[Official] Home Automation Thread

pustefix

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2012
Messages
537
Reaction score
10
Anyone feel Amazon Echo is better than Google Home?

The consensus from what I've read online is Google response to query better and has better integration with Google services (big surprise!). Amazon has more skills, is easier to wake up (Alexa vs OK Google) and better integration with Amazon!
 

ksapple

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2012
Messages
27,532
Reaction score
4,897
I prefer alexa since can control my xiao mi lol~

Anyone tried harmony on KDK fan ??
 

zoneguard

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2000
Messages
1,957
Reaction score
398
The consensus from what I've read online is Google response to query better and has better integration with Google services (big surprise!). Amazon has more skills, is easier to wake up (Alexa vs OK Google) and better integration with Amazon!

Just a thought, since Google Home exposes Bluetooth A2DP sink aka it acts as a Bluetooth speaker, if you pair Echo Input with a Google Home Mini, you get the best of both worlds! Start with "Alexa" and the GHM will act like Alexa and start with "Hey Google", it will revert back to its Google personality...
Caveat: I haven't actually tried it myself yet...
 

medscy

Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2006
Messages
497
Reaction score
5
Anyone feel Amazon Echo is better than Google Home?

I using both at my home, but finds Echo responds/ uds me better than Google leh.
Thou the fun thing is Google can speak Singlish.
I also have an Echo dot and GH mini. I prefer GH mini anytime to Echo Dot. GH understands what I say better compared to Echo probably due to my non Ang Mo accent. No I don't speak Singlish to GH :p but it sure understands local context better. It is true that Echo has more skills than GH. But more importantly, are the skills useful? For me, I think the GH HA actions are sufficient and GH has better search capabilities due to the better backend search engine. Another advantage is that it allows connection to Spotify on a free account.

The only downside I can think of for GH mini is that it does not have the physical audio output that I can link up to a better speaker unlike Echo Dot.
 

gmt2102

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 25, 2019
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Connecting 3 wire motor blind to 4 wire wifi switch

Anyone has any instructions on how to connect a 3-wire motor blind to a 4-wire wifi smart switch?

The motor blind has a separate 3-core power cable from the 3-wire control wiring.

Currently I have been given a simple up-stop-down manual switch.

Thanks.
 

Revealed

Banned
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
68
Reaction score
0
I think for safety, better don't .

Anyone has any instructions on how to connect a 3-wire motor blind to a 4-wire wifi smart switch?

The motor blind has a separate 3-core power cable from the 3-wire control wiring.

Currently I have been given a simple up-stop-down manual switch.

Thanks.
 

kpo kia

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2019
Messages
16
Reaction score
0
I came across something interesting yesterday.. I was shopping with my wife yesterday at Orchard Centrepoint after dinner and walked past an aircon shop that had a cute doll house.

Thought of getting something similar for my daughter. Then the sales told me that it was a smart home solution by daikin. Does everyone know of it? Trying to find more details online.. but I think i may go back to check it out again.
 

kpo kia

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2019
Messages
16
Reaction score
0
For fibaro, I think it can start from 1k and then depends on how elaborate you want it to be. For my house, I quite a number of things. Other than lights and curtains, I also have like motion sensors and rain sensors. About 6k to set them up.

But so far it's good and quite secure and my wife is quite happy with the convenience so I guess it's good.
Can share quote
 

zoneguard

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2000
Messages
1,957
Reaction score
398
Got a Ikea Tradfri dimmer to pair with zigbee2mqtt.

Ikea Singapore's Tradfri product range is very strange:
1. They don't carry the Tradfri gateway. So presumably customers all have to use Hue bridge? Why?
2. Only carry Tradfri LED drivers and the dimmer and remote control. So customers need to buy OMLOPP and NORRFLY to use the drivers??
3. No Tradfri bulbs sold here.

Nevertheless Tradfri is still cheaper than Hue equivalent here.
 

wahjohreno

Master Member
Joined
May 15, 2017
Messages
3,382
Reaction score
216
Anyone feel Amazon Echo is better than Google Home?

I using both at my home, but finds Echo responds/ uds me better than Google leh.
Thou the fun thing is Google can speak Singlish.
I have both. 1 google home and 9 echos. From the numbers, you can see which I like more for home automation.

Google is great for asking detailed questions, not that echo is so bad.

But these devices to me are mostly for controlling devices by voice. Just the trigger words alone, “Alexa” vs “hey google”, you can already foresee which one is going to be much more pleasant to use if you’re going to say the trigger words many times a day. You may think it’s a stupid matter, but it is for me a deal breaker. “Alexa” simply rolls off the tongue like butter. The double “g”’s if google drives me up the wall if I say it 50 times a day.

Amazon is more established at this game. So whatever skills google has, amazon has too. But not everything amazon has, google has.

Amazon is built into certain sonos products as well. Google is said to be “coming soon”. But it’s already behind.

All in all, from my experience of home automation via fibaro/WiFi devices, I would always choose to use echo over google.

The only time I’d use google home is for fun. Even when I need detailed info, I’d rather just google it on my phone.
 

plustwo

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2009
Messages
12,689
Reaction score
580
I have both. 1 google home and 9 echos. From the numbers, you can see which I like more for home automation.

Google is great for asking detailed questions, not that echo is so bad.

But these devices to me are mostly for controlling devices by voice. Just the trigger words alone, “Alexa” vs “hey google”, you can already foresee which one is going to be much more pleasant to use if you’re going to say the trigger words many times a day. You may think it’s a stupid matter, but it is for me a deal breaker. “Alexa” simply rolls off the tongue like butter. The double “g”’s if google drives me up the wall if I say it 50 times a day.

Amazon is more established at this game. So whatever skills google has, amazon has too. But not everything amazon has, google has.

Amazon is built into certain sonos products as well. Google is said to be “coming soon”. But it’s already behind.

All in all, from my experience of home automation via fibaro/WiFi devices, I would always choose to use echo over google.

The only time I’d use google home is for fun. Even when I need detailed info, I’d rather just google it on my phone.
alexa and hey google both 3 syllable words though
 

pustefix

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2012
Messages
537
Reaction score
10
Got a Ikea Tradfri dimmer to pair with zigbee2mqtt.

Ikea Singapore's Tradfri product range is very strange:
1. They don't carry the Tradfri gateway. So presumably customers all have to use Hue bridge? Why?
2. Only carry Tradfri LED drivers and the dimmer and remote control. So customers need to buy OMLOPP and NORRFLY to use the drivers??
3. No Tradfri bulbs sold here.

Nevertheless Tradfri is still cheaper than Hue equivalent here.

Yeah, I think the Ikea Tradfri range in Singapore is strange too. They have the dimmer but no bulb at all. The dimmer can work with the bulb directly (using Zigbee), there is no need of the hub. The staff told me that she has no idea when the bulbs will be coming.
 
Last edited:

wahjohreno

Master Member
Joined
May 15, 2017
Messages
3,382
Reaction score
216
alexa and hey google both 3 syllable words though

Not about how many syllables. It’s about “g” and “gle” being far more of a chore to say.

In any case, echos respond to “Lexa” as well. Which is what I have ended up using.
 

Revealed

Banned
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
68
Reaction score
0
Finally got to upload the video properly.

This is how I have set up my bedroom home automaton. When I call for movie mode, the curtain closes, the apple TV switches on, the projector switches on, the projector screen lowers down, and the ceiling speakers switches on.

I used Fibaro with TP smart plug and Google home mini.


 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top