[Official] Home Automation Thread

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
Zwave wise, MCO has local support if the switch dies.. and i believe it's the nicest..
If going for zigbee or other types, there are other brands though I dont have any recommendation.

IMHO, Zwave has faster response than zigbee and RF.. since I have used all 3 before. I use neocoolcam sensors for place I need fast reaction and aqara sensor for places that don't
From my research so far, the only light switch that works with Zigbee and got support for our 240v is Xiaomi Aqara. :s22: Most of the atas branded Zigbee light switches like Legrand one only works with 110v tragically. :(

I saw a setup with Hubitat and interfaced with Zwave switches, it's near instant siah with Google Home setup.
 

viix

Master Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
3,236
Reaction score
2
From my research so far, the only light switch that works with Zigbee and got support for our 240v is Xiaomi Aqara. :s22: Most of the atas branded Zigbee light switches like Legrand one only works with 110v tragically. :(

I saw a setup with Hubitat and interfaced with Zwave switches, it's near instant siah with Google Home setup.

Zwave is very near instant.maybe 1/100 of a sec.. zigbee u can still sense a bit of latency..
Yes aqara, most of the others are 110v unfortunately.. can always check out robbshop to see whats available beside vesternet..

Dear All,
2. However, I read on a local blog yingvannie.com that the casing requires modifications. How do you guys tackle this? Mod the casing like the blog suggested?

This is a good point, the MCO switch fit just nice into a well dug out wall recess with very little room for the thick wires to daisy chain.
Luckily for mine, the pattress in my wall were relatively clean so I only had to make sure the wires were tucked neatly before installing the switch. My corlicks BTO though need to dig out some of the concrete as the builder were very messy when they installed the pattress case. Inside has blobs of concrete blocking the MCO switches.
 
Last edited:

viix

Master Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
3,236
Reaction score
2
porker997 said:
7. Lastly, on safety. With the neutral wire activated etc, the switches are always powered on. Would that imply if need to change out a bulb, I need to power down the main box for safety?
porker

This point, take note. When u pull neutral to the switch from the light, there will be some current at that light point. if switching out a bulb, there should be no issue as the current is small but still present.

An example, when u put a voltmeter to the live and neutral when switch is off, there is 0V and 0A as the circuit is open. BUT, when u are on a ladder and grounded (not wearing rubber soled shoes) when u put a test pen to the neutral, there might be a faint light as the small current leaks to ground due to potential differences at that neutral to the ground. It's wont shock u like putting a finger onto a live wire, but u can feel it..
If u are insulated on a rubber mat or if your home flooring is not conductive, u wont see any current.
You might have it you might not have it depending on the earth and neutral differences at your place.
 
Last edited:

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
This point, take note. When u pull neutral to the switch from the light, there will be some current at that light point. if switching out a bulb, there should be no issue as the current is small but still present.

An example, when u put a voltmeter to the live and neutral when switch is off, there is 0V and 0A as the circuit is open. BUT, when u are on a ladder and grounded (not wearing rubber soled shoes) when u put a test pen to the neutral, there might be a faint light as the small current leaks to ground due to potential differences at that neutral to the ground. It's wont shock u like putting a finger onto a live wire, but u can feel it..
If u are insulated on a rubber mat or if your home flooring is not conductive, u wont see any current.
I think changing bulb is fine, since you don't touch the base which is where the electricity is.
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
BTW those considering Philips Hue system, I strongly recommend that you try out the LIFX bulbs instead. It's brighter from people who tested it.

 

porker997

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2007
Messages
59
Reaction score
0
Afternoon All,

Many thanks again for all the replies Vixx/Vulpix and other seniors here.

It looks like I need to figure some practical aspects of my HA journey:

1. Can MCO switches + casing suit my current wall? If not, how much modification work my contractor needs to do and corresponding charges to make those casings work. I suppose local mkt not big enough for MCO to create new casings for SG.

2. MCO dimmers not practical. I suppose I can just stick to MCO switches (bearing point 1) to simply on/off. Will get my smart lighting + mood via Hue bulbs or others. I am able to pair those smart bulbs with Alexa directly using the Hue Bridge + Homey.

3. I haven't explored broadlink offering yet. Seems to be wifi based.

4. LIFX seems interesting and shipping is from HK.

I will report back once I got a better roadmap and share my journey.

Cheers,
Porker
 
Last edited:

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
Afternoon All,

Many thanks again for all the replies Vixx/Vulpix and other seniors here.

