*Official* Shiny Things club - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

chenghui

Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2007
Messages
168
Reaction score
3
If you're investing $1k a month anyway, then "Stanchart for local stocks, IBKR for global stocks" is the right choice. Go for it.

Hi Shiny Things, thanks for the reply. I would like to clarify this: for the $1k/mth here, are you referring to total investment amount for local and global stocks to be $1k/mth or $1k/mth each for local and global stocks?

If i follow the 40% allocation for global stocks, which works out to SGD$400/mth. With the IBKR's USD$10 commission per month, wouldn't that take up about 3.45% of SGD$400 for the global stocks? This seems to goes against the 0.3% for overseas stock trading.
 

crystalnox

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2006
Messages
8,625
Reaction score
2,222
can explain why ETF is better than buying company discount?

Is the yield better?
Spreading risk/diversification. The odds of your company going bankrupt/stock price crashing is much higher than a whole bunch of stocks going bankrupt all at once.


But do still take advantage of that company discount on your stocks, but get them off your hands asap.
 

ChinoGirl

Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2005
Messages
238
Reaction score
0
***Sorry,not sure how do i post a reply,so i had copied and pasted my original post and tangent314's comments (thanks for replying to my post!).

My replies:
1) Aviva Global Savings account (the one with Blackrock funds)- My friend informed me that the surrender value +penalty is currently SGD20,130.92.

Total losses around SGD 6100
He said there is an option for premium holiday for up to 5 years and asked me to consider that instead. :s8:

2)Thanks. Will redeem all holdings from cash account since there is no penalty.

3) Yes, an expensive lesson learnt.

4) Ok, I plan to redeem my CPF-OA investments and leave it to accrue the 2.5%. I have a housing loan of SGD320,000 with my spouse, so it will make up part of the monies.

ChinoGirl wrote:
I am 38 years old and not a DIY investor and has always left my investments to my friend. But I realise that my portfolio isn't going anywhere, and it is better to be hands-on for your own financial future. I need advice from members and understand that the final decision is up to myself. Time for some spring cleaning!
Welcome!

Quote:
1) Aviva Global Savings Account

- inception date is 20 Sepember 2010

- payment frequency is SGD250/month

- funds are since inception of account are BlackRock Global Funds - Latin American A2 Fund US, and BlackRock Global Funds - World Gold A2 Fund USD

- premium end date is 20 September 2035

- As of 29 May 2019, the total premiums paid is SGD26,250.00 and investment value is sgd21,213.8. I have asked my friend to let me know how much I will get back if I liquidate this account as there will be penalty charges =(

Questions:

1a) Should I surrender this account entirely? Or switch it to other funds offered under Aviva Global Savings? I do not mind lower returns (is 1% too much to ask for?but it does not beat inflation) less fund management fees etc.

1b) If the suggestion is to switch to other funds on offer under Aviva Global Savings Account, what would be your suggestions and the reason(s) for the selected funds (for my understanding and learning).
A quick look at this plan and I can only say ouch at the fees. I'm inclined to say that you should surrender it as soon as you can - but let's take a look at the surrender fees first.




Quote:
2) Aviva Navigator cash account

-inception date is 30 Dec 2008

-was in growth portfolio until mid of last year when I asked to switch to Balanced portfolio

- am not charged an advisory fee/wrap fee by my friend, but believe there may be a platform fee incurred for using the Aviva Navigator platform, and of course the usual fund management fees etc which are also gnawing at my returns.

- initial lump sum of cash investment was SGD28,000 and the current value is at SGD39,700. No further contribution.

-no penalty for terminating account
This would be an easy since there's no penalty, just redeem everything.



Quote:
3) CPF-SA

- I have terminated the investments last year with a loss of SGD854.20 (15.12%). Had some greens but after that it was red for as long as I can recall. Seeing that the past few years has been a bull run………

Using CPFIS-SA is almost always a mistake. Redeem this as soon as possible. You are going to need some bonds in your portfolio and SA is arguably the best 'bond' to be counted as part of your portfolio.


