Primary School Question

Joined
May 9, 2022
Messages
2,390
Reaction score
964
That “liquid breakfast” guy is so out of touch of the Singapore education scene that I suspect he is even a Singaporean with kids !

Talk so much about Chinese schools history and not heard of Chong Fu ? I bet he also don’t know about Red Swastika until the Bentley case.
Don’t even know the balloting scene of 2A1 in the past couple years and writing nonsense !
Don’t even know that only a few international schools limit Singaporean while the majority accept thousands of Singaporean (even with scholarships) from secondary one onwards !

Worse of all, his twisted view on Chinese-oriented neighbourhood school. I wonder how the teaching staffs & students of these reputable/well-run schools feel after seeing his comments.
Keep on crying. Anyway it is obvious by last evening after this crying post of yours that what kinda “international” schools they were talking about and what I was talking about. Still want to go on whining. Then go right ahead maybe it can be some kinda therapy you need.
 
Joined
May 9, 2022
Messages
2,390
Reaction score
964
… hmm … are you saying Rulang is a popular school? If Rulang is a popular school, then many other neighbourhood schools are also popular schools, right? From what I have heard since years ago, Rulang is special in that it’s situated near where NTU lecturers reside as it’s near the NTU campus. So you tend to have highly educated parents who teach their own kids at home.

I am not sure what kind of ‘environment and culture’ you are talking about. Every school emphasises on their own culture but none of the schools would put ‘academic excellence’ as its emphasis. At most, “top schools” emphasise on Chinese values, di zi gui and teamwork.
According to popularity rankings Rulang is #8 under non GEP primary schools and you did not know of its popularity yet nobody reacted about it yet just because I had not heard of some neighborhood non GEP primary school in some ghetto town like Yishun ranked #19 under non GEP ranking (this means that it can be safely assumed that all people generally all know all the GEP schools plus maybe the top 10 of the non GEP schools so in total 20 sure well known popular primary schools) and got so many ppl with hurt feelings cried and whines about me not knowing some ranked #19 non GEP school in a ghetto town that most people would not go to often. Even got someone replied by saying it’s the top in THAT town. :rolleyes: :s13:
https://schoolbell.sg/primary-school-ranking/
 

katenash

Banned
Joined
Jul 14, 2020
Messages
5,995
Reaction score
3,895
According to popularity rankings Rulang is #8 under non GEP primary schools and you did not know of its popularity yet nobody reacted about it yet just because I had not heard of some neighborhood non GEP primary school in some ghetto town like Yishun ranked #19 under non GEP ranking (this means that it can be safely assumed that all people generally all know all the GEP schools plus maybe the top 10 of the non GEP schools so in total 20 sure well known popular primary schools) and got so many ppl with hurt feelings cried and whines about me not knowing some ranked #19 non GEP school in a ghetto town that most people would not go to often. Even got someone replied by saying it’s the top in THAT town. :rolleyes: :s13:
https://schoolbell.sg/primary-school-ranking/
Nobody except you would refer to that so called ranking. I saw it once and totally dismissed it as rubbish. It’s not even worthy for me to point out why it’s rubbish. If you have ever participated in the craze of P1 registration before, you would know Chongfu IS the top school in Yishun. And it has been the top school for many years, probably for at least 2 decades. Yes, you may collect all your materials from the internet but nothing beats listening to the voices on the ground and going through the experience yourself. Do you have any idea which forum all Sg parents rush to for their info during P1 registration? I suggest you go read up that forum’s threads for the different schools during P1 registration instead of giving all your high and mighty theories and opinion here.

I was asking if you meant that Rulang was popular because I wasn’t sure I read your post correctly. And Rulang is just one of the neighbourhood schools. Yes, it’s popular, but many other neighbourhood schools are also very popular. At least no parent had been photographed crying at Rulang when they were balloted out.

If you have ever participated in a P1 registration exercise before, you would know it’s a challenge to get into schools that are above average, not just popular or top, so much so that people would rather send their kids to their alma maters that are far away from their house than to risk getting balloted out at 2C even when the popular school in their own neighbourhood is within 1km.
 
Joined
May 9, 2022
Messages
2,390
Reaction score
964
Nobody except you would refer to that so called ranking. I saw it once and totally dismissed it as rubbish. It’s not even worthy for me to point out why it’s rubbish. If you have ever participated in the craze of P1 registration before, you would know Chongfu IS the top school in Yishun. And it has been the top school for many years, probably for at least 2 decades. Yes, you may collect all your materials from the internet but nothing beats listening to the voices on the ground and going through the experience yourself. Do you have any idea which forum all Sg parents rush to for their info during P1 registration? I suggest you go read up that forum’s threads for the different schools during P1 registration instead of giving all your high and mighty theories and opinion here.

