[Official] Home Automation Thread

MaxLeung

Master Member
Joined
Apr 11, 2003
Messages
2,797
Reaction score
0
They will protrude yes. My previous HDB home had to run exposed wire trunking so those surface mount were perfect for those.

Those faceplates are for USA and Australia regular styled switches. The TP link and Wemo switches are designed for use in those countries.

There is no one sized fits all as our switches are sized and designed a little differently. My current home are using Aqara smart switches which are sized for our use.

Posted from PCWX using Me dic stinks

Thanks once again. Are you restricted to using MiHome since you are using Aqara smart switches? I was thinking of using TP Link wall plugs too together with Philip Hue lights via Google Home or Alexa.

Able to share your setup?
 

bullfrog

Banned
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
18,188
Reaction score
1,152
Thanks once again. Are you restricted to using MiHome since you are using Aqara smart switches? I was thinking of using TP Link wall plugs too together with Philip Hue lights via Google Home or Alexa.

Able to share your setup?

All my Aqara switches and curtain motor connect to a xiaomi gateway. I'm running Home Assistant on a Raspberry Pi that interfaces with the xiaomi gateway. I have the HomeAssistant alexa skill installed so all my alexas can control my light switches and curtains.

Posted from PCWX using Me dic stinks
 

zoneguard

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2000
Messages
1,957
Reaction score
398
Some stock has come in at Ikea for the Tradfri gateway and dimming kit (warm white bulb and dimmer). Most of the Tradfri LED bulbs are out of stock though.

Sidenote: rooted my Xiaomi Mi robot vacuum (Gen1) with Valetudo as MQTT vacuum in HA without using the Mi Home app at all. From Day 1, I didn't connect it to Xiaomi cloud.

Integrated the Valetudo map via MQTT to HA and added GH/Alexa voice commands for zoned cleaning. Will look at the Lovelace Vacuum cleaner card next.
 
Last edited:

pustefix

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2012
Messages
537
Reaction score
10
this stick need to plug into some type of pc right? means need 2xpi extra at least?

Yes, you need to plug into another host. At least for HA user, the stick can be plugged into the pi that is running HA, so no additional hardware.
 

krazyhippo

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 1, 2004
Messages
675
Reaction score
150
Hi guys, I am rookie. I can link my Google home app to my mi home but I don't seems to be able to do anything
 

porker997

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2007
Messages
59
Reaction score
0
Understanding lighting

Dear All,

Been reading this thread (from 2018) to try to learn more about HA. Total noob.

My renovation will be starting in June and I'm trying to work on this issue with my ID/contractor. They seem to leave this topic to me to drive and I guess they will execute only, so I need to understand the basics of HA so I can advise them accordingly.

My queries relate to lighting. I have the following questions please:

1. I understand that having a neutral wire for switches is the way to go, at least in future proofing the house. And broadly speaking, it is better to install smart switches now than smart bulbs to achieve flexibility etc.

2. It seems that MCO switches come recommended and they look nice. However, I read on a local blog yingvannie.com that the casing requires modifications. How do you guys tackle this? Mod the casing like the blog suggested?

3. Besides MCO switches, are there any other compatible brands that look nice I could compare with?

4. If want to lights that can dim (bright/soft tone), can the MCO switches handle it? My current home has the simple traditional knobs besides the old style switches to control. How is this achieved? (e.g. can Alexa handle"turn lights down to 50%"?)

5. I am considering pairing the MCO switching with Philips Hue Lighting. Would that work well?

6. Also, it seems to me, most smart bulbs are not LED type. I prefer to go all LED in my home. If that is the case, would having a smart switch like the MCO able to control the LED lighting, like a normal bulb?

7. Lastly, on safety. With the neutral wire activated etc, the switches are always powered on. Would that imply if need to change out a bulb, I need to power down the main box for safety?

Apologise for the noob questions but I am really trying to connect the points (haha)

Many thanks in advance.

Cheers,
porker
 

MaxLeung

Master Member
Joined
Apr 11, 2003
Messages
2,797
Reaction score
0
May I know any bros have used Xiaoyan before? Any feedback? I saw the smart switch available with 4 buttons and look pretty good aesthetically too. No neutral wire required. Xiaoyan also has curtain motors available too. Will it be ok to pair with TP link wifi plugs and Alexa for home automation?
 

zoneguard

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2000
Messages
1,957
Reaction score
398
3. Besides MCO switches, are there any other compatible brands that look nice I could compare with?

