• The HardwareZone forums will be temporarily unavailable on January 21, from 5:00am to 6:00am (+8GMT) while we perform scheduled maintenance.

Webull Singapore

revhappy

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2012
Messages
12,208
Reaction score
2,662
I just converted the USD to SGD and submitted the withdrawal request. Adding bank account for withdrawal is a bit of a pain. They ask for swift details and bank address which should not be necessary if we choose SG bank account and SGD withdrawal. Also made me submit bank statement. Let's see how it goes.
 

sohguanh

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2010
Messages
8,886
Reaction score
3,014
I just converted the USD to SGD and submitted the withdrawal request. Adding bank account for withdrawal is a bit of a pain. They ask for swift details and bank address which should not be necessary if we choose SG bank account and SGD withdrawal. Also made me submit bank statement. Let's see how it goes.
Please share later if it is successful. Also this process need to be repeated for every withdrawal request?
 

platee

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2009
Messages
16,749
Reaction score
1,837
Yes US stock ETF really 0 comm fee. Minimum is 5 for fractional shares if supported. Change into USD minimum is 10 but their rate not so good but no need pay 2 like IBKR
How long does it take for them to reflect the 5 buy trades? I made like 8 trades ystd alr. Today 4pm I check they only show 2 buys completed. Strange.
 

sohguanh

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2010
Messages
8,886
Reaction score
3,014
How long does it take for them to reflect the 5 buy trades? I made like 8 trades ystd alr. Today 4pm I check they only show 2 buys completed. Strange.
Are you using Limit order or Market order? Market order is close to immediate get filled. Limit order will depend. Anyway inside the app got CSO chat can ask and they are quite fast to reply based on my own experience.
 

platee

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2009
Messages
16,749
Reaction score
1,837
Are you using Limit order or Market order? Market order is close to immediate get filled. Limit order will depend. Anyway inside the app got CSO chat can ask and they are quite fast to reply based on my own experience.
All limit order. 1 buy and sell # 1 trade. I made 8 trades. All above 3k usd in value.

They count by ticker bought? Because I only traded 2 stocks - AMD and Googl.
 

sohguanh

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2010
Messages
8,886
Reaction score
3,014
All limit order. 1 buy and sell # 1 trade. I made 8 trades. All above 3k usd in value.

They count by ticker bought? Because I only traded 2 stocks - AMD and Googl.
If limit order does not guarantee it always succeed correct? Only 2 stocks but 8 trades means you buy and sell total 8 times for the 2 stocks in a single trading day. Last time I read somewhere some brokers impose restriction on buy and sell same stock within same trading day.

E.g for Syfe trade. A day trade is considered the opening and closing of the same position within the same day.
https://help.syfe.com/hc/en-us/arti...n-day-trading-rule-and-how-does-it-affect-me-
https://help.syfe.com/hc/en-us/arti...s-if-I-m-flagged-as-a-PDT-pattern-day-trader-
I think it is best you reach out to inside app CSO for your case so they can check for you.
 

platee

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2009
Messages
16,749
Reaction score
1,837
If limit order does not guarantee it always succeed correct? Only 2 stocks but 8 trades means you buy and sell total 8 times for the 2 stocks in a single trading day. Last time I read somewhere some brokers impose restriction on buy and sell same stock within same trading day.

E.g for Syfe trade. A day trade is considered the opening and closing of the same position within the same day.
https://help.syfe.com/hc/en-us/arti...n-day-trading-rule-and-how-does-it-affect-me-
https://help.syfe.com/hc/en-us/arti...s-if-I-m-flagged-as-a-PDT-pattern-day-trader-
I think it is best you reach out to inside app CSO for your case so they can check for you.
As long as order filled means successful lor. I closed all my positions ystd, and I didn't buy sell just to fulfill the trade requirement. Still made $100+ kopi money on those 8 trades.

If free Comms of course day trading better ma. But anyway I still got 20days to see how it goes lol, just find it strange.
 

sohguanh

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2010
Messages
8,886
Reaction score
3,014
As long as order filled means successful lor. I closed all my positions ystd, and I didn't buy sell just to fulfill the trade requirement. Still made $100+ kopi money on those 8 trades.

If free Comms of course day trading better ma. But anyway I still got 20days to see how it goes lol, just find it strange.
If you don't want to chat with the CSO it is ok then just wait and see you get the AAPL share or not. Becuz I know if chat they will investigate all your trades hahaha.

Last time using poems for SGX stocks, one can buy and sell same stock same day. In fact the settlement is T + 3 so one can trade longer than a single day. One can buy without paying upfront since buy and sell in same day etc etc. Now is "new age brokers" got new rules maybe.
 

crystalnox

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2006
Messages
8,636
Reaction score
2,229
If you don't want to chat with the CSO it is ok then just wait and see you get the AAPL share or not. Becuz I know if chat they will investigate all your trades hahaha.

