whole place.


When I first started, all my switches were smart switch and dumb lights.
Then slowly philips hue/yeelight the whole places. What I did then was to remove my switch and terminate the light to always on. The switches with smartlight now don't connect to load (meaning no connection to light) and I use it to turn on scenes (to turn on a few lights configuration base on time of the day or the colour of the light based on time of the day.)

The scene is useful cause when someone is sleeping, or its past 2359hrs, the same switch will only on the indirect spotlights at 10% dimness vs brighter downlights when we come home in the evening, or when someone wake up at 4am where it's 1% dimmness and only all the recessed lights and table lamps will be on.

So why I say redundent is because with PIR sensor, I dont touch the switch anymore.. I have it just because the other members of my family prefer to physically use a switch to turn off although I always nag at them that it will auto off after a while when there is no movement..



Can try scenes? Its exposed to alexa IIRC
 

gheesung

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2000
Messages
49
Reaction score
0
For my home, I have option C. I have setup some smart bulbs and smart led strips to control the scene in the living room. After 1 year, it is hardly activated. Smart switches are more often used compared to smart bulb/led strip.


Appreciate the quick reply. I'm getting a better sense now of the lighting setup but now in a slight dilemma.

I'm also not sure which is a better approach?

a) smart bulb + dumb switch
b) smart switch + dumb bulbs
c) smart switch + smart bulb --> costly and redundant

I guess if I need dimming + moods + colors, I would need to go with option A or option C only?

What are you guys planning for lighting?

Cheers,
P
 

gheesung

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2000
Messages
49
Reaction score
0
Firstly I DIY my smart home.

For Xiaomi, I used their sensors, Air purifiers, Vacuum Robot, light bulbs and IR control. I have tried the Mihome app and it is ok.

All their product range are cheap and reliable.

Is the Xiaomi mijia smart home kit good?

Sent from Pm Me For Geneco Promo Codes And Plans using GAGT
 

kenho_23

Member
Joined
Jul 9, 2004
Messages
183
Reaction score
5
Anybody here heard about Lifesmart product? They seems to be relatively cheap and support multiple voice assistant product. Their light switch requires smart hub
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
Anybody here heard about Lifesmart product? They seems to be relatively cheap and support multiple voice assistant product. Their light switch requires smart hub

Does it use z-wave or zigbee? Their site is useless siah.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top