MCO is Z-wave where Hue is Zigbee. You are aware you need a hub that supports multiple protocols? Either get a hub (Smartthings , Hubitat ) or go DIY route with HA/OpenHAB.

4. If want to lights that can dim (bright/soft tone), can the MCO switches handle it? My current home has the simple traditional knobs besides the old style switches to control. How is this achieved? (e.g. can Alexa handle"turn lights down to 50%"?)
Yes, if the hub/platform supports Alexa/GoogleHome. I understand MCO has a dimmer panel.

5. I am considering pairing the MCO switching with Philips Hue Lighting. Would that work well?
You can consider Ikea Tradfri as Ikea SG is releasing some Tradfri products - some items are available already.

6. Also, it seems to me, most smart bulbs are not LED type. I prefer to go all LED in my home. If that is the case, would having a smart switch like the MCO able to control the LED lighting, like a normal bulb?
Huh? Most smart bulbs are LED.

7. Lastly, on safety. With the neutral wire activated etc, the switches are always powered on. Would that imply if need to change out a bulb, I need to power down the main box for safety?
Should always turn off current at the circuit breaker when dealing with mains electricity.
 

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
Dear All,

Been reading this thread (from 2018) to try to learn more about HA. Total noob.

My renovation will be starting in June and I'm trying to work on this issue with my ID/contractor. They seem to leave this topic to me to drive and I guess they will execute only, so I need to understand the basics of HA so I can advise them accordingly.

My queries relate to lighting. I have the following questions please:

1. I understand that having a neutral wire for switches is the way to go, at least in future proofing the house. And broadly speaking, it is better to install smart switches now than smart bulbs to achieve flexibility etc.

Yes, because in the end replacing a generic light bulb is far cheaper than replacing a smart bulb, assuming you do not require a lot of special lighting options. If you need fancy colours and dimming options, better to get smart bulb.

2. It seems that MCO switches come recommended and they look nice. However, I read on a local blog yingvannie.com that the casing requires modifications. How do you guys tackle this? Mod the casing like the blog suggested?

3. Besides MCO switches, are there any other compatible brands that look nice I could compare with?
Are you looking at MCO because you want Z-Wave or what?

4. If want to lights that can dim (bright/soft tone), can the MCO switches handle it? My current home has the simple traditional knobs besides the old style switches to control. How is this achieved? (e.g. can Alexa handle"turn lights down to 50%"?)

You need to buy a specific light switch with dimming function. Here's a link.

5. I am considering pairing the MCO switching with Philips Hue Lighting. Would that work well?

Sure it will work, but you will be spending double the price for that.

6. Also, it seems to me, most smart bulbs are not LED type. I prefer to go all LED in my home. If that is the case, would having a smart switch like the MCO able to control the LED lighting, like a normal bulb?

I am pretty sure smart bulbs are mostly LEDs. Can you link one that isn't?

7. Lastly, on safety. With the neutral wire activated etc, the switches are always powered on. Would that imply if need to change out a bulb, I need to power down the main box for safety?

You just need to switch off the power for the light, there is no current running through if the light switch is working properly.

Apologise for the noob questions but I am really trying to connect the points (haha)

Many thanks in advance.

Cheers,
porker
I replied in red, all opinions are my own, I'm no expert but this is my understanding so far. Anyone wants to correct me please feel free.
 

waterfoe

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2002
Messages
71
Reaction score
0
Dear All,

Been reading this thread (from 2018) to try to learn more about HA. Total noob.

My renovation will be starting in June and I'm trying to work on this issue with my ID/contractor. They seem to leave this topic to me to drive and I guess they will execute only, so I need to understand the basics of HA so I can advise them accordingly.

My queries relate to lighting. I have the following questions please:

1. I understand that having a neutral wire for switches is the way to go, at least in future proofing the house. And broadly speaking, it is better to install smart switches now than smart bulbs to achieve flexibility etc.

It better to run a neutral wire so that in future if you feel like changing to another system, the infrastructure is already in place

2. It seems that MCO switches come recommended and they look nice. However, I read on a local blog yingvannie.com that the casing requires modifications. How do you guys tackle this? Mod the casing like the blog suggested?

This will depend on the experience of the electrician you working with. An experienced electrician that dealt with home automation project before will have no major issues

3. Besides MCO switches, are there any other compatible brands that look nice I could compare with?

There are many in the market, it depend on the kind of budget you have actually. Well known brand like Jung, Control4, Lutron..... and many many more

4. If want to lights that can dim (bright/soft tone), can the MCO switches handle it? My current home has the simple traditional knobs besides the old style switches to control. How is this achieved? (e.g. can Alexa handle"turn lights down to 50%"?)

