[Official] Home Automation Thread

kenho_23

Member
Joined
Jul 9, 2004
Messages
183
Reaction score
5
Does it use z-wave or zigbee? Their site is useless siah.

No idea, their website didn't specify. I did check with taobao seller and they have wall switch that work without Neutral wire, but smart hub is required. They also say it work with Google home and alexa.
 

waterfoe

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2002
Messages
71
Reaction score
0
It depend on the brand of dimmer switch....

If you are getting the well established brand, there shouldn't be any issue with the dimmable lighting fixture. If you are having multiple dimmable lighting on a circuit, the cost of the smart bulb will be more expensive.

By the way I also don't recommend buying smart dimmer switches as they often require very specific bulb types to work. If you need dimmer functions, just buy a smart bulb, connect it to a dumb switch.
 

viix

Master Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
3,236
Reaction score
2
It depend on the brand of dimmer switch....

If you are getting the well established brand, there shouldn't be any issue with the dimmable lighting fixture. If you are having multiple dimmable lighting on a circuit, the cost of the smart bulb will be more expensive.

If using incandescent, any brand will do.
If using dimmable led, there really isn't much dimmable smart switch or modules that I've tried that works well.. either the dimming is not linear enough, or totally not compatible and flickers due to the PWM..

What brands of switches have you tried that works well and what's the model of the compatible led bulbs? I'm still looking for something for my work place..

The branded dimmer switch that work are not cheap, neither is the dimmable leds..
the cost of both is enough to purchase a set of decent smart bulbs.. I personally still find smartbulbs more cost effective as I can dim very smoothly from 100% down to 1% linearly.
I forgotten which brand of wall dimmers I've tried for LED but the led dimming is only able to dim 100-30% relative to a incandescent lamp or smart bulb's dimming.
I've the megaman dimmable leds but they're in the store somewhere after changing them to philips hue.
 
Last edited:

zoneguard

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2000
Messages
1,957
Reaction score
398
Thank you very much. Does this mean the physical switch can be switched off, and the relay will still function? (eg using electronic terminal to trigger the relay)

In this configuration, no current flows to the Shelly when physical switch is switched OFF and hence Shelly doesn't work. You need to hard-wire the physical switch to be always ON if you want the relay to work all the time and hence control the lighting through other means.
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
If using incandescent, any brand will do.
If using dimmable led, there really isn't much dimmable smart switch or modules that I've tried that works well.. either the dimming is not linear enough, or totally not compatible and flickers due to the PWM..

What brands of switches have you tried that works well and what's the model of the compatible led bulbs? I'm still looking for something for my work place..

The branded dimmer switch that work are not cheap, neither is the dimmable leds..
the cost of both is enough to purchase a set of decent smart bulbs.. I personally still find smartbulbs more cost effective as I can dim very smoothly from 100% down to 1% linearly.
I forgotten which brand of wall dimmers I've tried for LED but the led dimming is only able to dim 100-30% relative to a incandescent lamp or smart bulb's dimming.
I've the megaman dimmable leds but they're in the store somewhere after changing them to philips hue.
I have also read the same thing, though it's mostly from angmohs into home automation that some people can't get their lights to dim properly even when connected to branded GE dimmer Zigbee switches... Some work some don't.
 

waterfoe

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2002
Messages
71
Reaction score
0
I have tired, Control4 and Lutron.... I do understand this are not the DIY brands that are commonly use in this post.

Another point you need to note is the LED driver.... I have tested brand like HEP, Meanwell, philips and Osram without any issue you mentioned below.

GU10 bulb, i tried before a few china brands also no problem.

Not sure if you notice why the china brand always have issue with the dimmer module but not the on/off switch. Most of the dimmable module technology are all patented by Lutron.


If using incandescent, any brand will do.
If using dimmable led, there really isn't much dimmable smart switch or modules that I've tried that works well.. either the dimming is not linear enough, or totally not compatible and flickers due to the PWM..

What brands of switches have you tried that works well and what's the model of the compatible led bulbs? I'm still looking for something for my work place..