It looks like I need to figure some practical aspects of my HA journey:

1. Can MCO switches + casing suit my current wall? If not, how much modification work my contractor needs to do and corresponding charges to make those casings work. I suppose local mkt not big enough for MCO to create new casings for SG.
TBH, I think this is very hard for any of us to answer as we are not the ones who installed for you, nor do we know what casing you using, nor the positioning on your wall. Best you ask h4h who are selling these.

4. LIFX seems interesting and shipping is from HK.
I am planning to go with LIFX for my home end of this year for some rooms including dining room. Not doing track lighting so it shouldn't be too costly.

I will report back once I got a better roadmap and share my journey.

Cheers,
Porker
Good luck with Homey. If you are the type who loves tinkering, might want to consider the cheaper and capable Hubitat. It's very powerful as long as you are willing to tinker a bit.
 

waterfoe

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2002
Messages
71
Reaction score
0
If you are in for an off the shelf solution you might want to check out C.Inhaus showroom in Woodlands.

The showroom does provide very comprehensive solution.

Afternoon All,

Many thanks again for all the replies Vixx/Vulpix and other seniors here.

It looks like I need to figure some practical aspects of my HA journey:

1. Can MCO switches + casing suit my current wall? If not, how much modification work my contractor needs to do and corresponding charges to make those casings work. I suppose local mkt not big enough for MCO to create new casings for SG.

2. MCO dimmers not practical. I suppose I can just stick to MCO switches (bearing point 1) to simply on/off. Will get my smart lighting + mood via Hue bulbs or others. I am able to pair those smart bulbs with Alexa directly using the Hue Bridge + Homey.

3. I haven't explored broadlink offering yet. Seems to be wifi based.

4. LIFX seems interesting and shipping is from HK.

I will report back once I got a better roadmap and share my journey.

Cheers,
Porker
 

plustwo

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2009
Messages
12,689
Reaction score
580
BTW those considering Philips Hue system, I strongly recommend that you try out the LIFX bulbs instead. It's brighter from people who tested it.

no yeelight? during sale can get 1 color bulb for $10+
 

viix

Master Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
3,236
Reaction score
2
Afternoon All,

Many thanks again for all the replies Vixx/Vulpix and other seniors here.

It looks like I need to figure some practical aspects of my HA journey:

1. Can MCO switches + casing suit my current wall? If not, how much modification work my contractor needs to do and corresponding charges to make those casings work. I suppose local mkt not big enough for MCO to create new casings for SG.

2. MCO dimmers not practical. I suppose I can just stick to MCO switches (bearing point 1) to simply on/off. Will get my smart lighting + mood via Hue bulbs or others. I am able to pair those smart bulbs with Alexa directly using the Hue Bridge + Homey.

3. I haven't explored broadlink offering yet. Seems to be wifi based.

4. LIFX seems interesting and shipping is from HK.

I will report back once I got a better roadmap and share my journey.

Cheers,
Porker

MCO should fit if the wiring inside has sufficient space to be push backed into the recess.. just check the pattress box when u get the keys. if not u might have to get 86mm pattress spacers but not sure if it's available locally from choo chiang..

yes broadlink is wifi to IR and RF.. homey lacks RF support for non kaku devices, so I still have a broadlink rmpro bridging homey - broadlink - RF fans and dooya curtains..

All the best on your HA journey!
 

zoneguard

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2000
Messages
1,957
Reaction score
398
A quick check at Ikea site: more stock has arrived for the various Tradfri bulbs at Tampines store and online. Cheaper alternative compared to Hue.
 

zoneguard

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2000
Messages
1,957
Reaction score
398
A 'Tuya' version of Shelly relay sold on Aliexpress. Works with GH/Alexa/IFTTT. Can find on Youtube a video demo of the product.

In theory, it should be flashable with Tasmota with Tuya Convert since it uses 'Smart Life' app.
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
Homey now supports direct google home control on the latest firmware!!! No need for Ok google, tell homey!

With the Google TTS App and an Alexa TTS app coming up, you can now use google home or alexa to broadcast from homey triggers too.
Superb news, now I definitely considering Homey as an alternative to Hubitat. But am I being too paranoid of Homey closing down, rendering the device useless? The Hubitat will still work even if Hubitat close down, but not the case for Homey.
 

porker997

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2007
Messages
59
Reaction score
0
Afternoon All,

The homey is indeed good news. Seal the deal!

Just had my second meeting with my ID. They plan on using LED lights and strips for the whole house anyway but cautioned on installing dimmers (which sometimes result in fickle lighting apparently). They are happy to pull neutral wires for all my switches, at a cost of course and they will plan some power points for motorized curtains. However, for the rest of HA, they didn't have much input and kinda left it to me to decide and drive...