There is a dimmable module from MCO Home, however not sure if you notice the dimmable module from MCO home only can connect to 1 dimmable load. For example if your living room has 3 to 4 dimmable circuits, you will need to have 3 of the module at the wall..... In term of design, is it going to be something you can accept?

5. I am considering pairing the MCO switching with Philips Hue Lighting. Would that work well?

of course you can, but is there any particular reason you need to do that?

6. Also, it seems to me, most smart bulbs are not LED type. I prefer to go all LED in my home. If that is the case, would having a smart switch like the MCO able to control the LED lighting, like a normal bulb?

Nowadays most bulb are LED.....

7. Lastly, on safety. With the neutral wire activated etc, the switches are always powered on. Would that imply if need to change out a bulb, I need to power down the main box for safety?

Basically the neutral wire at the switch area is to provide constant power to the switch only. Inside the switch there is another relay that control the lighting circuits

You might want to go check out some of the vendors in Singapore so that they can better advice you. You also need to ask yourself are you more of a hand on person or do u prefer to let someone handle everything for you and just enjoy the end product.

Apologise for the noob questions but I am really trying to connect the points (haha)

Many thanks in advance.

Cheers,
porker
 

Elon Jobs

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2018
Messages
2,434
Reaction score
1,261
7XWonoJ.jpg
JfLSuXr.jpg

I finally had the time to head down in person to take a look this afternoon. Really nice place, well furnished, just like an Apple Store, just that the products don’t cost an arm and a leg. All the Broadlink home automation products plus GHM and AED etc are all on display. There are some other brands too like Funry etc.

The new and interesting stuff are the Broadlink Smart Curtains and a smart rubbish bin! Really got to see it to believe it. Most importantly, the staff there were super knowledgeable and never anyhow upsell me.

Anyway, I know it’s not the most accessible, but there’s free parking and shuttle bus for those who don’t drive, plus if it’s at a mall or what overheads will be high and the costs will be inevitably passed down to us.

Broadlink Experience Centre
186, Woodlands Industrial Park E5, #04-01F, 757515
https://goo.gl/maps/i9ZifeRKBFaVTtqn6

Personally, I feel it’s a great place to get a feel of the products and visualise how your future smart home is going to be. It’s like test driving a car before you buy it. More importantly, I think it would be the perfect place to convince your wives who will definitely have doubts and suspicion about the usefulness of smart home automation! 😊

I will upload some better looking photos later, my old iPhone SE camera really doesn’t do the place justice.
 

Elon Jobs

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2018
Messages
2,434
Reaction score
1,261
7XWonoJ.jpg
JfLSuXr.jpg

I finally had the time to head down in person to take a look this afternoon. Really nice place, well furnished, just like an Apple Store, just that the products don’t cost an arm and a leg. All the Broadlink home automation products plus GHM and AED etc are all on display. There are some other brands too like Funry etc.

The new and interesting stuff are the Broadlink Smart Curtains and a smart rubbish bin! Really got to see it to believe it. Most importantly, the staff there were super knowledgeable and never anyhow upsell me.

Anyway, I know it’s not the most accessible, but there’s free parking and shuttle bus for those who don’t drive, plus if it’s at a mall or what overheads will be high and the costs will be inevitably passed down to us.

Broadlink Experience Centre
186, Woodlands Industrial Park E5, #04-01F, 757515
https://goo.gl/maps/i9ZifeRKBFaVTtqn6

Personally, I feel it’s a great place to get a feel of the products and visualise how your future smart home is going to be. It’s like test driving a car before you buy it. More importantly, I think it would be the perfect place to convince your wives who will definitely have doubts and suspicion about the usefulness of smart home automation! 😊

I will upload some better looking photos later, my old iPhone SE camera really doesn’t do the place justice.

A9tA3gR.jpg

Suwp6OI.jpg

WPtPr0N.jpg

XUtDLDB.jpg
 

punkster

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2004
Messages
1,669
Reaction score
3
Can I ask for those that change the wall sockets to the international type, where do u buy the sockets? I saw those no brand one from Lazada and taobao selling for < $10 while the local shops selling at > $50 but they have the safety mark logo.

Is the safety mark worth the price? My current place I use a lot of China adapters and chargers also so I'm just wondering if there really is a risk?
 

porker997

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2007
Messages
59
Reaction score
0
Evening All,

Many thanks to those who replied my noob queries. Appreciate it. I will reply in general as best as I can.