Last time using poems for SGX stocks, one can buy and sell same stock same day. In fact the settlement is T + 3 so one can trade longer than a single day. One can buy without paying upfront since buy and sell in same day etc etc. Now is "new age brokers" got new rules maybe.
It's not a new rule, it's called the pattern day trading rule and it usually applies to US brokers.
 

sohguanh

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2010
Messages
8,886
Reaction score
3,014
It's not a new rule, it's called the pattern day trading rule and it usually applies to US brokers.
When I say "new rule" I am comparing the poems I use for SGX stock trading last time not US stock trading. Sorry if it confuse readers.
 
Joined
Jun 16, 2008
Messages
130
Reaction score
16
Tried on my end as well last night:
1. Funded the minimum 2K
2. Exchanged 10 USD (this is the minimum they allow)
3. Did 6 x buy trades of VLTA consecutively (~2.24 USD per piece), selling them along the way to minimise exposure

Now have to wait at least 30 calendar days for the 60 + 40 USD worth of AAPL shares to be credited, i.e. 1-Jul-22.

Coincidentally, I was changing some USD in IBKR a few hours apart, so exchange rate comparison as such:
Webull = 0.723789
IBKR = 0.727775
Not too good, but I guess worth it just for the 100 USD AAPL shares.

And Webull cited to have really high PFOF on stocks:

A quick update that:
1. AAPL shares were credited (did not manage to trace the exact date as I have left the app there)
2. Just withdrew most of my 2K SGD, was quite a hassle to set up the linkage to my OCBC as there's a need to provide bank statements etc

In any case, I'm leaving some of the token USD (~10) and AAPL shares there as I foresee using WeBull as a complement to my TDA and IBKR accounts. The zero commissions for US is really very attractive to me, and I've heard good things about the improving FX spread (but perhaps this will be subject to another round of tests in the future). Once the withdrawal is set up, it certainly beats TDA which is charging a heft USD 25 per withdrawal.

Only wrinkle left is the PFOF, but some say setting limit orders should mitigate this concern (at least I see it as "out of sight, out of mind"). I personally think they also need to earn something and I'm also trying to find a way to understand the quantification of PFOF impacts across brokerages.
 

sohguanh

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2010
Messages
8,886
Reaction score
3,014
Only wrinkle left is the PFOF, but some say setting limit orders should mitigate this concern (at least I see it as "out of sight, out of mind"). I personally think they also need to earn something and I'm also trying to find a way to understand the quantification of PFOF impacts across brokerages.
I agree with you. By giving investor 0 comm fees they need to earn monies somewhere. So when a super enthusiastic reader keep posting about PFOF and I take a look at online references hmmm.... I guess it is a trade off. My thinking would be how do we know other brokers like IBKR that charge 35 cents don't do PFOF confirm no?

Fractional shares (same for Syfe too) can only be done via market order. For investor that want to buy full share I think choosing limit order should be default to mitigate the PFOF concern
 

crystalnox

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2006
Messages
8,636
Reaction score
2,229
I agree with you. By giving investor 0 comm fees they need to earn monies somewhere. So when a super enthusiastic reader keep posting about PFOF and I take a look at online references hmmm.... I guess it is a trade off. My thinking would be how do we know other brokers like IBKR that charge 35 cents don't do PFOF confirm no?

Fractional shares (same for Syfe too) can only be done via market order. For investor that want to buy full share I think choosing limit order should be default to mitigate the PFOF concern
IIRC IBKR Pro doesn't do PFOF, only their Lite version(which is not avail. in SG) has PFOF.

But to be frank, for the majority of investors on these low-cost brokers, PFOF isn't going to affect them much. Nobody gonna front run your 5 qty order of TSLA..and a 1 cent worse fill order isn't going to burn any holes in your pockets either. So many people acting like they're trading 6 digits volumes daily and PFOF is going to eat their lunch.
 

dappermen

Banned
Joined
Mar 5, 2017
Messages
8,665
Reaction score
1,017
PFOF isn't going to affect them much.
we all knew that!
PFOF is never an issue at all

it was raised only when a particular member kicked a big fuss of it (all over the threads, esp i m a small (sorry , a mini) player only


can any users of Moomoo confirmed here is Webull better than Moomoo? In terms of UI and customer services?
 

ashethen

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2005
Messages
19,156
Reaction score
10,120
is it possible to deposit USD from DBS via FAST transfer to webull?

their TT deposit account is also DBS
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts.

Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards, Terms of Service and Member T&Cs for more information.
Top