Quote:
4) CPF-OA

- current value as of 29 May 2019 is 23,742.07, with a loss of -7.14%. Had some greens but after that it was red for as long as I can recall. Thinking of terminating this too.

-was in growth portfolio until mid of last year when I asked to switch to Balanced portfolio.

Appreciate it if you could advise this newbie. Thank you very much! Have a lot to learn.
Ideally, redeem your CPFIS-OA, but you want to plan what to do with them, depending on whether you will need your OA for future housing. If you don't plan to use your OA, then it would make sense to transfer your OA to SA. If you are planning to keep it for housing, you should keep it around. Otherwise, you can choose to keep it around for the 2.5% interest, or use some with CPFIS-OA to purchase ES3.
 

tangent314

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jul 26, 2002
Messages
5,136
Reaction score
228
1) Which are the brokers I should use? (Assuming 6 figure sum over the next 6mths to a year)
a) Global Stock (IWDA): Will go with IBKR as recommended
b) Singapore Stock (ES3): Should I invest from SCB-Priority or DBS-Treasures
c) Total Bonds (MBH): Should I invest from SCB-Priority or DBS-Treasures

* Seems like DBS treasure is only charging 0.12% for their online equity trading?
https://www.dbs.com.sg/treasures/pricing-guide.page#equities

Go with the cheaper one I guess, but if they are similar, I would prefer DBS for the CDP custodian.

2) SRS
- Should I sell the 2 unit trust I bought? [Aberdeen Eur Opp & Uni Inc FC D(H)]
- Will there could be different broker fees for ES3 & MBH due to investing from SRS? (e.g. with SCB-Priority or DBS-Treasures?)
- What will be the recommended action for SRS funds to minimize charges (e.g. Lion Global with Poem?)

SCB does not support SRS afaik, so you have to do DBS at standard changes, I believe 0.28%. While it is free to purchase UTs on Poems, in the longer run, you lose more on the higher TER on the UTs even for Lion Global.

3) I have a small USD fixed Deposit of US$16k maturing in Aug this yr
- Does IBKR take USD banker's draft issued by SG Bank?
- Or what will be the best action for this USD deposit (e.g. just banking into DBS eMCA or SCB's FCY CA?)

Normal wire transfer of USD to IBKR is free with DBS, according to reports by others.
 

tangent314

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jul 26, 2002
Messages
5,136
Reaction score
228
*
1) Aviva Global Savings account (the one with Blackrock funds)- My friend informed me that the surrender value +penalty is currently SGD20,130.92.

Total losses around SGD 6100
He said there is an option for premium holiday for up to 5 years and asked me to consider that instead. :s8:


Ok so the penalty seems to be about 5%. It should be better to surrender now, since the plan's costs is more than 1% per year over DIY. So over 5 years you make back the penalty from the difference.
 

ChinoGirl

Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2005
Messages
238
Reaction score
0
Ok so the penalty seems to be about 5%. It should be better to surrender now, since the plan's costs is more than 1% per year over DIY. So over 5 years you make back the penalty from the difference.
Thank you, tangent314. I will submit the forms today to end all the accounts.
 

LexusIS

Senior Member
Joined
May 29, 2008
Messages
1,245
Reaction score
149
Go with the cheaper one I guess, but if they are similar, I would prefer DBS for the CDP custodian.



SCB does not support SRS afaik, so you have to do DBS at standard changes, I believe 0.28%. While it is free to purchase UTs on Poems, in the longer run, you lose more on the higher TER on the UTs even for Lion Global.



Normal wire transfer of USD to IBKR is free with DBS, according to reports by others.

Thanks so much Tangent :)
 

BBCWatcher

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2010
Messages
23,038
Reaction score
4,574
Normal wire transfer of USD to IBKR is free with DBS, according to reports by others.
Look for DBS’s “USA Remit,” which is currently free if you already have U.S. dollars at DBS that you want to send to your IB account (or Schwab account for that matter).
 