I was asking if you meant that Rulang was popular because I wasn’t sure I read your post correctly. And Rulang is just one of the neighbourhood schools. Yes, it’s popular, but many other neighbourhood schools are also very popular. At least no parent had been photographed crying at Rulang when they were balloted out.

If you have ever participated in a P1 registration exercise before, you would know it’s a challenge to get into schools that are above average, not just popular or top, so much so that people would rather send their kids to their alma maters that are far away from their house than to risk getting balloted out at 2C even when the popular school in their own neighbourhood is within 1km.
Do you think being the top school of Yishun is really a very strong credible trump card? Are you trolling, or serious?

What’s the strong calling of being the top school of Yishun to people living elsewhere?
 
Joined
May 9, 2022
Messages
2,390
Reaction score
964
Nobody except you would refer to that so called ranking. I saw it once and totally dismissed it as rubbish. It’s not even worthy for me to point out why it’s rubbish. If you have ever participated in the craze of P1 registration before, you would know Chongfu IS the top school in Yishun. And it has been the top school for many years, probably for at least 2 decades. Yes, you may collect all your materials from the internet but nothing beats listening to the voices on the ground and going through the experience yourself. Do you have any idea which forum all Sg parents rush to for their info during P1 registration? I suggest you go read up that forum’s threads for the different schools during P1 registration instead of giving all your high and mighty theories and opinion here.

I was asking if you meant that Rulang was popular because I wasn’t sure I read your post correctly. And Rulang is just one of the neighbourhood schools. Yes, it’s popular, but many other neighbourhood schools are also very popular. At least no parent had been photographed crying at Rulang when they were balloted out.

If you have ever participated in a P1 registration exercise before, you would know it’s a challenge to get into schools that are above average, not just popular or top, so much so that people would rather send their kids to their alma maters that are far away from their house than to risk getting balloted out at 2C even when the popular school in their own neighbourhood is within 1km.
I was not the one who talked about Rulang. Someone else did and you replied to him, not me.
 
Joined
May 9, 2022
Messages
2,390
Reaction score
964
Nobody except you would refer to that so called ranking. I saw it once and totally dismissed it as rubbish. It’s not even worthy for me to point out why it’s rubbish. If you have ever participated in the craze of P1 registration before, you would know Chongfu IS the top school in Yishun. And it has been the top school for many years, probably for at least 2 decades. Yes, you may collect all your materials from the internet but nothing beats listening to the voices on the ground and going through the experience yourself. Do you have any idea which forum all Sg parents rush to for their info during P1 registration? I suggest you go read up that forum’s threads for the different schools during P1 registration instead of giving all your high and mighty theories and opinion here.

I was asking if you meant that Rulang was popular because I wasn’t sure I read your post correctly. And Rulang is just one of the neighbourhood schools. Yes, it’s popular, but many other neighbourhood schools are also very popular. At least no parent had been photographed crying at Rulang when they were balloted out.

If you have ever participated in a P1 registration exercise before, you would know it’s a challenge to get into schools that are above average, not just popular or top, so much so that people would rather send their kids to their alma maters that are far away from their house than to risk getting balloted out at 2C even when the popular school in their own neighbourhood is within 1km.
You can use other rankings you can find online, they would all give you the same results. That’s because that ranking uses the level of over subscription to calculate popularity. If you have other rankings you can find that places Chong Fu the top school of Yishun in a higher place, feel free to show it. I will wait for you.
 

katenash

Banned
Joined
Jul 14, 2020
Messages
5,995
Reaction score
3,895
Do you think being the top school of Yishun is really a very strong credible trump card? Are you trolling, or serious?

What’s the strong calling of being the top school of Yishun to people living elsewhere?
Being a top school in any neighbourhood means one thing: their PSLE result is the best among the schools in the neighbourhood. I do know the stats so Chongfu is very impressive for a neighbourhood school. It doesn’t have any GEP class and most kids from Chongfu, if selected for GEP, are likely to join a GEP school. So unlike schools like Nanyang, Nanhua and the likes, Chongfu’s cohorts are neighbourhood kids who shoot to the moon and stars during psle by their own effort.

When I compare results, I compare using the non-GEP classes as GEP kids’ results tilt the scale unfavourably against the non-GEP schools. Some GEP schools don’t even produce the same percentage of students scoring more than 250 among their non-GEP classes.