For one, I have been doing more reading over the weekend and picked up quite a bit more knowledge.

For starters, most bulbs are using LEDs these days! haha

1) For Philips Hue system, I understand it requires their Philips Bridge to work.

2) Vulpix: It seems like the Philips hue system is redundant based on your advice, if I am going with MCO switches i.e. I can use any type of bulbs which are cheaper than Philips Hue I like since the magic happens with the MCO switches?

3) I picked up quite a bit of information from H4SH website, the official distributor of MCO switches, they seem to have the popular selection of other smart items for sale and a useful beginner's blog, at least for me. I can buy locally without incurring UK shipment e.g. Vesternet.

3*) Good point on the need of multiple dimmer modules for MCO, didn't know that. No, doesn't pass my design needs. May need to speak to someone on this, perhaps those guys selling it.

4) I read another bro said there are quite a few brands out there besides MCO, so I will do more desktop research. For now, they are aesthetically pleasing, at least to me.

5) Yes I plan to get a hub to put everything together. Homey seems popular and very versatile? The only issue is that it seems I need to tell Alexa or GH to "tell Homey to switch on the lights". Not as efficient or slick. Apparently, this will be fixed in the future, not sure.

6) As for protocol, I dont know enough to choose z-wave or others, so ideally, I will go with a hub with the widest range of acceptance. Does that make sense?

Again, many thanks to all.

Cheers,
Porker
 

lamtw22

Member
Joined
Mar 16, 2007
Messages
337
Reaction score
0
Can anyone confirm that if your devices are setup in Mi Home App on China server, you can still integrate with Google Home using voice command?
 

viix

Master Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
3,236
Reaction score
2
Can I ask for those that change the wall sockets to the international type, where do u buy the sockets? I saw those no brand one from Lazada and taobao selling for < $10 while the local shops selling at > $50 but they have the safety mark logo.

Is the safety mark worth the price? My current place I use a lot of China adapters and chargers also so I'm just wondering if there really is a risk?

Choo chiang has the international socket. I changed some of mine to those. I think under 20 or 30 each.. most of your china devices, if using wires, just re-terminate it to a UK plug. I do these for all my devices as it fits more securely in the socket for safety.

Evening All,

Many thanks to those who replied my noob queries. Appreciate it. I will reply in general as best as I can.

For one, I have been doing more reading over the weekend and picked up quite a bit more knowledge.

For starters, most bulbs are using LEDs these days! haha

1) For Philips Hue system, I understand it requires their Philips Bridge to work.

2) Vulpix: It seems like the Philips hue system is redundant based on your advice, if I am going with MCO switches i.e. I can use any type of bulbs which are cheaper than Philips Hue I like since the magic happens with the MCO switches?

3) I picked up quite a bit of information from H4SH website, the official distributor of MCO switches, they seem to have the popular selection of other smart items for sale and a useful beginner's blog, at least for me. I can buy locally without incurring UK shipment e.g. Vesternet.

3*) Good point on the need of multiple dimmer modules for MCO, didn't know that. No, doesn't pass my design needs. May need to speak to someone on this, perhaps those guys selling it.

4) I read another bro said there are quite a few brands out there besides MCO, so I will do more desktop research. For now, they are aesthetically pleasing, at least to me.

5) Yes I plan to get a hub to put everything together. Homey seems popular and very versatile? The only issue is that it seems I need to tell Alexa or GH to "tell Homey to switch on the lights". Not as efficient or slick. Apparently, this will be fixed in the future, not sure.

6) As for protocol, I dont know enough to choose z-wave or others, so ideally, I will go with a hub with the widest range of acceptance. Does that make sense?

Again, many thanks to all.

Cheers,
Porker

1) For Philips Hue system, I understand it requires their Philips Bridge to work.
Yes and No, for hue lights, u can pair with their dimmer switch only but u will not be able to use the app or integrate it with a home automation or IFTTT for example. U are also limited to just adjusting between warm and cool whites + brightness.

A bridge is better as u can set scenes and color.
For me, Im using philips hue and also 3rd party zigbee light link downlights like the Zemismart and Gledopto lightstrips.


2) Vulpix: It seems like the Philips hue system is redundant based on your advice, if I am going with MCO switches i.e. I can use any type of bulbs which are cheaper than Philips Hue I like since the magic happens with the MCO switches?