ChinoGirl

Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2005
Messages
238
Reaction score
0
I will be heading to Standard Chartered bank today to open the trading account for purchase of IWDA(USD). Do they only need to see my NRIC for opening of the account?
I remember that the form (argh, i am unable to locate the form now) asks customer to indicate which currency account (sorry, i do not know what is the correct term to use) to open. Do i select all the options in the form?
 

smart alex

Master Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2019
Messages
2,671
Reaction score
2
I will be heading to Standard Chartered bank today to open the trading account for purchase of IWDA(USD). Do they only need to see my NRIC for opening of the account?
I remember that the form (argh, i am unable to locate the form now) asks customer to indicate which currency account (sorry, i do not know what is the correct term to use) to open. Do i select all the options in the form?

ok you definitely need to bring ic, tell them wat account u wanna open,for me i open esaver,minimum 1k. then tell them u want to open trading account. they will ask u which currency account u wanna open, u can choose to tick everything, the account manager will help u.

Sent from Xiaomi POCOPHONE F1 using GAGT
 

sumos23

Junior Member
Joined
Jul 23, 2015
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Hi all, i have a quick qn hoping someone can help me out.
i finally opened the interactive brokers account and am trying to wire USD from my standard chartered account to IB.

In the wire instructions, IB gave an ABA routing number but I did not use it at all when I was inputting the required info on standard chartered. I only input the BIC code and my bank account number provided by IB.
Anyone else experienced the same?


Secondly, I tried transferring with $2 late last night. any idea how long it will take to have IB reflect the funds?

thanks!
 
Last edited:

hwckhs

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2012
Messages
1,152
Reaction score
1,241
Still doing dca when market is trending down?

That's the beauty of DCA. It makes sure you will buy some shares when it is cheap (it brings down your average price per share), unless you voluntarily give up. A down trend or crisis is the best time to accumulate more shares, and if necessary, rebalance.
 

Trader11

Banned
Joined
Oct 14, 2018
Messages
15,690
Reaction score
5,233
That's the beauty of DCA. It makes sure you will buy some shares when it is cheap (it brings down your average price per share), unless you voluntarily give up. A down trend or crisis is the best time to accumulate more shares, and if necessary, rebalance.

But the price will not be the best price? Why not buy at support levels?
 

hwckhs

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2012
Messages
1,152
Reaction score
1,241
Agreed.
I have seen friends DCA to the bottom for prolong periods & when recovery comes but weak, their return is pathetic. My friend even claimed put in FD get better returns & no risk vs DCA into ETFs.

How long was the period? What ETF? Did they consider total return (with dividend) or only price return?

Personally, I keep buying every month as if I pay for monthly premium of a life insurance policy. I don't believe my return will be bad if I keep doing this for 20 years or longer.

DCA requires a long term commitment. Fully understand its pros and cons, benefits and pitfalls, before you start.
 

BBCWatcher

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2010
Messages
23,038
Reaction score
4,574
Reposted with emphasis added for the one person who might still be confused....

BBCWatcher said:
There are no U.S. taxes of any sort for non-U.S. persons on U.S. Treasuries (directly held, not in fund form), U.S. bank deposits, U.S. credit union deposits, U.S. municipal bonds (directly held), and U.S. state bonds (directly held), as examples.

Hint: The U.S. estate tax is a U.S. tax. Sales, goods and services, value added, wealth, gift, inheritance, income, excise, import.... there's a very long list of tax types. But there are no U.S. taxes of any sort in the situations described.
 
Last edited:

revhappy

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2012
Messages
12,204
Reaction score
2,659
Hi Shiny/BBCW, do you have any reading suggestions for selling of cash secured long term PUT options as a way to earn better risk adjusted returns?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts.

Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards, Terms of Service and Member T&Cs for more information.
Top