[Official] Home Automation Thread

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
The whole ecosystem is being built up by the community and so far I am contented with it for my basic needs.

I am using a mix of zigbee and zwave products and all are supported:

  1. IKEA TRÅDFRI outlets (Zigbee)
  2. Samsung SmartThings outlets (Zigbee)
  3. TKB outlets (Zwave)
  4. Some zwave 2-gang switches (Zwave - cant recall the brand)
  5. Samsung Presence Sensor (Zigbee)
  6. Xiaomi Mijia button (Zigbee)

Drivers are developed either in-house or by the community. For Xiaomi zigbee products, it's community-developed with the core development/updates done for ST first before it's ported over to Hubitat. I have tested Xiaomi smoke sensor and it works fine, but I have yet to deploy it.

On a side note, I notice that Zwave performs better than zigbee, I suspect it's interference from my router.

My dashboard is still lacking, let me spend some time on it before i share it. :)
I really want to go z-wave, but I find their light switches simply too expensive and few choices. What is that tkb outlet in your list? You using their z-wave products? Can you also check what z-wave switch you are using for no. 4? Thanks.
 

gheesung

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2000
Messages
49
Reaction score
0
Nice work! It is an interesting way to present it as a floor plan. I designed mine as a more conventional dashboard style.

How do you handle iOS presence detection because it disconnects from the network when in sleep mode?

This is my humble HDB and the automation in it. It is my main tab in Home Assistant interface and provide an overview of the status of my devices.

- Person icons are motion sensor, square icons are door sensor and bulbs are either smart bulb or smart switch.
- Cast icons are my Google home devices, the one in living room is playing some music.
- Temperature and humidity sensors in each room and in the hall.
- The word "Docked" is where my roborock S5 is, it will clean when no one is around (more on this later).
- The snowman and umbrella icons are to indicate if there is holdiay for kids and parents. It is updated by fetching events from Google calendar.
- The bus icon is to show the arrival timings of a particular bus. It is obtained from LTA API.
- The bottom row is to show presence of each occupant, it is obtained from their phone connection to my router. Automation can be based on whether there is someone at home or not.
 

downtown2007

Junior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2007
Messages
50
Reaction score
0
anyone able to share their experience using Habitat and the range of Xiaomi sensor/switches they have used so far? Any issues or quirks?
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
anyone able to share their experience using Habitat and the range of Xiaomi sensor/switches they have used so far? Any issues or quirks?

You mean Hubitat right? I'm also considering this solution but ugh ZigBee is a pain in the arse as some of the brands tend to stick to their own ecosystem.
 

downtown2007

Junior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2007
Messages
50
Reaction score
0
You mean Hubitat right? I'm also considering this solution but ugh ZigBee is a pain in the arse as some of the brands tend to stick to their own ecosystem.

You mean even though xiaomi sensors are zigbee, its still considered closed ecosystem and cant work with hubitat?
 

downtown2007

Junior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2007
Messages
50
Reaction score
0
If I get xiaomi gateway instead as the hub, how many gateway do i need for my house? 1 enough or like router have to cover every room?
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
You mean even though xiaomi sensors are zigbee, its still considered closed ecosystem and cant work with hubitat?

No, it means even if a product is a ZigBee product, it won't work with generic ZigBee drivers if the manufacturer don't want to. Aqara switches are a great example as they don't comply with the ZigBee standards thus requiring custom drivers on both Homey and Hubitat.
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
If I get xiaomi gateway instead as the hub, how many gateway do i need for my house? 1 enough or like router have to cover every room?

Each ZigBee item acts like a repeater. You just need 1 gateway, but the Aqara gateway limit is 32 devices last I checked.
 

JackDulouz

Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2002
Messages
5,432
Reaction score
57
If I get xiaomi gateway instead as the hub, how many gateway do i need for my house? 1 enough or like router have to cover every room?

I got 2 for my house cos the last two water sensors unable to detect with just one gateway.. Btw I using one gateway and the Aqara Cam V2 with the built in gateway..
 

porker997

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2007
Messages
59
Reaction score
0
Impressive sharing here! Nice work.

I also want to explore motion sensor + light for:

1. bathroom (when I enter, the smart bulbs light up, extractor fan switches on but I don't want voice control here)
2. the corridor outside my main door. (a simple xiaomi battery light will do? bright enough?)