The branded dimmer switch that work are not cheap, neither is the dimmable leds..
the cost of both is enough to purchase a set of decent smart bulbs.. I personally still find smartbulbs more cost effective as I can dim very smoothly from 100% down to 1% linearly.
I forgotten which brand of wall dimmers I've tried for LED but the led dimming is only able to dim 100-30% relative to a incandescent lamp or smart bulb's dimming.
I've the megaman dimmable leds but they're in the store somewhere after changing them to philips hue.
 

viix

Master Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
3,236
Reaction score
2
I have tired, Control4 and Lutron.... I do understand this are not the DIY brands that are commonly use in this post.

Another point you need to note is the LED driver.... I have tested brand like HEP, Meanwell, philips and Osram without any issue you mentioned below.

GU10 bulb, i tried before a few china brands also no problem.

Not sure if you notice why the china brand always have issue with the dimmer module but not the on/off switch. Most of the dimmable module technology are all patented by Lutron.

Lutron isn't cheap either..
well my point is, it would serve more purpose to just use a generic smart switch to pair with a hub and use the hub to set scenes or dimming base on time.
With a capable hub that can be programmed easily, that same switch can set different purposes base on time of the day vs just a single dimming switch. And honestly, with automation, how often does one go to the switch to dim nowadays..
 

waterfoe

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2002
Messages
71
Reaction score
0
Totally agree with you....

Problem is there isn't that many dimmable keypad available in the market.... Mainly are from the ang mo brands....

Lutron isn't cheap either..
well my point is, it would serve more purpose to just use a generic smart switch to pair with a hub and use the hub to set scenes or dimming base on time.
With a capable hub that can be programmed easily, that same switch can set different purposes base on time of the day vs just a single dimming switch. And honestly, with automation, how often does one go to the switch to dim nowadays..
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
Lutron isn't cheap either..
well my point is, it would serve more purpose to just use a generic smart switch to pair with a hub and use the hub to set scenes or dimming base on time.
With a capable hub that can be programmed easily, that same switch can set different purposes base on time of the day vs just a single dimming switch. And honestly, with automation, how often does one go to the switch to dim nowadays..
To be honest, if you need dimming functionality, just get a smart bulb and save yourself the trouble. This situation is like the non-neutral Aqara wall switch. You get many people who use a few months spoil, while you have some use 1 year no issue. Might as well just save the trouble pull neutral so can use the ones with neutral function too.
 

waterfoe

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2002
Messages
71
Reaction score
0
The below assumption make sense if you only have little lighting fixture per dimmable circuit.

If you have a living room that require say 12 to 14 dimmable lighting fixture, the smart bulb option is going to be much more expensive. Not forgetting, smart bulb only has either e27 or gu10 therefore limit the lighting fixture design.

To be honest, if you need dimming functionality, just get a smart bulb and save yourself the trouble. This situation is like the non-neutral Aqara wall switch. You get many people who use a few months spoil, while you have some use 1 year no issue. Might as well just save the trouble pull neutral so can use the ones with neutral function too.
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
The below assumption make sense if you only have little lighting fixture per dimmable circuit.

If you have a living room that require say 12 to 14 dimmable lighting fixture, the smart bulb option is going to be much more expensive. Not forgetting, smart bulb only has either e27 or gu10 therefore limit the lighting fixture design.

You save yourself some trouble spending the money though. No need to troubleshoot why the light you buy cannot dim properly.
 

waterfoe

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2002
Messages
71
Reaction score
0
I don't have any issue with my dimmable circuits.....

Just quoting scenario whereby smart bulb might not be suitable... It does has it advantages but not a 1 size fit all solution.

You save yourself some trouble spending the money though. No need to troubleshoot why the light you buy cannot dim properly.
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
I don't have any issue with my dimmable circuits.....

Just quoting scenario whereby smart bulb might not be suitable... It does has it advantages but not a 1 size fit all solution.
That's true. I have decided to only have dimming in my bedroom, living room all that not going to bother.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top