MCO, u control the light to on and off.. thats it. Hue, u can dim and set scenes. I use both because the seniors in my house prefer a physical button that is a straight forward or or off.
I dont touch the switches since I use sensors to dim on the lights and scenes.
For your case, since u prefer dimming, I rather u spend it via a smart bulb to dim than on an Dimmable MCO switch, bacause if u use dimmable switches like the MCO, u need to ensure the bulb is dimmable and compatible to MCO's dimmer. Some LED drivers requires forward phase some reverse. Finding compatible ones is a headache.. Usually dimmers are more for incandescent lights. I have 2 that are unused. waste of money IMHO.



3*) Good point on the need of multiple dimmer modules for MCO, didn't know that. No, doesn't pass my design needs. May need to speak to someone on this, perhaps those guys selling it.

See above, finding dimmable led lights than dim at the switch is not worth it. Dimmable leds are more ex than philips hue.. unless using incandescent lights.

4) I read another bro said there are quite a few brands out there besides MCO, so I will do more desktop research. For now, they are aesthetically pleasing, at least to me.

Zwave wise, MCO has local support if the switch dies.. and i believe it's the nicest..
If going for zigbee or other types, there are other brands though I dont have any recommendation.


5) Yes I plan to get a hub to put everything together. Homey seems popular and very versatile? The only issue is that it seems I need to tell Alexa or GH to "tell Homey to switch on the lights". Not as efficient or slick. Apparently, this will be fixed in the future, not sure.

Alexa no need to tell homey. It's transparent to alexa now. Google home still a work in progress. The good thing about homey is I can set Homey to annouce to Google and Alexa (using the TTS app) so when I use Homey to poll AQICN and SG weather, it can announce the weather to me. It also tells me if my door is left open too long (fridge and main door has contact sensors that tell me if someone never close the main door or shut the fridge door properly for example)
It can also greet me and say goodbye when I leave (done via samsung lock as it can tell which direction door is open to determine I'm ingressing or egressing.

6) As for protocol, I dont know enough to choose z-wave or others, so ideally, I will go with a hub with the widest range of acceptance. Does that make sense?

If going for Homey, reminder that RF has limited app support. I'm still using a broadlink to bridge that (via the homey broadlink app) to control my RF fans and using RM Mini to make my own ambiclimate (automating via temp sensors and presence detection to lower or increase the AC for comfort via flows..)

IMHO, Zwave has faster response than zigbee and RF.. since I have used all 3 before. I use neocoolcam sensors for place I need fast reaction and aqara sensor for places that don't
 
Last edited:

Vulpix

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
105,337
Reaction score
3,864
Evening All,

Many thanks to those who replied my noob queries. Appreciate it. I will reply in general as best as I can.

For one, I have been doing more reading over the weekend and picked up quite a bit more knowledge.

For starters, most bulbs are using LEDs these days! haha

1) For Philips Hue system, I understand it requires their Philips Bridge to work.

2) Vulpix: It seems like the Philips hue system is redundant based on your advice, if I am going with MCO switches i.e. I can use any type of bulbs which are cheaper than Philips Hue I like since the magic happens with the MCO switches?
Yes that is correct. But just remember these switches need to be the more expensive dimmer type, and likely you can't change colours.

3) I picked up quite a bit of information from H4SH website, the official distributor of MCO switches, they seem to have the popular selection of other smart items for sale and a useful beginner's blog, at least for me. I can buy locally without incurring UK shipment e.g. Vesternet.
H4SH is very expensive though lol. I am considering TKB switches as they are way cheaper for Z-Wave.

3*) Good point on the need of multiple dimmer modules for MCO, didn't know that. No, doesn't pass my design needs. May need to speak to someone on this, perhaps those guys selling it.

4) I read another bro said there are quite a few brands out there besides MCO, so I will do more desktop research. For now, they are aesthetically pleasing, at least to me.

5) Yes I plan to get a hub to put everything together. Homey seems popular and very versatile? The only issue is that it seems I need to tell Alexa or GH to "tell Homey to switch on the lights". Not as efficient or slick. Apparently, this will be fixed in the future, not sure.
Usually, you need a hub only if you are trying to control Z-Wave or Zigbee stuff. If you decide to go Wifi devices like the popular Broadlink, then usually a hub is not needed.

As for Homey? I would not purchase it until it fully works with Google Home without the "tell homey".


6) As for protocol, I dont know enough to choose z-wave or others, so ideally, I will go with a hub with the widest range of acceptance. Does that make sense?
I suggest you read up more on Z-Wave and Zigbee first. Z-wave is pretty good if you are willing to spend the money. Wifi is also a good option if you don't need any complicated procedures.

Again, many thanks to all.

Cheers,
Porker
I replied with what I know. Good luck on your journey.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top