Questions please:

1) I decided to limit smart lighting just to my study room for now to keep cost under control and a test bed for the project (my better half not convinced about spending $ on HA)
2) Assuming I go with Philips Hue lights there, all I need is the bulbs and the Philips hub right? I can just use the existing switches without changing them out etc.
3) I actually like the look of MCO switches. If I change my existing switches (in the study) out for them, I can use any kind of smart bulbs to connect with the MCO switches?
4) There are wifi ready MCO switches too, if I don't have the neutral wires pulled. What would be the pros and cons of that vs non-wifi MCO switches.

Again, many thanks in advance.

Cheers,
P
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
Afternoon All,

The homey is indeed good news. Seal the deal!

Just had my second meeting with my ID. They plan on using LED lights and strips for the whole house anyway but cautioned on installing dimmers (which sometimes result in fickle lighting apparently). They are happy to pull neutral wires for all my switches, at a cost of course and they will plan some power points for motorized curtains. However, for the rest of HA, they didn't have much input and kinda left it to me to decide and drive...

Questions please:

1) I decided to limit smart lighting just to my study room for now to keep cost under control and a test bed for the project (my better half not convinced about spending $ on HA)
2) Assuming I go with Philips Hue lights there, all I need is the bulbs and the Philips hub right? I can just use the existing switches without changing them out etc.
Yes that is correct. You can use existing switches, but just note that if you switch off power to the bulbs, the bulbs will not work.


3) I actually like the look of MCO switches. If I change my existing switches (in the study) out for them, I can use any kind of smart bulbs to connect with the MCO switches?

Yes, you can connect smart bulbs to those smart switches, but that sounds kinda pointless. You can control smart bulbs to go on and off without the smart switch. You use smart switch to control bulbs which are not smart bulbs.

4) There are wifi ready MCO switches too, if I don't have the neutral wires pulled. What would be the pros and cons of that vs non-wifi MCO switches.

You should consult the people you are buying those switches from. MCO Z-Wave switches usually require a hub, but if it's wifi type it is most likely the type that works without a hub but requires an app on your phone to work. You really need to find out which type fits your idea of a smarthome.

Again, many thanks in advance.

Cheers,
P
By the way I also don't recommend buying smart dimmer switches as they often require very specific bulb types to work. If you need dimmer functions, just buy a smart bulb, connect it to a dumb switch.
 
Last edited:

zoneguard

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2000
Messages
1,957
Reaction score
398

Summary of video:
1. Support sucks in UK.
2. Software/app sucks.
3. It's cheap!
4. The Missus love it! Cute wireless dimmer.
5. Compatible with Hue/HA/OpenHAB etc. Not IFTTT which is one of his complaints.
6. Cheap Ikea smart blinds are coming!

Personally I use just the hardware(cheap!) and never touch the software/apps as I use Zigbee2mqtt and HA to drive it so my experience is atypical compared to him and I don't use IFTTT since HA has local automation. I got on-board before Ikea SG brought in most of Tradfri bulbs anyway and they are one of the cheapest ones around for Zigbee Light Link, even Glepopto prices have been steadily rising.
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
Summary of video:
1. Support sucks in UK.
2. Software/app sucks.
3. It's cheap!
4. The Missus love it! Cute wireless dimmer.
5. Compatible with Hue/HA/OpenHAB etc. Not IFTTT which is one of his complaints.
6. Cheap Ikea smart blinds are coming!

Personally I use just the hardware(cheap!) and never touch the software/apps as I use Zigbee2mqtt and HA to drive it so my experience is atypical compared to him and I don't use IFTTT since HA has local automation. I got on-board before Ikea SG brought in most of Tradfri bulbs anyway and they are one of the cheapest ones around for Zigbee Light Link, even Glepopto prices have been steadily rising.
In my current smart home plan, I only planning to use some sort of smart bulb in my dining room and master bedroom. :s13: So far I'm very convinced LIFX bulbs are worth the dough from the reviews I've seen. Don't really see much value for cheap smart bulbs as I feel we're better off with a smart switch, and a good cheap bright bulb/lighting.
 

porker997

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2007
Messages
59
Reaction score
0
Appreciate the quick reply. I'm getting a better sense now of the lighting setup but now in a slight dilemma.

I'm also not sure which is a better approach?

a) smart bulb + dumb switch
b) smart switch + dumb bulbs
c) smart switch + smart bulb --> costly and redundant

I guess if I need dimming + moods + colors, I would need to go with option A or option C only?

What are you guys planning for lighting?

Cheers,
P
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top