Cheers

An
 

downtown2007

Junior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2007
Messages
50
Reaction score
0
No, it means even if a product is a ZigBee product, it won't work with generic ZigBee drivers if the manufacturer don't want to. Aqara switches are a great example as they don't comply with the ZigBee standards thus requiring custom drivers on both Homey and Hubitat.

If using hubitat with the custom drivers for xiaomi sensors, can it still work with xiaomi dc smart fan?
 

yamashita

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Dec 23, 2000
Messages
9,676
Reaction score
51
I really want to go z-wave, but I find their light switches simply too expensive and few choices. What is that tkb outlet in your list? You using their z-wave products? Can you also check what z-wave switch you are using for no. 4? Thanks.

For TKB, I am using only the socket outlets. I bought it off Vesternet a few years ago and I recall it being expensive. It's the only zwave products I have from TKB. :)

For the light switches, I am using NEO Coolcam - the ones with the backlit.

All my zwave products are on EU frequency. Even though Singapore has moved to Korea frequency, I find that zwave products on Korea frequency are pretty rare to source for. The frequency is one disadvantage zwave has over zigbee.
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
For TKB, I am using only the socket outlets. I bought it off Vesternet a few years ago and I recall it being expensive. It's the only zwave products I have from TKB. :)

For the light switches, I am using NEO Coolcam - the ones with the backlit.

All my zwave products are on EU frequency. Even though Singapore has moved to Korea frequency, I find that zwave products on Korea frequency are pretty rare to source for. The frequency is one disadvantage zwave has over zigbee.

Omg. The prices of coolcam are exactly within my budget. How the heck did you even find this? Thanks a huge bunch!
 

pustefix

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2012
Messages
537
Reaction score
10
Nice work! It is an interesting way to present it as a floor plan. I designed mine as a more conventional dashboard style.

How do you handle iOS presence detection because it disconnects from the network when in sleep mode?

All our phones are Android so no such problem :) I find that using a floor plan is better as it gives an overview of all the devices. With automation rules, I don't really need to control each device, so an overall view is better for me.

Each ZigBee item acts like a repeater. You just need 1 gateway, but the Aqara gateway limit is 32 devices last I checked.

Not all Zigbee device is a repeater, usually only those that are plugged into power are repeater.

Impressive sharing here! Nice work.

I also want to explore motion sensor + light for:

1. bathroom (when I enter, the smart bulbs light up, extractor fan switches on but I don't want voice control here)
2. the corridor outside my main door. (a simple xiaomi battery light will do? bright enough?)

For the bathroom, you might want to add a door sensor. From my experience, having only a motion sensor is tricky because a lot of time there is no motion detected and the light will go off (e.g in the middle of a shower). With the door sensor, I don't turn off the light if there is no motion when the door is closed.

For the area near my main door, I have a motion sensor LED light bulb that is only 5W.
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
For the bathroom, you might want to add a door sensor. From my experience, having only a motion sensor is tricky because a lot of time there is no motion detected and the light will go off (e.g in the middle of a shower). With the door sensor, I don't turn off the light if there is no motion when the door is closed.

For the area near my main door, I have a motion sensor LED light bulb that is only 5W.
Actually do you have any good ideas for those door sensors? I was planning to have one at my main door to trigger my living room lights to switch on, and to also trigger when I leave the home, but I cannot come up with a good routine.
 

viix

Master Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
3,236
Reaction score
2
Actually do you have any good ideas for those door sensors? I was planning to have one at my main door to trigger my living room lights to switch on, and to also trigger when I leave the home, but I cannot come up with a good routine.

You mean to detect egress and ingress? You can try adding a motion sensor.. so if contact sensor is on and motion sensor is on, egress. If contact sensor on and motion sensor off ingress.. the motion sensor though should only look at a place where you'd be before you leave and not look at the door so the detection is more accurate, ie at the area behind the door for example.

I use to do this till I added a zwave module to my digital lock that can detect door direction opening to do speech greeting when I leave or come home.
 

viix

Master Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
3,236
Reaction score
2
On a side note, I notice that Zwave performs better than zigbee, I suspect it's interference from my router.

zwave is always going to be more responsive due to the lower freq band. Although zigbee has more bandwidth.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top