Oh, I don’t just know Chongfu is the top and most popular school in Yishun, I also knew the different schools that were top and popular in different neighbourhoods when I was in the foray. When you are caught up in the heat of the P1 registration, you will be fed with info of many top and/or popular schools in different places and not just the school and area you are interested in. That means I also knew that Peichun was a popular school in TPY, Anderson in YCK, Red Swastika in Bedok … and these are just what I offhand rattle off. Yes. I do know Rulang. Since more than 20 years ago, my colleagues told me it’s a ‘good’ school. In some places, I also knew the second popular schools.

I don’t know what trump card you are talking about. I also don’t know why you would want to discuss whether schools are good or popular here for because this is obviously not the right place. The TS was just trying to sound out others’ opinion on whether it’s a good thing for him to move to his dream home or stay for his dream school for his kid. His ‘good’ or ‘popular’ may not be ‘good’ or ‘popular’ to you. So no need to say so much about your opinion on whether this school is international or that school is good or popular or not. You just have to imagine yourself in his position with your own dream school that you think is good and popular and answer his question. I don’t think he’s interested to know whether his definition of ‘good’ and ‘popular’ is correct by your yardstick.

I think most people here would think you are the troll. Not me.
 

katenash

Banned
Joined
Jul 14, 2020
Messages
5,995
Reaction score
3,895
You can use other rankings you can find online, they would all give you the same results. That’s because that ranking uses the level of over subscription to calculate popularity. If you have other rankings you can find that places Chong Fu the top school of Yishun in a higher place, feel free to show it. I will wait for you.
P1 registration is not your BTO registration. There are different reasons why some schools are not more popular than others even tho they are supposed to be more popular. You only have one chance and parents won’t risk messing up that chance by joining Phase 2C if they think their chance is low. I have a friend who could enrol her kid in the school she was teaching in, and it’s a top school, but instead, she enrolled her kid in her alma mater because it’s a safe choice at Phase 2A. She might get balloted out if she were to enrol her child in her school as it’s Phase 2B. Then she would have to go to Phase 2C where the fight is even fiercer. I did something similar - enrolled in 2A because I didn’t want to risk the chance at 2C. Many people do the same thing.

Maybe you should just have a kid and try out P1 registration yourself to understand all the works and psychology behind it.
 

crazythen

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 21, 2013
Messages
2,157
Reaction score
914
I want to follow and read this thread to better prep my children for this. But the stress level getting higher with the stats and ranks and impact on losing out, and types of crowd, etc etc...
Can’t this be a little bit more forgiving...they are only 7 - 12 year old ffs...
 

䏣炆玧示老太

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2021
Messages
23,586
Reaction score
7,402
I want to follow and read this thread to better prep my children for this. But the stress level getting higher with the stats and ranks and impact on losing out, and types of crowd, etc etc...
Can’t this be a little bit more forgiving...they are only 7 - 12 year old ffs...
What’s unforgiving?
PSLE is a fair exam for all kids. Whoever study hard for it sure can score high marks
 

googoogaga

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2009
Messages
1,485
Reaction score
601
What’s unforgiving?
PSLE is a fair exam for all kids. Whoever study hard for it sure can score high marks
In competitive exams like these the margin of error is very very small. Exams can't be used to differentiate and rank amongst 1000s of test takers. A small mistake can pull down the grades even though the kid is a bright child.
This is not what a primary school student should go through.
 

䏣炆玧示老太

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2021
Messages
23,586
Reaction score
7,402
In competitive exams like these the margin of error is very very small. Exams can't be used to differentiate and rank amongst 1000s of test takers. A small mistake can pull down the grades even though the kid is a bright child.
This is not what a primary school student should go through.
its always been a test to see who are more careful and composed. Not testing who are smarter
 

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,299
Reaction score
3,015
Hehe, Useless PSLE scores can initiate such a boring debate. As though the employers would be interested to see your PSLE grades before they employ u. Lol :o
 
Last edited:

䏣炆玧示老太

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2021
Messages
23,586
Reaction score
7,402
Hehe, Useless PSLE scores can initiate such a boring debate. As though the employers would be interested to see your PSLE grades before they employ u. Lol :o
Definitely will
Because PSLE is the most important exam of sinkie life
 

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,299
Reaction score
3,015
Definitely will
Because PSLE is the most important exam of sinkie life
Will your head. :o
And I’m still here airing balls right now with no fantastic PSLE scores or from any excellent pri school.
Don’t feel like debating this topic. Impractical and boring.
.
 

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,299
Reaction score
3,015
Haha.. clickbait topic…
If the debate was on which property overprice, which property can buy I still find it more practical and relevant. Lol
In life, there’s so many factors that will determine someone’s success over time, ie your disposition, the friends you mixed with, your values and priorities, your ability to articulate and network with others, your luck to meet a good mentor in work and so many more. Which employers would care on the useless PSLE scores. Lol :o
 
Last edited:
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top