Some opnions,
Plan to propose to my girlfriend. She's non-local but had studied and worked in SG for 10years. She mentioned she has no preference for diamonds and preferred gold. But still as part of proposal, still wanted to get her a simple diamond.
I booked appointment with eclarity and told them budget of 4k.
Can't rem details
0.6 carat
D/E/F
3EX
VS2
Can't rem details
0.8
F
3EX
SI2 $5.3k++(Original price 6.2k) 0.8 looks far much bigger than 0.61
Amanda focus was carat and colour.
I checked with my friend at least get VS2, not SI1 or SI2.
Now is a dilema between
price
face
Small diamond good specs? OR
Bigger diamond poor specs?
Is it very shamful to get a SI1/SI2 grade diamonds for her? Worry her friends/colleagues will compare say nasty things.
In the past, people cared more about carat than anything else cos the mentality was the bigger the better, no matter what. They also had limited information, it was always hear-say. Nowadays, people are getting smarter and started paying more attention to the quality.
Personally, I'll pass the SI2. Even if the inclusion marks on the diamond doesn't bother her, it bothers me. Not to mention, diamonds with bad inclusions are prone to chipping.
A simple search about diamonds online, you'll realize that the most important C is the cut. Not the carat or colour.
IMHO, it is either she doesn't know her stuff or she is not honest..
You'll also have to ask yourself, what's the purpose of you getting a diamond for? Is it for a show or one time gesture? Or something you want her to wear everyday for a lifetime..
Either way, there's no shame with either of your choice

It's your choice afterall
What i said above, is my opinion afterall.
If her friends says nasty things, I think she needs to change her group of friends
